BRENNEN

Industries / Food, farming and forestry / Agriculture and farming / Nursery and horticulture / Vertical farming and hydroponics

Nutrients

Choosing, mixing, dosing and checking the solution of dissolved mineral salts that replaces soil as the plants' food, including systems where fish waste supplies it.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1860 to 2022.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1860

    Plants fed from a recipe

    In 1860 the German botanist Julius von Sachs published experiments showing that land plants can take all their nutrients from a water solution, without soil, and not only stay alive but grow vigorously and set seed. He grew seedlings in a perforated cork with the roots dipping into his standard solution. Wilhelm Knop, working at the same time, proposed a solution in 1865 that became one of the most widely used in plant nutrition studies. Hoagland and Arnon wrote in 1938 that Sachs's technique was "still widely used, essentially unaltered".

    archive.org

    Credit

    Julius von Sachs; Wilhelm Knop

  2. 1961

    A recipe from ion ratios

    Abram A. Steiner published a method for computing in advance a nutrient solution with chosen ratios between the nutrient ions, a chosen total concentration and a chosen pH (acidity), without salts settling out of the solution (Plant and Soil, 1961). "Steiner solution" is still a standard baseline: a 2025 study of greenhouse tomatoes by researchers in Michoacán, Mexico, used it as the full-strength control.

    link.springer.compmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    Abram A. Steiner

  3. 1997

    Europe caps nitrate in lettuce

    Leafy greens store nitrate from their nutrient supply in their leaves. Commission Regulation (EC) No 194/97 set EU-wide maximum nitrate levels for lettuce and spinach, different by season, after some member states had adopted or planned their own. Today's limits, in Regulation (EU) 2023/915, allow 5,000 mg of nitrate per kg in lettuce grown under cover and harvested from October to March, against 4,000 mg/kg for lettuce grown in the open air, and 4,000 against 3,000 mg/kg from April to September. Lettuce must be labeled as grown under cover to use the higher limit.

    LessonThe 1997 regulation set levels by season because "climatic conditions, production methods and eating habits vary widely" across Europe.

    eur-lex.europa.eueur-lex.europa.eu

    Credit

    European Commission

  4. 2006

    Fish waste feeds lettuce

    Aquaponics joins fish farming to hydroponics. Bacteria turn the ammonia that fish excrete into nitrate, which the plants take up, cleaning the water for the fish. The University of the Virgin Islands (UVI) developed a commercial-scale system with plants on floating rafts. The November 2006 revision of a fact sheet from the US Department of Agriculture's Southern Regional Aquaculture Center puts its output at about 11,000 lb (5 t) of tilapia and 1,400 cases of lettuce, or 11,000 lb of basil, a year.

    LessonThe authors found that UVI's break-even prices for tilapia and lettuce "do not compare favorably to commodity prices", and wrote that "niche markets may be required for profitability".

    blogs.ifas.ufl.edupods.okstate.edu

    Credit

    James E. Rakocy and colleagues, UVI; fact sheet by Rakocy with Michael P. Masser (Texas A&M University) and Thomas M. Losordo (North Carolina State University)

  5. 2014

    Lettuce low in potassium

    People on dialysis or with chronic kidney disease are told to limit potassium, and raw vegetables are hard for them to eat. On 7 May 2014 Fujitsu began selling leaf lettuce grown in a converted semiconductor clean room in Aizu-Wakamatsu, Fukushima, with the potassium in its liquid fertilizer controlled. Fujitsu said it held less than 100 mg of potassium per 100 g, against 490 mg for ordinary leaf lettuce in Japan's standard food tables. The method is patented by Akita Prefectural University, and two bunches of about 90 g sold for ¥450 to ¥500, more than ordinary lettuce.

    eco-business.comfujitsu.com

    Credit

    Akita Prefectural University; Aizufujikako; Fujitsu Home & Office Services

  6. 2015

    Aquaponics farms surveyed

    David Love, Jillian Fry and colleagues surveyed 257 commercial aquaponics operations, 81% of them in the US (Aquaculture, 2015). The median start year was 2010, 69% raised tilapia, and unpaid workers and volunteers (1,720) outnumbered full-time staff (538) about three to one. Operations were more likely to report a profit in the past 12 months when aquaponics was the owner's main income, when they were in warmer US climate zones (USDA plant hardiness zones 7 to 13), when sales reached at least $5,000, when the owner knew more about aquaponics, and when they also sold supplies, consulting, workshops or farm tours.

    LessonProfit went with scale, experience and climate, and with selling supplies and training as well as fish and vegetables.

    ebi.ac.uk

    Credit

    David C. Love, Jillian P. Fry and colleagues

  7. 2022

    Organic rules split on soil

    In 2019 the Center for Food Safety petitioned the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) to bar organic certification of crops grown hydroponically. USDA refused that June, the center and a group of organic farms sued in March 2020, and a district court sided with USDA in March 2021. On 22 September 2022 the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed, finding that "no part of the statute clearly precludes organic certification of crops grown hydroponically". The European Union decided the opposite: its 2018 organic regulation says organic crops "shall be produced in living soil" and that hydroponic production "is prohibited".

    nationalaglawcenter.orgcenterforfoodsafety.orgeur-lex.europa.eu

    Credit

    US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit; European Parliament and Council, Regulation (EU) 2018/848

Watch for

  1. Color tests for drain water

    Greenhouses that recirculate their nutrient solution measure only its total salt content, by electrical conductivity (EC), so they sometimes discard water that still holds usable fertilizer. NutriCycle, a €1.8 million Danish–German project led by the University of Southern Denmark (SDU) with Kiel University, plans a compact device that takes small water samples, reacts them on a chip so that their color changes, and reads each nutrient optically, so a grower can top up only what is low. It is to connect to the InfoGrow greenhouse control platform and be tested at NPZ Innovation in Germany.

    Achieved whenthe prototype runs through a full crop at NPZ Innovation with its readings matched to laboratory tests, and the partners report how much less solution was discarded.

    sdu.dk

    Claimed by

    SDU and Kiel University, September 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Ion probes through whole crops

    Leave inline probes for nitrate, potassium and calcium in a recirculating lettuce system, unattended, through three back-to-back crops (about 15 weeks), and check them weekly against a laboratory. Then dose each nutrient from the probe readings for one crop, beside a crop dosed the usual way by EC.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Nitrate in indoor lettuce

    A public survey of nitrate in lettuce sold by vertical farms and hydroponic greenhouses, bought in both halves of the EU's nitrate year and tested by an accredited laboratory, with each result set against the EU limits.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Ion probes through whole crops

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Leave inline probes for nitrate, potassium and calcium in a recirculating lettuce system, unattended, through three back-to-back crops (about 15 weeks), and check them weekly against a laboratory. Then dose each nutrient from the probe readings for one crop, beside a crop dosed the usual way by EC.

Why it is still open

The longest closed-loop run found with probes left in the solution, at Kyung Hee University in 2014, kept nitrate, potassium and calcium in balance for two weeks, with ion-selective electrodes reading within 12% of standard analyzers. The Agricultural University of Athens's NUTRISENSE software has dosed a closed-loop cucumber crop from ion readings and held the nutrients close to target, but the readings were taken once a day with handheld LAQUAtwin meters, not with probes left in the solution. A 2019 method that corrects the probes' drift was tested on eight greenhouse samples, and a 2024 German study of transistor-type probes (ISFETs) worked mainly in the laboratory. Aptisens, a UK company, said in April 2025 that its multi-ion probes can run unattended for 6 to 12 months; no outside long-term test was found. SDU's NutriCycle team said in 2026 that equipment to measure individual nutrients exists but "integrating it can cost many thousands of euros".

khu.elsevierpure.comishs.orgpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govapi.crossref.orghortidaily.com

Built with what exists

Off-the-shelf ion-selective electrodes for nitrate, potassium and calcium, or a multi-ion probe such as Aptisens's; an ESP32 or Raspberry Pi logger; peristaltic dosing pumps; the NUTRISENSE nutrient calculator to turn readings into doses; a deep-water-culture lettuce tank in a grow tent; a commercial water laboratory for weekly reference tests.

  1. First step

    Set up a 40-plant deep-water-culture tank and send two solution samples to a laboratory to learn the range the probes must cover.

  2. Done looks like

    15 weeks of hourly readings and 15 weekly laboratory results for each ion, published with the error, the drift per week and every recalibration. One ion-dosed crop and one EC-dosed crop compared on yield, fertilizer used and solution discarded.

Open 02 · the brief

Nitrate in indoor lettuce

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public survey of nitrate in lettuce sold by vertical farms and hydroponic greenhouses, bought in both halves of the EU's nitrate year and tested by an accredited laboratory, with each result set against the EU limits.

Why it is still open

The EU limits depend on season and on whether lettuce was grown under cover or in the open air, a split made for sunlight; a farm lit only by lamps has no season. Stiftung Warentest, the German consumer testing foundation, wrote in 2017 that there were no official tests yet of residues or nutrient content in indoor vegetables, and that it had not tested them itself because they were niche products. A Brazilian survey of leafy greens on sale found the most nitrate in hydroponic lettuce (Nascimento, 2019), but it did not single out lettuce grown under lamps alone or judge it against the EU limits. Research trials do measure nitrate in vertical-farm lettuce under set treatments; in 2026 Aldiyab, Gruda and colleagues found that it changed with LED spectrum and growing system. Searches in English and German found no survey of lamp-grown lettuce on sale.

test.deeur-lex.europa.euejfa.mepmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Built with what exists

Retail purchases; an accredited food laboratory; a spreadsheet; a handheld nitrate meter to screen samples before they go to the laboratory.

  1. First step

    List the lettuce products in local shops labeled as vertical-farm or hydroponic, buy ten, and get quotes from two accredited laboratories.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 60 samples from at least six indoor-farm brands and two field-grown brands, half bought from October to March and half from April to September. Each result is published with brand, label wording, purchase date and nitrate in mg/kg, with the share of samples above each EU limit.