BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial machinery / Valves

Leaks to the air

This work is about the gas that escapes from valves into the air, around the stem, through body joints or on purpose from gas-driven controls, and about the tests and rules that limit it.

6

Milestones achieved, from 2006 to 2024.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2006

    One world test for leaks

    ISO 15848-1, issued in January 2006 by Valve Magazine's account, is a type test: a sample valve's stem seal and body seals are measured while it is opened and shut and heated, and the result qualifies the design. It allows helium or methane as the test gas, sets three tightness classes for each (for methane, AM at 50 ppm or less, BM at 100 ppm and CM at 500 ppm), endurance classes from 205 to 2,500 cycles for on-off valves and 20,000 to 100,000 cycles for control valves, and test temperatures from −196 °C to 400 °C. A second edition followed in 2015.

    valvemagazine.compumpsandsystems.com

    Credit

    International Organization for Standardization (ISO)

  2. 2014

    A few controllers, most methane

    Pneumatic controllers use the pressure of the gas in the line to work valves, and many vent that gas, mostly methane, as they operate; EPA counted 477,606 of them at US natural gas production sites. A team led by David Allen of the University of Texas at Austin, with the testing firm URS and with the Environmental Defense Fund and producers as partners, measured 377 controllers at US production sites, published on 9 December 2014. Of these, 19% of the devices, each venting more than 6 standard cubic feet (0.17 m³) of gas an hour, gave 95% of the emissions, while more than half vented 0.001 cubic feet an hour or less during 15 minutes of measurement.

    Lessonthe worst emitters included controllers that were not working as designed, so finding faulty devices matters as much as choosing a low-venting design.

    news.utexas.eduauthors.library.caltech.edu

    Credit

    David Allen and colleagues, University of Texas at Austin; URS; Environmental Defense Fund

  3. 2016

    Leak tests for quarter-turn valves

    API 641, issued in October 2016, type-tests quarter-turn valves, which open and shut with a quarter turn of the stem, in methane: 610 mechanical cycles, three heat cycles up to 260 °C (500 °F), test pressures from 100 to 600 psi, no tightening of the packing, and a limit of 100 ppm measured by EPA Method 21, the standard way of reading a leak with a hand-held gas analyzer. In 2018 Phil Mahoney of A.W. Chesterton, writing in Pumps & Systems, said the next edition of API's quarter-turn standard API 608 would require it and that API 609 and API 599 were expected to.

    valvemagazine.compumpsandsystems.com

    Credit

    American Petroleum Institute

  4. 2021

    Germany adopts the ISO test

    TA Luft, Germany's general administrative rule on air quality, first issued in 1964, used the VDI 2440 guideline to judge valve emissions. In its December 2021 update it switched to ISO 15848-1 (2015) as the test method but kept its own leak limits, whose tightest class, LA, allows 1.0E-05 mg/(s·m) of helium or methane, and whose pass mark depends on pressure.

    valvemagazine.com

    Credit

    German federal government

  5. 2023

    Canada caps controller venting

    From 1 January 2023, Canada's federal methane regulations for upstream oil and gas (SOR/2018-66, registered on 4 April 2018) bar a pneumatic controller from running on hydrocarbon gas unless its bleed rate is at most 0.17 standard m³ an hour or its gas is captured or destroyed, with a recorded exception where a process needs a higher setting. Every gas-driven controller must be recorded with its use and its design bleed rate.

    laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

    Credit

    Government of Canada

  6. 2024

    Zero-emission controllers required

    EPA's final rule of 8 March 2024, announced on 2 December 2023, sets a standard of zero methane and VOC emissions for all process controllers at covered sites outside Alaska, met with controllers not driven by natural gas, by routing their gas back to a process, or with self-contained gas-driven controllers. At gas processing plants each leaking valve must be repacked with low-emission ("low-e") packing, replaced with a low-e valve or repaired by drill-and-tap with low-e injectable packing, where that is technically feasible. The rule defines a low-e valve as one whose maker gives a written warranty that it will not leak above 100 ppm in its first five years.

    govinfo.govepa.gov

    Credit

    US Environmental Protection Agency

Watch for

  1. A looser rule proposed

    EPA proposed on 29 October 2026 (docket EPA-HQ-OAR-2025-0163) to let gas plants make a first attempt at repairing a leaking valve, such as tightening packing gland nuts, before repacking or replacing it with low-e parts; to allow low-bleed controllers at low-producing and conventional well sites; and to create a subcategory for high-pressure controllers at transmission compressor stations, where EPA now finds that switching to zero-emission controllers is not technically feasible or cost-effective.

    Achieved whena final rule is published in the Federal Register and takes effect; comments close on 16 December 2026.

    hklaw.comepa.gov

    Claimed by

    US Environmental Protection Agency, October 2026

Open

  1. 01

    One register of leak certificates

    An open, searchable table of published fugitive-emission type-test certificates for valves (ISO 15848-1, API 624, API 641, TA Luft) and published low-e warranties, giving for each the maker, valve type, size and pressure-class range, standard and edition, test gas, tightness and endurance class, temperatures, test laboratory and date, with a link to the certificate.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Stem leak sensors, tested blind

    A bench of small used valves leaking a non-flammable calibration mixture of methane in nitrogen through loosened packing at set rates and low pressure, on which clamp-on stem sensors are scored blind, with the leak rate unknown to the person reading them, against readings by EPA Method 21 with a calibrated analyzer.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

One register of leak certificates

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open, searchable table of published fugitive-emission type-test certificates for valves (ISO 15848-1, API 624, API 641, TA Luft) and published low-e warranties, giving for each the maker, valve type, size and pressure-class range, standard and edition, test gas, tightness and endurance class, temperatures, test laboratory and date, with a link to the certificate.

Why it is still open

Certificates sit as PDFs and press releases on makers' own sites, such as Trillium's note of its TÜV SÜD hydrogen certificate, and a search in November 2026 found the standards and makers' pages but no public register of which designs passed which test. EPA's 2024 rule defines a low-e valve by its maker's written warranty of no more than 100 ppm for five years, so a buyer or inspector has to gather each warranty separately.

trilliumflow.comgovinfo.gov

Built with what exists

A web crawler; an AI model that reads PDFs and scanned certificates into fixed columns (the Note "Seven more flagged"); a person checking each row against its certificate; a CSV on GitHub with a Zenodo DOI.

  1. First step

    Collect 30 certificates from five makers' websites, write the rules for each column, and have two people enter the same 10 to compare.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 300 certificates from at least 40 makers in at least 8 countries, each row linked to its source; a second person rechecks a random 10% of rows and the error rate is published.

Open 02 · the brief

Stem leak sensors, tested blind

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A bench of small used valves leaking a non-flammable calibration mixture of methane in nitrogen through loosened packing at set rates and low pressure, on which clamp-on stem sensors are scored blind, with the leak rate unknown to the person reading them, against readings by EPA Method 21 with a calibrated analyzer.

Why it is still open

A blind test of continuous methane monitors at Colorado State University's METEC test site, published in 2024 by Chiemezie Ilonze, Daniel Zimmerle and colleagues, hid leaks at points such as valve packing, but scored whole-site monitors: the best four of nine detected 90% of leaks only from about 3.9 to 6.2 kg of methane an hour, far above a single stem leak. Emerson says its products can monitor valve packing, relief valves and steam traps for fugitive emission events, but the page gives no detection limit.

pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govemerson.com

Built with what exists

Low-cost methane sensors such as Figaro's TGS2611; mass flow controllers, such as Alicat's, to set each leak rate; a portable analyzer that meets Method 21, rented; a Raspberry Pi to log readings; a fume hood or well-ventilated room.

  1. First step

    Build one leaking-stem fixture with a mass flow controller and log one low-cost sensor beside a borrowed Method 21 analyzer at three leak rates.

  2. Done looks like

    At least four sensors tested at six leak rates spanning a thousandfold range, 20 blind repeats each; the rate each sensor detects 90% of the time, in grams an hour and in Method 21 ppm, its false alarms over 100 hours with no leak, and all raw data published.