BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Turnaround management

Deciding the scope

Deciding the scope means choosing which jobs go into a turnaround, which can be done while the unit runs, and how long the unit can run before the next one.

4

Milestones achieved, from 1996 to 2016.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

1

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1996

    Inspection ranked by risk

    In 1993 the American Petroleum Institute (API) started a project, sponsored by 23 companies including Amoco, Exxon, Shell, Chevron and Saudi Aramco, to rank equipment for inspection by the chance and the consequence of its failure. This is risk-based inspection (RBI). The group published its Base Resource Document in October 1996, and API released RP 580 on the method in 2002. RBI lists are now a main input to turnaround scope.

    inspectioneering.com

    Credit

    API and its sponsor group; history as told by Lynne Kaley of Pinnacle

  2. 1999

    A job that should have waited

    On 23 February 1999 workers at Tosco's Avon refinery in Martinez, California, replaced corroded naphtha piping 112 feet up a fractionator tower while the tower kept running above 500°F. The unit operator had argued for shutting down first, but a maintenance supervisor decided to go ahead. Naphtha sprayed out of the open pipe and ignited, killing four workers. The CSB, the US Chemical Safety Board, told the refinery to write a protocol for deciding when a job needs a shutdown.

    LessonSome repairs belong in a shutdown, and the choice should not rest with one supervisor under time pressure.

    csb.govcsb.gov

    Credit

    CSB investigation, report March 2001

  3. 2000

    The examiner sets the interval

    The UK's Pressure Systems Safety Regulations came into force on 21 February 2000. A pressure system may not be run without a written scheme of examination, drawn up or certified by a competent person, that sets the nature and frequency of each examination. That scheme decides which vessels must be opened in a turnaround and how often.

    legislation.gov.uklegislation.gov.uk

    Credit

    UK government

  4. 2016

    Scope growth measured

    Shawn Hansen and Brett Schroeder of AP-Networks, from a database of more than 1,350 turnarounds, reported that the work list grows on average 19% between scope freeze, the date the list is meant to close, and the shutdown itself, against 7% for the best quarter of turnarounds.

    digitalrefining.com

    Credit

    AP-Networks (Asset Performance Networks)

Watch for

  1. Open code for risk ranking

    An unofficial Python package for the API RP 581 risk-based inspection calculations, published on GitHub in October 2026, says it has 509 calculations traced to 861 sections of the standard. Its author calls it "software-verified" and states that outside evaluation is out of the project's scope.

    Achieved whenan inspection engineer outside the project runs the standard's worked examples, or a commercial RBI program's results, through it and publishes the match.

    github.com

    Claimed by

    GitHub user lyullee, October 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Run or wait, a casebook

    A public casebook of at least 200 maintenance jobs taken from published accident reports, each coded for whether it was done on a running unit or in a shutdown, whether the equipment could be isolated and drained, and what happened. Then a written set of rules, and an AI model that applies them, that flags jobs which should wait for a shutdown.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Run or wait, a casebook

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public casebook of at least 200 maintenance jobs taken from published accident reports, each coded for whether it was done on a running unit or in a shutdown, whether the equipment could be isolated and drained, and what happened. Then a written set of rules, and an AI model that applies them, that flags jobs which should wait for a shutdown.

Why it is still open

After Tosco in 1999 the CSB asked for a written protocol for shutdown decisions, but the protocols plants wrote are internal. A search found no public casebook or tool for this choice.

csb.gov

Built with what exists

CSB reports and the French accident database ARIA, both public; a spreadsheet; an AI model that reads long documents (see the Note "Seven more flagged").

  1. First step

    Code the 20 CSB investigations that mention work on a running unit, with the fields above, and ask one retired operator to check them.

  2. Done looks like

    200 coded cases published, and on 50 held-back cases the tool agrees with two experienced operators at least as often as the operators agree with each other.