BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Education / Trade schools and vocational training

Testing and credentials

How a trade's skills are examined and certified: written and practical tests, national qualifications, the frameworks that compare them, and credit for skills learned at work.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1879 to 2025.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1879

    National exams for trades

    In 1879 the new City and Guilds of London Institute took over the technological examinations that the Society of Arts had run since 1873. Its examinations department registered and inspected technical classes and held yearly exams in the subjects taught, so workers in different towns sat the same papers, and by 1887 it held exams overseas, starting in New South Wales.

    atom.aim25.comtechnicaleducationmatters.org

    Credit

    City and Guilds of London Institute, set up in 1878 by the Corporation of the City of London and 16 livery companies

  2. 1952

    One exam across provinces

    At Canada's first National Conference on Apprenticeship in Trades and Industries, in Ottawa in 1952, delegates recommended that the provinces and the federal government analyse skilled trades together. That work became the Interprovincial Standards Red Seal Program. Most provinces and territories now use the Red Seal exam as the final certification exam in its trades, and a pass adds a Red Seal endorsement to the provincial certificate, which the program says eases moving between provinces.

    red-seal.cared-seal.ca

    Credit

    Canada's provincial, territorial and federal governments, through the Canadian Council of Directors of Apprenticeship

  3. 2002

    Experience earns a diploma

    Since 2002 France's validation des acquis de l'expérience (VAE), validation of learning from experience, has given adults a third route to a recognized qualification beside school and apprenticeship: a jury judges a file built from their work and decides on the award. The government's VAE service counts more than 400,000 people who have earned a diploma this way since 2002. A 2022 reform created a public VAE service with one online platform, which listed 2,042 qualifications on 12 November 2026.

    vae.gouv.fr

    Credit

    the French state; France VAE, the public service under the Ministry of Labour

  4. 2008

    One ladder for qualifications

    The European Qualifications Framework (EQF), set up in 2008 and revised in 2017, describes eight levels by learning outcomes, meaning what a person knows, understands and can do. Each country maps its own qualification levels onto it in a referencing report, so a trade certificate from one country can be read against the same eight steps as one from another. Besides the EU member states, 11 countries work towards it, among them Norway, Switzerland and Türkiye.

    europass.europa.eu

    Credit

    the European Union and the national bodies that reference their frameworks to it

  5. 2020

    Germany restores the master rule

    A 2004 reform of Germany's Crafts Code ended the rule that a business in 53 trades must be run by someone who has passed the master craftsman's exam. The federal government later reported that from 2003 to 2016 apprentice numbers fell about 36% in the freed trades against 27% in trades that kept the rule, and passed master's exams fell about 55% against 17%. From 14 February 2020 the rule returned for 12 trades, among them tile, slab and mosaic laying.

    LessonIn Germany most apprentices train in master-led firms, so dropping the master's exam also thinned out the places where the trade was taught.

    dserver.bundestag.deihk.de

    Credit

    the German Bundestag and federal government

  6. 2025

    Counting 1.85 million credentials

    Credential Engine, a US nonprofit that publishes credential data in an open format, counted at least 738,428 unique credentials in the United States in 2019, 1,076,358 in 2022 and at least 1.85 million in its 2025 count, from degrees to industry certifications, apprenticeships and digital badges, offered by more than 134,000 providers.

    LessonThe number of credentials has grown faster than the means to compare them, which is why the count's authors push for describing every credential in one open data language.

    credentialengine.orgcredentialengine.orgcredentialengine.org

    Credit

    Credential Engine

Watch for

  1. Tests at any stage

    England is replacing end-point assessment, the independent test at the end of an apprenticeship, with "apprenticeship assessment", which can take place at any stage. Employers will confirm the behaviours an apprentice shows at work, training providers may mark some parts, and assessment plans are being rewritten to be shorter. The government says this answers feedback that end-point assessment was "overly disproportionate, burdensome, and time-consuming" while keeping rigour; Ofqual, which regulates assessment for more than 580 occupational standards, is writing new rules.

    Achieved whenOfqual or an independent evaluator compares trade apprenticeships assessed under the new plans with those under the old, for example by having a second marker re-mark samples, and publishes whether the standard held.

    gov.uk

    Claimed by

    the UK Department for Work and Pensions and Skills England, October 2025 (updated August 2026)

Open

  1. 01

    Filmed tests, same verdict

    A recording kit and protocol for a trade school's own practical tests, such as a carpentry joint, a copper pipe assembly or wiring on a practice board that is never connected to power, filmed by three fixed cameras and one head camera. Each performance is then marked by one assessor in the room and by two assessors who see only the video, using the same marking sheet.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Guess the level, then check

    A test of whether AI models can read a trade qualification's published learning outcomes and place it on the EQF's eight levels, scored against the level each country assigned it, plus a list of trade qualifications where the model and the official level are two or more levels apart, for people to review.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Filmed tests, same verdict

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A recording kit and protocol for a trade school's own practical tests, such as a carpentry joint, a copper pipe assembly or wiring on a practice board that is never connected to power, filmed by three fixed cameras and one head camera. Each performance is then marked by one assessor in the room and by two assessors who see only the video, using the same marking sheet.

Why it is still open

Studies of marking from video come from clinical skills. In a 2025 Dublin City University study, 12 nursing assessors thought aloud while marking four videos; video reduced their guesswork but narrowed their field of view and, for some, weakened their trust in the test. Searches found no published comparison of video and in-room marking for a trade practical, the kind of evidence a school would need before accepting filmed tests for remote candidates or for recognizing an experienced worker's skills.

rpajournal.com

Built with what exists

Three phones or action cameras on tripods and one head-mounted camera; OBS Studio or a video editor to put the four views side by side; the school's existing marking sheets; Python with scikit-learn to compute Cohen's kappa, a measure of agreement beyond chance.

  1. First step

    With the instructor's and learners' consent, film five practice tests at one college and have a second instructor mark them from the video.

  2. Done looks like

    60 performances in at least two trades, each marked live and by two video assessors who do not see the live mark; agreement on pass or fail and on each criterion published with kappa values, plus a list of the criteria that video could not judge.

Open 02 · the brief

Guess the level, then check

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A test of whether AI models can read a trade qualification's published learning outcomes and place it on the EQF's eight levels, scored against the level each country assigned it, plus a list of trade qualifications where the model and the official level are two or more levels apart, for people to review.

Why it is still open

Since 23 January 2026 the qualifications that countries publish to Europass's Qualification Dataset Register can be downloaded as open data, per country or per dataset, or queried through a SPARQL endpoint. The nearest AI work found, a December 2025 paper by Stylianos Saroglou and colleagues, links job advertisements to ESCO and EQF; it does not place qualifications on levels from their own outcomes. A search of arXiv found no level-placement benchmark.

europass.europa.euarxiv.org

Built with what exists

The register's JSON-LD downloads or SPARQL endpoint; Python with rdflib; the EQF level descriptors; AI models through their public interfaces, including models that return a probability for each answer in a fixed list (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass").

  1. First step

    Download one country's dataset and check that each trade qualification carries both its EQF level and the text of its learning outcomes.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 1,000 trade qualifications from at least 10 countries; for each model, the share placed at the official level and within one level; the disagreement list reviewed by two people who know national frameworks; data and code published.