Industries / Government, education and community / Education / Trade schools and vocational training
Accreditation and funding
Who approves trade schools and their programs, and how public money, levies and loans pay for training.
6
Milestones achieved, from 1917 to 2025.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1917
Federal money for trade teachers
The US Smith-Hughes Act of 23 February 1917 set aside money every year, paid to the states, toward the salaries of teachers of agriculture, trade, home economics and industrial subjects and toward training such teachers. It created a Federal Board for Vocational Education to run the program.
Credit
the US Congress; the bill, S. 703, was introduced by Senator Hoke Smith of Georgia
1942
Industry pays for its schools
A Brazilian decree-law of 22 January 1942 created SENAI, the National Service for Industrial Apprenticeship, to organize and run apprenticeship schools for industrial workers across the country. The National Confederation of Industry was to run it, and industrial firms had to pay a monthly contribution of two mil-réis per worker, 20% more for firms with more than 500 workers. SENAI says it has trained more than 92 million people since.
Credit
the Brazilian government of Getúlio Vargas, with the education minister Gustavo Capanema; the National Confederation of Industry
2017
Australia ends a loan scheme
In 2012 Australia widened VET FEE-HELP, a government loan that paid vocational course fees to the provider. By the education department's count, students using it rose from about 55,000 in 2012 to more than 272,000 in 2015, loans from A$325 million to A$2.9 billion, and average tuition fees from A$4,060 in 2009 to A$14,018 in 2015, while dropout stayed high and completion low; some providers and brokers offered gifts to sign students up. The Australian National Audit Office found the 2012 design "weighted heavily towards supporting growth" without a matching quality and accountability framework. VET Student Loans replaced the scheme from 1 January 2017.
LessonPaying providers for each loan-funded enrolment, without checks on what was taught, rewarded signing students up rather than training them.
Credit
the Australian Government; the Australian National Audit Office
2022
An accreditor loses recognition
A US career school's students can get federal aid only if the school's accreditor is recognized by the Department of Education. The department first withdrew recognition of the Accrediting Council for Independent Colleges and Schools (ACICS) on 12 December 2016, largely over its oversight of the for-profit chains Corinthian Colleges and ITT Technical Institute, in the account of NASFAA, the financial aid administrators' association. A court overturned that decision in March 2018 and the department reinstated ACICS that November. On 19 August 2022 the department ended its recognition for good, finding it no longer a reliable authority on the quality of the training it accredited; its 27 schools, with about 3,800 students, had 18 months to find another accreditor.
LessonRemoving an accreditor took six years and one reversal, and its schools kept federal aid in the meantime.
Credit
the US Department of Education and its advisory committee, NACIQI
2024
Training accounts tightened
France gives each worker a personal training account, the compte personnel de formation (CPF), spent since 2019 through the Mon Compte Formation app. Fraud followed: a deputy's question to the government, citing the Journal du Dimanche, said the Caisse des Dépôts, which runs the scheme, had paid more than €16 million to just 23 sham training firms. From 25 October 2022 users had to log in through FranceConnect+, a stronger identity check; a law of 19 December 2022 banned cold-calling to sell CPF courses; in 2023 the Caisse removed more than 1,065 training firms from the platform after checks, which the government says saved more than €160 million; and from 2 May 2024 account holders must pay a fixed share of each course themselves, €150 in 2026.
LessonAn app that let anyone spend public training money in a few taps also let fraudsters do it, and identity checks, a ban on cold-calling and a co-payment had to follow.
Credit
the French Ministry of Labour and the Caisse des Dépôts
2025
Audit finds training records unreliable
India's Pradhan Mantri Kaushal Vikas Yojana (PMKVY), launched in July 2015, pays for short skills courses and certification; its first three phases, to 2022, had an outlay of about ₹14,450 crore and a target of 1.32 crore (13.2 million) candidates. The Comptroller and Auditor General's audit, laid before Parliament on 18 December 2025, found candidates enrolled without regard to the age, education and experience rules, no policy for keeping photo or video evidence that training took place, weak checks on the identities and accounts of trainers, assessors and candidates, and unreliable documents in the strand that certified existing workers' skills. The ministry says it has since added Aadhaar-based identity checks and a year of tracking after certification.
LessonA scheme that pays for each certified trainee needs its own proof that the training happened, or an auditor cannot tell training from paperwork.
Credit
the Comptroller and Auditor General of India (audit); the Ministry of Skill Development and Entrepreneurship (scheme)
Watch for
Pell grants for short courses
A US law of July 2025, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (also called the Working Families Tax Cuts Act), opened Pell Grants, the main federal grant for low-income students, to short "eligible workforce programs" of 150 to 599 clock hours. A state's governor must certify each program, which must have run for at least a year and lead to an industry-recognized credential, and programs lose eligibility unless at least 70% of students finish and they pass the law's outcome tests. The Department of Education published its final rule on 19 May 2026 and began taking applications for program approval on 1 July 2026.
Achieved whenThe department or an outside evaluator publishes how many trade programs were approved, how many students received the grant and what share finished.
Claimed by
the US Department of Education, May 2026
Open
01
Check the course listings
An open checker that reads the trade course listings on France's Mon Compte Formation and flags those that break the scheme's rules or stand far out of line: a certification no longer in France compétences' registers, hours or prices far from other providers' for the same certification, or promises the rules forbid. It is tested on a sample that two people have labelled by hand.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Test a funding rule first
An open simulation of a training market in which learners, providers and brokers respond to the way public money is paid out, tuned on one past funding change and then tested, unchanged, on another.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Check the course listings
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open checker that reads the trade course listings on France's Mon Compte Formation and flags those that break the scheme's rules or stand far out of line: a certification no longer in France compétences' registers, hours or prices far from other providers' for the same certification, or promises the rules forbid. It is tested on a sample that two people have labelled by hand.
Why it is still open
The Caisse des Dépôts publishes the full catalogue every week as open data, 200,153 listings on 20 November 2026, each with its objectives, content, hours and price. Its own checks removed more than 1,065 training firms in 2023, and in July 2026 it said it would make more use of AI against fraud, but its methods and error rates are not public. A GitHub search found only a 2022 scraper and descriptive analyses of the catalogue.
Built with what exists
The catalogue's open API at opendata.caissedesdepots.fr; France compétences' register of certifications on data.gouv.fr; Python with pandas; a language model to read each listing's text against the rules (see the Note "Seven more flagged").
First step
Download one week's catalogue, keep the building and electrical certifications, and chart hours and price per certification to find the outliers.
Done looks like
500 listings in building, electrical and mechanical trades labelled by two reviewers; precision and recall published for each rule, with at least 80% of the checker's flags confirmed by both reviewers; flagged listings, labels and code public.
Open 02 · the brief
Test a funding rule first
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open simulation of a training market in which learners, providers and brokers respond to the way public money is paid out, tuned on one past funding change and then tested, unchanged, on another.
Why it is still open
Agent-based models, in which many simulated people each follow simple rules, exist for choices about university, such as Jean-Paul Daemen and Silvia Leoni's 2025 model of Dutch higher education, which tests grants and loans. They model students, not training providers, and searches found none checked against a past funding change in vocational training. Australia's VET FEE-HELP expansion (see Achieved) and France's 2024 CPF co-payment give before-and-after numbers to test against.
Built with what exists
Mesa, an open-source Python library for agent-based models; the Australian education department's VET FEE-HELP figures given to the Senate; Mon Compte Formation's open data on courses bought; Python with pandas.
First step
Rebuild the 2012 to 2015 VET FEE-HELP series from the department's Senate answers and download Mon Compte Formation's monthly course counts for 2023 to 2025.
Done looks like
A model tuned on Australia's 2012 to 2015 figures that, without changes, predicts the direction and size of the change in monthly CPF course purchases in the 12 months after 2 May 2024 to within 25%, with code and data published.