BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Education / Trade schools and vocational training

Programs and curriculum

Deciding what a trade program teaches, in what order and for how long, and keeping that content up to date as the trade changes.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1881 to 2023.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1881

    Schools in place of masters

    Richard Tylden Auchmuty opened the New York Trade Schools to teach trades in workshops, first in evening classes for young men already at work and later in day classes, one of them a course in steam and hot water fitting. Writing in 1892, he said attendance began at thirty and had reached five to six hundred each winter, and that the schools "encountered the hostility of the trade-unions", which then required apprenticeships of at least four years.

    LessonA school that shortens the way into a trade can meet resistance from those who control the existing way in.

    archive.orgarchive.org

    Credit

    Richard Tylden Auchmuty

  2. 1950

    India's craftsman courses

    India introduced its Craftsmen Training Scheme in 1950. It runs courses of six months to two years in Industrial Training Institutes (ITIs), which state governments run, and the national Directorate General of Training lists 169 trades, 86 of them in engineering. In May 2025 the Prime Minister's Office counted 14,615 ITIs with 1.44 million (14.40 lakh) students enrolled.

    niti.gov.indgt.gov.inpmindia.gov.in

    Credit

    Government of India; Directorate General of Training

  3. 1966

    Expert workers draw the chart

    DACUM, short for "Developing A Curriculum", began in 1966 at the Women's Job Corps center in Clinton, Iowa, in work by Canada's Department of Manpower and Immigration and the General Learning Corporation of New York. Nova Scotia NewStart took it up in 1968, and Holland College in Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island, adopted it in 1969 for all its programs. In a two-day workshop a trained facilitator guides 5 to 12 expert workers as they list the duties and tasks of their own job, and that chart becomes the base of the course. By 1997 Singapore's Institute of Technical Education had used it to write more than 130 skills standards.

    files.eric.ed.gov

    Credit

    Robert E. Adams (Nova Scotia NewStart); Donald Glendenning and Larry Coffin (Holland College); Robert E. Norton (Ohio State University)

  4. 2011

    Narrow skills age faster

    Eric Hanushek, Ludger Woessmann and Lei Zhang compared adults with vocational and with general schooling in 18 countries, using the International Adult Literacy Survey. The early advantage of vocational schooling in finding work shrank with age and turned into a disadvantage later in life, most strongly in countries that rely on apprenticeships.

    LessonTraining tied closely to one job's current tools can leave people less able to adapt when technology changes, so programs need general skills as well.

    nber.org

    Credit

    Hanushek, Woessmann and Zhang (NBER working paper 17504)

  5. 2020

    A new course, many leave

    England began teaching T Levels in September 2020: two-year technical courses after age 16 that combine classroom learning with an industry placement of more than 315 hours. In a July 2023 review commissioned by the Department for Education, Ofsted found that "many leave before the end of the course" and that many students "reported being misled and ill informed" about the content, some having expected more practical work.

    LessonA new course needs enough placements, and students who know what it involves, before it opens.

    gov.uk

    Credit

    UK Department for Education (T Levels); Ofsted (review)

  6. 2022

    Equal standing in law

    China revised its Vocational Education Law for the first time since 1996. The revision, in force from 1 May 2022, states that vocational education is as important as general education and asks companies to take part in it. Reporting the Ministry of Education, CGTN put the system at 11,300 vocational schools with 30.88 million students.

    news.cgtn.com

    Credit

    Standing Committee of the National People's Congress

  7. 2023

    A curriculum years behind

    NITI Aayog, the Indian government's policy think tank, reported in January 2023 that ITI principals said the tools taught "are years or sometimes decades old", giving HTML taught where the market uses Python, and that "the curriculum is years behind". Citing the skills ministry, it added that only 15% of more than 95,000 ITI instructors had been trained under the national scheme for instructors.

    LessonWhen approving a new course and buying its equipment take years, what is taught falls behind the trade.

    niti.gov.in

    Credit

    NITI Aayog, Skill Development and Employment Vertical

Watch for

  1. Humanoid robot majors for 2027

    China's Ministry of Education added 27 vocational majors in July 2026, among them humanoid robot engineering technology, digital twin engineering technology and vehicle-to-everything communication technology, with the first students enrolling in 2027. It says 169 majors have been added since the list was first issued in 2021, about 11% of the total, and a ministry official said fields such as these create demand "faster than the typical three-to-four-year talent training cycle can meet".

    Achieved whenThe first classes enroll and an outside review reports what they teach and on what equipment.

    chinadaily.com.cn

    Claimed by

    China's Ministry of Education, July 2026

Open

  1. 01

    AI against a DACUM panel

    A test of how close an AI model comes to the chart of duties and tasks that a DACUM panel of expert workers writes for its own job. For ten trades with a published panel chart, have two or three AI models draft a chart from the job title and public documents only, match their tasks to the panel's, and have a second group of practitioners judge the tasks that each side missed.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    How fast curricula catch up

    A public timeline of when new technology first appears in national trade curricula. For about ten technologies (heat pumps, low-flammability refrigerants, high-voltage systems in electric cars, home batteries, collaborative robots, metal 3D printing) and at least five countries, find the first official curriculum version that requires each one, and set its date beside a stated reference date, such as the first safety standard for that technology.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

AI against a DACUM panel

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A test of how close an AI model comes to the chart of duties and tasks that a DACUM panel of expert workers writes for its own job. For ten trades with a published panel chart, have two or three AI models draft a chart from the job title and public documents only, match their tasks to the panel's, and have a second group of practitioners judge the tasks that each side missed.

Why it is still open

A DACUM chart takes a trained facilitator and 5 to 12 expert workers for two days. AI drafting tools have appeared on GitHub, such as Hsham Jawad's DACUM Live Pro, whose page offers "AI-Powered DACUM Generation" of duties and tasks from occupation details, and a "Digital DACUM Frontend" with an "AI Interface" (2026), but neither publishes a comparison with a real panel's chart, and searches of the web, arXiv and GitHub in November 2026 found no such comparison.

files.eric.ed.govhshamjawad.github.iogithub.com

Built with what exists

Published DACUM charts, such as those in ERIC from the 1980s and 1990s (for example ED368988) and recent charts shared by the colleges that ran the panels; AI models such as Claude or Gemini through their public interfaces; an embedding model to pair similar task statements; Python; two or three trade instructors per chart to judge the pairs.

  1. First step

    Take one published trade chart from ERIC, have one model draft its own from the job title, and pair the tasks by hand.

  2. Done looks like

    Ten trades, each with the panel's chart, the AI drafts and a scored match table (the share of panel tasks each model found, and the share of model tasks the second group judged real but missing from the panel's chart), published with prompts and code.

Open 02 · the brief

How fast curricula catch up

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public timeline of when new technology first appears in national trade curricula. For about ten technologies (heat pumps, low-flammability refrigerants, high-voltage systems in electric cars, home batteries, collaborative robots, metal 3D printing) and at least five countries, find the first official curriculum version that requires each one, and set its date beside a stated reference date, such as the first safety standard for that technology.

Why it is still open

Curricula are revised often, but the delay is not measured. Germany's Federal Institute for Vocational Education and Training (BIBB) says it revised 138 training regulations between 2013 and 2024, and China's Ministry of Education says new fields create demand faster than its three-to-four-year training cycle, but neither publishes how long a technology waited before it was taught. Searches in November 2026 for a measured lag found none.

bibb.dechinadaily.com.cn

Built with what exists

Curriculum records that software can read, with versions and dates: Skills England's apprenticeship standards API, which returns 2,068 standard records with version numbers and full lists of knowledge, skills and behaviours, and Australia's training.gov.au API; Germany's published training regulations; India's ITI syllabi from the Directorate General of Training; an AI model to search the texts, with every hit checked by a person (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); Python and a public Git repository.

skillsengland.education.gov.uktraining.gov.au

  1. First step

    Download every version of England's standards from the Skills England API and list the first version of each that mentions heat pumps; 24 of the records returned in November 2026 mention them.

  2. Done looks like

    A table of at least 10 technologies by 5 countries in which each cell gives the first curriculum version that requires the technology, its date and a link to the text, or "not yet", checked by a second reader, with the lag in years from the reference date.