BRENNEN

Industries / Mining and materials / Steel and metals / Tool and die

Heat treatment and coating

Heat treatment hardens the steel of a die or mold by heating and cooling it under control; surface treatments and coatings then add a thin, harder skin that resists wear and sticking.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1868 to 1998.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1868

    Steel that hardens in air

    Until then, tool steel was made hard by quenching it in water. Robert Mushet's steel, alloyed with a large share of tungsten, hardened when it cooled from yellow heat in a draft of air, and an 1869 account in The Engineer said it should "under no circumstances" be quenched. Grace's Guide says that between 1880 and 1900 many steelmakers came to produce such "self" or "air-hardening" steels.

    gracesguide.co.uk

    Credit

    Robert Forester Mushet; made in Sheffield by Samuel Osborn from 1872

  2. 1924

    Hardening the skin with ammonia

    Nitriding hardens the surface of a steel part by diffusing nitrogen into it from a gas. Adolf Fry's US patent for Fried. Krupp, filed in 1921 and granted in 1924, hardened alloy steel by heating it in a stream of ammonia, kept below the temperature at which the steel's structure changes. In one example the surface hardness rose from 298 to 500 on the patent's scale. Nitriding is now among the most common surface treatments for dies, and dies that stamp advanced high-strength steel are often nitrided before a hard coating goes on, a "duplex" treatment, according to Ohio State University's metal forming research center.

    patents.google.comthefabricator.com

    Credit

    Adolf Fry, Fried. Krupp AG

  3. 1970

    Tool steel made from powder

    When a large ingot of highly alloyed steel cools slowly, the alloying elements separate and form large carbides, hard particles that make the steel brittle. In powder metallurgy, molten steel is sprayed into a fine powder that freezes almost at once, and the powder is pressed into a solid billet, so the carbides stay small and even. The metallurgist Larrin Thomas writes that Crucible Steel first commercialized tool steel made this way and announced commercial-scale production in December 1970. Crucible's later 10V grade used vanadium carbides for wear resistance with enough toughness, and later grades from Uddeholm and Böhler follow the same idea.

    knifesteelnerds.com

    Credit

    Crucible Steel (Crucible Particle Metallurgy, CPM)

  4. 1970s

    Carbide skins from borax

    In the Toyota Diffusion (TD) process, a steel tool is dipped in molten borax at about 1,050 °C that carries vanadium, niobium or chromium. These combine with carbon from the steel to grow a carbide layer harder than 3,000 on the Vickers scale, and dies can be hardened straight from the bath. Papers on the process by T. Arai and colleagues at Toyota Central Research & Development Laboratories in Nagoya date from 1975. The Open University lists hot and cold forging, die casting and plastic molding among its uses, and Ohio State's metal forming center names it, as thermal diffusion, with PVD and CVD as the three coatings typically used on dies for advanced high-strength steel.

    link.springer.comopen.eduthefabricator.com

    Credit

    T. Arai and colleagues, Toyota Central R&D Labs

  5. 1977

    Titanium nitride on forming tools

    Physical vapor deposition (PVD) lays a thin ceramic layer on a tool inside a vacuum chamber. Oerlikon Balzers says its first trials coating forming tools with titanium nitride (TiN) succeeded in 1977, and that BALINIT A, its first TiN coating, went on sale a year later. Ohio State's metal forming center names nitrides such as TiN and CrN among the most common die coatings. It adds that chemical vapor deposition (CVD) runs hot enough to soften a die, which then needs hardening again and can distort.

    LessonA thin, brittle coating needs hard steel under it, so dies are hardened or nitrided before coating, and the coating method is chosen so that its heat does not undo the hardening.

    oerlikon.comthefabricator.com

    Credit

    Balzers, now Oerlikon Balzers

  6. 1998

    Faster quench, longer die life

    Die casting dies of H13 hot-work steel wear out by thermal fatigue, fine cracks that grow from repeated heating and cooling. In work for the US Department of Energy with the North American Die Casting Association (NADCA), Case Western Reserve University found that H13 quenched faster resisted these cracks best. It also found that large blocks quenched faster distorted more, and that interrupting the gas quench to let the surface and core temperatures even out cut distortion by 30 to 40%. The project's findings went into NADCA's published H13 acceptance criteria and heat treatment procedures, which call for a minimum quench rate of 50 °F (28 °C) per minute, checked on the furnace chart.

    LessonThe quench that gives the longest die life also warps the die most, and the answer was a fast quench with a pause, not a slow one.

    osti.govengineering.case.edufoundrymag.com

    Credit

    John F. Wallace and David Schwam, Case Western Reserve University; NADCA; US Department of Energy

Watch for

  1. Steel for giant casting dies

    Kind & Co. of Wiehl, Germany, part of GMH Gruppe, launched MT1, a tool steel for high-pressure die casting dies, including dies for giga-castings, single castings that replace many welded car-body parts. It says MT1 has a "significantly reduced risk of bainite formation during heat treatment", bainite being an unwanted structure in thick sections of a die, and that this gives better dimensional stability and less rework. It published no test figures.

    Achieved whena die caster or an independent lab publishes die life or heat treatment results for MT1 dies against H13 dies of the same design.

    gmh-gruppe.de

    Claimed by

    Kind & Co., January 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Predict how far dies distort

    A public test of how much die steel blocks change shape when hardened, and an open simulation tuned to predict it. Ten H13 blocks of two shapes are measured, hardened by a commercial vacuum heat treater at two gas quench pressures with thermocouples in place, and measured again. The scans, furnace charts and hardness readings are published.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Check furnace charts automatically

    A program that reads a heat treater's furnace chart for a die, whether a data file, a PDF or a photo of a paper chart, and checks it against the buyer's rules: preheat holds, time and temperature at the hardening heat, and the quench rate. For H13 die casting dies that rate is at least 50 °F per minute between the surface's hardening temperature and 1,000 °F. The program returns pass or fail and marks the evidence on the chart.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Predict how far dies distort

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test of how much die steel blocks change shape when hardened, and an open simulation tuned to predict it. Ten H13 blocks of two shapes are measured, hardened by a commercial vacuum heat treater at two gas quench pressures with thermocouples in place, and measured again. The scans, furnace charts and hardness readings are published.

Why it is still open

Models now match some measurements, but each study tests its own blocks and keeps the data. Case Western's 1998 study for the US Department of Energy found that its models matched the pattern of distortion but that "the magnitude of the predicted distortion and residual stresses does not match well the measured values". In 2018 Jung and colleagues reported that their simulation of a 200 × 150 × 70 mm tool steel block quenched in nitrogen agreed well with their experiments, and that holding the quench at 500 °C cut distortion by 30%; their measurements are not published as open data. No public, machine-readable set of before-and-after measurements for hardened die steel was found.

osti.govlink.springer.com

Built with what exists

a commercial vacuum heat treater with high-pressure gas quenching that supplies a furnace chart; a coordinate measuring machine (CMM) service or a structured-light 3D scanner; an open finite element program such as code_aster or CalculiX for the heat flow and stresses; Python for the comparison.

  1. First step

    Have two H13 test blocks machined, scan them, and ask heat treaters for quotes to harden them with surface and core thermocouples attached and the furnace chart supplied.

  2. Done looks like

    Ten blocks with published scans and furnace charts, and an open simulation whose predicted distortion at 50 marked points is within 25% of the measured value on at least eight of the ten blocks, rerun by a second group with the same result.

Open 02 · the brief

Check furnace charts automatically

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A program that reads a heat treater's furnace chart for a die, whether a data file, a PDF or a photo of a paper chart, and checks it against the buyer's rules: preheat holds, time and temperature at the hardening heat, and the quench rate. For H13 die casting dies that rate is at least 50 °F per minute between the surface's hardening temperature and 1,000 °F. The program returns pass or fail and marks the evidence on the chart.

Why it is still open

The die buyer reads the chart by eye. Mark L. Purtee, writing in Foundry Management & Technology in 2017, said "the challenge for the customer is determining whether a proper heat treatment has been performed" and listed what the chart must show. Aerospace software checks quench data inside its own furnace monitoring against aerospace specifications, but no tool was found that reads any heat treater's chart and checks it against die casting criteria.

foundrymag.comifactoryapp.com

Built with what exists

Python with pandas for logged data; WebPlotDigitizer or OpenCV to pull curves from chart images; a vision-language AI model to read chart labels, scales and units; NADCA's published acceptance criteria as the rule set.

  1. First step

    Collect five furnace charts from one die shop's past jobs, write the quench-rate check for charts that come as data files, and compare its verdicts with the shop's.

  2. Done looks like

    Run on 50 real furnace charts from die shops and heat treaters, the program agrees with an experienced reviewer's pass or fail on at least 48 and names the failing step in every failed chart. The code is public.