BRENNEN

Industries / Retail, hospitality and personal services / Retail and e-commerce / Thrift and resale

What does not sell

This is what happens to donated and collected goods that shops and websites cannot sell: dealers sort and press them into bales, ship them abroad, cut them into wiping rags, or dump and burn what is left.

6

Milestones achieved, from 2000 to 2026.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2000

    The export trail traced

    In Salaula, published by the University of Chicago Press in 2000, Karen Tranberg Hansen followed clothes donated to charity in the West through salvage houses in North America and Europe, where they are sorted and pressed into bales, to markets in Zambia. Salaula is a Bemba word meaning "to rummage through a pile."

    LessonClothes a charity cannot sell become a traded export, and their second life depends on buyers far away.

    ideas.repec.orgnationalhumanitiescenter.org

    Credit

    Karen Tranberg Hansen

  2. 2018

    A ban meets US tariffs

    The East African Community planned in 2015 to ban imports of used clothing and shoes, and in 2016 said it would phase the ban in by 2019. In March 2017 SMART, the US trade body of used-clothing sorters and exporters, petitioned the US government, and Kenya, Tanzania and Uganda later revised their policies. Rwanda kept what the US Trade Representative called prohibitive tariffs on used clothing and shoes, and on 30 July 2018 the US suspended duty-free entry for all Rwandan apparel under the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), covering $1.5 million of imports in 2017.

    LessonCountries that receive unsold Western clothes have found it hard to stop the trade when exporting countries push back.

    ustr.gov

    Credit

    Office of the US Trade Representative; SMART; Government of Rwanda

  3. 2019

    Exports triple in two decades

    The European Environment Agency (EEA), using UN Comtrade trade data, found that exports of used textiles from the EU and UK rose from just over 550,000 tonnes in 2000 to almost 1.7 million tonnes in 2019, or 3.8 kg per person. In 2019, 46% went to Africa and 41% to Asia, and the average price had fallen to about €0.57 per kg.

    LessonThe EEA calls the fate of these exports "highly uncertain"; bales declared as worn clothing (trade code 6309) can contain rags.

    eea.europa.eu

    Credit

    European Environment Agency

  4. 2023

    Trackers follow returned clothes

    The Changing Markets Foundation hid AirTag trackers in 21 items handed to the take-back schemes of ten fashion brands, including H&M, Zara, Primark and Nike, in the UK, France, Belgium and Germany between August 2022 and July 2023. Seven items were destroyed, dumped or cut down for stuffing and cleaning cloths, one of them burned in a cement plant; several sat in warehouses for up to a year, and four reached the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Mauritania and Mali.

    LessonCheap trackers let outsiders check where collected clothes really go.

    changingmarkets.org

    Credit

    Changing Markets Foundation

  5. 2025

    A court orders a cleanup

    Used clothing enters Chile through the free-trade zone at Iquique, and what does not sell has been dumped and burned in the Atacama Desert near Alto Hospicio. In September 2025 Chile's First Environmental Court found significant environmental damage there and ordered the state to present, within six months, a plan to remove the waste, restore the land and prevent new dumping. Estimates of the pile's weight ranged from 11,000 to 59,000 tons, as reported by Grist in 2024.

    LessonWhen no one owns the unsold clothes, the cost of clearing them can fall on the country where they were dumped.

    economiasustentable.comgrist.org

    Credit

    First Environmental Court of Chile

  6. 2026

    Waste counts still disagree

    How much of a bale of imported clothing is waste is disputed. The Or Foundation, a nonprofit working in Accra's Kantamanto market, says about 15 million garments pass through the market each week and 40% of the clothing leaves it as waste. The Ghana Used Clothing Dealers Association put waste at under 5% of imports in May 2024. Market surveys run for the UN Environment Programme (UNEP) in November 2024 found 9.24% to 22.96% of the average bale unsold or waste. A 2026 study for UN Trade and Development (UNCTAD) and the UK government, with data from the US trade body SMART, surveyed 2,020 traders in Uganda and Tanzania covering 244,500 items and found 1.1% to 1.3% waste and 2.9% to 3.2% rags.

    LessonThe numbers differ in what they count, waste on opening a bale or clothing that never sells, and most rest on surveys of traders, not counts of opened bales.

    atmos.earthfashiondive.comunosd.un.orgsmepprogramme.org

    Credit

    The Or Foundation; Ghana Used Clothing Dealers Association; UNEP; Jennifer Wang and Richard Wang for UNCTAD

Watch for

  1. Zimbabwe bans used imports

    Zimbabwe's Statutory Instrument 59 of 2026, gazetted in March 2026, bans imports of second-hand clothes unless the government grants a permit, which it says it will issue only on conditions that keep the goods out of shops and markets; the government frames the ban as support for its textile makers.

    Achieved whentrade data reported by exporting countries show shipments of worn clothing to Zimbabwe falling, or an independent market survey finds bales no longer arriving.

    allafrica.comtextilevaluechain.in

    Claimed by

    Government of Zimbabwe, March 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Count the bale, in public

    A published counting method and an open dataset from real bales of used clothing as traders open them at Kantamanto in Accra and at a second market such as Owino in Kampala. Each item is photographed and classed as sellable, repairable, rag or waste using one written set of definitions, such as the East African Standard 356:2024 on second-hand clothing, with the bale's grade, weight, origin and price recorded.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Find gaps in trade data

    An open table, updated each year, comparing what each exporting country says it shipped under trade codes 6309 (worn clothing) and 6310 (rags) with what each importing country says it received, by weight and value, for the 50 largest routes since 2010, flagging re-export hubs and routes where the two sides differ by more than 20%.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Count the bale, in public

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A published counting method and an open dataset from real bales of used clothing as traders open them at Kantamanto in Accra and at a second market such as Owino in Kampala. Each item is photographed and classed as sellable, repairable, rag or waste using one written set of definitions, such as the East African Standard 356:2024 on second-hand clothing, with the bale's grade, weight, origin and price recorded.

Why it is still open

Published waste shares run from about 1% to 40%, and most rest on surveys of traders or estimates (the UNCTAD study, the UNEP surveys, the dealers' association, The Or Foundation). Fashion for Good's Project Rewear examined about 2,500 garments from bales imported to Kantamanto as wearable and found some damage on 86.5% of them, but damaged is not the same as unsellable, and its item records are not public. Searches found no public, item-by-item dataset of opened bales with photos that others could check.

smepprogramme.orgunosd.un.orgfashionforgood.com

Built with what exists

Phone cameras; a hanging scale; a fixed classification sheet; KoboToolbox or ODK Collect for offline data entry; a vision-language model to pre-sort photos, which people then check. The team works alongside traders opening their own bales, with their consent, and buys nothing.

  1. First step

    Ask one Kantamanto retailer, or the traders' association, to let the team record five bales as they are opened this month, and test the sheet.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 100 bales and 20,000 items across at least three grades and two markets, each item photographed, with the waste share per grade; a second team reclassifies a random 5% and the agreement is reported; data published under an open license.

Open 02 · the brief

Find gaps in trade data

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open table, updated each year, comparing what each exporting country says it shipped under trade codes 6309 (worn clothing) and 6310 (rags) with what each importing country says it received, by weight and value, for the 50 largest routes since 2010, flagging re-export hubs and routes where the two sides differ by more than 20%.

Why it is still open

The EEA warns that bales declared as worn clothing may contain rags and that the fate of exports is "highly uncertain." CEPII's BACI database reconciles what exporters and importers report into a single figure, weighting the more reliable reporter, so the gap itself is not shown. Searches found country pages of 6309 trade figures but no study of these gaps for used clothing.

eea.europa.eucepii.fr

Built with what exists

The UN Comtrade API (free key); CEPII BACI for comparison; Python and pandas; a public GitHub repository; Datawrapper or Observable for charts.

  1. First step

    Download 6309 and 6310 flows for 2019 to 2023 for Ghana, Kenya and Chile and their five largest suppliers, and compute the gaps.

  2. Done looks like

    Gap tables for the 50 largest routes from 2010 to 2024, published with their code; the three routes with the largest gaps sent to the national statistics office or customs authority concerned, with any reply published.