BRENNEN

Industries / Retail, hospitality and personal services / Retail and e-commerce / Thrift and resale

Online resale

Online resale is selling used goods through websites and apps: the seller photographs and describes an item, the site carries the payment, and the buyer collects it or waits for it in the post.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1995 to 2026.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1995

    An auction website opens

    Over Labor Day weekend in September 1995, Pierre Omidyar launched AuctionWeb, later renamed eBay, as a personal project from his home. The first item listed and sold was a broken laser pointer, bought by Mark Fraser. Anyone could now sell a used item to a stranger in another city without a shop.

    time.comebayinc.com

    Credit

    Pierre Omidyar

  2. 2000

    Ratings tied to real sales

    eBay let buyers and sellers rate each other with a +1, 0 or −1 and a line of text. From February 2000 a rating had to be tied to an actual sale between the two. Paul Resnick of the University of Michigan and Richard Zeckhauser of Harvard studied eBay's sales from February to June 1999: buyers rated sellers on 52.1% of items, and 99.1% of those ratings were positive.

    LessonRatings let strangers trust each other, but they run so positive that a few bad ratings carry most of the information.

    presnick.people.si.umich.edu

    Credit

    eBay; Paul Resnick and Richard Zeckhauser

  3. 2016

    Selling to the neighbors

    Facebook launched Marketplace on 3 October 2016 for adults in the US, UK, Australia and New Zealand, turning the buy-and-sell groups on its site into one place to browse and sell nearby. Facebook said more than 450 million people visited such groups each month; the figure is Facebook's own.

    about.fb.com

    Credit

    Facebook (now Meta)

  4. 2023

    Tax offices see sellers

    From 1 January 2023, an EU directive known as DAC7 requires online marketplaces to report to tax authorities each seller who makes 30 or more sales, or more than €2,000, in a year. In the US, the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 lowered the threshold at which payment apps and marketplaces must file a Form 1099-K to $600. The IRS delayed that change three times, and in 2025 the One, Big, Beautiful Bill restored the old threshold of $20,000 and 200 transactions, retroactively.

    LessonA threshold low enough to catch business sellers also catches households clearing out their wardrobes, and the US reversed its $600 rule.

    eur-lex.europa.euirs.govirs.gov

    Credit

    Council of the EU; US Congress; IRS

  5. 2025

    Free to sell, at scale

    Vinted, a marketplace based in Vilnius, Lithuania, charges sellers no selling fee and runs its own parcel service (Vinted Go) and payments wallet (Vinted Pay). Its members traded €10.8 billion of goods in 2025, up 47% on 2024, and the company reported €1.1 billion in revenue and €62 million in net profit; the figures are Vinted's own annual results.

    company.vinted.comcompany.vinted.com

    Credit

    Vinted

  6. 2026

    Depop sold at a loss

    Etsy bought Depop, a resale app founded in the UK in 2011 and popular with young buyers, for $1.6 billion in 2021. In February 2026 it agreed to sell Depop to eBay for $1.2 billion in cash, and completed the sale on 30 July 2026 for about $1.4 billion including adjustments and interest. Depop had 7 million active buyers at the end of 2025, by the companies' figures.

    LessonEtsy said the sale lets it focus on its own marketplace, five years after buying Depop to grow beyond it.

    retailgazette.co.ukinvestors.etsy.com

    Credit

    Etsy; eBay

Watch for

  1. EU may drop sale counts

    The European Commission proposed in June 2026, as part of a recast of its tax-cooperation directives (COM(2026) 308), to stop reporting sellers on the number of their sales and to raise the reporting threshold for goods to €3,000, "to continue to support the circular economy in the sale of second-hand goods." Vinted estimates that about 3.5 million of its members would no longer need to give tax details.

    Achieved whenthe Council of the EU adopts the directive and the new threshold applies to marketplaces.

    data.consilium.europa.eucompany.vinted.com

    Claimed by

    European Commission, June 2026

  2. Resale replacing new buying

    Vinted says 76% of its orders in 2025 avoided the purchase of a new item, and from that rate estimates 1,607 kilotonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent avoided. The 76% comes from a survey of about 50,000 members in nine European markets.

    Achieved whenan outside party measures how often a resale purchase replaces a new one from actual purchase records, not a survey of members, and reports a rate.

    company.vinted.com

    Claimed by

    Vinted, May 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Score photo-listing tools on labels

    A public test of tools that write a resale listing from photos. Photograph 300 garments the same way (front, back, brand label, size label, care label and any flaw), record the true brand, size, fiber content, color and flaws from the labels and a hand check, then ask each tool for a draft listing: Poshmark's Smart List AI, eBay's photo listing, Mercari's if offered, a general vision-language model and a small open model. Publish the error rate for each field. Drafts only; nothing is put up for sale.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Displacement from real receipts

    A 12-month study of at least 300 consenting adults in two countries who share every clothing order confirmation and shop receipt, new and second-hand. Compare each person's new-clothing purchases before and after they start buying second-hand, and against similar people who do not, to give a displacement rate (the share of second-hand purchases that replace a new one) from records instead of recall.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Score photo-listing tools on labels

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test of tools that write a resale listing from photos. Photograph 300 garments the same way (front, back, brand label, size label, care label and any flaw), record the true brand, size, fiber content, color and flaws from the labels and a hand check, then ask each tool for a draft listing: Poshmark's Smart List AI, eBay's photo listing, Mercari's if offered, a general vision-language model and a small open model. Publish the error rate for each field. Drafts only; nothing is put up for sale.

Why it is still open

Poshmark rolled out Smart List AI, which drafts a listing from photos, in the US and Canada in February 2025. Tool makers publish figures from their own users, such as FlowLister's report on 2,806 of its listings, which gives publishing rates and times but no accuracy by field. Searches found no independent test of these tools on the same garments; hands-on reviews say size and fiber content are where they go wrong.

valueaddedresource.netflowlister.com

Built with what exists

A phone camera and a light box; the platforms' listing tools as offered to sellers; a vision-language model such as Claude or Gemini through its API; Liquid AI's LFM3, a family of small open-weight models that includes vision and can be fine-tuned on one GPU (see the Note "One GPU to fine-tune"); Python and pandas for scoring.

  1. First step

    Photograph 30 garments this month with a fixed shot list, transcribe their labels, and run two tools to time the work.

  2. Done looks like

    300 garments in at least five categories, each run through at least four tools, with accuracy for brand, size, fiber content, color and flaws reported per tool; photos, labels and scores published under an open license; an outside person reruns the scoring and matches it within 2 percentage points.

Open 02 · the brief

Displacement from real receipts

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A 12-month study of at least 300 consenting adults in two countries who share every clothing order confirmation and shop receipt, new and second-hand. Compare each person's new-clothing purchases before and after they start buying second-hand, and against similar people who do not, to give a displacement rate (the share of second-hand purchases that replace a new one) from records instead of recall.

Why it is still open

The rates in use come from asking buyers what they would otherwise have bought. Vinted's 76% comes from a member survey. Depop's 88% to 93% comes from a March 2022 survey of 5,531 of its users. WRAP's "Displacement Rates Untangled" (April 2025) gives 64.6% for peer-to-peer resale from consumer surveys, and names wardrobe studies and market data as other methods. Searches found no displacement study built on purchase records.

company.vinted.comnews.depop.comtransition-pathways.europa.eu

Built with what exists

A consent form and a data-protection plan; a large language model to pull item, price and new-or-used from forwarded receipts, with a person checking a sample; Python with pandas and statsmodels for a before-and-after comparison against a matched group; an analysis plan registered in advance on the Open Science Framework (OSF).

  1. First step

    Recruit 20 volunteers to forward three months of past clothing receipts, and check how well the extraction labels 200 of them as new or used.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 300 people followed for 12 months and at least 5,000 clothing purchases classed as new or used, giving a displacement rate with a confidence interval; anonymized totals and code published, and the rate reproduced by a second analyst from the shared code.