BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Nonprofits / Standards bodies

Access and cost

This work is how standards bodies pay for the writing of standards, mostly by selling copies, and how far the public can read the standards that laws make binding.

7

Milestones achieved, from 2001 to 2026.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2001

    Sponsors pay for free copies

    The IEEE, an engineering society, and its 802 committee, which writes the Ethernet and Wi-Fi standards, began the Get IEEE 802 program as a three-year pilot on 15 May 2001. Each current 802 standard became a free PDF download six months after it went on sale, and never more than 194 days; the PDF was still sold during the wait, and print copies were sold throughout. To make up for lost sales, the 802 committee paid the IEEE Standards Association $75 for every paid attendee at its plenary meetings, and companies were asked for sponsorships from under $5,000 up to $100,000, with the terms to be adjusted if revenue strayed more than 20% from budget. A later agreement dropped the pilot wording, and IEEE now runs GET programs for other families of its standards, such as AI ethics and radiation detection. The European Commission notes that ETSI, the European telecoms standards body, also gives its standards away free.

    LessonFree reading can be paid for by the people who write and use a standard instead of by each reader, if the lost sales are budgeted and reviewed every year.

    ieee802.orgieee802.orgstandards.ieee.orgdata.consilium.europa.eu

    Credit

    the IEEE Standards Association (Judith Gorman, managing director) and the IEEE 802 committee (Paul Nikolich, chair)

  2. 2002

    Model codes become law

    On 7 June 2002 the full US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, sitting en banc, ruled for Peter Veeck, who had posted on his non-commercial website the building codes of Anna and Savoy, two small towns in north Texas. Both towns had adopted a model code written by the Southern Building Code Congress International (SBCCI), a code-writing body, which sued him for copyright infringement and won in the lower court. The appeals court held that "as law, the model codes enter the public domain", while SBCCI kept its copyright in the same text as a model code. It added that the case "does not involve references to extrinsic standards", meaning standards that a law cites without being written to become law.

    LessonThe line drawn here, between a code written to become law and a standard a law merely cites, is the line that later cases over ASTM and other standards have been fought along.

    law.resource.org

    Credit

    Judge Edith H. Jones for the majority; Peter Veeck

  3. 2003

    Germany sets reasonable terms

    German copyright law says that laws and official decrees carry no copyright. Since 13 September 2003 a third paragraph of the same section, section 5(3) of the Copyright Act (Urheberrechtsgesetz), has said that private standards, such as DIN standards, keep their copyright when a law refers to them without quoting their text, but that the rights holder must license any publisher to copy and distribute them "on reasonable terms". The paragraph came in with the law of 10 September 2003 that updated German copyright for the information society.

    LessonA country can keep paid standards and still stop the writer from being the only seller of a standard that the law relies on.

    gesetze-im-internet.dedejure.org

    Credit

    the German Bundestag

  4. 2016

    Reasonably available, spelled out

    US law requires that a standard incorporated by reference into a federal rule be "reasonably available" to the people it affects. In January 2016 the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) issued its first revision since 1998 of Circular A-119, its instruction to agencies on using standards written by private bodies. OMB said defining the phrase is the job of the Office of the Federal Register, but it listed factors agencies should weigh: whether the writer will put the standard online free in read-only form while the rule is open for comment, the cost of getting it, including "the cumulative cost to obtain incorporated materials", how much access the public needs to judge the agency's program, and whether the writer can supply a plain summary for a reader without technical training.

    obamawhitehouse.archives.govgovinfo.gov

    Credit

    OMB

  5. 2023

    India frees its standards

    The Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS), India's national standards body, now lets anyone who registers download Indian Standards free; its guide says "indigenous standards are available free of cost". Public.Resource.Org, a US nonprofit, says the free downloads are for non-commercial use and leave out Indian adoptions of ISO and IEC standards, which international agreements cover. The change ended a public-interest case that Public.Resource.Org, Sushant Sinha of Bengaluru and Srinivas Kodali of Hyderabad filed in the Delhi High Court on 23 November 2015, asking it to order BIS to make all Indian Standards free. On 29 August 2023 their counsel told the court that the standards "are now available online free of cost", and the petition was dismissed as withdrawn, with leave to file again.

    bis.gov.inlaw.resource.orglaw.resource.org

    Credit

    BIS; the petitioners

  6. 2024

    Harmonised standards must be readable

    Harmonised standards are European standards that the European Commission cites in its Official Journal; a product made to one is presumed to meet the EU law it supports. On 5 March 2024 the Grand Chamber of the Court of Justice of the EU ruled in a case brought by Public.Resource.Org and Right to Know, an Irish nonprofit, over the Commission's refusal to release four harmonised standards written by CEN, the European standards committee, among them EN 71-4 on chemistry sets for children. Because such a standard "may specify the rights conferred on individuals as well as their obligations", the court found "an overriding public interest" in disclosing them, and annulled the refusal. The Commission and CEN-CENELEC then agreed that all 34 national standards bodies would open read-only portals for the four standards; Danish Standards opened its portal on 28 June 2024, for registered users, with no right to download or print, and with "all rights concerning text and data mining" reserved. When the Commission went on, on 27 September 2024, to grant access to some standards based on ISO and IEC texts, ISO and IEC took it to the EU General Court in December 2024 (Case T-631/24), which Casus Consulting, a medical-device regulatory firm, described as still pending.

    LessonA ruling that standards must be readable did not settle how: the bodies chose read-only screens behind a login, which keeps their sales of downloads and printed copies.

    eur-lex.europa.euds.dkds.dkcasusconsulting.com

    Credit

    Public.Resource.Org and Right to Know; the Court of Justice of the EU

  7. 2026

    Fair use for a business

    On 7 April 2026 the US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit upheld a lower court's refusal to stop UpCodes, a for-profit startup that runs a searchable online library of building codes, from posting ASTM standards that the International Building Code incorporates, as adopted by Philadelphia and other places. ASTM International, a nonprofit standards writer, told the court that sales and licences of its standards bring in about 70% of its revenue, including a subscription of more than 2,300 construction standards referenced in building codes. The court found UpCodes likely to win on fair use, the US rule that allows some copying without permission, because UpCodes posts only the versions of standards that laws have adopted, a different purpose from ASTM's sale of current best practice, and because to comply with an incorporated standard "one needs access to the entire standard". The ruling was on a preliminary injunction; the case continues in the district court.

    LessonThe reasoning that protected a nonprofit's posting of incorporated standards in 2023 now also covers a company that charges for extra features.

    www2.ca3.uscourts.gov

    Credit

    Circuit Judge Restrepo, with Judges McKee and Smith

Watch for

  1. Free access written into law

    The European Commission proposed on 6 October 2026 a new regulation on European standardisation (COM(2026) 780) to replace Regulation 1025/2012. It would require the European standards bodies to give anyone in the EU free access to the standards the law cites, through repositories, "in a readable, searchable, printable and electronically accessible format", "without barriers, including mandatory pre-identification or subscription", and kept available after a standard is withdrawn. It would also let the bodies use digital rights management because AI "may facilitate the mass extraction or re-use of content". The Commission estimates that removing the paywalls saves businesses about €30 million a year and could cut national standards bodies' revenues by up to €30 million a year, about 15% of their standards sales in the EU and 6% of their total revenues.

    Achieved whenThe European Parliament and the Council adopt the regulation, and the first repository lets an unregistered reader search and print a harmonised standard.

    data.consilium.europa.eu

    Claimed by

    European Commission, October 2026

  2. Taxes pay instead of readers

    KANBrief, the newsletter of Germany's Commission for Occupational Health and Safety and Standardization (KAN), reports that Slovenia's economy ministry "decided to partly nationalise funding" of SIST, the national standards body, so that harmonised standards are paid for from taxes and free to the public. The same report says that of 24,982 CEN and CENELEC standards in the first quarter of 2026, 3,614 were harmonised; DIN makes 446 of them free to read online, but not to download or print, and is trying "sponsored access", where ministries or industry associations pay for a standard instead of its readers.

    Achieved whenSIST or the Slovenian government publishes the funding line, and SIST's catalogue shows every harmonised standard free to read without charge.

    kan.de

    Claimed by

    KAN's report (issue 2/26, after April 2026), quoting DIN Media's managing director Marion Winkenbach

Open

  1. 01

    One standard, many prices

    A public table of the list prices that each of the 34 national standards bodies in CEN and CENELEC charges for the same European standards, for a sample of 100, including harmonised standards for toys, machinery and household appliances. Record format, language, member discounts and VAT, convert to euros, refresh every quarter, and add up what one small firm must pay for the full set of standards behind one product, such as a toy.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Read-only portals, tested

    A filmed, public test of the read-only portals that the 34 national standards bodies opened after the 2024 ruling, and of other free reading rooms such as DIN's, against the conditions in the Commission's 2026 proposal: no registration, and text that is readable, searchable, printable and accessible to disabled readers. Each portal gets the same ten tasks, such as finding EN 71-4, searching it for a word, zooming to 200%, reading a table with a screen reader and printing one page.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

One standard, many prices

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of the list prices that each of the 34 national standards bodies in CEN and CENELEC charges for the same European standards, for a sample of 100, including harmonised standards for toys, machinery and household appliances. Record format, language, member discounts and VAT, convert to euros, refresh every quarter, and add up what one small firm must pay for the full set of standards behind one product, such as a toy.

Why it is still open

The published comparisons are single examples. A 2009 study for the European Commission gave the price of EN 12622:2001 in 2008 as €48 in Luxembourg against €199 in the UK; ComplianceGate's buying guide, updated in September 2025, lists EN 71-1:2018 at three bodies only (BSI £350, DIN €390.90, AFNOR €361.90). The Commission's 2026 proposal estimates the total cost of paywalls to business but gives no prices standard by standard.

erim.eur.nlcompliancegate.comdata.consilium.europa.eu

Built with what exists

Each body's public web shop; a web agent such as Browser Use to collect prices and save dated page snapshots (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); the Commission's published lists of harmonised standard references; the European Central Bank's reference exchange rates; Python and a spreadsheet.

  1. First step

    Price EN 71-1, EN 71-3 and EN 60335-1 by hand at all 34 bodies, and note which shops show a price only after login.

  2. Done looks like

    Prices for at least 90% of the 3,400 standard-and-body pairs, each with a dated snapshot, four quarterly updates, the ratio of highest to lowest price for every standard, and the total cost for three example products.

Open 02 · the brief

Read-only portals, tested

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A filmed, public test of the read-only portals that the 34 national standards bodies opened after the 2024 ruling, and of other free reading rooms such as DIN's, against the conditions in the Commission's 2026 proposal: no registration, and text that is readable, searchable, printable and accessible to disabled readers. Each portal gets the same ten tasks, such as finding EN 71-4, searching it for a word, zooming to 200%, reading a table with a screen reader and printing one page.

Why it is still open

The portals set their own terms. Danish Standards' requires registration and forbids downloading and printing; DIN reads the ruling as allowing online reading only. The proposal would require access without "mandatory pre-identification or subscription", in line with the EU directive on accessible public websites (2016/2102). No comparison of the portals was found.

ds.dkkan.dedata.consilium.europa.eu

Built with what exists

A web agent such as Browser Use to run the same steps on every portal and record them (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); axe-core, a free accessibility checker; NVDA, a free screen reader; a checklist written from the proposal's wording.

  1. First step

    Run the ten tasks by hand on five portals (Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Germany and Ireland) and revise the checklist.

  2. Done looks like

    All 34 portals and at least five other free reading rooms tested by two people on all ten tasks, with screen recordings, a pass or fail per task, and the table published.