BRENNEN

Industries / Energy, water and waste / Oil and gas extraction / Oilfield services / Saltwater disposal

Records and regulation

This work sets the rules for where produced water may go and collects the well-by-well numbers that show whether the rules are kept.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1969 to 2023.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1969

    Texas orders no pits

    The Railroad Commission of Texas had required fresh water to be protected while drilling since its Rule 20 of 1919, and in 1933 extended that to the disposal of produced salt water. In January 1969 it added what it calls the "no-pit order" to Rule 8, its water-protection rule, and later added rules on hauling salt water (1977). The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) says that as states began to forbid putting brine onto soil and into surface water, injection underground became the preferred way to get rid of it.

    rrc.texas.govepa.gov

    Credit

    Railroad Commission of Texas

  2. 1974

    Federal rules for injection

    The US Safe Drinking Water Act of 1974 required the EPA to set minimum rules for underground injection so that injection wells do not contaminate underground sources of drinking water. Its Section 1425 lets the EPA approve a state's existing oil and gas (Class II) program if the state shows it works, and the EPA runs the program itself where a state does not. EPA puts the number of Class II wells at about 180,000, of which about 20% are disposal wells, and says more than 2 billion gallons of fluid a day are injected in the United States.

    epa.govepa.govepa.gov

    Credit

    US Congress; US EPA

  3. 1988

    Not regulated as hazardous

    The Solid Waste Disposal Act of 1980 barred the EPA from regulating "drilling fluids, produced waters, and other wastes" from oil and gas production as hazardous waste until it had studied them. EPA's study estimated 20.9 billion barrels of produced water from more than 800,000 production sites in 1985, and on 6 July 1988 the agency decided that hazardous-waste rules (RCRA Subtitle C) were "not warranted", relying instead on state programs and existing federal law. After a 2016 consent decree in a lawsuit, EPA reviewed the question again and in April 2019 found no need to revise its rules.

    Lessonthe decision left the detailed rules for produced water to the states.

    archive.epa.govaglaw.psu.edu

    Credit

    US EPA

  4. 2001

    An oil limit offshore

    At sea, produced water is usually either treated and discharged or injected back into the reservoir. OSPAR, the treaty commission for the North-East Atlantic, set a performance standard of 30 mg of dispersed oil per liter of discharged produced water in its Recommendation 2001/1, later amended. OSPAR's 2023 assessment reports a 16% fall in dispersed oil discharged in produced water since 2009 and fewer installations above 30 mg/l; under its later risk-based approach, 54% of installations had been judged under adequate control and 39% needed further action.

    oap.ospar.orgospar.org

    Credit

    OSPAR Commission

  5. 2014

    Auditors fault EPA oversight

    The US Government Accountability Office (GAO) reviewed eight states' Class II programs, six run by states and two by the EPA, at a time when 39 states ran their own. It found the EPA did not consistently make the yearly on-site evaluations its guidance called for, that the program data it collected were "not reliable (i.e., complete or comparable) to report at a national level", and that the rules did not address emerging risks such as earthquakes and high formation pressure.

    Lessonnational figures are only as good as the least consistent state's records.

    gao.gov

    Credit

    US Government Accountability Office, report GAO-14-555

  6. 2022

    Counting the nation's brine

    In November 2022 the Ground Water Protection Council (GWPC) published the fourth edition of its national count, using 2021 data collected from 36 states. It counted about 25.9 billion barrels of produced water in 2021. Of the 24.9 billion barrels whose fate was reported, about 95.7% was injected: 48.3% to push more oil out of reservoirs (enhanced recovery), 37.3% into operators' own disposal wells and 10.1% into commercial disposal wells. Texas led with about 8.1 billion barrels. The report says volumes "are not reported or documented in a consistent or regular manner from state to state" and many states do not separate commercial from operator disposal.

    gwpc.org

    Credit

    Ground Water Protection Council; earlier editions by C. E. Clark and J. A. Veil (2009, for the US Department of Energy) and by Veil (2015 and 2020)

  7. 2023

    Daily data from disposal wells

    A December 2023 RRC notice requires every new or amended disposal-well permit in the greater Permian Basin to record injection volume and surface pressure every day and to report them monthly through the TexNet Injection Volume Reporting Tool, which is open to industry, academia and the public. It also requires periodic bottom-hole pressure readings and asks existing wells permitted for 5,000 barrels a day or more to report daily data as well. All Texas disposal operators still file injection figures once a year as well, on Form H-10.

    rrc.texas.govrrc.texas.gov

    Credit

    Railroad Commission of Texas; Bureau of Economic Geology

Watch for

  1. Western discharge rules rewritten

    Under Subpart E of its 1979 oil and gas wastewater rules, the EPA lets onshore produced water be discharged into surface waters west of the 98th meridian only when it has a use in farming or wildlife. EPA says it has completed a study of whether affordable treatment exists and, based on it, has announced a rulemaking to revise Subpart E "and to expand produced water reuse opportunities nationwide".

    Achieved whena final revised Subpart E is published in the Federal Register.

    epa.gov

    Claimed by

    US EPA, announced 12 March 2025 and restated on its page last updated in June 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Yearly reports against daily ones

    For every Permian disposal well that reports daily data to the TexNet tool and monthly figures on its yearly Form H-10, a month-by-month comparison of the two, published with other warning flags: the same numbers repeated year after year, values marked as estimated, and pressures above the permit limit.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Every disposal well, one table

    An open table with one row per Class II disposal well per month for the eight states the GWPC says each produced more than 1 billion barrels of water in 2021 (Texas, Illinois, California, Oklahoma, New Mexico, Wyoming, Alaska and Kansas), giving volume, pressure, target formation and depth in one format, each row linked to its state source.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Yearly reports against daily ones

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

For every Permian disposal well that reports daily data to the TexNet tool and monthly figures on its yearly Form H-10, a month-by-month comparison of the two, published with other warning flags: the same numbers repeated year after year, values marked as estimated, and pressures above the permit limit.

Why it is still open

Texas operators must measure volume and pressure monthly but file only once a year. The RRC's guidance lets an operator who takes over a well with missing reports file zeros for a well that was shut in, or estimate volumes from the well's oil-to-water ratio, and its staff training slides show duplicate entries and rejected forms. Since the December 2023 notice, a growing number of Permian wells report the same injection twice, daily and yearly. Open projects on GitHub that scrape H-10 data, such as juand009/texas-injection-wells (1,414 Delaware Basin wells, 1997–2025) and data-desk-eco/zombie-wells, clean and map it but do not compare it with the daily reports.

rrc.texas.govrrc.state.tx.usgithub.comgithub.com

Built with what exists

The RRC's H-10 query and data downloads; the TexNet Injection Volume Reporting Tool; the InjectA package; Python with DuckDB.

  1. First step

    Take 20 wells from the RRC's Northern Culberson-Reeves well list, download their 2024 daily data and H-10 filings, and compute the monthly differences.

  2. Done looks like

    A public table of at least 500 wells over at least 24 months, giving the share of well-months where the yearly and daily figures differ by more than 5%, with each flagged case linked to both source records.

Open 02 · the brief

Every disposal well, one table

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open table with one row per Class II disposal well per month for the eight states the GWPC says each produced more than 1 billion barrels of water in 2021 (Texas, Illinois, California, Oklahoma, New Mexico, Wyoming, Alaska and Kansas), giving volume, pressure, target formation and depth in one format, each row linked to its state source.

Why it is still open

The GWPC's count gives state totals, not wells. The we3lab/uic-well-inventory project on GitHub, begun in October 2026, is building a national inventory of injection wells' locations and types from state and EPA files, without volumes. Weingarten and colleagues (Science, 2015) combined public injection-well databases for the central and eastern US for one study of earthquakes. FracTracker Alliance's Class II repository (2015) holds well locations and volumes for Ohio only, and a USGS data release for the Colorado River Basin used commercial S&P Global data summed over 2-mile squares.

gwpc.orggithub.comdoi.orggithub.comdata.usgs.gov

Built with what exists

State regulators' injection data (the RRC's H-10 records, and the Oklahoma, New Mexico, Kansas and California regulators' files); we3lab's well-inventory code as the list of wells; Python, DuckDB and Zenodo for versioned releases.

  1. First step

    Run the we3lab code on its Texas and Oklahoma files, join 2021 H-10 volumes to the Texas wells by well number, and compare the total with the GWPC's Texas disposal figure.

  2. Done looks like

    Monthly volumes for 2015 to 2024 for at least six of the eight states, with each state's 2021 disposal total within 10% of the GWPC figure for that state, and every row traceable to its source file.