BRENNEN

Industries / Food, farming and forestry / Agriculture and farming / Ranching and livestock

Breeding

Choosing which bulls, cows, rams and ewes become parents, recording their pedigrees and performance, and spreading their genes by insemination, embryo transfer and, lately, gene editing.

6

Milestones achieved, from c. 1760 to 2022.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. c. 1760

    Breeding for the butcher

    Robert Bakewell was managing his father's farm at Dishley, Leicestershire, before his father died in 1773, when he inherited the tenancy (Wykes), and bred sheep and Longhorn cattle for meat rather than for wool or work. He mated close relatives to fix the traits he wanted, culled hard, and hired out his rams for a season instead of selling them, so his New Leicester sheep spread into flocks across Britain.

    LessonClose inbreeding fixed the type but had a cost: Wykes records "a decline in fecundity and meat quality" in Bakewell's stock.

    ans.iastate.edubahs.org.uk

    Credit

    Robert Bakewell (1725–1795), helped by a group of local breeders (David Wykes, Agricultural History Review, 2004)

  2. 1822

    Pedigrees go into print

    A herd book lists each registered animal and its parents, so a buyer can check its ancestry. George Coates rode across northern England collecting the breeding of Shorthorn cattle and published the first volume of Coates's Herd Book in 1822, with 710 bulls and about 800 cows (The Scottish Farmer's figures). The Museum of English Rural Life calls it the oldest cattle herd book on record.

    LessonA record is only as good as what goes into it: many early entries had vague pedigrees, some of them "hand me down stories" (The Scottish Farmer).

    merl.reading.ac.ukthescottishfarmer.co.uk

    Credit

    George Coates

  3. 1951

    Embryos moved between cows

    E. L. Willett and four colleagues reported in Science the successful transfer of a fertilized egg from one cow into another. Embryo transfer lets one valuable cow have many more calves a year than she could carry herself. The work has since moved into the laboratory: eggs are drawn from a live cow's ovaries with a needle and fertilized in a dish (in vitro production). By the International Embryo Technology Society's count, 2,029,007 cattle embryos were made this way worldwide in 2024, more than seven times the 296,520 flushed from cows' wombs, and 929,474 of the lab embryos made from live donors came from beef cows.

    ebi.ac.ukiets.org

    Credit

    Willett, Black, Casida, Stone and Buckner (1951); 2024 counts by João H. M. Viana for the IETS Data Retrieval Committee

  4. 1970s

    Bulls ranked across herds

    Beef breed associations began to work out each bull's genetic merit from records sent in by many breeders, so a buyer could compare bulls raised on different ranches. By 1980 most US breed associations reported these as expected progeny differences (EPDs): the predicted difference between a bull's calves and those of an average bull, for a trait such as birth weight. In Australia, BREEDPLAN began in 1985 and by 2011 also ran evaluations for breeders in the US, Canada, the UK, Europe, southern Africa, South America and New Zealand.

    brahmanjournal.combreedplan.une.edu.au

    Credit

    the American Simmental Association, which livestock specialist Joe Paschal says "led the way"; the Beef Improvement Federation (1968); the Agricultural Business Research Institute and the Animal Genetics Breeding Unit at the University of New England (BREEDPLAN)

  5. 2008

    DNA test for curly calf

    In late August 2008 Angus breeders began reporting dead calves born with twisted spines and rigid legs. The defect, arthrogryposis multiplex (AM), is recessive: a calf is affected only if both parents carry it. Researchers traced it to the maternal grandsire of GAR Precision 1680, a widely used bull, and commercial DNA tests were on sale by December 2008, about four months later. Animals are now listed as carriers (AMC) or free of it (AMF).

    LessonHeavy use of one popular bull put him on both sides of many pedigrees, which brought a rare hidden defect to the surface; Van Eenennaam credits the cattle genome sequence for the speed of the test.

    animalbiotech.ucdavis.edu

    Credit

    Jonathan Beever (University of Illinois) and David Steffen (University of Nebraska), with the American Angus Association; account by Alison Van Eenennaam, University of California, Davis

  6. 2022

    Gene-edited beef cattle cleared

    On 7 March 2022 the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) found that two cattle with an edit to the prolactin receptor gene posed low risk, and did not object to the sale of the cattle, their offspring, semen, embryos and meat. The edit gives a short, "slick" coat and copies a variant found naturally in some tropical breeds. In September 2025 the FDA extended the decision to new founder animals of any breed of European-type (Bos taurus) cattle.

    LessonEdits must be checked for changes nobody intended: FDA scientists found that cattle edited earlier to be born without horns also carried a copy of the plasmid, the ring of lab DNA used to deliver the edit, at the edited site (Norris and colleagues, Nature Biotechnology, 2020).

    fda.govebi.ac.ukebi.ac.uk

    Credit

    Acceligen, a subsidiary of Recombinetics, which made the edit with CRISPR-Cas9; reviewed by the FDA's Center for Veterinary Medicine

Watch for

  1. Breeding sheep that burp less

    New Zealand ram breeders can already select on a breeding value for methane, the greenhouse gas sheep burp out. The research program's head says its high- and low-methane research flocks differ by about 18% in methane. AgriZeroNZ, the Ag Emissions Centre, Beef + Lamb New Zealand and the Ministry for Primary Industries are spending NZ$1.2 million to measure 5,000 more sheep and to test whether low-methane sheep also use feed more efficiently.

    Achieved whensomeone outside the program measures commercial flocks bred from low-methane rams and finds less methane per kilogram of meat and wool, with no loss of growth or wool.

    agnavigator.com

    Claimed by

    AgriZeroNZ and Suzanne Rowe (Bioeconomy Science Institute), May 2026

  2. Heat-tolerant coats in any breed

    After a September 2025 review, the developer may add the slick-coat edit to any breed of European-type cattle, such as Angus. The FDA's summary confirms the slick coat and finds the animals' health and growth comparable to unedited cattle, but it describes the heat benefit only as "reported to be linked to increased thermotolerance".

    Achieved whenedited cattle are sold to ranches and an independent trial in a hot climate shows lower body temperature or better weight gain than unedited herdmates.

    fda.gov

    Claimed by

    Recombinetics and its subsidiary Acceligen, in the FDA's risk assessment summary, September 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Score breech traits from photos

    A phone app, or a camera over the race (the single-file lane sheep walk through), that scores breech wrinkle and dag on the 1-to-5 scales of Australia's Visual Sheep Scores, plus a public set of scored photos. Breech wrinkle is the folded skin around a Merino's tail and down its hind legs; dag is dung stuck to the wool there. Both make breech flystrike (blowfly maggots in the skin) more likely, and AWI says a sheep with dag score 4 can be up to seven times more likely to be struck than a dag score 1 sheep in the same flock. Ram breeders score these traits by eye and send the scores to Sheep Genetics, Australia's sheep evaluation, to breed sheep that need no mulesing (see Animal health); only scores on sheep that have not been mulesed are accepted.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Score beef feet from photos

    A phone app that takes side and front photos of a standing animal's feet and returns foot angle and claw set scores on the American Angus Association's 1-to-9 scale, where 5 is ideal (a pastern angle of about 45 degrees and even, evenly spaced claws), ready for a breeder to send in.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Score breech traits from photos

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A phone app, or a camera over the race (the single-file lane sheep walk through), that scores breech wrinkle and dag on the 1-to-5 scales of Australia's Visual Sheep Scores, plus a public set of scored photos. Breech wrinkle is the folded skin around a Merino's tail and down its hind legs; dag is dung stuck to the wool there. Both make breech flystrike (blowfly maggots in the skin) more likely, and AWI says a sheep with dag score 4 can be up to seven times more likely to be struck than a dag score 1 sheep in the same flock. Ram breeders score these traits by eye and send the scores to Sheep Genetics, Australia's sheep evaluation, to breed sheep that need no mulesing (see Animal health); only scores on sheep that have not been mulesed are accepted.

Why it is still open

The 2024 guide from AWI and Meat & Livestock Australia says most traits are best scored in a classer's box, against its diagrams. Australian Wool Innovation's AI pilot (neXtgen Agri, 2019) photographed 4,072 sheep from four angles (1,482,041 images) but scored face cover, neck wrinkle and body wrinkle, not breech wrinkle or dag. On the full 1-to-5 scale its models scored neck and body wrinkle correctly 38–58% of the time, AWI says "AI technology is not yet ready to be deployed in the wool industry", and the report lists breech strike susceptibility from images as future work. The images were not found in any public release, and searches of Europe PMC, OpenAlex, arXiv, GitHub and the web found no image model for breech wrinkle or dag.

wool.comwool.comwool.comwool.commla.com.au

Built with what exists

a smartphone, or a fixed camera over the race triggered by each sheep's electronic ear tag, as in AWI's pilot; Ultralytics YOLO to find the breech in each photo; an image classifier from the open timm library, or a small vision model from Liquid AI's LFM3 family fine-tuned on one graphics chip (see the Note "One GPU to fine-tune"); Label Studio for scoring photos; Zenodo or Hugging Face Datasets to publish the set.

  1. First step

    Ask a Merino ram breeder who already sends visual scores to Sheep Genetics to let you photograph 200 sheep in the race on scoring day while two people score them, and measure how often the two scorers agree.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 2,000 unmulesed sheep from at least five flocks, photographed when the guide says to score (breech wrinkle within a month after shearing, dag before crutching) and each scored by two trained classers. On flocks not used in training, the model agrees with the classers at least as well as the two classers agree with each other, measured as weighted kappa (a statistic for agreement on ordered scores), and at least 10,000 photos are released under an open license.

Open 02 · the brief

Score beef feet from photos

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A phone app that takes side and front photos of a standing animal's feet and returns foot angle and claw set scores on the American Angus Association's 1-to-9 scale, where 5 is ideal (a pastern angle of about 45 degrees and even, evenly spaced claws), ready for a breeder to send in.

Why it is still open

The Association's foot angle and claw set EPDs date from 2019 and have "limited phenotypic data submitted thus far"; there are too few scores from 1 to 4 to use them. A 2023 review notes that scores are visual and subjective and hopes for "a more quantified method with the use of technology". The nearest tools are for dairy cows: OsRostrum's BoviPhIT iPhone app, still in development in March 2026, and the Holstein Association's camera system, still in pilot. No photo scorer for beef feet, or published accuracy for one, was found.

pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govambrook.com

Built with what exists

a smartphone; open pose models that place points on the hoof, pastern and claws, such as DeepLabCut or Ultralytics YOLO pose, to measure angles and claw spread; Label Studio; the Association's foot scoring guidelines as the reference.

  1. First step

    At a bull test station or sale day, photograph the feet of 100 bulls standing on flat concrete while a trained scorer scores them.

  2. Done looks like

    1,000 yearling cattle from at least five herds, each scored in person by two trained scorers. On herds not used in training, the app is within one point of the scorers on at least 90% of animals, its agreement is reported next to the scorers' agreement with each other, and the photos and scores are published.