BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Government / Public transit

Safety

This is the work of keeping riders, staff and people in the street from harm in and around buses, trams and metros: fires, crashes, falls from platforms and assaults.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1903 to 2024.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1903

    A fire on wooden trains

    On 10 August 1903 a fire on a train of Paris Métro Line 2 killed 84 people at Couronnes station. The RATP, which runs the Métro today, blames trains built of wood with unreliable electrical circuits, and says the disaster set off a broad overhaul: metal Sprague trains in place of wooden ones, lines split into separate electrical sections, signs to the exits, lamps over each platform exit until emergency lighting was fitted, fire posts and detectors, and smoke extraction from the tunnels.

    LessonA car built like a wooden streetcar was not safe to run in a tunnel.

    web.archive.org

    Credit

    the Compagnie du métropolitain de Paris (CMP), the operator then

  2. 1987

    King's Cross escalator fire

    On 18 November 1987 a fire beneath a wooden escalator at King's Cross Underground station in London killed 31 people. Desmond Fennell's investigation found that a lighted match had probably fallen through a gap beside the steps onto grease and dust on the escalator's running track. The inquiry was given details of 46 escalator fires between 1956 and 1988, 32 of them put down to smokers' materials, and none before had killed anyone. Its scientists found a previously unknown way for fire to spread fast up an escalator shaft into the ticket hall, and the report ended with 157 recommendations.

    LessonSmall fires that go out on their own are warnings, not proof of safety.

    jesip.org.uk

    Credit

    Desmond Fennell's investigation for the UK Department of Transport

  3. 2009

    Nine killed, oversight rewritten

    On 22 June 2009 a Washington Metrorail train struck a stopped train near Fort Totten station, killing nine people. The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) found that faulty track circuit modules had lost track of the stopped train, and among the contributing factors it listed the operator's "lack of a safety culture" and the Federal Transit Administration's (FTA's) "lack of statutory authority to provide federal safety oversight". A 2012 law, MAP-21, gave the US transportation secretary power to inspect transit systems, issue safety directives and withhold up to 25% of some federal grants. Under that power the FTA oversaw Metrorail's safety directly from October 2015 until 18 March 2019, when a new regional body, the Washington Metrorail Safety Commission, took over.

    LessonAn overseer that cannot compel a fix cannot make a system safe.

    ntsb.govlaw.cornell.edumasstransitmag.com

    Credit

    the NTSB; the US Congress; the FTA

  4. 2012

    Screen doors on MRT platforms

    Singapore's MRT metro opened in 1987 with no screen doors at its above-ground stations. Doors along the platform edges were fitted from 2009 and finished in 2012, by the Ministry of Transport's account. The ministry says the city's smaller light-rail (LRT) stations have no room for the equipment such doors need. There, on 18 May 2026, a man fell onto the track at Segar station in front of a train and died, although alarms that detect people on the track had been fitted to the light-rail lines in 2023 and 2024; the acting minister asked for barrier options to be re-examined.

    mot.gov.sg

    Credit

    Singapore's Ministry of Transport and Land Transport Authority

  5. 2016

    A tram overturns at Sandilands

    On 9 November 2016 a tram in Croydon, south London, entered a curve limited to 20 km/h at 73 km/h and overturned; 7 of its 69 passengers died and 61 were injured. The Rail Accident Investigation Branch (RAIB) found it probable that the driver had briefly lost awareness, and that nothing monitored a driver's alertness or braked a tram automatically when it went too fast. It made 15 recommendations. By the Office of Rail and Road's (ORR's) account in March 2023, London's trams had automatic overspeed prevention from 5 April 2019, and every UK tram network had fitted speed control and driver-vigilance equipment or given a timed plan to do so.

    LessonA driver who steers by sight needs a machine check at places where one lapse can kill.

    gov.ukorr.gov.uk

    Credit

    the RAIB; the ORR; UK tram operators

  6. 2019

    A safety standard for buses

    In 2019 Transport for London (TfL) began requiring new buses to meet a Bus Safety Standard, raised in 2021 and 2024, with features such as cameras and screens in place of mirrors and speed limiting tied to the road's limit. In an interim evaluation for TfL dated April 2026, the research firm TRL found that casualties fell 47.7% on routes with the camera systems against 20.9% on comparison routes. Routes with speed limiting "did not consistently outperform" comparison routes, and their rate of people killed or seriously injured rose significantly more, which TRL says needs further study.

    content.tfl.gov.uk

    Credit

    TfL; TRL

  7. 2024

    Worker assaults in safety plans

    A US federal rule in force from 13 May 2024 requires large transit agencies to set up safety committees with equal numbers of frontline workers and managers, and to run programs to cut assaults on transit workers and collisions between buses and pedestrians, measured with National Transit Database data. In October 2022 the FTA had issued special directives to the agencies that accounted for 79% of all transit worker assaults reported to that database.

    govinfo.gov

    Credit

    the US Congress, in the 2021 Bipartisan Infrastructure Law; the FTA

Watch for

  1. Fatigue alarms on London buses

    A TfL bus safety standard published on 2 June 2026 requires cameras or sensors that watch a driver's eyes, blinking and head position, and warn the driver, and the bus company's control room, when they detect fatigue. It is phased in for buses joining the fleet from 2027, after trials on around 400 buses, and TfL says the data will help bus companies "better manage fatigue risk".

    Achieved whena published evaluation, by TfL or an outside party, shows fewer fatigue events or collisions on buses with the system than on comparable buses without it.

    britsafe.org

    Claimed by

    TfL, June 2026

  2. AI alarms for track intrusions

    The MTA, which runs New York's subway, is seeking a firm to build and test an AI-supported system at one underground and one elevated station that would alert train operators, station staff and the control center when someone enters the track. Jamie Torres-Springer of the MTA said earlier systems, tested at two Manhattan stations from 2014 to 2019, could identify an intrusion but not "in a precise-enough way" to manage the response. The MTA counted 1,297 unauthorized track entries in 2025.

    Achieved whenthe MTA or an outside evaluator publishes detection and false-alarm rates from the two-station test.

    route-fifty.com

    Claimed by

    the MTA, April to June 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Narratives against the codes

    Every major safety event a US transit agency reports to the National Transit Database comes with coded fields (event type, who was hurt, whether a transit worker was assaulted) and a short free-text description. Build a tool that reads each description, codes it again from the text alone, and lists every event where the description and the codes disagree, with a hand-checked sample that measures how often the tool is right.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    A test for track alarms

    A public set of video clips from fixed cameras over a station platform, with staged track entries marked to the second, and a scoring script that measures how fast a detector raises the alarm and how many false alarms it raises per hour of ordinary platform footage. Stage the entries at a heritage railway or museum station on a day with no trains, with the owner's permission, using a mannequin for falls and volunteers stepping over a marked edge line at ground level.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Narratives against the codes

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Every major safety event a US transit agency reports to the National Transit Database comes with coded fields (event type, who was hurt, whether a transit worker was assaulted) and a short free-text description. Build a tool that reads each description, codes it again from the text alone, and lists every event where the description and the codes disagree, with a hand-checked sample that measures how often the tool is right.

Why it is still open

The FTA's own notes to the file say its transit-worker-assault flag was misleading for events before a 2023 reporting change, and that users had to filter on four columns to count those assaults. The nearest prior work found, TransitX Labs' Transit Safety Lens (October 2026), checks the coded fields for completeness and consistency but does not read the descriptions.

data.transportation.govgithub.com

Built with what exists

The FTA's Major Safety and Security Events file on data.transportation.gov, which held 117,285 events from 2014 on, each with a description, in November 2026, read through its public API; Python; a language model that answers fixed-choice questions with probabilities (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass").

  1. First step

    A keyword search made for this entry found 177 descriptions saying an operator was assaulted, 8 of them not flagged as transit worker assaults; pull those 8 and check each by hand.

  2. Done looks like

    Every event since 2014 coded from its text, a public list of disagreements by field, and a hand check of at least 500 events by two people, with the tool's agreement with them reported for each field.

Open 02 · the brief

A test for track alarms

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public set of video clips from fixed cameras over a station platform, with staged track entries marked to the second, and a scoring script that measures how fast a detector raises the alarm and how many false alarms it raises per hour of ordinary platform footage. Stage the entries at a heritage railway or museum station on a day with no trains, with the owner's permission, using a mannequin for falls and volunteers stepping over a marked edge line at ground level.

Why it is still open

The MTA says its earlier camera systems could spot an intrusion but not precisely enough to act on. The Chicago Transit Authority's 12-month camera pilot, approved in February 2025, is to be judged on accurate detections, response times and false alarms, and has published no results. The nearest open dataset found, RailGoerl24 (2025), was filmed from a train's own camera at a test center, not from platform cameras.

route-fifty.comtransitchicago.comarxiv.org

Built with what exists

Two or more fixed cameras; open object detectors such as Ultralytics YOLO; Meta's SAM 2 model to outline the track area; Python for scoring.

  1. First step

    Write to two heritage railways or transit museums that have a platform and ask to film on a day with no trains.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 300 staged entries and 50 hours of ordinary footage, published with labels, and a table giving each tested detector's share of entries caught within 2 seconds and its false alarms per hour.