BRENNEN

Industries / Food, farming and forestry / Food and beverage processing / Pet food

Formulation and nutrition

Formulation sets how much of each nutrient a food must hold for a species and life stage, and turns those targets into recipes that meet them.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1948 to 2026.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1948

    A diet for failing kidneys

    The veterinarian Mark Morris Sr. and his wife Louise made a food in their kitchen for Buddy, the dog of a blind man named Morris Frank, who had kidney failure. Morris contracted Burton Hill of the Hill Packing Company in Topeka, Kansas, to can it as Canine k/d. Hill's Pet Nutrition went into business in 1948 with Prescription Diet k/d, which Hill's calls the world's first veterinarian-prepared food for managing a canine disease.

    hillspet.com

    Credit

    Mark Morris Sr. and Louise Morris; Burton Hill

  2. 1987

    Taurine and failing cat hearts

    Taurine is a sulfur-containing compound related to the amino acids, which cats cannot make in sufficient amounts. In 1975 Hayes, Carey and Schmidt had tied a loss of retinal cells in cats fed casein-based diets to taurine deficiency. In 1987 Pion, Kittleson, Rogers and Morris found low blood taurine and failing heart muscle (dilated cardiomyopathy) in 21 cats fed commercial cat foods, and taurine given by mouth restored heart function.

    LessonTaurine levels judged adequate in purified laboratory diets proved too low in heat-processed commercial foods, so FEDIAF, the European pet food industry federation, now advises about 2 to 2.5 times as much taurine in canned cat food as in dry.

    ebi.ac.ukebi.ac.ukeuropeanpetfood.org

    Credit

    Paul D. Pion, Mark D. Kittleson, Quinton R. Rogers and James G. Morris (Science); K. C. Hayes, R. E. Carey and S. Y. Schmidt (Science, 1975)

  3. 1992

    AAFCO profiles replace NRC

    AAFCO expert subcommittees for dogs (1990 to 1991) and cats (1991 to 1992) wrote nutrient profiles, tables of minimum and some maximum nutrient levels, that replaced the US National Research Council's recommendations as the reference for "complete and balanced" claims. The levels allow for how well nutrients are absorbed from common ingredients, with separate tables for adult maintenance and for growth and reproduction. A food can instead support its claim by passing an AAFCO feeding trial.

    LessonThe new maximums included 6.25 g of calcium and 4 g of phosphorus per 1,000 kcal in dog food, set out of concern over excess, and FEDIAF later adopted the same limits.

    ebi.ac.ukeuropeanpetfood.org

    Credit

    AAFCO Canine and Feline Nutrition Expert Subcommittees; reported by David A. Dzanis (Journal of Nutrition, 1994)

  4. 2019

    Home recipes tested in labs

    A team at the University of São Paulo analyzed home-prepared diets for 75 dogs and 25 cats in the laboratory. None supplied every measured nutrient at the levels recommended by the NRC and FEDIAF, more than 84% fell short on three or more, and lead, cobalt, mercury, uranium and vanadium exceeded FDA's maximum tolerable levels. Calcium and potassium were most often short in dog diets, iron and zinc in cat diets.

    LessonIn the US, the Dog Aging Project's coders judged in 2025 that only 6% of 1,726 home-prepared diets described by owners were potentially complete by AAFCO's adult standard.

    ebi.ac.ukebi.ac.uk

    Credit

    V. Pedrinelli, M. A. Brunetto and colleagues (Scientific Reports)

  5. 2020

    Phosphorus measured in cat food

    High phosphorus and a low ratio of calcium to phosphorus are linked to kidney damage in cats, and no maximum for phosphorus in cat food had been set. A team at Colorado State University and the University of California, Davis measured 82 non-prescription cat foods: 27 held 3.6 g or more of phosphorus per 1,000 kcal, 7 held more than 4.8 g, and 13 held no more calcium than phosphorus. The minimum phosphorus and calcium declared on labels were well below the amounts measured.

    LessonThe authors concluded that pet food rules should be reconsidered.

    ebi.ac.uk

    Credit

    S. C. Summers, J. Stockman, J. A. Larsen and colleagues (Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine)

  6. 2026

    New mineral limits for cats

    An expert panel convened in 2023 by AAFCO's Pet Food Committee reviewed research on calcium and phosphorus in cat nutrition and presented its findings in January 2025. AAFCO members approved revised cat calcium and phosphorus profiles at the August 2026 annual meeting. In October 2026 AAFCO asked state regulators to hold off enforcing them during the window already set for the new label rules, so makers can reformulate and test their foods.

    petfoodindustry.com

    Credit

    AAFCO Pet Food Committee and its expert panel; Austin Therrell, AAFCO executive director

Watch for

  1. A senior life stage

    AAFCO's nutrient profiles cover two life stages, growth and reproduction, and adult maintenance; a presenter told its Pet Food Committee that the standards are about 20 years old. In January 2026 the committee set up a workgroup, led by Charlotte Conway, to look into a nutrient profile for senior dogs and cats. Members questioned whether enough data exist, and industry data shared with the workgroup are to stay private.

    Achieved whenAAFCO members adopt a nutrient profile for senior dogs or cats.

    aafco.org

    Claimed by

    AAFCO Pet Food Committee, January 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Check the recipe checkers

    A public test of the free software that checks home-cooked recipes for dogs and cats. Thirty published recipes are cooked exactly as written and sent to an accredited laboratory for protein, fat, calcium, phosphorus, zinc, copper, iron and sodium. The same recipes go through the open calculators, and predicted and measured values are compared nutrient by nutrient.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Cat foods against new limits

    A public survey of phosphorus and calcium in cat foods on sale after AAFCO's 2026 revision. At least 80 dry, wet and raw cat foods are bought in shops, measured by an accredited laboratory and compared with the revised profiles and with FEDIAF's guidelines, with each product's results, label photo and batch code published.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Check the recipe checkers

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test of the free software that checks home-cooked recipes for dogs and cats. Thirty published recipes are cooked exactly as written and sent to an accredited laboratory for protein, fat, calcium, phosphorus, zinc, copper, iron and sodium. The same recipes go through the open calculators, and predicted and measured values are compared nutrient by nutrient.

Why it is still open

Open tools now exist, but none has been checked against laboratory analysis. PawCook, an app released under the MIT license in May 2026, computes portions against AAFCO, NRC and FEDIAF targets, and Open Animal Nutrition's guide to checking diets against the same three standards calls itself an "unvalidated scaffold" (October 2026). A UC Davis study of 200 published dog recipes, led by Jennifer Larsen, planned in 2013 to check every recipe with software and analyze 15 of them in a laboratory, and the 2019 São Paulo study measured diets without a calculator's prediction; neither tested the free calculators now in use.

github.comgithub.comccah.vetmed.ucdavis.edu

Built with what exists

PawCook and the Open Animal Nutrition checker; USDA FoodData Central for ingredient composition; a commercial feed laboratory using the Dumas method for protein and ICP-OES, a plasma instrument that measures minerals, as in the São Paulo and Colorado State studies; a kitchen scale reading to 1 g.

  1. First step

    Run ten free online recipes through both calculators and get one laboratory quote for the eight nutrients.

  2. Done looks like

    Thirty recipes analyzed, the error for each nutrient and each calculator published, and a count of recipes whose verdict (meets or misses FEDIAF's adult minimums) changes between calculation and laboratory.

Open 02 · the brief

Cat foods against new limits

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public survey of phosphorus and calcium in cat foods on sale after AAFCO's 2026 revision. At least 80 dry, wet and raw cat foods are bought in shops, measured by an accredited laboratory and compared with the revised profiles and with FEDIAF's guidelines, with each product's results, label photo and batch code published.

Why it is still open

The newest such count, of 82 US cat foods by Summers and colleagues, was made in 2020, when no maximum applied to phosphorus in cat food. AAFCO approved revised cat calcium and phosphorus profiles in August 2026 and expects makers to reformulate and verify their products, and no independent count against the new limits has been published.

ebi.ac.ukpetfoodindustry.com

Built with what exists

ICP-OES mineral analysis and Dumas protein analysis at a commercial feed laboratory; the label's energy statement (kcal per kg) to convert results to grams per 1,000 kcal; the revised profiles as published by AAFCO; FEDIAF's 2025 Nutritional Guidelines.

  1. First step

    Get the revised profile values from AAFCO's published materials and price the analysis of ten foods at a commercial laboratory.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 80 products from at least 20 brands measured, with the share above each revised limit reported beside the 2020 results.