Industries / Finance and business services / Payroll / PEOs
Payroll
This is the work of paying a client's workers, often under the PEO's own tax account, and of reporting and paying the employment taxes on their wages.
4
Milestones achieved, from 2004 to 2024.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
2004
Moving pay to cut tax
"SUTA dumping" is moving payroll between accounts to get a lower state unemployment tax rate. The SUTA Dumping Prevention Act, signed on 9 August 2004, set federal rules against it, and the Labor Department's guidance used a PEO as its example: "A PEO was recently found to be 'payrolling' by shifting its payroll to the account of a client with a lower rate." States still differ on whose account a PEO's clients are reported under. Indiana lets a PEO report all its clients under its own account or each client under its own, and Oregon passed a law in 2025 letting PEOs choose.
LessonA PEO that pools many clients' payroll can also shift it between rate accounts, so the law treats such shifts as evasion.
Credit
US Congress; US Department of Labor
2014
One employer for tax
A law enacted on 19 December 2014 created the certified PEO (CPEO). For the wages it pays to a client's workers, a CPEO "shall be treated as the employer... (and no other person shall be treated as the employer)" for federal employment taxes. The CPEO and its client also count as successor and predecessor employers, so the yearly Social Security and federal unemployment (FUTA) wage limits do not start again from zero when a client joins or leaves. In return a CPEO posts a bond of at least $50,000 and up to $1,000,000, files financial statements audited by an independent accountant, and makes quarterly assertions, checked by an accountant, that it has paid the taxes. It files one return for all its clients, with a schedule (Schedule R) dividing the totals by client.
Credit
US Congress, in the Stephen Beck, Jr. ABLE Act of 2014, part of the Tax Increase Prevention Act of 2014
2017
First PEOs certified
The IRS began accepting applications, with a $1,000 fee, in July 2016, and on 1 June 2017 it "issued notices of certification to 84 organizations," effective from 1 January 2017 for complete applications filed by 1 September 2016. ADP TotalSource was among them. The IRS list of active CPEOs dated August 2026 has 122 entities by this research's count, 68 of them with certification effective from 1 January 2017, and many belong to the same company.
Credit
Internal Revenue Service
2024
Tax money kept, not paid
Robert Kohnle ran Aliat, an Oregon PEO, and kept money that clients paid him for payroll tax withholdings "rather than pay the IRS," from late 2016 to late 2022, a tax loss of more than $22.6 million. On 9 January 2024 he was sentenced to 27 months in prison and ordered to pay $14,092,693.42 in restitution.
LessonThe IRS manual says the client employer "remains liable unless the third party is the section 3401(d)(1) employer or a CPEO" (a 3401(d)(1) employer is one that controls the payment of the wages), so a client's choice of PEO decides who owes taxes the PEO does not pay.
Credit
IRS Criminal Investigation and the US Department of Justice, which brought the case; Aliat (a failure)
Watch for
Pay errors caught before payday
Paychex, which runs a PEO, says its WISE AI system has handled "more than 350,000 workforce conversations, with more than 20% resolved without human involvement," that its voice agent "operates at nearly 100% accuracy," and that "nearly 90%" of pay errors were fixed before payroll day. It does not say how these were counted.
Achieved whenPaychex publishes how it counted the errors and an outside auditor or customer study confirms the figures.
Claimed by
Paychex, August 2026
Open
01
Wage limits when clients switch
A public answer key of invented cases on Social Security and FUTA taxes when a business joins, leaves or moves between a certified PEO, an uncertified PEO and its own payroll partway through a year. For each employer and each worker it gives the correct taxable wages and tax, and it comes with a published score for AI models and payroll software.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Unemployment rates on switching
A sourced table of each state's rule for reporting a PEO client's state unemployment tax (under the PEO's account, under the client's, or at the PEO's choice) and for what happens to the client's tax rate and claims history when it joins or leaves a PEO, with 100 worked cases.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Wage limits when clients switch
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public answer key of invented cases on Social Security and FUTA taxes when a business joins, leaves or moves between a certified PEO, an uncertified PEO and its own payroll partway through a year. For each employer and each worker it gives the correct taxable wages and tax, and it comes with a published score for AI models and payroll software.
Why it is still open
The rules come without worked numbers. The CPEO regulation has no examples, and the IRS manual says only that when an employee has several common-law employers in a year, the paying employer "will apply a separate FICA and FUTA wage base for each common law employer." The AI payroll tests this research found, Remote's PayMark and a synthetic payroll dataset posted in January 2026, do not mention wage limits or PEO changes.
Built with what exists
The statute, the regulation and the IRS manual; Python to work out the answers; AI models such as Claude Opus 5.5 and, for firms that keep payroll data on their own machines, the open-weight Mistral Large 4 (see the Note "A trillion open parameters").
First step
Write 15 cases around one worker who earns more than the Social Security wage limit and whose employer joins a PEO on 1 July, in three versions (certified PEO, uncertified PEO, back to its own payroll), and work them by hand.
Done looks like
150 cases, each answer worked out by script and checked by two people, one of them an enrolled agent or accountant, and each citing the rule it applies; at least three models scored three times each; all cases public.
Open 02 · the brief
Unemployment rates on switching
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A sourced table of each state's rule for reporting a PEO client's state unemployment tax (under the PEO's account, under the client's, or at the PEO's choice) and for what happens to the client's tax rate and claims history when it joins or leaves a PEO, with 100 worked cases.
Why it is still open
The fullest public list found, a guide from the employer-of-record firm Deel updated on 9 June 2026, sorts states into PEO-level, client-level and hybrid reporting. It labels some states differently in its table and its text, for example New York, Missouri and Kansas, and it does not say what happens to a client's rate on joining or leaving. A guide from Mosey classifies one state. Indiana's own page shows that the choice of account has lasting effects: a PEO reporting at the client level cannot change its election.
Built with what exists
State unemployment statutes and agency pages; a web agent to collect them; an AI model that reads long documents, such as Claude Opus 5.5, to draft each state's entry for a person to check.
First step
Code Indiana, Oregon, Florida, California and Texas from their own agency pages and compare the results with Deel's labels.
Done looks like
51 jurisdictions, each with its reporting rule and its rate rule on joining and leaving, citing the statute or agency page; two people code each one independently and agree on at least 95% of fields; 100 cases across at least 10 states giving the rate the client would pay.