Industries / Finance and business services / Payroll / PEOs
Benefits
This is the work of offering health, retirement and other plans to clients' workers, usually by pooling many small employers into one plan that buys like a large one.
6
Milestones achieved, from 1983 to 2024.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1983
States may police pooled plans
A multiple employer welfare arrangement (MEWA) is a plan that covers the workers of several unrelated employers. By the Labor Department's account, MEWA promoters used federal pension law (ERISA) to keep state insurance regulators out, and "a number of MEWAs have been unable to pay claims." A law of 14 January 1983 (Public Law 97-473) let states apply their insurance laws to MEWAs. Even so, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) found that MEWAs left "at least 398,000 participants and their beneficiaries" with over $123 million in unpaid claims between January 1988 and June 1991. In December 1991 the Labor Department told South Carolina that a labor-leasing firm's plan was a MEWA subject to state regulation.
LessonA pooled plan sold to small employers needs reserves like an insurer's, or its members' claims go unpaid.
Credit
US Congress; the Labor Department's guide names Congressman Erlenborn as the amendment's sponsor
2002
Retirement plans rebuilt
The IRS ruled in Revenue Procedure 2002-21, released on 24 April 2002, that a PEO's retirement plan covering client workers could break the "exclusive benefit rule," under which a plan must benefit its sponsor's own employees. A PEO could keep its plan qualified by turning it into a multiple employer plan, or else end it, by 31 December 2003 for a plan run on the calendar year.
Credit
Internal Revenue Service
2004
Bogus coverage counted
GAO identified 144 unauthorized entities that sold health coverage from 2000 to 2002. They covered more than 15,000 employers and "left at least $252 million in unpaid medical claims, only about 21 percent" of which had been recovered. Of these entities, 26% "were professional employer organizations, also known as employee leasing firms."
LessonEmployee leasing was one of the main channels through which unauthorized health plans reached small employers.
Credit
US Government Accountability Office, for the count; the entities (failures)
2019
PEOs sponsor shared 401(k)s
A Labor Department rule, effective 30 September 2019, let a "bona fide" PEO, one that performs "substantial employment functions on behalf of its client employers," sponsor one retirement plan for many clients. The SECURE Act then allowed "pooled employer plans" from 1 January 2021, open to unrelated employers "without the need for any commonality." In 2022 the IRS proposed an exception to the old rule under which a failure by one employer "will result in the disqualification" of a shared plan for all, a rule practitioners call "one bad apple."
Credit
US Department of Labor; US Congress; Internal Revenue Service
2022
One plan or many
The Labor Department's MEWA guide, revised in April 2022, says that a PEO health plan covering the employees of two or more clients "is a MEWA," and that a PEO's status as co-employer under other laws is "not determinative". TriNet calls this view "contrary to our interpretation" and to the position of other national PEOs, and Insperity describes its plan as "a single-employer plan." New Mexico passed a law in 2023 that treats employee leasing contractors as MEWAs. Maryland's insurance regulator wrote in January 2025 that Maryland, Maine and Wyoming are the only states that do not let PEOs offer large-group insurance to small clients, a count it took from a NAPEO email.
LessonWhether a pooled plan counts as one large employer's plan decides which insurance rules and prices apply, and the federal regulator and the largest PEOs still disagree.
Credit
US Department of Labor; New Mexico Legislature
2024
Health costs outrun fees
TriNet's insurance cost ratio, its insurance costs as a share of the insurance fees it charges clients, was 84% in 2023, 90% in 2024 and 91% in 2025. Its chief executive, Mike Simonds, said in October 2024 that it was "dealing with healthcare cost inflation steeper than we have seen in several years," and TriNet raised its fees. By its third quarter 2026 report, it was losing clients "primarily due to the repricing increases of our health benefits services," and it had ended 2025 with about 323,200 worksite employees, 10% fewer than a year before. At Insperity, group health costs rose 9.2% per covered employee in 2025.
LessonA PEO that sets a year's health fees in advance takes the loss when claims rise faster, and raising fees afterwards costs it clients.
Credit
TriNet (a failure); Insperity, for its figures
Watch for
A new health contract
Insperity says it extended its UnitedHealthcare contract through 2028 and, from 1 January 2026, lowered the level above which large claims are pooled to $500,000; through 2025 its responsibility had been "limited to the first $1 million of paid claims per claimant." In its third quarter 2026 results it reports benefits costs per covered employee up 4%, against 9.2% in 2025.
Achieved whenInsperity's annual report for 2026 shows full-year growth in health costs per covered employee below 2025's 9.2%.
Claimed by
Insperity, November 2025 and October 2026
Open
01
PEO health plans in filings
A free public dataset of the health plans PEOs sponsor, drawn from the Labor Department's Form 5500 filings: participants, insurer, whether insured or self-funded, and premiums paid, year by year, with premiums per covered worker set beside the government's survey figures for small private employers.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Large-group access by state
A sourced table showing whether each state lets a PEO cover small clients' workers under a large-group health plan, whether the plan must register as a MEWA, and any other limits, citing the statute, regulation or insurance bulletin for each.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
PEO health plans in filings
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A free public dataset of the health plans PEOs sponsor, drawn from the Labor Department's Form 5500 filings: participants, insurer, whether insured or self-funded, and premiums paid, year by year, with premiums per covered worker set beside the government's survey figures for small private employers.
Why it is still open
The only compilation found is sold: Mark Farrah Associates' "5500 Employer Health Plus", which reported UnitedHealth taking "over $2B in premiums while partnered with Insperity." NAPEO's researchers mined Form 5500 filings for PEO retirement plans, not health plans. The Labor Department's Form M-1 site, where MEWAs file their annual reports, is a filing system and describes no public search. Maryland's insurance regulator wrote in January 2025 that "Little empirical data exists" to judge PEOs' effect on its small-group market.
markfarrah.comnapeo.orgaskebsa.dol.govinsurance.maryland.gov
Built with what exists
The Labor Department's Form 5500 datasets, which include Schedule A, the insurance schedule; the IRS list of certified PEOs and state registers, to find PEO sponsors; the Insurance Component of AHRQ's Medical Expenditure Panel Survey, which publishes private-sector premium data by firm size and state; Python.
First step
Find the health plan filings of the five largest PEOs and pull their Schedule A premiums and participant counts.
Done looks like
Every PEO-sponsored health plan filing for three plan years, matched to at least 100 PEOs; 50 plans checked by hand against the filed form; premiums per enrolled employee compared with the survey's small-firm averages by year, with the method published.
Open 02 · the brief
Large-group access by state
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A sourced table showing whether each state lets a PEO cover small clients' workers under a large-group health plan, whether the plan must register as a MEWA, and any other limits, citing the statute, regulation or insurance bulletin for each.
Why it is still open
The one count found, that only Maryland, Maine and Wyoming bar it, comes from a NAPEO email cited by Maryland's regulator. New Mexico's 2023 law treats employee leasing contractors as MEWAs, and TriNet says New Mexico seeks to bar small clients from PEO large-group plans. A 2026 Maryland bill to exempt PEO plans for small employers from small-group rules has not moved past a hearing.
insurance.maryland.govosi.state.nm.ussec.govmgaleg.maryland.gov
Built with what exists
State insurance codes and bulletins; a web agent to collect them; an AI model that reviews long documents, such as Claude Opus 5.5, to draft entries for people to check (see the Note "Seven more flagged" on a Claude-based reviewer that found issues people had missed in long records).
First step
Code Maryland, Maine, Wyoming, New Mexico and Florida from their own insurance codes.
Done looks like
51 jurisdictions coded on at least five fields, each field cited; two people agree on at least 95% of fields; any difference from the NAPEO count explained.