BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Painting and abrasive blasting

Surface preparation

Surface preparation means getting steel clean, free of salt and rough enough before it is coated, and checking that it is.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1950 to 2020.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1950

    A council for painting steel

    The Steel Structures Painting Council was founded in 1950 as a nonprofit body for the coatings that protect industrial steel structures. By its board president's account in 2019, NACE, the corrosion engineers' society, and the American Institute of Steel Construction were among the groups that wrote its original charter. Its numbered surface preparation standards became the terms that US coating specifications use. A 2020 Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) study, for example, cleaned its test panels to "SSPC-SP 1, Solvent Cleaning" and blast cleaned them to "SSPC-SP 10, Near-White Metal". The council was renamed SSPC: The Society for Protective Coatings in 1997, and its standards are now published by AMPP, the society it later formed with NACE.

    pcimag.comfhwa.dot.govampp.org

    Credit

    the Steel Structures Painting Council and its founding members, NACE and AISC among them

  2. 1967

    Photographs set the grades

    The Swedish Standards Institution published SIS 05 59 00 in 1967, a standard for judging by eye how clean steel is before it is painted. ISO 8501-1, issued in 1988, is equivalent to the Swedish standard's 1988 edition. It defines four grades of rust and mill scale (the dark oxide skin that rolling leaves on new steel) on uncoated steel, and grades of cleanliness after blasting or after old coatings are removed. Each grade has a written description and photographs, 28 in all. Estonia's standards body describes the Swedish standard as used worldwide and published in 12 languages. Grade names such as Sa 2½, very thorough blast cleaning, now appear in coating specifications around the world.

    LessonA picture standard still leaves the call to the eye. The Australasian Corrosion Association notes that Sa 2½ has no exact US equivalent, sitting between SSPC-SP 10 and SP 6, and that specifications naming both cause disputes.

    codehub.building.govt.nzevs.eecorrosion.com.au

    Credit

    Swedish Standards Institution; International Organization for Standardization (ISO)

  3. 1995

    A patch to collect salt

    Salt left on blasted steel can make a coating blister and fail early. An SSPC technology update cited by the FHWA puts the danger at more than 50 µg/cm² (micrograms per square centimeter) of chloride or 100 µg/cm² of sulfate. ISO 8502-6, published in 1995, set out the Bresle method. An adhesive patch is stuck to the steel to extract its soluble salts for analysis, and it works on any shape and in any orientation, so inspectors can use it in the field before painting. ISO 8502-9 of 1998 added a field method that measures the extracted salt by the electrical conductivity of the water.

    evs.eeevs.eefhwa.dot.gov

    Credit

    ISO

  4. 2012

    Grades for water jetting

    By AMPP's definitions, water jetting cleans steel with water at more than 10,000 psi (about 69 MPa), and ultra-high-pressure jetting uses more than 30,000 psi (about 207 MPa). On 10 March 2012 NACE and SSPC issued four cleanliness grades for it, from WJ-1 (waterjetting to bare substrate) to WJ-4 (light waterjetting). They replaced the joint standard NACE No. 5/SSPC-SP 12, last issued in 2002. AMPP notes that water jetting does not create a surface profile, the roughness a coating grips. It only uncovers the profile already there, and flash rust that forms as the steel dries is graded separately as light, moderate or heavy.

    LessonWater can clean steel but cannot roughen it, which is why AMPP describes it as a method for maintenance and refurbishment, on steel that already has a profile.

    shop.standards.ieshop.standards.ieampp.org

    Credit

    NACE International and SSPC

  5. 2014

    Same steel, different salt counts

    FHWA researchers extracted salts from new A588 bridge steel in three ways. On average the latex sleeve method found 2.05 µg/cm² of chloride, boiling the panels in water found 0.61, and a clamped glass test cell found 0.15. The report cites earlier work finding that the patch method overestimated chloride by 50% on average. It also notes that rust holds salt at the steel's surface, where it is hard to extract, and that some abrasives add salt instead of removing it.

    LessonA salt limit means little unless the specification also names the test method.

    fhwa.dot.gov

    Credit

    FHWA Turner-Fairbank Highway Research Center, report FHWA-HRT-14-026, January 2014

  6. 2020

    How much salt coatings tolerate

    An FHWA literature review found published chloride limits for coated steel running from 1 to 50 µg/cm². It reported that the US Navy allowed 5 µg/cm² for non-immersion service and 3 for immersion, and that some state transportation departments used 10. R. Liu and A. Runion of the FHWA then dosed steel panels with 0, 20 and 60 µg/cm² of chloride, coated them with four systems, and aged them in the laboratory and outdoors. The three-coat systems tolerated up to 60 µg/cm² "without substantial effect on creepage", the spread of rust from a scratch, and the one with an inorganic zinc primer did best. Two-coat panels sprayed with salt water developed significant creepage.

    LessonNo single salt level is safe for every job; the safe level depends on the coating system and its service.

    fhwa.dot.gov

    Credit

    R. Liu and A. Runion, FHWA, report FHWA-HRT-20-065, September 2020

Watch for

  1. A model checks blasted steel

    SteelBlastQC is a public set of 1,654 photos of a steel yacht hull, each labeled "ready for paint" or "needs shot-blasting" by an expert, released with code. Its authors report 95% accuracy for two models on their own images. The labels are not the ISO 8501-1 grades, and every image comes from the one hull.

    Achieved whenan outside party tests the method on steel from other yards and abrasives, against inspectors' ISO 8501-1 grades, and publishes the accuracy.

    arxiv.org

    Claimed by

    Irina Ruzavina, Guangzhi Tang, Rico Mockel and colleagues, Maastricht University, in the proceedings of the 2025 International Joint Conference on Neural Networks, June 2025

  2. Laser clears salt and rust

    In a 2026 preprint, the authors report that a pulsed Nd:YAG laser removed thick rust from corroded, coated S355 structural steel at practical area rates. They say it left roughness equal to or greater than vacuum suction blasting and cut residual salt, measured by the Bresle method, to at or near the detection limit. Grinding and bristle blasting, a rotating power tool, often left less roughness and more salt. The steel was corroded artificially in the laboratory.

    Achieved whenthe work passes peer review and another laboratory or a field repair repeats it, with the repair coatings' performance reported.

    api.crossref.org

    Claimed by

    Till Vallée, Uwe Specht, Sascha Buchbach, Oliver Kranz, Thorben Steinberg and Marc Aurel Viehöfer, SSRN preprint, 2026

Open

  1. 01

    How often inspectors agree

    A public set of photos of blast-cleaned steel from working jobs. At least three certified coating inspectors each grade every photo separately on the ISO 8501-1 preparation grades (Sa 1, Sa 2, Sa 2½ and Sa 3). The set reports how often the inspectors agree and includes an image model trained to give the same grades.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Salt tests, side by side

    A round robin, in which many people test the same samples. Steel test panels are dosed with known amounts of chloride and measured by 10 or more inspectors with the field methods in common use: the Bresle patch read by conductivity, latex sleeve kits, swabs and automated cells. Each result is compared with the known dose.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

How often inspectors agree

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public set of photos of blast-cleaned steel from working jobs. At least three certified coating inspectors each grade every photo separately on the ISO 8501-1 preparation grades (Sa 1, Sa 2, Sa 2½ and Sa 3). The set reports how often the inspectors agree and includes an image model trained to give the same grades.

Why it is still open

Visual grading is known to cause disputes. The Australasian Corrosion Association says that results are "interpreted differently by individuals" and that Sa 2½ has no direct US equivalent, but a search in November 2026 found no study that measures how often inspectors agree. The one open image set of blasted steel that was found, SteelBlastQC, has 1,654 images of one yacht hull with two labels, not the ISO grades.

corrosion.com.auarxiv.org

Built with what exists

Phone cameras and a printed color reference card; Label Studio, an open-source labeling tool; Python with statsmodels for Fleiss' kappa, a standard measure of agreement among several raters; Meta's open DINOv2 vision model, fine-tuned on one graphics card; the SteelBlastQC code as a starting point.

  1. First step

    Ask two fabrication shops for permission to photograph 100 surfaces that are already blasted and waiting for inspection, taking photos only after blasting has stopped, and have two inspectors grade them separately.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 1,000 photos from at least 10 sites and three abrasive types, each graded by three inspectors and published under an open license. The release gives the kappa for each pair of neighboring grades, and the model's agreement with the inspectors' majority grade on held-out photos set beside the inspectors' agreement with one another.

Open 02 · the brief

Salt tests, side by side

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A round robin, in which many people test the same samples. Steel test panels are dosed with known amounts of chloride and measured by 10 or more inspectors with the field methods in common use: the Bresle patch read by conductivity, latex sleeve kits, swabs and automated cells. Each result is compared with the known dose.

Why it is still open

The FHWA's 2014 study compared extraction methods in one laboratory and got readings from 0.15 to 2.05 µg/cm² of chloride on the same kind of steel. The limits those readings are checked against run from 1 to 50 µg/cm². A search in November 2026 found no published round robin that gives the spread between inspectors and kits.

fhwa.dot.govfhwa.dot.gov

Built with what exists

Steel panels blast cleaned to Sa 2½ by a test-panel supplier or a fabricator, so the team does no blasting; a micropipette and sodium chloride solution to apply a known dose, as in the FHWA method; Bresle patches made to ISO 8502-6, a handheld conductivity meter, CHLOR*TEST sleeve kits and chloride test strips; a university laboratory's ion chromatograph as the reference, the method the FHWA used; a spreadsheet.

  1. First step

    Dose six panels at 0, 5, 10, 20, 30 and 50 µg/cm², measure each with two field methods, and send them to a laboratory for ion chromatography.

  2. Done looks like

    30 panels at five dose levels, each measured by 10 inspectors. The results, published with the raw readings, give the recovery (salt measured divided by salt applied) and the spread for each method and dose.