BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Nonprofits

Grants

Foundations and other funders give money to charities and projects, decide whom to fund, and set the terms.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1911 to 2025.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

In depth

The same ground is charted in more depth, as an industry of its own.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1911

    A trust for knowledge

    Andrew Carnegie founded Carnegie Corporation of New York in 1911 "to promote the advancement and diffusion of knowledge and understanding", the last of more than 20 organizations he set up. By 1912 he had given it $125 million, which the Corporation calls the largest single philanthropic trust established up to that time.

    carnegie.org

    Credit

    Andrew Carnegie

  2. 1957

    Foundation data made public

    Marianna Olmstead Lewis of the Foundation Center traveled by train to 62 Internal Revenue Service offices to copy foundations' financial records, which went into the first Foundation Directory. Candid, formed in 2019 when the Foundation Center merged with GuideStar, says her work established the public's right to see foundations' financial information.

    candid.org

    Credit

    Marianna Olmstead Lewis; the Foundation Center, now Candid

  3. 1969

    Foundations must pay out

    Congressman Wright Patman campaigned against foundations from 1961, and a 1965 Treasury report confirmed cases of self-dealing and of foundations that hoarded wealth. On 30 December 1969 President Richard Nixon signed the Tax Reform Act, which set private foundations apart from public charities, required a minimum yearly payout, added an excise tax and banned deals that benefit insiders. The minimum today is based on 5% of a foundation's investment assets.

    LessonFoundations that gave little brought rules for all of them.

    resource.rockarch.orglaw.cornell.edu

    Credit

    Wright Patman; the US Treasury; the US Congress

  4. 2009

    Small schools fell short

    From about 2000 the Gates Foundation made more than $2 billion in grants to build better US high schools, many of them small. In his 2009 annual letter Bill Gates wrote that "many of the small schools that we invested in did not improve students' achievement in any significant way", although many had higher attendance and graduation rates than their peers.

    LessonThe foundation found it had more success helping create new schools than changing existing ones.

    gatesfoundation.org

    Credit

    Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation

  5. 2016

    Grants as open data

    360Giving, a UK effort now run by the charity Funders Together, set a common format for publishing grants as open data, and its search tool GrantNav opened in 2016 with data from 25 funders. By September 2026 nearly 360 funders had published more than 1.5 million grants worth over £338 billion, by 360Giving's count.

    360giving.org

    Credit

    360Giving

  6. 2025

    Big gifts without strings

    MacKenzie Scott gives large grants with few reporting requirements and no time limits on spending. In the last report of a three-year study, the Center for Effective Philanthropy (CEP) surveyed 813 nonprofit leaders and compared the tax filings of recipients with similar nonprofits. Recipients held twice as many months of operating costs in reserve two years after the gift, nearly 90% reported no negative consequences, and only 7% expected much difficulty covering the costs the gift started.

    Lesson60% of foundation leaders CEP surveyed named a "funding cliff" as the main risk of such gifts, but few recipients reported one.

    cep.org

    Credit

    MacKenzie Scott; the Center for Effective Philanthropy

Watch for

  1. Gates Foundation to close

    Bill Gates said on 8 May 2025 that the Gates Foundation will spend about $200 billion over 20 years, about $9 billion a year, and close in 2045, with goals that include eradicating polio, controlling malaria and reducing child deaths. The endowment then held about $77 billion, and Gates pledged 99% of his remaining fortune, which the Associated Press estimated at about $107 billion.

    Achieved whenThe foundation's audited accounts show spending at about the pledged pace each year, and it closes in 2045.

    pbs.org

    Claimed by

    Bill Gates and the Gates Foundation, May 2025

  2. Set it at six

    The MacArthur Foundation pledged in early 2025 to pay out at least 6% of its endowment in 2025 and 2026, above the 5% legal floor, and in September 2026 extended the pledge through 2028. It estimates its 2025 charitable spending at $647 million, a payout rate of 7.1%.

    Achieved whenIts filed Form 990-PF tax returns, which are public, show a payout of at least 6% for each pledged year.

    macfound.org

    Claimed by

    John Palfrey, president of the MacArthur Foundation, September 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Open grants data for Europe

    Grant-by-grant open data for one country in continental Europe, in the 360Giving Data Standard's format, built from foundations' annual reports and project lists. Each row records who gave, who received, how much, when and for what, with a link to the page it came from.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Core grants and survival

    A study that links grants published through 360Giving to the Charity Commission's register for England and Wales, to compare how many recipients of core or unrestricted grants are still registered five years later with recipients of project grants of similar size. Classify each grant from its title and description, and check a sample by hand.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Open grants data for Europe

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Grant-by-grant open data for one country in continental Europe, in the 360Giving Data Standard's format, built from foundations' annual reports and project lists. Each row records who gave, who received, how much, when and for what, with a link to the page it came from.

Why it is still open

In the UK nearly 360 funders publish grants through 360Giving, by its count. US foundations list their grants on public tax returns, and Canada's charity tax returns list gifts between charities, which the Investigative Journalism Foundation publishes as a database. Philea, the association of European foundations, says data on foundations "is not standardised across Europe" and that financial data is missing in countries where foundations need not publish accounts; in 2023 it wrote that "a lack of truly open data" holds the field back.

360giving.orgtheijf.orgphilea.euphilea.eu

Built with what exists

The 360Giving Data Standard and its spreadsheet template, which anyone may copy and adapt; organization identifiers that link each recipient to an official register; an AI model that reads PDF reports, such as Gemini or Claude; Python.

  1. First step

    List the 30 largest foundations in one country from its national foundation association, and record which publish grant lists and in what form.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 10,000 grants from at least 50 foundations in one country, published under an open license; a hand check of 300 random rows against the source documents finds at least 98% correct.

Open 02 · the brief

Core grants and survival

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A study that links grants published through 360Giving to the Charity Commission's register for England and Wales, to compare how many recipients of core or unrestricted grants are still registered five years later with recipients of project grants of similar size. Classify each grant from its title and description, and check a sample by hand.

Why it is still open

The Institute for Voluntary Action Research wrote in 2023 that "there has never been a considered assessment" of the case and evidence for restricted versus unrestricted grants. A 2021 study of UK charities by Elizabeth Green and colleagues linked dependence on grant income to lower survival, but treated all grants as one type of income. CEP's 2025 study of MacKenzie Scott's unrestricted gifts followed recipients for about two years. This research found no study that uses grant-level open data to compare core and project grants.

ivar.org.ukapi.crossref.orgcep.org

Built with what exists

GrantNav's downloads; the Charity Commission's daily register extract, which records each charity's date of removal; a classifier such as Gemini Decision 1, which returns probabilities for fixed-answer questions (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); Python with lifelines, an open-source survival-analysis library.

  1. First step

    Download one year of GrantNav data and the register extract, and count how many grants match a registered charity number.

  2. Done looks like

    Five-year removal rates for every England and Wales charity that received a 360Giving grant awarded from 2016 to 2020, split by grant type and size band, with code published; the classifier agrees with hand labels on at least 90% of a 500-grant sample; the report notes that removal from the register is not always the date a charity stopped work, and that a link is not proof of cause.