BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Nonprofits

Fundraising

Charities ask the public, companies and wealthy donors for money, by letter, phone, event, text message and online.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1887 to 2016.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1887

    One campaign for many charities

    On 16 October 1887 in Denver, Colorado, a woman, a priest, two ministers and a rabbi formed the Charity Organization Society and ran a single fundraising campaign for more than 20 local health and welfare agencies. By United Way's account it raised $21,700, and the model grew into the Community Chest, the United Fund and, by 1970, United Way.

    unitedway.org

    Credit

    the founders of Denver's Charity Organization Society

  2. 1938

    Dimes by mail

    The National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis, set up with President Franklin Roosevelt's backing, first raised money for polio patient care and research through annual balls on his birthday. In 1938 the entertainer Eddie Cantor proposed "The March of Dimes", and radio, posters and film shorts asked the public to mail their dimes straight to the White House.

    LessonAfter polio vaccines arrived, the charity kept going by moving to birth defects and later to premature birth, so a charity named for one fight can outlast it.

    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govmarchofdimes.org

    Credit

    Eddie Cantor; Basil O'Connor and the National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis

  3. 2010

    Gifts by text message

    After the January 2010 earthquake in Haiti, donors in the US gave an estimated $43 million to relief by text message. A Pew Research Center survey of 863 of these donors found that 89% heard of the appeal on television, half gave the moment they learned of it, and 74% had never given by text before.

    LessonFast giving brought in new donors who did little research; 58% of those surveyed followed the rebuilding "not too closely" or "not at all".

    pewresearch.org

    Credit

    the Text for Haiti appeal; the study by Aaron Smith of the Pew Research Center, with Harvard's Berkman Center and the mGive Foundation

  4. 2012

    Giving days

    GivingTuesday began in 2012 at the 92nd Street Y in New York as a day that asks people to give, and is now an independent nonprofit. In China, Tencent began 99 Giving Day in 2015 on its online giving platform, adding matching money of its own. By Tencent's count, 2.05 million people gave RMB 130 million (USD 18.6 million) in the first year, and 68.7 million people gave RMB 3.57 billion (USD 520 million) in 2021.

    givingtuesday.orgtencent.comchinadevelopmentbrief.org

    Credit

    the 92nd Street Y (GivingTuesday); Tencent Foundation (99 Giving Day)

  5. 2014

    The Ice Bucket Challenge

    In the summer of 2014 people filmed themselves pouring ice water over their heads, named friends to do the same, and gave to fight ALS, a fatal disease of the nerves that control muscles. The ALS Association says 17 million people took part and that it raised $115 million. RTI International, a research firm, reported in 2019 that the money let the Association raise its yearly research funding by 187%.

    als.orgals.org

    Credit

    Anthony Senerchia, Pete Frates and Pat Quinn, whom the ALS Association credits with starting it; the ALS Association

  6. 2016

    Fundraising gets a regulator

    Olive Cooke, a 92-year-old poppy seller, died in 2015, and national newspapers said fundraisers had "hounded" her. At the Prime Minister's request, the Fundraising Standards Board investigated and found in January 2016 that 99 of the 1,442 charities it checked held her details, 24 had passed them on, and only 14 offered a way to opt out on every mailing. After a government-commissioned review led by Sir Stuart Etherington, a new Fundraising Regulator took over in England, Wales and Northern Ireland on 7 July 2016; it runs the Fundraising Preference Service, which lets people stop charities from contacting them.

    LessonSharing donors' details on assumed consent ended the sector's self-regulation of fundraising.

    civilsociety.co.ukfundraisingregulator.org.ukfundraisingregulator.org.uk

    Credit

    the Fundraising Standards Board; Sir Stuart Etherington's review; the Fundraising Regulator

Watch for

  1. Saying "AI" costs gifts

    Three researchers report that labeling a charity's Facebook ad as made with AI lowered clicks in a field test that reached 118,927 people. In four controlled experiments with 2,355 participants in all, revealing that a nonprofit used AI reduced giving, because people judged the charity less sincere; companies that disclosed the same AI use did not lose as much.

    Achieved whenAnother team finds a similar drop in actual gifts, not clicks or stated intent, in a field test with real donors.

    link.springer.com

    Claimed by

    Yujie Zhao, Pete Pengcheng Zhou and Zengxiang Chen, in the Journal of Business Ethics, January 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Check appeal price tags

    A public dataset of the cost claims charities make in appeals, such as "£15 pays for a night in a shelter", each matched to a figure the charity has published or marked as unsupported. Collect only public material: web pages, social posts and newsletters anyone can sign up for. Before publishing, send each charity its results and a chance to point to its evidence.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Donation forms by screen reader

    A repeatable test of whether people who use a screen reader, software that reads the screen aloud, or only a keyboard can complete charity donation forms up to the payment step. Stop before any card details are entered, so no money moves.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Check appeal price tags

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public dataset of the cost claims charities make in appeals, such as "£15 pays for a night in a shelter", each matched to a figure the charity has published or marked as unsupported. Collect only public material: web pages, social posts and newsletters anyone can sign up for. Before publishing, send each charity its results and a chance to point to its evidence.

Why it is still open

In the UK the Advertising Standards Authority requires charities, like other advertisers, to hold evidence for factual claims, but it acts on complaints one ad at a time. In 2002 it upheld complaints about a Tommy's poster that said "Your 50p will keep a premature baby alive for 1.8 seconds", because the charity funded research, not baby care. This research found no systematic audit of such claims.

asa.org.ukuk.themedialeader.com

Built with what exists

A web agent to collect appeal pages and sign up for newsletters (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); an AI model such as Claude or Gemini to pull out each cost claim; the Charity Commission's public register to find each charity's published accounts; a spreadsheet for two human reviewers.

  1. First step

    Sign up for the newsletters of 20 large charities and log every cost claim they send for one month.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 500 cost claims from the 100 largest fundraising charities in England and Wales, each classed as matched to a published figure, plausible but undocumented, or contradicted; two reviewers agree on at least 90% of the classes; the dataset, method and each charity's reply published together.

Open 02 · the brief

Donation forms by screen reader

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A repeatable test of whether people who use a screen reader, software that reads the screen aloud, or only a keyboard can complete charity donation forms up to the payment step. Stop before any card details are entered, so no money moves.

Why it is still open

The evidence found comes from the makers of donation software. Fundraise Up, for example, says its forms meet WCAG 2.2 AA, the middle level of the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines, and that auditors check this. Charities place such forms inside their own pages and settings, and this research found no independent test of many charities' live forms.

fundraiseup.com

Built with what exists

Playwright, an open-source tool that drives a web browser; axe-core, an open-source accessibility rule checker; NVDA, a free screen reader for Windows; paid testers who use screen readers every day.

  1. First step

    Run axe-core on the donation pages of 20 large charities and ask one screen reader user to try five of them.

  2. Done looks like

    200 live donation forms from charities in two countries tested; for each, the axe-core error count plus a pass or fail from two screen reader users on reaching the payment step with an amount chosen; results published by form platform and rerun after six months.