BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Motor rewinding

Deciding to repair or replace

Deciding to repair or replace is the choice, when a motor fails, between repairing or rewinding it and buying a new one, weighing price, downtime, stock on hand, energy use and the law.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1997 to 2023.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1997

    A US efficiency floor

    The Energy Policy Act, signed on 24 October 1992, required most general-purpose motors of 1 to 200 hp made five years later, from October 1997, to meet minimum full-load efficiencies, such as 94.5% for a 100 hp four-pole enclosed motor. The rule covers newly made motors.

    law.cornell.edu

    Credit

    US Congress; enforced by DOE

  2. 2010

    Premium becomes the US minimum

    The Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007 required general-purpose motors of 1 to 200 hp made after 19 December 2010 to meet Table 12-12 of the 2006 edition of NEMA MG 1, the motor standard of the National Electrical Manufacturers Association, which DOE calls the NEMA Premium or IE3 level.

    law.cornell.edugovinfo.gov

    Credit

    US Congress

  3. 2014

    Bigger motors get repaired

    A survey of 45 repair shops in China, Japan, New Zealand, the US and Vietnam, done for APEC, found that 54% of failed motors under 50 kW were repaired, 69% of those of 51 to 200 kW, 87% of those of 202 to 375 kW and 89% of larger ones, and that motors are rewound one to three times in lives of 16 to 30 years. It found no field data on motor failure and repair in China, Japan or Vietnam.

    Lessonbecause the shops kept no records in the survey's format, some answers came from staff experience rather than counts.

    cleanenergyministerial.org

    Credit

    Econoler, with ABB's research and development laboratory

  4. 2018

    India sets an IE2 floor

    Under a 2017 quality control order from India's Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion, all motors made in or imported into India had to meet at least IE2 under the Indian standard IS 12615 from 1 January 2018. Power Line magazine reports that 90 to 95% of motors sold in India had been IE1 or below, and that repeated rewinding lowers their efficiency further.

    powerline.net.in

    Credit

    Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion, Government of India

  5. 2021

    Europe and China raise floors

    After an IE2 floor from 16 June 2011, the European Union's Regulation 2019/1781 required three-phase motors of 0.75 to 1,000 kW to reach IE3 from 1 July 2021, and most of 75 to 200 kW to reach IE4 from 1 July 2023; it exempts motors sold as spare parts for a time so that older products can be repaired rather than scrapped. China's GB 18613-2020, in force from 1 June 2021, raised the minimum efficiency of three-phase induction motors and replaced two older standards.

    publications.europa.eupublications.europa.euchinesestandard.net

    Credit

    European Commission; China's State Administration for Market Regulation and Standardization Administration

  6. 2021

    Few plants plan the choice

    DOE's motor system market assessment, built on visits to a statistical sample of US plants and commercial buildings, found that 54% of industrial facilities had a repair-or-replace policy, 36% chose on lowest first cost and 8% on lifetime running cost, 74% replaced a failed motor with one of the same size, and 60% did not know whether their repair shop was EASA-accredited. Only 16% of commercial buildings had a policy.

    Lessonfacilities could give no rewind information for 46% of their 1 to 6 hp motors, so the repair history behind a choice is often unknown.

    osti.gov

    Credit

    Prakash Rao and colleagues at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, for DOE

  7. 2023

    A regulator moves the breakpoint

    To write its June 2023 motor efficiency rule, DOE had to assume which failed motors get repaired. After EASA and NEMA objected to a 20 hp cutoff, DOE assumed that motors below 100 hp are replaced and larger ones repaired at least once, noting that downtime and whether a new motor is in stock often matter more than price; EASA supplied counts from 11,000 rewind inquiries from 2017 to 2021, 32% of them about motors under 20 hp.

    Lessona national rule's repair assumption rested on comments and old guidebooks, because no one publishes repair decisions by motor size.

    govinfo.gov

    Credit

    US Department of Energy, EASA and NEMA

Watch for

  1. IE4 for large US motors

    DOE's 2023 rule raises motors of 100 to 250 hp to IE4, the "Super Premium" level with about 20% lower losses than IE3 by DOE's count, from 1 June 2027. A DOE enforcement policy issued on 10 June 2026 repeats that compliance with the 2023 standards is required from 1 June 2027, while giving inverter-only and synchronous motors until 14 October 2029 before DOE enforces its test rules for them.

    Achieved when1 June 2027 passes without a further delay and IE4 models across 100 to 250 hp are certified to DOE.

    energy.govgovinfo.gov

    Claimed by

    US Department of Energy, June 2026

  2. Circular rules for EU motors

    The European Commission opened a review of its motor rules on 25 August 2025, saying it will look at extending them to material efficiency and the circular economy, with new rules aimed for 2029. The 2019 regulation had asked the review to consider identifying and reusing the rare earths in permanent-magnet motors, and the study team, Viegand Maagøe and Fraunhofer ISI, surveyed makers' bills of materials until 30 September 2026.

    Achieved whena revised regulation with material-efficiency, repair or magnet-reuse requirements is published in the EU's Official Journal.

    energy.ec.europa.euenergy-efficient-products.ec.europa.eupublications.europa.eu

    Claimed by

    European Commission, Directorate-General for Energy, August 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Count repair decisions by size

    A public table of what happens to failed motors, built from shop job tickets and plant work orders: for each motor its power, age, fault, repair quote, new-motor price, lead time and the decision taken (repair, rewind or replace), summed into the share repaired in each size class.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Test the shelf assumption

    A weekly public record of whether new general-purpose motors are in stock and how soon they ship, by power from 1 to 500 hp, taken from distributors' public catalog pages where their terms allow, or from exports distributors agree to share, and set beside the rewind turnaround times shops quote.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Count repair decisions by size

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of what happens to failed motors, built from shop job tickets and plant work orders: for each motor its power, age, fault, repair quote, new-motor price, lead time and the decision taken (repair, rewind or replace), summed into the share repaired in each size class.

Why it is still open

DOE moved its assumed breakpoint from 20 hp to 100 hp in 2023 on the strength of EASA and NEMA comments and a utility guidebook, and EASA told DOE that substantive data on how often motors are repaired would need a poll of many end users. EASA's 2014 end-user survey, open only to members, found that half of plants automatically replace motors below a set size, with a median of 10 hp; DOE's 2014 guide put the cost breakpoint at 25 hp using 2011 prices. APEC's 2014 survey found no field data in China, Japan or Vietnam.

govinfo.goveasa.comenergy.govcleanenergyministerial.org

Built with what exists

Anonymized job tickets from cooperating shops and plants; the field list of the motor inventory module in DOE's free MEASUR software (GitHub ORNL-AMO/AMO-Tools-Desktop); an open nameplate reader such as GitHub mrchandrayee/motor_nameplate_reader_project to read nameplate photos; a model that answers fixed questions about each ticket, such as Gemini Decision 1 (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); DuckDB.

  1. First step

    Ask two repair shops for one year of anonymized job tickets and code 100 of them by hand to settle the fields.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 3,000 failed-motor decisions from at least 10 shops or plants in at least two countries; the share repaired in each size class with 95% confidence intervals; a second person checks 100 tickets against the table; data published.

Open 02 · the brief

Test the shelf assumption

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A weekly public record of whether new general-purpose motors are in stock and how soon they ship, by power from 1 to 500 hp, taken from distributors' public catalog pages where their terms allow, or from exports distributors agree to share, and set beside the rewind turnaround times shops quote.

Why it is still open

DOE's 100 hp assumption rests partly on the statement that most motors under 100 hp are typically on the shelf while larger and specialty motors are not, which DOE sourced to a Bonneville Power Administration guidebook for utilities. The APEC survey found that many plants hold no spare motors and choose fast turnaround over repair quality. A November 2026 search for motor lead times by size found reports on transformers and switchgear, and no public, repeated record of new-motor stock and lead times by size.

govinfo.govcleanenergyministerial.org

Built with what exists

A browser agent that records catalog pages on a schedule, such as one built with Browser Use 1.0 (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); Python; DuckDB or a spreadsheet; rewind turnaround quotes gathered from shops by email.

  1. First step

    List 100 NEMA Premium and IE3 catalog numbers from 1 to 500 hp and record their stock status at three distributors by hand for one week.

  2. Done looks like

    26 weekly snapshots covering at least 500 catalog numbers from at least five distributors in at least two countries; the share in stock and the median ship time for each size class; compared with turnaround quotes from at least 10 shops.