BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Government / Libraries

Collections

Choosing, buying, licensing and removing what a library holds, and defending those choices when someone objects.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1939 to 2025.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

3

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1939

    A written rule for selection

    The American Library Association (ALA), the main US librarians' body, adopted the Library Bill of Rights on 19 June 1939. It says library materials should not be kept out because of who wrote them, and should not be removed because of "partisan or doctrinal disapproval", which gave librarians a published standard to point to when someone asked for a book to go. ALA has amended it six times, most recently on 29 January 2019.

    LessonA written policy does not stop challenges: ALA tracked 4,235 unique titles challenged in 2025, second only to 4,240 in 2023, and 92% of challenges came from pressure groups, government officials and decision makers.

    ala.orgala.org

    Credit

    ALA Council

  2. 1976

    Weeding gets a formula

    The Texas State Library published the CREW method (Continuous Review, Evaluation, and Weeding), which turned weeding, the routine removal of worn, outdated or unused items, into a rule for each subject. Under the rule "8/3/MUSTIE", for example, a book is a candidate for removal if its latest copyright is more than 8 years old, or nobody has borrowed it in 3 years, or it is Misleading, Ugly, Superseded, Trivial, Irrelevant, or available Elsewhere.

    LessonWeeding needs a public record: in 2015 the director of Berkeley Public Library in California resigned after first saying about 2,200 items had been discarded that year and later acknowledging 39,000.

    archive.orgkqed.org

    Credit

    Texas State Library; the 2012 edition, by Jeanette Larson, "builds on the work of Joseph P. Segal and Belinda Boon"

  3. 1982

    Court limits school removals

    In Board of Education, Island Trees v. Pico, decided on 25 June 1982, the US Supreme Court let students' challenge to their school board's book removals go to trial. Justice Brennan wrote that school boards "may not remove books from school library shelves simply because they dislike the ideas" in them.

    LessonA plurality opinion, one whose reasoning lacks a majority of the justices, is a weak shield: on 23 May 2025 the full Fifth Circuit appeals court ruled 10–7 in Little v. Llano County that library users "cannot invoke a right to receive information to challenge a library's removal of books", and the Supreme Court declined to review that ruling on 8 December 2025.

    law.cornell.edureason.comsupremecourt.gov

    Credit

    Justice Brennan, joined by Justices Marshall and Stevens

  4. 2000

    Readers' requests become purchases

    In January 2000 Purdue University Libraries started "Books on Demand": when a reader requested a new scholarly book through interlibrary loan, the library bought it instead of borrowing it. This is demand-driven acquisition, buying what readers ask for rather than what librarians predict they will want. A 2010 Purdue study found these books were borrowed a mean of 4.1 times, against 2.4 for books chosen the usual way.

    LessonHeavy use is not the only goal: in 2012 William H. Walters argued that buying on readers' requests may not separate students' immediate wants from their long-term educational needs.

    docs.lib.purdue.edudocs.lib.purdue.edujournals.ala.org

    Credit

    Purdue University Libraries (Judith M. Nixon, E. S. Saunders and colleagues)

  5. 2011

    E-book licences start expiring

    From March 2011 HarperCollins allowed each library e-book to be lent only 26 times, after which the library had to buy it again; the publisher said selling e-books to libraries for good would "undermine the emerging e-book eco-system". From 1 November 2019 Macmillan sold each library system only one copy of a new e-book for its first eight weeks, and it dropped this embargo on 17 March 2020 after libraries such as King County and San Antonio stopped buying its titles.

    LessonA US state cannot simply order publishers to license e-books to libraries: Maryland's 2021 law requiring licences "on reasonable terms" was blocked on 16 February 2022 and declared "preempted by the U.S. Copyright Act" in June 2022.

    phys.orgamericanlibrariesmagazine.orgpublishersweekly.cominfodocket.com

    Credit

    HarperCollins; Macmillan (chief executive John Sargent)

  6. 2019

    Walking away from Elsevier

    On 28 February 2019 the University of California (UC) let its Elsevier "Big Deal" lapse. A Big Deal is a bundle of a publisher's whole journal list sold for one price. UC, whose 10 campuses produce nearly 10% of US research publishing by its count, left because Elsevier would not agree to universal open access for UC research. A new agreement began on 1 April 2021, under which UC libraries pay the first $1,000 of each article's open-access publishing fee. Germany's national consortium, Projekt DEAL, took a similar path: its talks with Elsevier collapsed in 2018 and a five-year deal came only in September 2023.

    LessonCancelling gives a library bargaining power only if its readers can manage without access for a while, and German researchers lived through what one called a "five-year gap".

    universityofcalifornia.eduosc.universityofcalifornia.edutimeshighereducation.com

    Credit

    University of California libraries; Projekt DEAL

  7. 2025

    A province orders removals

    On 4 July 2025 Alberta's education minister, Demetrios Nicolaides, issued Ministerial Order 030/2025, requiring school libraries to remove books with explicit sexual content by 1 October 2025, and Edmonton Public Schools drafted a removal list of more than 200 titles. On 8 September the province narrowed the order to visual depictions only and moved the deadline to 5 January 2026. Records released under an access-to-information request later showed that 41 of 63 school divisions reported removing books, more than 170 titles in all.

    LessonOne order can swamp a country's numbers: challenges reported by Canadian libraries rose from 172 in 2024 to 512 in 2025, and the Centre for Free Expression links 360 of the 2025 challenges to Alberta's orders.

    ablawg.calivewirecalgary.comthetyee.cacfla-fcab.ca

    Credit

    Government of Alberta

Watch for

  1. Limits on e-book contracts

    Instead of ordering publishers to sell, as Maryland tried, new state laws limit the contracts libraries may sign. Connecticut's 2025 law (Public Act 25-9) bars libraries from contracts that force them to buy a digital book again after a set number of loans or a set time. Rhode Island's bills H 7606 and S 2525 passed on 11 June 2026 and became law without the governor's signature; they also bar licences that charge libraries more than the public or charge per loan. Neither law is in force yet: Connecticut's starts only once other states with a combined 7 million people pass similar laws, and Rhode Island's once four other states with at least 10 million people do. A spokesperson for the Association of American Publishers called Rhode Island's bills "unconstitutional legislation".

    Achieved whena trigger is met, one of these laws takes effect, and libraries sign contracts under it that survive any court challenge.

    library.law.uconn.eduoceanstatestories.orginfodocket.com

    Claimed by

    the Connecticut and Rhode Island legislatures and the Connecticut Library Consortium, May 2025 to June 2026

  2. AI screening of school shelves

    Bookmarked, a Dallas startup, sells software it markets as "antivirus for libraries", which compares a school's catalogue with books challenged or banned elsewhere. Its chief executive, Steve Wandler, says it works with at least 150 Texas school districts, which pay $2 to $3 per student a year. Several districts, including Katy, Leander and New Braunfels, confirmed in October 2025 that they use AI tools to find titles that may break SB 13, the 2025 Texas law that makes school boards approve library purchases.

    Achieved whenan independent party confirms the district count from contracts and publishes measured error rates on a labelled set of books.

    k12dive.comhppr.orginfodocket.com

    Claimed by

    Bookmarked (Steve Wandler), April 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Scoring AI book screeners

    A public answer key for about 200 frequently challenged titles on one fixed yes/no question taken word for word from a statute, such as Iowa SF 496's test of whether a book contains "descriptions or visual depictions of a sex act". Two librarians label each title from the book itself and cite page numbers. Several AI tools then get the same question from title and author only, which is how Mason City, Iowa, asked ChatGPT in 2023, and each is scored against the key.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    A UK challenge register

    A public, sourced database of requests to remove or restrict books in UK school and public libraries from 2021 to 2026, using the fields of Canada's Canadian Library Challenges Database: date, library type, title, who complained, outcome and source.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  3. 03

    Current Big Deal prices

    A public table of what universities paid for the largest journal bundles, from Elsevier, Springer Nature, Wiley and others, in 2023 to 2026, built from public-records and Freedom of Information responses and extending SPARC's archived dataset. SPARC is a US group that campaigns for open research.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Scoring AI book screeners

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public answer key for about 200 frequently challenged titles on one fixed yes/no question taken word for word from a statute, such as Iowa SF 496's test of whether a book contains "descriptions or visual depictions of a sex act". Two librarians label each title from the book itself and cite page numbers. Several AI tools then get the same question from title and author only, which is how Mason City, Iowa, asked ChatGPT in 2023, and each is scored against the key.

Why it is still open

K-12 Dive reported in April 2026 that no independent accuracy evaluation of Bookmarked or of the Texas district screening exists. The nearest research, by Xucheng Yu, Emily Knox and Haohan Wang of the University of Illinois (August 2026, accepted at AIES 2026), put six AI models to 400 books, half of them from ALA's most-challenged lists, and found sexual content mentioned in 87.5% of answers about challenged books against 44.5% for unchallenged ones. It measured what models say about books, not whether they answer a legal test correctly, and it publishes no librarian-labelled answer key.

k12dive.comarxiv.org

Built with what exists

title lists from ALA's 2025 most-challenged list; Gemini Decision 1 to put the fixed yes/no question to each title at scale and return a probability for each answer (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); Claude, Gemini and GPT as tools under test; a local model through llama.cpp for runs that can be repeated exactly (see the Note "A first stable number for local AI"). Book texts stay in library-owned copies, and only labels and page numbers are published.

  1. First step

    Write the question in the statute's exact words, pick 30 titles from ALA's 2025 list, and have two librarians label 10 as a pilot to measure their agreement.

  2. Done looks like

    200 titles labelled, with the two librarians' agreement reported as Cohen's kappa, a standard measure of agreement beyond chance; at least 3 tools each run 5 times per title; each tool's false-positive rate, false-negative rate and run-to-run agreement published.

Open 02 · the brief

A UK challenge register

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, sourced database of requests to remove or restrict books in UK school and public libraries from 2021 to 2026, using the fields of Canada's Canadian Library Challenges Database: date, library type, title, who complained, outcome and source.

Why it is still open

The Runnymede Trust reported in 2026 that CILIP, the UK library and information association, "is calling for a central system to record book challenges". Canada has such a database, run by the Centre for Free Expression with the Canadian Federation of Library Associations, and the US has ALA's and PEN America's trackers, but this research found none for the UK.

runnymedetrust.orgcfla-fcab.ca

Built with what exists

a Browser Use agent to sweep council minutes and local news (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); Claude or an agent built with the Cursor Agent SDK to pull out the fields and link each one to its source (see the Note "Findings that cite notes"); Freedom of Information requests to local councils; Canada's database as the template.

  1. First step

    Copy Canada's field list, enter the cases already reported in the press, and send Freedom of Information requests to 10 councils asking for removal requests from 2021 to 2026.

  2. Done looks like

    at least 100 incidents, each with at least one public source; a UK librarian checks a random 20% sample and finds at least 95% of fields correct; published under an open licence and refreshed every quarter.

Open 03 · the brief

Current Big Deal prices

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of what universities paid for the largest journal bundles, from Elsevier, Springer Nature, Wiley and others, in 2023 to 2026, built from public-records and Freedom of Information responses and extending SPARC's archived dataset. SPARC is a US group that campaigns for open research.

Why it is still open

SPARC closed its Big Deal Knowledge Base on 17 February 2023, citing "the time and effort required to obtain up-to-date big deal subscription data". Its dataset of nearly 12,000 data points stays online for free reuse but is no longer updated.

sparcopen.orgzenodo.org

Built with what exists

the SPARC CSV file as a starting point; US state public-records laws and the UK Freedom of Information Act; Claude to pull prices out of contract PDFs (see the Note "Seven more flagged").

  1. First step

    Download the SPARC CSV, list the institutions whose latest entry is before 2020, and send records requests for current contracts to 10 of them.

  2. Done looks like

    at least 50 institutions with figures for at least 2 publishers, each figure linked to its source document; a librarian re-checks a random 10% against the documents and leaves no discrepancy unresolved.