BRENNEN

Industries / Consumer goods / Jewelry

Lab-grown stones

Lab-grown stones are crystals made in factories with the same chemistry and structure as the natural gem, grown from melted powder, from carbon dissolved in molten metal under high pressure and high temperature (HPHT), or from a carbon-rich gas in a vacuum chamber (chemical vapor deposition, CVD).

6

Milestones achieved, from 1902 to 2025.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1902

    Flame fusion grows rubies

    Auguste Verneuil, a French chemist, announced in 1902 that he had made ruby by dropping powdered chemicals through a very hot flame, where they melt and build up a single crystal called a boule, and published the method in 1904. GIA calls ruby the first gem created in a laboratory, and says flame fusion is still the cheapest and most common way to make synthetic corundum (ruby and sapphire) and spinel. By 1907 several makers were producing about 5 million carats of synthetic ruby a year, by Kurt Nassau's figure as cited by the Swiss Gemmological Institute SSEF.

    Lesson"Geneva rubies" sold from 1885, now thought to be flame-fusion stones, confused the trade, and SSEF's gemologists conclude that strict, consistent use of the word "synthetic" is what keeps buyers' trust.

    ssef.chgia.edu

    Credit

    Auguste Verneuil

  2. 1954

    Diamond made under pressure

    On 16 December 1954, H. Tracy Hall at General Electric made what the American Society of Mechanical Engineers calls the first verifiable synthetic diamond, in a high-pressure press of his own design. GE announced the result on 14 February 1955, and Bundy, Hall, Strong and Wentorf described it in Nature in July 1955. ASME named the apparatus a landmark in 1998.

    asme.orgdoi.org

    Credit

    H. Tracy Hall and the General Electric team

  3. 1970

    Gem crystals, but too costly

    General Electric grew cuttable, gem-quality diamond crystals in 1970 as a by-product of its high-pressure research, using a molten iron flux, and Robert Crowningshield described the four largest in 1971. In 1984 John Koivula and Charles Fryer of GIA studied eight of them and found they could be told from natural diamonds with standard gem tests.

    LessonKoivula and Fryer reported that one one-carat rough stone tied up an expensive press for at least a week, so making a gem diamond still cost far more than mining one; a lab gem changes the trade only once it is cheaper to make than to dig up.

    gia.edu

    Credit

    General Electric

  4. 2003

    Diamond grown from gas

    In chemical vapor deposition, diamond seed plates sit in a vacuum chamber with carbon-rich gases and the diamond grows on them layer by layer over a few weeks, by Pandora's description of the process. Wuyi Wang and colleagues at GIA described gem-quality CVD crystals grown by Apollo Diamond Inc. in Gems & Gemology in winter 2003: flat crystals of about a carat or more and a few millimeters thick, grown on a natural or synthetic diamond plate.

    gia.edupandoragroup.com

    Credit

    Apollo Diamond; described by GIA researchers

  5. 2018

    Lab-grown counts as diamond

    The US Federal Trade Commission revised its Jewelry Guides, effective 16 August 2018, and dropped the word "natural" from its definition of diamond, because lab-created products with essentially the same optical, physical and chemical properties as mined diamonds "are also diamonds". Sellers must still say clearly that such a stone is laboratory-grown, laboratory-created or made by a named maker, and may call it "cultured" only with a clear statement that it is not a mined stone.

    federalregister.gov

    Credit

    Federal Trade Commission

  6. 2025

    A miner quits lab-grown

    De Beers Group launched Lightbox in 2018 to sell lab-grown diamond jewelry at a flat $800 per carat, and announced in May 2025 that it would close it, saying wholesale prices of lab-grown jewelry stones had fallen 90% since the launch. Its subsidiary Element Six, which grew Lightbox's stones, now makes diamond only for industrial uses. The analyst Edahn Golan put wholesale lab-grown prices near $100 per carat in Surat and Mumbai at the end of 2025, with production costs of about $10.85 per carat.

    LessonOnce a gem can be made at will, its price falls toward the cost of making it; De Beers said lab-grown prices now follow "a cost-plus model".

    benchpeg.comgjepc.orgjckonline.com

    Credit

    De Beers Group

Watch for

  1. A carbon label per carat

    Pandora says a one-carat Pandora lab-grown diamond, grown with 100% renewable electricity, carries 12.58 kg CO2e (carbon dioxide equivalent) from raw materials to the polished stone, about 90% less than a mined diamond of the same size, by a study from outside life-cycle experts verified by the auditing firm EY. It now shows the figure for each lab-grown piece it sells.

    Achieved whensomeone outside Pandora and its suppliers reproduces the figure from metered factory energy data, or a peer-reviewed study of the same supply chain agrees within its stated range.

    pandoragroup.com

    Claimed by

    Pandora, May 2026

  2. India passes China in output

    A report by the diamond analyst Edahn Golan with Eyal Axelrod of Lexa International estimates that India grew about 8% more carats of gem-quality lab-grown diamond than China in 2025, out of a world total of 69.4 million carats, against 98.8 million carats of natural rough mined; China had been considered the largest producer.

    Achieved whena second independent count, such as national trade statistics or another analyst's survey, confirms India's lead.

    jckonline.com

    Claimed by

    Edahn Golan and Lexa International, November 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Open lab-grown carbon model

    A public, documented calculator for the electricity (kWh) and carbon (kg CO2e) per polished carat of lab-grown diamond, by growth method (HPHT or CVD), power source and region, with every input cited, and a table that tests published claims against it.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Lab-grown disclosure audit

    A public audit of how US online listings describe lab-grown diamonds: sample 2,000 listings across marketplaces and retailer sites and score each for whether "lab-grown" or an equivalent appears clearly with the word "diamond", as the FTC Guides ask, whether "cultured" is used without that disclosure, and whether environmental claims carry any support.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Open lab-grown carbon model

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, documented calculator for the electricity (kWh) and carbon (kg CO2e) per polished carat of lab-grown diamond, by growth method (HPHT or CVD), power source and region, with every input cited, and a table that tests published claims against it.

Why it is still open

Published energy figures disagree by more than ten times. Vladislav Zhdanov, Stanislav Evlashin and colleagues put modern HPHT presses at about 36 kWh per carat and their own CVD machine at about 215 kWh per carat, against 77 and 143 kWh per carat reported for two commercial CVD growers (Energies, October 2021); JCK reported in 2019 a producer's figure of 1,000–1,700 kWh per polished carat for CVD, and noted that the FTC called such energy claims difficult to substantiate. Furberg and Arvidsson wrote in ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering in 2023 that the life-cycle impacts of synthetic diamond are largely unknown, and published open process data for CVD diamond film, not gems. Pandora's 2026 figure covers only its own suppliers. A GitHub repository named Diamond-Carbon-Footprint-calculator (August 2025) holds only a title, and no open calculator per polished carat with grid emissions was found.

doaj.orgjckonline.comdoi.orggithub.com

Built with what exists

Furberg and Arvidsson's process data, published open access, and Zhdanov and colleagues' per-carat energy figures; grid emission factors from national sources and Ember's open electricity data; a Python notebook or spreadsheet; an AI agent that pulls energy figures and dates out of producer reports and press releases (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"), with a second model flagging doubtful extractions for a person to check (see the Note "Seven more flagged").

  1. First step

    Rebuild Furberg and Arvidsson's CVD diamond-film inventory in a spreadsheet from their supporting information and scale it from 1 cm² of film to one carat of single crystal, writing down every assumption.

  2. Done looks like

    A published model with a source for every input that reproduces Pandora's 12.58 kg CO2e per carat within 10% when given Pandora's stated conditions, gives ranges for HPHT and CVD on coal-heavy and renewable power, compares at least ten published producer claims, and has been reviewed by one life-cycle analyst outside the project.

Open 02 · the brief

Lab-grown disclosure audit

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public audit of how US online listings describe lab-grown diamonds: sample 2,000 listings across marketplaces and retailer sites and score each for whether "lab-grown" or an equivalent appears clearly with the word "diamond", as the FTC Guides ask, whether "cultured" is used without that disclosure, and whether environmental claims carry any support.

Why it is still open

The FTC's 2018 Guides say sellers must disclose clearly that a lab-grown stone is not mined, and enforcement has gone one seller at a time. The FTC sent warning letters to eight sellers of lab-grown diamonds and simulants in April 2019. In March 2021 the National Advertising Division, the US industry's self-regulatory body, told Diamond Foundry to disclose clearly that its stones are laboratory-grown and to stop calling them "real" without that context. In April 2024 the UK Advertising Standards Authority ruled that the online seller Skydiamond's ads did not make clear that its diamonds were lab-grown. The last two cases began with complaints from the Natural Diamond Council, which promotes mined diamonds. Web, Crossref and GitHub searches found no published audit that samples listings across the market.

federalregister.govjckonline.combbbprograms.orgnationaljeweler.com

Built with what exists

A crawler such as Playwright that respects each site's robots.txt and terms; a vision-language model such as Claude Fable 5.2 to read listing text and images (see the Note "Three working devices"); a reviewer model that flags doubtful scores for people to check (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); Label Studio for the human checks.

  1. First step

    Have two people label 100 listings from three marketplaces by hand and measure how often they agree.

  2. Done looks like

    2,000 listings scored and published with the share missing a clear disclosure by site, after the AI first pass agrees with two human labelers on at least 95% of a 300-listing check sample.