BRENNEN

Industries / Consumer goods / Jewelry

Grading and tracing

Grading and tracing is checking what a piece is made of and how good its stones are, and keeping a record of where they came from, through hallmarks, grading reports, instrument tests and digital records.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1300 to 2023.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1300

    A royal mark for metal

    A statute of Edward I set a standard for gold and silver and told the wardens of London's goldsmiths' guild to test wares and mark them with a leopard's head, which the Goldsmiths' Company calls the beginning of hallmarking in Britain. Makers' marks became compulsory in 1363. In 1478 the Company set up an assay office at Goldsmiths' Hall under a full-time assayer, added a date letter to the marks, and required workers to bring their wares to the Hall to receive the "hallmark".

    thegoldsmiths.co.uk

    Credit

    Edward I; the Worshipful Company of Goldsmiths

  2. 1907

    One carat, 200 milligrams

    Diamonds, pearls and gems were weighed in carats that varied from country to country and fitted no metric unit. On a proposal from its International Committee, presented by Jules Violle, the 4th General Conference on Weights and Measures in Paris (15 to 22 October 1907) approved the "metric carat" of 200 mg for the trade in diamonds, fine pearls and precious stones, and recommended that governments adopt it.

    LessonThe conference could only recommend; Belgium's weights commission wrote that it would have to tolerate the old carat in the wholesale trade, so each country had to make the change in its own law.

    bipm.org

    Credit

    General Conference on Weights and Measures

  3. 1955

    The first grading report

    Richard T. Liddicoat, who became executive director of the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) in 1952, built a full diamond grading system, with a color scale from D (colorless) to Z (light yellow), and first taught it to jewelers in 1953. Jewelers began sending stones to GIA to check their own grading, and the GIA laboratory issued its first formal diamond grading reports in 1955, by a 2008 history in GIA's journal Gems & Gemology; a GIA web page gives 1953.

    gia.edu4cs.gia.edu

    Credit

    Richard T. Liddicoat and GIA, building on a color scale that GIA and the American Gem Society had developed by 1941

  4. 2014

    A network drops lab reports

    RapNet, the diamond trading network of the Rapaport Group, stopped listing diamonds graded by any branch of European Gemological Laboratories (EGL) from 1 October 2014, citing "confusion and inconsistency" among EGL reports and "misrepresentation of diamond quality". National Jeweler reported that some EGL labs overstated color and clarity, sometimes by several grades, and that a Nashville retailer faced at least three consumer lawsuits over EGL-graded diamonds.

    LessonLetter grades are a common language only if every lab applies them the same way.

    nationaljeweler.com

    Credit

    RapNet and Martin Rapaport

  5. 2019

    Diamond testers tested independently

    The ASSURE program of the Diamond Producers Association and Signet Jewelers had UL, an independent testing company, test the 18 most widely available instruments for telling natural diamonds from laboratory-grown ones, from 11 makers, at its laboratories in Canton, Massachusetts, on a deliberately difficult set of natural, laboratory-grown and imitation stones. Results came out in March 2019. De Beers said its four instruments passed no laboratory-grown stone as natural and that two of them sent fewer than 0.75% of natural stones for further testing. A second round, ASSURE 2.0, began in summer 2022.

    institute.debeers.cominstoremag.comthediamondcollective.world

    Credit

    Diamond Producers Association, Signet Jewelers and UL

  6. 2021

    A code on every piece

    India made hallmarking of 14, 18 and 22 carat gold jewelry mandatory from 23 June 2021 in 256 districts, and from 1 July 2021 each hallmarked piece carries a six-character Hallmark Unique Identification (HUID) code, which buyers can check in the Bureau of Indian Standards' BIS Care app from 24 December 2021. The bureau counted 86.8 million articles hallmarked in 2021–22, and by 3 August 2026 eight phases had extended the rule to 392 districts.

    bis.gov.inbis.gov.in

    Credit

    Bureau of Indian Standards

  7. 2023

    A provenance ledger collapses

    Everledger, a Brisbane company whose blockchain platform (a shared digital ledger) let diamond traders and retailers share a stone's history, collapsed in March 2023 when an investor's second funding tranche did not arrive, and administrators from Vincents Chartered Accountants were appointed in April. It had raised more than $50 million.

    LessonA provenance record kept by one private company lasts only as long as that company's funding.

    jewellermagazine.com

    Credit

    Everledger, led by Leanne Kemp

Watch for

  1. A narrow range for lab-grown

    GIA said in June 2025 that it would stop using its natural-diamond color and clarity grades for laboratory-grown diamonds and would instead sort them as "premium" or "standard", giving no designation to stones below its minimum. Its reason: "more than 95% of laboratory-grown diamonds entering the market fall into a very narrow range of color and clarity."

    Achieved whensomeone outside GIA publishes the spread of grades in a large sample of laboratory-grown diamonds and confirms the 95% figure.

    gia.edu

    Claimed by

    GIA (Tom Moses, chief laboratory and research officer), June 2025

  2. Machines grade diamond color

    Sarine Technologies says its automated color grading, in its second generation since 2022, is commercially available for grading at manufacturers' own facilities and gives "better accuracy and consistency", and it publishes no agreement figures against a grading lab or human graders.

    Achieved whenan outside party grades a blind set of stones with the system and with a major lab and publishes how often they agree.

    blog.sarine.com

    Claimed by

    Sarine Technologies, March 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Same stones, several labs

    A blind, published test of grading labs. Take 30 polished diamonds, natural and laboratory-grown, that already carry a report; send each to at least three labs that grade that kind of stone; and send ten of them back to the same lab a second time. Publish every report, photos of each stone, and the share of stones on which the labs agree within one color grade and one clarity grade.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Reading hallmarks on jewelry

    A public test set of close-up photos of the marks on rings, chains and clasps, which are smaller, more curved and more worn than marks on tableware, each with an answer key (metal standard, assay office, date letter, maker's mark, and India's six-character HUID code where there is one), and a scoreboard of how well phone apps and AI models read them.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Same stones, several labs

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A blind, published test of grading labs. Take 30 polished diamonds, natural and laboratory-grown, that already carry a report; send each to at least three labs that grade that kind of stone; and send ten of them back to the same lab a second time. Publish every report, photos of each stone, and the share of stones on which the labs agree within one color grade and one clarity grade.

Why it is still open

The published tests are small and old. JCK sent five diamonds to GIA, IGI and EGL in 1995, and two came back two grades apart; in 2013 it sent one diamond to four labs. A Rapaport survey announced in June 2013 sent ten diamonds to labs in the United States and abroad and found color grades as much as three apart, without publishing every report. A search for a larger blind test, or any test since GIA changed its laboratory-grown reports in 2025, found only forum posts and retailers' rules of thumb.

octonus.comjckonline.comrubel-menasche.com

Built with what exists

Grading fees at commercial labs; a loupe and a carat scale to confirm each stone on its return; laser inscriptions or photographed inclusions to match stones to reports; a spreadsheet; optionally an automated grader as a fourth opinion.

  1. First step

    Buy five laboratory-grown diamonds that already have reports and send them to a second lab.

  2. Done looks like

    30 stones graded by three or more labs each, ten repeat submissions, all reports and photos public, and agreement rates for color and clarity with the size of each disagreement.

Open 02 · the brief

Reading hallmarks on jewelry

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test set of close-up photos of the marks on rings, chains and clasps, which are smaller, more curved and more worn than marks on tableware, each with an answer key (metal standard, assay office, date letter, maker's mark, and India's six-character HUID code where there is one), and a scoreboard of how well phone apps and AI models read them.

Why it is still open

The published work is on silverware. Atmik Tiwari, Vincent Christlein and colleagues released a hand-labeled set of goldsmiths' marks on silver objects, with code and a public web interface, in September 2026; their best method put the right mark first 73.74% of the time. Ellen van Bork, Robert Erdmann and Dirk Jan Biemond built a training database and neural network for hallmarks on Dutch silver in 2019. Phone apps listed in 2026 say they identify silver hallmarks from a photo; one, Silver Hallmark Identifier, publishes no accuracy test, and an open-source hallmark agent built on Anthropic's Claude API (April 2026) has no test set. Searches of GitHub, Hugging Face and the web found no labeled set of marks on jewelry.

arxiv.orgicom-cc-publications-online.orgapps.apple.comgithub.com

Built with what exists

A phone with a macro lens or a USB microscope; pieces whose marks an assay office or specialist dealer has read; the assay offices' published date-letter tables; a vision-language model such as Claude Fable 5.2 (see the Note "Three working devices") and a second model that flags doubtful readings for a person to check (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); labeling in Label Studio.

  1. First step

    Photograph the marks on 50 rings and chains whose marks a specialist has read, write the answer key, and score two apps against it.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 1,000 photographed marks on jewelry from four or more marking systems, released under an open license, with each app's and model's accuracy reported separately for metal standard, office, date letter, maker and HUID code, and the silverware method of Tiwari and colleagues run on the same photos as a baseline.