BRENNEN

Industries / Technology / Telecommunications / Internet providers and rural broadband

Funding programs

This work is public money that pays providers to build, or to price, internet service where what customers pay would never cover the cost.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1996 to 2025.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1996

    A fund for the internet

    The Communications Act of 1934, which created the FCC, set out to make wire and radio service available "so far as possible, to all the people of the United States" at reasonable charges, and the FCC says universal service policies since then made telephone service common in remote and rural areas. The Telecommunications Act of 1996 widened the goal to advanced services such as high-speed internet, and the FCC set up four programs inside the Universal Service Fund: support for high-cost rural areas (now the Connect America Fund), Lifeline for low-income households, and programs for schools and libraries and for rural health care.

    fcc.govlaw.cornell.edu

    Credit

    the US Congress; the FCC

  2. 2013

    One bidder for rural Britain

    The UK government's rural broadband program aimed to bring superfast broadband to 90% of premises in every area. On 5 July 2013 the National Audit Office reported that other suppliers had withdrawn from the bidding framework, leaving BT as the only active bidder and likely winner of all 44 local projects; that BT was now expected to put in 23% of the £1.5 billion projected cost, £207 million less than modelled in 2011, while receiving about £1.2 billion of public money; and that rollout would finish 22 months late. By 2026 Project Gigabit, the program that followed, had contracts with regional builders such as Fibrus, which won £108.5 million to reach up to 59,000 premises in Cumbria, as well as eight call-off contracts with Openreach, BT's network arm.

    LessonThe National Audit Office concluded the program was "moving forward late and without the benefit of strong competition to protect public value.".

    nao.org.ukgov.ukgov.uk

    Credit

    the National Audit Office (Amyas Morse); BT; Building Digital UK

  3. 2015

    Paid for yesterday's speed

    On 29 January 2015 the FCC raised its broadband benchmark to 25 Mbps down and 3 Mbps up, calling the old 4/1 Mbps standard "dated and inadequate." On 27 August 2015 ten carriers, most of them large national ones, accepted $1.5 billion a year from Phase II of the Connect America Fund, over six years, to serve 3,629,996 rural homes and businesses at only 10 Mbps down and 1 Mbps up, and USAC checked the build-out against locations the carriers reported themselves. In 2024 researchers at UC Santa Barbara and UC Berkeley audited more than 500,000 funded addresses in 15 states with their Broadband-plan Querying Tool (BQT), which enters each address on the provider's own website and records the plans offered. Service could be ordered at only 55% of the addresses certified as served, and only 33% met the program's requirements.

    LessonA subsidy checked mainly against the carrier's own reports of where it built can be paid for homes that still cannot order the service.

    docs.fcc.govtellusventure.comusac.orgsites.cs.ucsb.eduebelding.cs.ucsb.edu

    Credit

    the FCC under Chairman Tom Wheeler; the ten carriers; Haarika Manda, Laasya Koduru, Elizabeth Belding, Arpit Gupta, Tejas Narechania and colleagues (SIGCOMM 2024)

  4. 2018

    Africa's funds sit unspent

    A universal service and access fund collects a levy from telecom operators to pay for connections the market will not build. In March 2018 the Alliance for Affordable Internet (A4AI), with the Web Foundation and UN Women, found that 37 African countries had such a fund, that in 2016 these funds paid out just 54% of what they collected, and that about US$408 million sat unspent. A later GSMA report counted more than $265 million unspent across 12 countries and found that only 30% of the funds publish regular reports.

    LessonA levy collected for access connects no one until it is spent, and most funds did not publish enough to show whether it was.

    adi.a4ai.orgafricanwirelesscomms.com

    Credit

    A4AI, the Web Foundation and UN Women; GSMA

  5. 2020

    Auction winners walk away

    In the Rural Digital Opportunity Fund's reverse auction, providers bid for the smallest subsidy they would take to serve each rural area, and the FCC announced the winners on 7 December 2020: $9.2 billion for more than 5.2 million locations. By 2025, by the Benton Institute's count from FCC default records, $3.3 billion of those awards were in default and 1.9 million locations were no longer scheduled for service, more than one award in three. Over 95% of the defaults came before any money was authorized, but each winning bid had shut out every other applicant for the same area.

    LessonAn auction that ranks bids on price and checks whether the winner can build only afterwards can leave places with no builder at all.

    benton.orgfcc.gov

    Credit

    the FCC; the Benton Institute's analysis

  6. 2024

    A discount runs out

    The Affordable Connectivity Program took up to $30 a month off eligible households' internet bills, and up to $75 on qualifying Tribal lands, from 31 December 2021. It enrolled 23 million households, one in six nationwide by the FCC's count, and ended on 1 June 2024 for lack of additional funding from Congress, although a bill to add $7 billion had more than 200 co-sponsors.

    LessonA subsidy paid from a one-time sum ends when the sum does, however many people rely on it.

    fcc.govdocs.fcc.gov

    Credit

    the FCC (Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel); USAC, which ran the program

  7. 2025

    The fund survives in court

    Telecom carriers pay into the Universal Service Fund a share of their revenue set each quarter by a "contribution factor," which the FCC set at 25.2% for early 2022. Consumers' Research argued that letting the FCC and its private administrator, USAC, set that rate was an unconstitutional handover of Congress's power, and the full Fifth Circuit agreed. On 27 June 2025 the Supreme Court reversed it, 6 to 3, in an opinion by Justice Elena Kagan holding that the law's demand for contributions "sufficient" to fund the programs sets both a floor and a ceiling on what the FCC may raise. The opinion cites payouts of about $8.59 billion in 2024.

    law.cornell.edu

    Credit

    the US Supreme Court; the FCC and USAC

Watch for

  1. BEAD's $21 billion savings

    On 6 June 2025 NTIA replaced parts of the rules for BEAD, the $42.45 billion federal broadband grant program, with a "Benefit of the Bargain" policy. It dropped the preference for fiber, so that fixed wireless and low Earth orbit satellite service could compete on equal terms, and withdrew approval of all spending on "non-deployment" uses such as adoption and workforce programs. NTIA says the reforms put BEAD "on track to connect every BEAD eligible location while reducing costs by $21 billion and securing almost $12 billion in private matching funds." On 3 September 2026 it opened a second round for locations left unserved by defaults in other programs, misreported coverage or map changes, capped at each state's average cost per location, and left the rest of the savings to later guidance.

    Achieved whenstates report the funded locations as built, and an outside check, by GAO, an inspector general or independent measurement at the addresses, confirms service there within the stated budget.

    ntia.govbenton.orgntia.gov

    Claimed by

    NTIA, June 2025 to September 2026

  2. Gigabit for 99% by 2032

    The UK government says it is committed to nationwide gigabit coverage and expects 99% of premises to have a gigabit-capable connection by 2032, with Project Gigabit paying for areas that suppliers leave out of their commercial plans. It reports more than 30 signed Project Gigabit contracts, and its vouchers of up to £4,500 a premises closed to new projects on 31 August 2026.

    Achieved whenOfcom's Connected Nations report records gigabit-capable coverage for 99% of UK premises.

    gov.uk

    Claimed by

    the UK government and Building Digital UK, on a Project Gigabit page last updated 26 November 2025

Open

  1. 01

    One table of service funds

    A public table of every country's universal service fund: the levy charged on operators, the money collected and paid out each year, the balance carried forward and what it paid for, with each figure linked to the regulator's or fund's own report, and a flag where no report exists.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Subsidy per home, compared

    A public table of public money per home or business reached, award by award, across several countries' programs: UK Project Gigabit contracts, US BEAD state awards, the Connect America Fund and the Rural Digital Opportunity Fund, and Canada's Universal Broadband Fund, each with a note on what it counts (premises passed or connected, with or without the provider's own money).

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

One table of service funds

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of every country's universal service fund: the levy charged on operators, the money collected and paid out each year, the balance carried forward and what it paid for, with each figure linked to the regulator's or fund's own report, and a flag where no report exists.

Why it is still open

A GSMA report found that only 30% of Africa's universal service funds publish regular reports. A4AI's 2018 count of US$408 million unspent across 37 African funds was a one-time study. A search in November 2026 found reports and toolkits from GSMA, A4AI and ITU, but no maintained table that covers many countries year by year.

africanwirelesscomms.comadi.a4ai.org

Built with what exists

Regulators' and funds' annual reports; the A4AI and GSMA reports as a starting list of funds; a web agent such as Browser Use 1.0 to find and save each report (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); a language model to pull figures out of PDF tables, with a person checking every figure (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); Python and a public GitHub repository.

  1. First step

    For ten African funds, find the latest annual report, record the levy, collections, payouts and balance, and note which publish none of these.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 40 funds with five years of figures each, every figure linked to a saved copy of its source document, and one figure in ten checked by a second person.

Open 02 · the brief

Subsidy per home, compared

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of public money per home or business reached, award by award, across several countries' programs: UK Project Gigabit contracts, US BEAD state awards, the Connect America Fund and the Rural Digital Opportunity Fund, and Canada's Universal Broadband Fund, each with a note on what it counts (premises passed or connected, with or without the provider's own money).

Why it is still open

The OECD's 2025 review of national programs tabulates each country's targets, funding programs and cost studies, marks some cost estimates "Not published," and compares no cost per home across countries. The figures exist one award at a time: GOV.UK states that Fibrus won £108.5 million for up to 59,000 premises in Cumbria, and the FCC put Connect America Phase II at $1.5 billion a year for 3,629,996 homes and businesses. A search in November 2026 found US cost studies and state-by-state BEAD averages, but no comparison across countries.

oecd.orggov.uktellusventure.com

Built with what exists

GOV.UK Project Gigabit contract pages; NTIA-approved BEAD final proposals; FCC auction results; Canadian government project announcements; a language model to read award tables, with a person checking each row (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); a spreadsheet with published exchange rates and price indexes.

  1. First step

    Work out pounds per premises for every Project Gigabit build contract listed on GOV.UK.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 200 awards from at least four countries, each with amount, premises and source link, grouped by technology, with a median per program and a stated rule for passings against connections and for multi-year payments.