Industries / Mining and materials / Insulation manufacturing
Foam boards and spray foam
Foam boards and spray foam is the making of plastic foams whose small closed cells hold a gas that slows the flow of heat: boards and blocks made in factories, and foam made on site from two liquids that react and expand as they are sprayed.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1937 to 2024.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1937
Polyurethane chemistry discovered
At IG Farben's main laboratory in Leverkusen, Germany, Otto Bayer and his team found the diisocyanate polyaddition process, in which reactive compounds called diisocyanates join with alcohols into long chains. The Deutsche Biographie says the process opened the way to polyurethane plastics, used for insulation, car seats and coatings, and lists a 1954 patent application by Bayer and three colleagues for a way of making foams.
Credit
Otto Bayer and his team at IG Farben
1948
Polystyrene foam by extrusion
US patent 2,450,436, filed by Otis Ray McIntire of Dow Chemical in July 1947 and granted on 5 October 1948, dissolves a gas such as methyl chloride in polystyrene under pressure, then opens a valve so the gel flows out and expands into a block of closed cells. The patent says earlier work by Munters and colleagues had given "an excellent heat insulating material", and aims at blocks large enough to cut into insulating panels. Dow adapted the method into extruded polystyrene (XPS), a closed-cell foam that resists moisture.
Credit
Otis Ray McIntire, Dow Chemical, building on Carl Georg Munters
1983
Foam ban struck down
Urea-formaldehyde foam insulation (UFFI) raised formaldehyde, an irritant gas, inside the homes where it was used. The US Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) banned it in homes and schools on 2 April 1982, citing in-home measurements, residents' complaints and a study of nasal cancer in rats that its risk model turned into up to 51 extra cancers per million people. On 7 April 1983 the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, in Gulf South Insulation v. CPSC, held the ban invalid: it found the in-home data too imprecise and the cancer data too fragmentary to support the risk estimate.
LessonA ban is only as strong as the exposure measurements behind its risk estimate.
Credit
US CPSC; US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
2013
A flame retardant is banned
HBCD (hexabromocyclododecane) is a bromine compound added to EPS and XPS boards to slow ignition, and the Stockholm Convention on persistent organic pollutants says its main use worldwide was polystyrene foam insulation. The convention's parties listed it for elimination by decision SC-6/13, taken at their sixth meeting in Geneva, 28 April to 10 May 2013. Exemptions that Brazil, China, the European Union and others registered for building foam had all expired or been withdrawn by 26 December 2021. A US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) assessment of June 2014 found only three workable replacements for EPS and XPS, and judged one, a butadiene styrene brominated copolymer, "anticipated to be safer than HBCD for multiple endpoints".
LessonThe replacement is still a brominated and persistent compound, and EPA wrote that its long-term behavior in the environment "is not currently known".
Credit
Parties to the Stockholm Convention; US EPA Design for the Environment program
2017
Court stalls HFC switch
A blowing agent is the gas that expands a foam and stays in its cells. US makers of rigid polyurethane foam moved from CFC-11, which damages the ozone layer, to HCFC-141b, whose US production and import ended in 2003, and then to hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) such as HFC-245fa, which EPA accepted for all foam uses in 1999. HFCs spare the ozone layer but trap heat. On 20 July 2015 EPA's Significant New Alternatives Policy (SNAP) program moved certain HFCs to unacceptable for foam blowing and other uses. In Mexichem Fluor v. EPA (2017), the D.C. Circuit vacated that rule "to the extent it requires manufacturers to replace HFCs with a substitute substance", and EPA said it would not apply the rule's HFC restrictions for any purpose until a new rulemaking. Limits came back under a later law, the American Innovation and Manufacturing (AIM) Act: EPA's sector table sets a limit of 150 on global warming potential (GWP, the heat a gas traps compared with the same mass of carbon dioxide) for rigid polyurethane, XPS and phenolic boards made or imported from 1 January 2025.
LessonThe ozone law let EPA steer foam makers off ozone-damaging gases but not order a second move off HFCs; that took a new law.
Credit
US EPA; US Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit
2023
Training for isocyanate users
Spray foam and polyurethane boards are made from diisocyanates such as MDI. Commission Regulation (EU) 2020/1149, adopted on 3 August 2020, cites an estimate of more than 5,000 new cases a year of occupational disease from diisocyanates in the EU, mainly asthma. From 24 August 2023, industrial and professional users of products holding 0.1% or more diisocyanates by weight must complete training first and renew it at least every five years; spraying foam in open air or "with high energy" needs the advanced level.
Credit
European Commission
2024
Europe ends fluorinated foam gases
Regulation (EU) 2024/573, adopted on 7 February 2024, bans selling XPS that contains HFCs with a GWP of 150 or more from 1 January 2020, other foams with such HFCs from 1 January 2023, and from 1 January 2033 any foam that contains fluorinated greenhouse gases, except where needed to meet safety requirements. Those gases include, in the regulation's Annex II, the hydrofluoroolefins (HFOs) many makers had moved to, such as HCFC-1233zd (GWP 3.88) and HFC-1234ze (GWP 1.37).
LessonThe low-GWP fluorinated gases adopted to replace HFCs in foam have themselves been given an end date in the EU.
Credit
European Parliament and Council of the EU
Watch for
Flame retardant bonded into foam
LANXESS launched Purventis Core, a halogen-free phosphorus flame retardant for rigid polyurethane and polyisocyanurate (PIR) foams that reacts into the polymer instead of being mixed in, as additives such as TCPP are. LANXESS says its own tests show no contribution to total VOC emissions, stiffer foam than with conventional flame retardants, and higher efficiency than TCPP and TEP; no numbers or outside tests were given.
Achieved whenan independent laboratory publishes a fire classification and an emissions test for commercial boards made with it.
Claimed by
LANXESS, September 2026
Open
01
A register of blowing agents
A public table of foam insulation products sold in the US, the EU and at least one Asian market that gives, for each product, its blowing agent, that gas's GWP and the document the answer came from. A language model reads each maker's safety data sheets (SDS) and environmental product declarations (EPDs), and a person checks a sample. A new snapshot every six months shows the move off HFCs that US rules required from 2025 and that EU law requires for all fluorinated gases by 2033.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Spray foam emissions, compiled
An open, machine-readable dataset of every published chamber and test-house measurement of spray polyurethane foam emissions, giving the concentrations of MDI, amine catalysts, blowing agents and flame retardants in the hours, days and months after spraying. Each curve is digitized from its paper with units made uniform, and a script fits decay curves so that re-entry times can be compared across formulations and ventilation rates. No spraying is involved.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
A register of blowing agents
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table of foam insulation products sold in the US, the EU and at least one Asian market that gives, for each product, its blowing agent, that gas's GWP and the document the answer came from. A language model reads each maker's safety data sheets (SDS) and environmental product declarations (EPDs), and a person checks a sample. A new snapshot every six months shows the move off HFCs that US rules required from 2025 and that EU law requires for all fluorinated gases by 2033.
Why it is still open
EPA's SNAP lists say which gases are acceptable for each foam use, not which products use them. Association EPDs cover many brands under one label: the Spray Polyurethane Foam Alliance's EPD-085 (2018) lists more than twenty spray foam brands from several makers under one blowing agent. No product-level register was found.
Built with what exists
SDS and EPD files from makers' websites and EPD registries; a document-reading model such as Claude, or Gemini Decision 1 to pick each product's agent from a fixed list (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); GWP values from Annexes I and II of Regulation (EU) 2024/573; Python and a public Git repository.
First step
Download the SDS for the XPS and PIR boards of five makers sold in one country and fill the first 40 rows by hand to fix the columns.
Done looks like
At least 300 products from at least 15 makers in three regions, each row with agent, GWP, source link and date; a hand check of 50 random rows with the error rate published; a second snapshot six months later with a change log.
Open 02 · the brief
Spray foam emissions, compiled
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open, machine-readable dataset of every published chamber and test-house measurement of spray polyurethane foam emissions, giving the concentrations of MDI, amine catalysts, blowing agents and flame retardants in the hours, days and months after spraying. Each curve is digitized from its paper with units made uniform, and a script fits decay curves so that re-entry times can be compared across formulations and ventilation rates. No spraying is involved.
Why it is still open
The industry's Center for the Polyurethanes Industry tested three generic formulations at 10 air changes per hour for three hours, then 1 air change per hour, and posted the work as PDF reports in 2014. NIST's 2017 final report to the Consumer Product Safety Commission found emissions depend on chemistry, temperature, airflow and foam type, that small-chamber rates for flame retardants cannot be applied directly to a building, and that occupants of a test home could still be exposed to the flame retardant TCPP two years after open-cell foam went in; it was published as a report, with no dataset. Commercial labs such as Berkeley Analytical test products under ASTM D7859 for their clients. No compiled open dataset of these results was found.
Built with what exists
Published reports and papers (the CPI ventilation reports, ASTM symposium papers, peer-reviewed chamber studies); WebPlotDigitizer to read values off figures; Python with pandas and SciPy.
First step
Digitize the MDI and blowing agent curves in the CPI ventilation report.
Done looks like
At least 20 studies digitized, every value traced to a page and figure; a second person digitizes three curves and agrees within 5%; a published table of hours until each substance falls below a stated level, by formulation and air change rate.