BRENNEN

Industries / Mining and materials / Chemicals and petrochemicals / Industrial gases

Safety

Safety work keeps people from being suffocated, burned or struck when gases leak, burn or burst their containers, through standards, alarms and the study of accidents.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1913 to 2021.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1913

    Gas makers write safety rules

    The Compressed Gas Association (CGA) has written safety standards for industrial and medical gases since 1913 and now publishes nearly 500. US rules for shipping hazardous materials adopt CGA standards for testing and inspecting cylinders by reference. The CGA now writes shared standards with the Asia Industrial Gases Association, the European Industrial Gases Association (EIGA) and the Japan Industrial and Medical Gases Association through an International Harmonization Council.

    cganet.comlaw.cornell.edu

    Credit

    the Compressed Gas Association

  2. 1969

    Liquid CO2 tanks burst

    On 2 January 1969, at a plant making liquid carbon dioxide at Répcelak, Hungary, a storage tank burst while it was being filled, a second tank burst after it, and a third was thrown into a laboratory 30 m away. Nine people died and 15 were seriously hurt. France's accident database records the likely cause as overfilling because a level gauge had frozen, and says the tanks were made of steel not suited to low temperatures. In 1988 a liquid CO2 tank at a Procter & Gamble plant in Worms, Germany, failed and killed three people; after inspecting its other tanks, the company took most of them out of service.

    LessonCold liquid CO2 needs tanks made of steel that stays tough when cold and level gauges that cannot freeze.

    aria.developpement-durable.gouv.frdoi.org

    Credit

    BARPI, the French agency that keeps the ARIA accident database; W. Edward Clayton and Michael L. Griffin, who wrote up the Worms failure

  3. 1993

    Permits for confined spaces

    The US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) published its rule for permit-required confined spaces, such as tanks and vessels, on 14 January 1993. It defines an oxygen-deficient atmosphere as air with less than 19.5% oxygen by volume, against about 21% in normal air, and requires employers to test the air before entry, issue written entry permits and plan rescues.

    law.cornell.edu

    Credit

    OSHA

  4. 1997

    Haze ignites an air plant

    On 25 December 1997 the air separation unit at Shell's gas-to-liquids plant in Bintulu, Malaysia, which made 2,500 tonnes of oxygen a day, exploded and was destroyed; 12 people were slightly hurt and damage reached up to 5 km away. Shell's investigation found that fine particles from forest fires during a long haze had entered the unit and built up in it, and France's accident database adds residues from cleaning. The deposits ignited in the liquid oxygen, and the unit's aluminum packing burned as fuel. The plant restarted in June 2000.

    LessonAn air separation unit is only as clean as the air it takes in; in May 1997 a smaller unit at Fushun, China, had exploded after a burst of hydrocarbon pollution, killing four people.

    aria.developpement-durable.gouv.frogj.comaria.developpement-durable.gouv.fr

    Credit

    Shell's investigation, as reported by Oil & Gas Journal; BARPI

  5. 2003

    Counting nitrogen deaths

    The US Chemical Safety Board (CSB), which investigates chemical accidents, published a bulletin in June 2003 that counted 85 workplace nitrogen asphyxiation incidents in the US from 1992 to 2002, in which 80 people died and 50 were hurt. Nitrogen has no smell, so a person cannot sense air that is short of oxygen. Contractors were involved in 42 of the 85 incidents, and many happened in or next to confined spaces. The CSB noted that its count covered only incidents that were reported and accessible.

    csb.gov

    Credit

    US Chemical Safety Board

  6. 2021

    Oxygen fires in COVID wards

    Researchers at the European Commission's Major Accident Hazards Bureau counted more than 200 deaths in oxygen-related hospital fires worldwide from March 2020 to June 2021, including 82 people in a fire at a hospital in Iraq on 24 April 2021. Most victims were COVID-19 patients on oxygen. The authors note that a rise from about 21% to 24% oxygen in room air already makes a fire hazard, and that gas producers and health authorities were slow to warn hospitals.

    LessonOxygen leaking from many beds in a closed ward can raise the oxygen in the air enough that fires start more easily and burn harder.

    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    M. H. Wood, M. Hailwood and K. Koutelos, European Commission Joint Research Centre (2021)

  7. 2021

    Six deaths from one freezer

    On 28 January 2021 liquid nitrogen overflowed from a food freezer at Foundation Food Group in Gainesville, Georgia, and filled a room with no mechanical ventilation. Two maintenance workers died, then four coworkers who went in to help; three more workers and a firefighter were seriously hurt. The CSB's final report, in December 2023, found that a bent level-sensing tube let the freezer overflow, that the room had no oxygen monitor or alarm, and that the gas supplier, Messer, which owned and leased the freezer, kept supplying nitrogen despite known safety problems. It noted at least seven liquid nitrogen incidents with 13 deaths in the US since 2008.

    LessonWhere liquid nitrogen is used indoors, an oxygen alarm, an automatic shutoff and trained coworkers are what stand between one failed part and a room that kills rescuers.

    csb.govcsb.gov

    Credit

    US Chemical Safety Board

Watch for

  1. Fire codes add oxygen alarms

    After the Gainesville deaths, the CSB asked the US fire-code writers to require oxygen monitoring where liquid nitrogen and other very cold liquefied gases that can suffocate people are used. The National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) told the CSB that such language was approved for the 2026 edition of its NFPA 55 code for compressed gases and cryogenic fluids, and the International Code Council told it the same for the 2027 International Fire Code, expected in late 2027.

    Achieved whenboth codes are published with the requirement and the CSB closes its recommendations to them.

    csb.govcsb.gov

    Claimed by

    NFPA (accepted by the CSB on 4 December 2025) and the International Code Council (accepted on 16 September 2026)

Open

  1. 01

    Count asphyxiation deaths again

    A public, case-by-case record of US workplace deaths and injuries from nitrogen, argon, helium and carbon dioxide pushing oxygen out of the air, from 2003 to today, continuing the CSB's 1992–2002 count. Each case gives the date, place, gas, task, whether a rescuer was hurt, and the source.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Where to put oxygen alarms

    A public simulation study of where in a room an oxygen alarm sounds soonest after a liquid nitrogen release, for a few common rooms (a food-freezer room, a laboratory with storage flasks, a walk-in cold room) at several leak and ventilation rates, ending in a placement table.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Count asphyxiation deaths again

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, case-by-case record of US workplace deaths and injuries from nitrogen, argon, helium and carbon dioxide pushing oxygen out of the air, from 2003 to today, continuing the CSB's 1992–2002 count. Each case gives the date, place, gas, task, whether a rescuer was hurt, and the source.

Why it is still open

The CSB's 2003 bulletin is the last full count found, and it said its data were not complete. The CSB's 2023 Gainesville report lists only liquid nitrogen incidents since 2008. Searches for a newer count by EIGA, the CGA or NIOSH, the US workplace safety research agency, found older studies limited to deaths of workers wearing respirators, and none since.

csb.govcsb.gov

Built with what exists

OSHA's accident investigation search, which holds summaries of fatality investigations completed since 1984 and can be searched by keyword, date and industry; news archives for cases OSHA did not investigate; a model that answers a fixed set of questions about each summary, such as which gas and whether a rescuer was hurt, for example Google's Gemini Decision 1 (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"), with a person checking every case counted; a spreadsheet; Zenodo to publish with a DOI.

  1. First step

    Search OSHA's summaries for "nitrogen" with the fatality filter for 2003 to 2005, sort those cases by hand, and use them to test the model.

  2. Done looks like

    Every OSHA summary from 2003 to 2025 that mentions nitrogen, argon, helium, carbon dioxide, inert gas or oxygen deficiency read and sorted, and a published table of counts by gas, industry and year, each case linked, set beside the CSB's 85 incidents for 1992–2002.

Open 02 · the brief

Where to put oxygen alarms

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public simulation study of where in a room an oxygen alarm sounds soonest after a liquid nitrogen release, for a few common rooms (a food-freezer room, a laboratory with storage flasks, a walk-in cold room) at several leak and ventilation rates, ending in a placement table.

Why it is still open

In December 2023 the CSB asked the CGA to set requirements for where oxygen monitors go in liquid nitrogen systems, and the CSB still lists that recommendation as awaiting a response. Current guidance differs: Columbia University's 2026 guidance for building projects mounts monitors about 5 feet (1.5 m) above the floor, a monitor maker recommends about 1 m and warns that higher sensors may alarm too late, and the US National Institutes of Health says the height depends on the gas's density. In 2019 the safety group at EPFL, a Swiss university, published a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) tool, software that simulates how gas moves through a room, checked it against its own leak and spill tests, and used it to place detectors in its own laboratories, but it published no general table for other rooms.

csb.govresearch.columbia.eduvigiesolutions.comors.od.nih.govcetjournal.it

Built with what exists

OpenFOAM, free software for simulating gas flow, or NIST's free Fire Dynamics Simulator, which models how gases spread through rooms; the EPFL group's method as a model; the CSB report's description of the Gainesville freezer room for one case; published cryogenic release tests to check the model against; Python to run the many cases and draw the tables.

  1. First step

    Build a room like the Gainesville freezer room in OpenFOAM from the CSB report's description and run one overflow case.

  2. Done looks like

    The simulated time for oxygen to fall to 19.5% at sensor heights of 0.3 m, 1 m and 1.5 m and at breathing height, for at least three rooms, three leak rates and three ventilation rates, with the model checked against at least one published release test, and a table of placements that alarm before the air at breathing height falls below 19.5%.