BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Heat exchanger services

Plugging and retubing

Plugging and retubing is repairing tubes that leak or have thinned: sealing them shut with plugs, lining them with sleeves, or pulling them out and fitting new tubes into the tubesheet, the thick drilled plate that holds the tube ends.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1891 to 1990s.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1891

    Rollers seat the tube

    A tube is fixed in the tubesheet by expanding its end until it grips the hole. Richard H. Dudgeon and John Weeks of New York patented an improved roller expander in 1891, in which a tapering mandrel drives rollers that press the tube outward; their patent treats rollers as already "usual" and says earlier tools lost their rollers or cracked them "in heavy work".

    image-ppubs.uspto.gov

    Credit

    Richard H. Dudgeon and John Weeks

  2. 1972

    Titanium in the condenser

    Power station condensers cooled by sea or brackish water were losing copper alloy tubes to corrosion. Dennis J. Schumerth of the tube maker Valtimet, writing in POWER in 2011, says two US coastal utilities retubed condensers with grade 2 titanium from 1972 after years of side-by-side tests. EPRI's 1982 condenser retubing manual, written by Stone & Webster, reported that field tests and operating experience showed titanium and at least one high-alloy stainless steel "virtually immune" to the usual condenser corrosion, and a trend away from copper alloys.

    powermag.comosti.gov

    Credit

    two coastal utilities, not named in the source; EPRI; Stone & Webster Engineering

  3. 1980

    A retube that raised output

    The Tennessee Valley Authority retubed nine condensers with spirally indented "enhanced" tubes; Gallatin Unit 1 returned to service with them in 1980. Argonne researchers comparing TVA's records from before and after retubing at Gallatin and Shawnee found clean heat transfer 1.25 to 1.6 times that of plain tubes; the new tubes fouled faster but still did better for about a year without cleaning.

    Lessona retube can be an upgrade, but faster fouling takes back part of the gain.

    osti.gov

    Credit

    Tennessee Valley Authority; T. Rabas and R. Merring, Argonne National Laboratory

  4. 1989

    A plug breaks loose

    In February 1989 at North Anna Unit 1, a Westinghouse mechanical plug of thermally treated Alloy 600 cracked almost all the way round from stress corrosion in the reactor coolant. During a plant transient its top broke off, shot up the tube and punched through the U-bend, causing a significant leak. The NRC then required US utilities to remove, inspect or repair all such plugs and to stop installing them.

    Lessona plug sits in the same water as the tube and can crack the same way, so its material matters as much as the tube's.

    www-pub.iaea.org

    Credit

    US NRC; account in an IAEA review

  5. 1993

    Rolled joints crack

    By December 1993 at least 94 pressurized water reactors had found stress corrosion cracks in steam generator tubes at the roll transition, where a tube rolled into the tubesheet narrows back to its normal size, or at dents and U-bends; about 14,180 tubes cracked at or near the transition had been plugged at 85 plants, by EPRI's count. The IAEA ties much of it to Alloy 600 tubing "expanded by hard rolling", which leaves high stress locked into the transition. The worst steam generators had 20 to 38% of their tubes plugged and were replaced.

    Lessonthe way a tube is fixed decides where it later cracks; hydraulic expansion, which presses the tube out with fluid pressure, leaves less locked-in stress.

    www-pub.iaea.org

    Credit

    EPRI (data); IAEA (review)

  6. 1995

    Every tube sleeved

    A sleeve is a short tube slid inside a damaged one and expanded, brazed or welded in place to bridge the damage. Plugging was the only fix for steam generator tubes until the early 1980s; after 22 years of service, 60% of the tubes at Maine Yankee showed cracks around the circumference near the expansion transition, and the utility sleeved all 17,000 tubes in its three steam generators, by an NRC account of 1995. By 1997 sleeves were being laser welded in the USA, Europe and Japan.

    www-pub.iaea.org

    Credit

    Maine Yankee's owner; account in an IAEA review

  7. 1990s

    Copper out of the condenser

    Detroit Edison retubed the main condenser of its Fermi 2 boiling water reactor from admiralty brass to titanium. Copper from brass condensers had been tied to corrosion of fuel cladding at seven of twelve US boiling water reactors with such condensers and eleven of thirteen elsewhere, and 17 of those 25 plants were planning or making the switch, 14 to titanium and 3 to stainless steel. Titanium brought its own problem: in Swedish and Finnish nuclear plants, water droplets in the steam eroded titanium tubes, met by plugging, shields or partial retubing with harder alloys.

    Lessona tube metal can harm equipment far downstream, and its replacement can fail in a new way.

    osti.govosti.gov

    Credit

    Detroit Edison; J. W. O'Donnell and J. A. Mountford Jr (Titanium Metals Corp.); J. O. Tavast (ABB Stal)

Watch for

  1. Plugs that log themselves

    Curtiss-Wright's EST Group says its Smart Ram Plus, a cordless hydraulic ram with a pressure sensor linked to a tablet app, confirms that each Pop-A-Plug tube plug is installed correctly and records its tube location, lot number, pressure trace and photos, calling the system "first of its kind".

    Achieved whena plant or contractor outside Curtiss-Wright publishes a plugging job's records in which the system's pass and fail calls were checked against leak tests.

    valves.curtisswright.comvalves.curtisswright.com

    Claimed by

    Curtiss-Wright EST Group, product page dated June 2026

Open

  1. 01

    The right tube, by robot

    A robot arm that reads a tube map (the row and column of each tube to plug, as an inspection report lists them), finds those tubes on a mock tubesheet with a camera, pushes in plugs with controlled force and logs each plug's location and force. Bench mock-up only, with no pressure or fluid.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    A public retube ledger

    A public table of condenser and exchanger retubes and replacements, one row per project: site, year, tube count, old and new tube material, share of tubes plugged when the decision was made, the reason, labor hours, and back pressure or heat transfer before and after, each row linked to its public source.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

The right tube, by robot

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A robot arm that reads a tube map (the row and column of each tube to plug, as an inspection report lists them), finds those tubes on a mock tubesheet with a camera, pushes in plugs with controlled force and logs each plug's location and force. Bench mock-up only, with no pressure or fluid.

Why it is still open

Robotic plugging exists for nuclear steam generators, where radiation drives it; BWXT says its PRIMA manipulator handles all automated tube plugging in CANDU steam generators. In refineries plugs go in by hand: a 2024 refinery case describes mechanical plugs installed by hand in under 60 seconds, and Curtiss-Wright's 2026 system still uses a handheld ram. Flexiv's force-controlled robot inserts plugs on a compressor production line, not in exchangers. Finding the tubes is done in open code: a February 2026 GitHub app finds every tube opening in a photo of an evaporator tubesheet. A November 2026 search found no robot plugging industrial exchangers.

github.combwxt.combicmagazine.comflexiv.com

Built with what exists

A collaborative arm with force sensing, such as Flexiv's Rizon 4 or a Universal Robots UR5e; a wrist camera; NVIDIA's GR00T 2 robot model (Notes: "Five demonstrations per task") trained with Hugging Face's LeRobot (Notes: "No download"); an aluminum plate drilled on a triangular pitch with short 19 mm tube stubs; rubber test plugs or mechanical plugs.

  1. First step

    Drill a 20 by 20 hole plate, print five tube maps in the row-and-column style of an inspection report, and time a technician placing marked rubber plugs, counting wrong-tube errors.

  2. Done looks like

    Twenty filmed runs, each with a printed map of 25 tubes on a 400-hole mock tubesheet; all 500 plugs in the mapped tubes, with no plug in a wrong tube; every plug's row, column and insertion force logged; time per plug compared with two technicians on the same plate.

Open 02 · the brief

A public retube ledger

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of condenser and exchanger retubes and replacements, one row per project: site, year, tube count, old and new tube material, share of tubes plugged when the decision was made, the reason, labor hours, and back pressure or heat transfer before and after, each row linked to its public source.

Why it is still open

The figures exist one project at a time: TVA's before-and-after records at two stations; two condensers modeled by Argonne authors, who urged an economic study at each site; and one contractor's range of 5,000 to more than 50,000 labor hours for a large condenser retube. The worldwide plugging statistics in an IAEA report come from EPRI guidelines sold to EPRI members. A November 2026 search found no table across many plants.

osti.govosti.govpowermag.comwww-pub.iaea.org

Built with what exists

OSTI's free search API for conference papers and reports; utility commission filings and trade press; a document-reading AI model to draft rows, such as Claude (Notes: "Seven more flagged"), with a person checking every row against its source; a CSV file on GitHub.

  1. First step

    Code the TVA, Fermi 2 and Maine Yankee cases from the reports above and settle the column list.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 100 projects coded; a second person checks 20 rows chosen at random and agrees on at least 90% of fields; a first analysis published of the plugged share at which owners chose to retube or replace.