BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Heat exchanger services

Opening and pulling bundles

Taking an exchanger out of service, opening it and pulling its tube bundle out of the shell for cleaning or repair, then putting it back and starting it up, often several stories above the ground.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1962 to 2023.

0

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1962

    A cradle on a crane

    Before this, a bundle was jacked out by workers standing on a large steel scaffold, built for each job or left in place for good; bundles could be 4 ft (1.2 m) across, 20 ft (6 m) long, weigh several tons and sit up to 75 ft (23 m) above the ground. O. C. Huff and Norman C. Stanley of Port Arthur, Texas, working for Texaco, patented a pallet hung from a crane and clamped to the shell, onto which a motor-driven carriage drags the bundle; the crane then carries pallet and bundle away together. The patent was filed in May 1958, building on applications from 1957, and granted on 7 August 1962.

    image-ppubs.uspto.gov

    Credit

    O. C. Huff and Norman C. Stanley, Texaco

  2. 1971

    Hydraulic rams replace the winch

    Bobby J. Travis of Vidor, Texas, filed in September 1968 and was granted in March 1971 a patent for a crane-carried frame whose hydraulic cylinders step a skid along the frame to pull a bundle out or push it back in. His patent says the usual method was a cable on a powered winch with more cables from an overhead boom, criticized for the danger of a breaking winch line, the number of operators needed and the lack of any way to put the bundle back, and that earlier machines driven by screws, chains or cables did not support the bundle and damaged it.

    Lessona bundle stuck fast by deposits needs a controlled pull in both directions, not a cable that can snap.

    image-ppubs.uspto.gov

    Credit

    Bobby J. Travis

  3. 1972

    An overload warning stays dark

    In the UK on 13 May 1972, a crane lurched while lifting the channel cover, the bolted end plate, off a heat exchanger during maintenance. Its warning lights had failed to come on at 50% overload.

    Lessona crane's overload warning has to be shown to work before heavy parts come off an exchanger.

    icheme.org

    Credit

    recorded in the Institution of Chemical Engineers (IChemE) Accident Database, record 9344

  4. 1998

    Sling strikes a live line

    While a webbing sling was lowering a tube bundle into the lower of two stacked exchangers on a running crude unit, it struck the vent line of the exchanger in service and broke it, releasing about 32 barrels (5 m³) of crude oil. Nobody was hurt and nothing caught fire. The investigation found no method statement or formal risk assessment for the lift, and the vent line had been neither protected nor taken out of service.

    Lessona bundle lift next to running plant needs a written plan that names every live line within the load's reach.

    icheme.org

    Credit

    IChemE Accident Database, record 10605

  5. 2022

    Steam heats a blocked side

    On 11 July 2022, at a refinery in Burnaby, British Columbia, operators steamed out the shell side of a crude feed exchanger to prepare it for maintenance while its tube side was still blocked in and full of gas oil. The exchanger worked in reverse: the steam heated the trapped oil, the oil expanded, and the pressure blew the gaskets at the channel cover and between the channel and the shell. Nobody was hurt. Technical Safety BC, the province's safety regulator, found the site had no written step for draining one side of an exchanger before heating the other.

    Lessonan exchanger being emptied for maintenance can still burst its joints if one side is left full and the other is heated..pdf).

    files.technicalsafetybc.ca

    Credit

    Technical Safety BC (investigation)

  6. 2023

    One valve left open

    Two crude unit exchangers at the Pemex Deer Park refinery in Texas were shut down for cleaning on 12 February 2023. During startup on 23 February, a bleed valve on top of one of them was still locked open, though the operators believed they had dealt with every valve on the isolation drawing. About 164 lb (74 kg) of hydrocarbons at 562 °F (294 °C), above their autoignition temperature of 482 °F (250 °C), escaped and caught fire, causing an estimated $2.3 million in damage (Pemex's figure).

    Lessonthe CSB named the lack of a check, such as a leak test, that every valve is back in position before an exchanger returns to service.

    csb.gov

    Credit

    Pemex's investigation, reported by the US Chemical Safety Board (CSB)

Open

  1. 01

    Bundle weights from old drawings

    A tool that reads a heat exchanger's specification sheet and its general arrangement drawing, often a scanned PDF, and returns the bundle's weight, length, diameter and center of gravity, the figures a planner needs to choose an extractor and a crane, with each number linked to the place on the page it came from and the arithmetic shown.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    A record of bundle mishaps

    A public, coded table of accidents and near misses while removing, lifting, moving and reinserting exchanger bundles, drawn from IChemE's Accident Database extracts, the US Chemical Safety Board's incident reports, France's ARIA database, Japan's High Pressure Gas Safety Institute (KHK) reports, Technical Safety BC and OSHA's accident summaries. Each case is coded by step, equipment (crane, aerial extractor, winch, forklift), cause and harm.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Bundle weights from old drawings

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A tool that reads a heat exchanger's specification sheet and its general arrangement drawing, often a scanned PDF, and returns the bundle's weight, length, diameter and center of gravity, the figures a planner needs to choose an extractor and a crane, with each number linked to the place on the page it came from and the arithmetic shown.

Why it is still open

Planners still collect these figures exchanger by exchanger. Peinemann, a Rotterdam crane and extractor firm, describes a database of more than 25,000 exchangers with height, length, diameter and weight, built from site visits over decades; it is the company's own and not public. A search found document-reading tools sold for general equipment datasheets and drawings, but none aimed at exchanger datasheets or bundle weights; an open 2026 tool that sizes exchangers to China's GB/T 151 standard and checks them against Aspen EDR results works from design inputs, not from old drawings.

heat-exchanger-world.comgithub.com

Built with what exists

A model that reads PDFs and drawings, such as Claude Fable 5.2 (Notes: "Three working devices") or an open model fine-tuned on one GPU, such as Liquid LFM3 (Notes: "One GPU to fine-tune"); Python with pdfplumber; a short geometry calculation (tube count, tube size and length, tubesheets, baffles, steel densities) written out so an engineer can check it.

  1. First step

    Gather ten specification sheets and drawings that makers publish in catalogs or course material, work out the bundle weights by hand, and ask one maintenance contractor for crane load-cell readings from its last turnaround.

  2. Done looks like

    On 50 exchangers whose bundles were weighed on a crane load cell during a turnaround, the tool's weights fall within 10% for at least 45, every figure is traced to its source on the page, and a mechanical engineer signs off a written review of ten worked cases.

Open 02 · the brief

A record of bundle mishaps

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, coded table of accidents and near misses while removing, lifting, moving and reinserting exchanger bundles, drawn from IChemE's Accident Database extracts, the US Chemical Safety Board's incident reports, France's ARIA database, Japan's High Pressure Gas Safety Institute (KHK) reports, Technical Safety BC and OSHA's accident summaries. Each case is coded by step, equipment (crane, aerial extractor, winch, forklift), cause and harm.

Why it is still open

Bundle cases are filed among general crane and lifting records under each database's own headings. IChemE's lifting extract, for example, lists the 1998 bundle-sling release beside unrelated crane collapses and pipe lifts. No published count of bundle-handling incidents was found.

icheme.org

Built with what exists

Python and pandas; a language model to propose codes for each record, with every code checked by a person; machine translation for Japanese and French reports; a published codebook.

  1. First step

    Search IChemE's free extracts, ARIA and the CSB's incident report volumes for "bundle" and "tube bundle", and list every hit with its date and source.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 100 incidents from at least four databases coded, two people coding the same 30 cases independently and agreeing on at least 90% of codes, and the table published with the share of cases at each step.