BRENNEN

Industries / Retail, hospitality and personal services / Retail and e-commerce / Grocery

Cold cases and energy

This is the work of keeping chilled and frozen food cold on the shop floor, in display cases and the refrigeration plants behind them, while limiting refrigerant leaks and electricity use.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1930 to 2025.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1930

    Frozen food needs store cases

    On 6 March 1930 Birds Eye put what Supermarket News calls "the first line of frozen foods" on sale at a retail store in Springfield, Massachusetts, after Clarence Birdseye's work on quick freezing. The category was slow to catch on, and in the Depression many grocers could not afford freezer equipment. In 1934 Birds Eye had the American Radiator Corp. design a cheap low-temperature display case, which it leased to stores for $7.50 a month, or $10.00 for a larger model.

    LessonGrocers took up frozen food once the maker paid for the cases.

    supermarketnews.com

    Credit

    Clarence Birdseye; Birds Eye; American Radiator Corp

  2. 2007

    A benchmark for leaks

    The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) launched GreenChill, a voluntary partnership in which food retailers report their refrigerant leaks and set goals to cut them. At launch EPA put the industry's average leak rate at 25%, roughly a quarter of the refrigerant in a store's systems escaping each year, "based on research and expert input." Partner chains reported an average of 12.9% in 2021. By 2022 the partners ran about 13,500 stores, roughly a third of US food retailers.

    LessonThe industry average still quoted, 25%, is an estimate from 2007, not a measurement.

    epa.gov

    Credit

    US EPA; GreenChill's ten founding retail partners

  3. 2013

    Safeway pays for leaks

    On 4 September 2013 the US government settled claims that Safeway failed to repair leaks of the refrigerant HCFC-22 promptly and to keep servicing records. Safeway agreed to a $600,000 civil penalty and to cut its company-wide average leak rate from 25% in 2012 to 18% by 2015 across 659 stores, a plan EPA costed at about $4.1 million. EPA said the case involved the largest number of facilities ever under its refrigeration rules. In April 2026 the Justice Department lodged a proposed consent decree with Kroger over the same two kinds of failure, with $2.5 million in civil penalties.

    LessonThe same failures to repair leaks and keep records were alleged against another national chain 13 years later.

    epa.govfederalregister.gov

    Credit

    US EPA; US Department of Justice

  4. 2013

    A store cooled by CO2

    Hannaford Supermarkets opened a store in Turner, Maine, whose refrigeration runs on carbon dioxide alone, in a "transcritical" system built for the very high pressures CO2 needs. EPA calls it the first transcritical CO2-only grocery store in the United States, and says Hannaford's conversion of an existing store in Raymond, New Hampshire, in 2016 was the first such US retrofit. Canada was ahead: a count by shecco, a trade publisher, reported by the International Institute of Refrigeration (IIR), found 37 transcritical installations or orders there by 2012. CO2's global warming potential (GWP), the heat a gas traps compared with the same mass of CO2, is 1 by definition; R-404A, the most common refrigerant in GreenChill partner stores in 2021, has a GWP of 3,922.

    epa.goviifiir.org

    Credit

    Hannaford Supermarkets

  5. 2022

    California caps store refrigerants

    From 1 January 2022 California requires new refrigeration systems that hold more than 50 pounds (about 23 kg) of refrigerant, in new facilities, to use a refrigerant with a GWP below 150. Companies with existing grocery store systems must bring their company-wide average GWP below 1,400 by 2030, or cut their total emission potential 55% below 2019 levels. Chains with 20 or more California stores have an interim deadline of 31 December 2026.

    ww2.arb.ca.govww2.arb.ca.gov

    Credit

    California Air Resources Board (CARB)

  6. 2025

    Case efficiency rule overturned

    In January 2025 the US Department of Energy (DOE) published tighter energy standards for commercial refrigerators and freezers, display cases included, to apply from January 2029. DOE estimated they would save 1.11 quadrillion British thermal units (a unit of energy) over 30 years of sales, 6.5% of the equipment's energy use. Congress disapproved the rule under the Congressional Review Act, and DOE withdrew it on 20 May 2025, which leaves the standards set in March 2014 in force.

    LessonA finished efficiency rule can still be undone before anyone has to comply with it.

    federalregister.govfederalregister.gov

    Credit

    US Department of Energy; US Congress

Watch for

  1. Leak rates below 8%

    The Environmental Investigation Agency (EIA), an environmental campaign group, reports in its 2026 Climate-Friendly Supermarkets Scorecard of large US grocers that Meijer has an average annual leak rate below 8%, against EPA's industry estimate of 25%. Only four of the companies reviewed (Aldi, Meijer, Target and Kroger) disclose a leak rate for their US stores.

    Achieved whenan outside audit or EPA data confirm the rate, with the method and the stores covered stated.

    theshelbyreport.com

    Claimed by

    Meijer, as reported by EIA, June 2026

  2. HFC-free stores by 2035

    Aldi US reports that nearly 1,000 of its stores already run without HFCs (hydrofluorocarbons, the fluorinated refrigerants now being phased down), and it is the only company in EIA's scorecard with a public target to move all new and existing stores to natural refrigerants by 2035.

    Achieved whenan outside party, such as EPA's GreenChill program or a state regulator, confirms the store count and the method.

    theshelbyreport.com

    Claimed by

    Aldi US, as reported by EIA, June 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Leak rates for every chain

    An open table of yearly refrigerant leak rates for the 30 largest US grocers, from every public source: company sustainability reports, CDP climate disclosures, GreenChill awards, court settlements and state records. Each value carries its page link, the year, the stores covered and the company's definition of the rate. Where a company gives total refrigerant emissions and a store count but no rate, an estimate is shown with its method.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Shelf temperatures, open or doored

    A public survey of the temperature of chilled food at the moment it is bought, comparing open multideck cases (tall cases with open fronts and an air curtain) with cases fitted with doors. Volunteers buy a set basket (milk, sliced ham, yogurt, bagged salad) from each kind of case and measure each item's core temperature with a calibrated food probe within two minutes of paying. Each row gives the store, chain, case type, shelf height, product, temperature, time and outdoor temperature.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Leak rates for every chain

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open table of yearly refrigerant leak rates for the 30 largest US grocers, from every public source: company sustainability reports, CDP climate disclosures, GreenChill awards, court settlements and state records. Each value carries its page link, the year, the stores covered and the company's definition of the rate. Where a company gives total refrigerant emissions and a store count but no rate, an estimate is shown with its method.

Why it is still open

EPA's 25% industry figure is an estimate from 2007, and GreenChill publishes only its partners' average, 12.9% in 2021. EIA's 2026 scorecard found that only four of the US grocers it reviewed disclose a leak rate for their US stores, although EPA's leak-repair rules require stores to keep such records. Searches of the web, GitHub and Hugging Face found no table of rates by chain and year.

theshelbyreport.comepa.gov

Built with what exists

Company reports as PDFs; pdftotext and Python; an AI agent such as Meta's Muse Ember to pull figures out of long documents, with every figure checked by a person (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); a public spreadsheet on GitHub or Zenodo.

  1. First step

    Download the latest sustainability reports of Aldi US, Meijer, Target and Kroger and log every refrigerant figure they give.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 30 grocers and at least 200 company-year values from 2015 onward, each linked to its page. A second person rechecks 50 values at random and agrees on at least 48. A published chart sets each chain's figures beside EPA's 25%.

Open 02 · the brief

Shelf temperatures, open or doored

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public survey of the temperature of chilled food at the moment it is bought, comparing open multideck cases (tall cases with open fronts and an air curtain) with cases fitted with doors. Volunteers buy a set basket (milk, sliced ham, yogurt, bagged salad) from each kind of case and measure each item's core temperature with a calibrated food probe within two minutes of paying. Each row gives the store, chain, case type, shelf height, product, temperature, time and outdoor temperature.

Why it is still open

Lab tests favor doors: N. Chaomuang and colleagues reported in 2019 that a closed cabinet in a test room kept products colder and more even than an open one, even with frequent door openings. The store surveys found in this session date from the 1990s and 2000. A survey in Vest-Agder, Norway, found cabinet temperatures worse in 1997 than in 1995, despite a 1995 rule requiring daily checks, and worst on the upper shelves of open multideck cabinets. Doors have spread since then, but no recent open dataset of product temperatures in stores by case type was found.

iifiir.orgiifiir.org

Built with what exists

Calibrated digital probe thermometers, checked in ice water before each session; a phone form such as KoboToolbox; Python for the analysis.

  1. First step

    Check two probes in ice water, then measure 30 items bought from open and doored cases in two stores.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 1,200 readings from at least 40 stores of at least six chains, half of them from doored cases. Published: the share of items above 5 °C and above 8 °C for each case type and shelf height, with the full data.