BRENNEN

Industries / Health / Healthcare / Medical labs / Genetic testing and diagnostics

Privacy

Who may see, keep, sell or search genetic data, and what laws, courts and regulators have said about it; a person's DNA also says something about their relatives.

7

Milestones achieved, from 2003 to 2026.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2003

    Iceland's database law fails

    Iceland's Act No. 139/1998 let a licensed company build a national Health Sector Database from medical records, with patients counted as consenting unless they opted out. In 2003 the Supreme Court of Iceland upheld a woman's claim to keep her late father's records out, because information about his hereditary traits could also apply to her. It found that the act did not adequately ensure the data would stay non-identifiable, as the constitution's privacy article requires.

    LessonGenetic information about one person is also information about their relatives.

    europepmc.orgpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    Supreme Court of Iceland

  2. 2008

    Pooled DNA was not anonymous

    Nils Homer, David Craig and colleagues at the Translational Genomics Research Institute (TGen) in Phoenix showed that a person's presence in a DNA mixture can be detected even when they supply less than 0.1% of it. They concluded that summary statistics, such as how common each variant is among a study's participants, do not hide who took part in a genetic study. After their paper the US National Institutes of Health (NIH) and other data holders moved such summary data from public websites to controlled-access databases such as dbGaP.

    LessonNumbers published about a group can reveal its members when an outsider holds one member's DNA.

    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    Nils Homer, David W. Craig and colleagues, TGen

  3. 2008

    Health insurers barred, not life

    The Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA), signed on 21 May 2008, bars US health insurers from using genetic information to decide eligibility, coverage or premiums, and bars employers from using it in hiring, firing, promotion, pay and job assignments. It does not cover life, disability or long-term care insurance, the military, or employers with fewer than 15 employees.

    govinfo.govgenome.gov

    Credit

    US Congress

  4. 2009

    Blood spots go to court

    Newborn screening programs test a few drops of blood from a baby's heel, dried on a card, and many states kept the leftover spots. Families in Texas sued the state health department in March 2009, claiming that storing and using the spots for undisclosed research was an unlawful search and seizure. The case was settled, and the settlement required the state to destroy more than 5 million stored spots. A Minnesota suit under that state's Genetic Privacy Act was dismissed, the dismissal was upheld on appeal in 2010, and the case went on to the Minnesota Supreme Court.

    LessonSamples taken in a mandatory public health program need public rules and parents' consent for any other use.

    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    the plaintiff families; Texas Department of State Health Services

  5. 2018

    Cousins' DNA names suspects

    In 2013 Melissa Gymrek, Yaniv Erlich and colleagues showed that surnames can be inferred from Y-chromosome markers by searching genealogy websites. In 2018 investigators uploaded a DNA profile made from a crime-scene sample to GEDmatch, a free site where people share their consumer test files, found a third-degree cousin and traced the Golden State Killer; at least 13 cases were reported solved this way between April and August 2018. Erlich and colleagues estimated that about 60% of such searches for US people of European descent would find a third cousin or closer, and that the method could soon reach nearly anyone in that group. From 1 November 2019 the US Justice Department limited its own investigators mainly to unsolved homicides and sex crimes and to the remains of suspected homicide victims, with other violent crimes needing a prosecutor's approval, and to sites that tell users police may search them.

    LessonPeople who never took a test can be found through relatives who did.

    europepmc.orgpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govjustice.gov

    Credit

    investigators in the Golden State Killer case; Yaniv Erlich, Tal Shor, Itsik Pe'er and Shai Carmi; US Department of Justice

  6. 2023

    A breach through relatives

    Between April and September 2023 an attacker logged into about 0.1% of 23andMe accounts with passwords reused from other breaches, and through the DNA Relatives matching feature downloaded profile information that many more users had shared with their genetic relatives. In June 2025 the UK Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) fined the company £2.31 million after a joint investigation with Canada's privacy commissioner. It found no mandatory multi-factor authentication, data on 155,592 UK residents exposed, and a full investigation that began only in October 2023, when an employee saw the data advertised for sale. 23andMe filed for bankruptcy on 23 March 2025, and on 14 July 2025 sold substantially all its assets, including the Personal Genome Service, to TTAM Research Institute, a nonprofit led by co-founder Anne Wojcicki, for USD 305 million.

    LessonA matching feature turns one person's reused password into an exposure for their relatives.

    sec.govico.org.uksec.gov

    Credit

    UK ICO; Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada

  7. 2026

    Australia bars insurers' use

    On 1 April 2026 Australia's Parliament passed a law that bars life insurers from using adverse predictive genetic test results to deny or limit cover, and it took full effect on 8 October 2026. Applicants may still volunteer a result in writing, and insurers may use it only where it does not worsen the offer. Until then insurers could legally use such results, and Monash University researchers say many people delayed or skipped testing for that reason.

    ministers.treasury.gov.aumonash.edu

    Credit

    Australian Parliament; Assistant Treasurer Daniel Mulino, who led the bill through Parliament

Watch for

  1. A pledge to keep policies

    When the bankruptcy court approved the sale of 23andMe, the company said TTAM Research Institute was committed to adhering to 23andMe's existing privacy policies "in perpetuity", adopting further safeguards, and letting customers change their decision on joining research.

    Achieved whenan outside auditor or a state attorney general reports that TTAM has kept those policies and carried out deletion requests.

    sec.gov

    Claimed by

    23andMe and TTAM Research Institute, June 2025

  2. A list of barred suppliers

    Since 8 April 2025 a US Justice Department rule has barred deals that give China, Cuba, Iran, North Korea, Russia or Venezuela, or people and companies tied to them, access to genomic data on more than 100 US people. The BIOSECURE Act, signed on 18 December 2025, goes further for federal contracts: agencies may not buy biotechnology equipment or services from "biotechnology companies of concern", judged in part on whether a company passes multiomic data, meaning genetic and related molecular data, to a foreign adversary government or collects human multiomic data without express, informed consent. The Office of Management and Budget (OMB) must publish the list by December 2026. The sequencing companies BGI and MGI were on the Pentagon's list of Chinese military companies when the act was signed, and Complete Genomics and Novogene were added on 8 June 2026.

    Achieved whenOMB publishes the list and the federal purchasing rules are revised so that the ban applies to contracts.

    federalregister.govarnoldporter.comgtlaw.com

    Claimed by

    US Congress, in the defense act for fiscal 2026, December 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Privacy terms, tracked weekly

    A public archive that saves, every week, the privacy policy, terms of service, research consent form and law enforcement guide of the 30 largest consumer DNA companies, records each change with its date, and scores every version on one fixed checklist: whether a user can delete their data and have the sample destroyed, whether data is shared for research by default, what happens to it if the company is sold, whether police access needs a warrant, and whether relative matching is opt-in.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Police requests, tallied

    One dataset of every figure that consumer DNA and genealogy companies have published since 2015 on requests from police and courts: by period, country and kind of order, and how many requests led to data being handed over. Add each company's written rule on police use and a yearly comparison across companies.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Privacy terms, tracked weekly

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public archive that saves, every week, the privacy policy, terms of service, research consent form and law enforcement guide of the 30 largest consumer DNA companies, records each change with its date, and scores every version on one fixed checklist: whether a user can delete their data and have the sample destroyed, whether data is shared for research by default, what happens to it if the company is sold, whether police access needs a warrant, and whether relative matching is opt-in.

Why it is still open

James Hazel and Christopher Slobogin surveyed the policies of 90 US companies once, in 2018, and found that most fell well short of the Federal Trade Commission's privacy principles. Xengie Doan and colleagues studied six companies' EU policies in 2024 and found 81% of 62 data-sharing flows vague. The 23andMe sale showed that policies can pass to a new owner. Terms.Law's Privacy Watchdog scores the current policies of four DNA companies with an automated system, but keeps no dated versions or change history. Open Terms Archive, an open project that records changes to online services' terms, had no declaration for 23andMe or MyHeritage in a GitHub code search on 20 November 2026.

scholarship.law.cornell.eduorbilu.uni.luterms.lawgithub.com

Built with what exists

Open Terms Archive's open-source engine, which captures documents on a schedule and stores each version in Git; an AI model such as Claude to score each version against the checklist, quoting the sentence behind each score, with a person checking every score.

  1. First step

    Write capture declarations for five companies' privacy policies and law enforcement pages and run the first capture.

  2. Done looks like

    30 companies captured weekly for six months; every change dated, linked and scored; the AI's scores match two human readers on at least 90% of checklist items in a sample of 50 versions; the scores published as a table anyone can download.

Open 02 · the brief

Police requests, tallied

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

One dataset of every figure that consumer DNA and genealogy companies have published since 2015 on requests from police and courts: by period, country and kind of order, and how many requests led to data being handed over. Add each company's written rule on police use and a yearly comparison across companies.

Why it is still open

Each company publishes its own figures, in its own format and periods. 23andMe's transparency report loads its counts by script, so they do not appear in the page's text. Searches for a combined tally found only news snapshots from 2015 to 2020 and a 2017 law review article by Katherine Kwong that described the first Ancestry and 23andMe reports. The Justice Department's 2019 policy depends on which sites notify their users, which a tally of written rules would show.

23andme.comojs.library.dal.cajustice.gov

Built with what exists

A headless browser such as Playwright to capture pages that load figures by script; archived copies of older reports; an AI model to pull figures from PDFs and pages into rows, each checked by a person against the capture.

  1. First step

    Capture 23andMe's current transparency report with a headless browser and list every period and count it shows.

  2. Done looks like

    every published report from at least five companies, 2015 to 2026, in one CSV file with a source link and capture date for each figure; totals by company and year; each company sent its rows before release, with any reply published.