Industries / Mining and materials / Mining and quarrying / Frac sand
Land and water
Land and water covers what a sand mine does to the ground, water and wildlife around it, the local rules that decide where mines may go, and the work of returning mined land to farmland, prairie or habitat.
7
Milestones achieved, from 2000 to 2026.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
2000
Wisconsin requires mine reclamation
Chapter NR 135 of Wisconsin's administrative code, in force from 1 December 2000, requires every county to run a reclamation permit program for nonmetallic mines, which include sand mines: a plan to restore the land, fees, inspections and financial assurance, a bond that pays for the work if the operator does not. In October 2025 a DNR official told the state's mining advisory committee of about three recent cases, two of them industrial sand sites, where the county claimed the bond after a bankruptcy or foreclosure and directed the reclamation itself.
Credit
Wisconsin DNR and county regulators
2015
Mines cluster in unzoned towns
Christina Locke mapped where frac sand mines were built in the upper Midwest, where local zoning is the main control on such mines, and compared them with model landscapes. Mines clustered in rural townships with no zoning, statewide and in 7 of 8 counties tested; the predicted mine count in unzoned townships was more than twice that in zoned ones, and was not linked to land value, tax rate or income.
LessonPlaces that plan land use before a boom have more say over where mines go.
Credit
Christina Locke, PLoS ONE
2017
Wisconsin tallies water and wetlands
The DNR's 2017 review found that sand sites with high-capacity wells (wells able to pump more than 100,000 gallons a day) reporting withdrawals rose from 12 in 2011 to 31 in 2014, while their total pumping rose only 25%, from 1.5 to 1.8 billion gallons a year, because four older sites drew 60 to 90% of it. Since 2008 it had permitted 47 acres of permanent wetland loss for sand mining, offset by 51 acres of wetland credits bought from mitigation banks or a state fund.
Credit
Wisconsin DNR
2017
Dune mining watched from orbit
Defenders of Wildlife, a conservation group, used satellite data to find that nine new Permian sand mines had cleared nearly 300 acres of habitat of the dunes sagebrush lizard, a small lizard that lives only in shinnery oak dunes, between February and August 2017. From the mines' leases it projected that 23,000 acres, 9.5% of the habitat and its buffer, could eventually be disturbed; the Texas Comptroller's office answered that a typical mine digs 70 to 100 acres a year.
Credit
Defenders of Wildlife
2018
A mined plot becomes prairie
Students led by Holly Dolliver of the University of Wisconsin–River Falls sampled soils at a Superior Silica Sands mine in Chippewa County from 2013 and planted a native prairie mix on a reclaimed plot in June 2015. Within three years it was "a reasonably diverse and fully vegetated native prairie", by the seed supplier's account. The rebuilt soil was compacted, and fines from sand washing added to it did not change plant growth but lowered metals in the water.
LessonLong-term study of reclaimed land depends on the landowner, because the site returns to private hands after mining.
Credit
Holly Dolliver, UW–River Falls, with Chippewa County
2020
Court upholds county ban
Winona County, Minnesota, banned the mining and processing of silica sand for fracking in 2016. On 11 March 2020 the Minnesota Supreme Court ruled 4 to 3 that the ban was constitutional, rejecting a challenge from Minnesota Sands LLC, which held five mining leases.
LessonA county can refuse frac sand mining outright, not only regulate it.
Credit
Winona County; Minnesota Supreme Court
2026
Lizard listed, then unlisted
In May 2024 the US Fish and Wildlife Service listed the dunes sagebrush lizard as endangered, naming habitat loss from oil and gas work and frac sand mining as the main threats. It said a sand mine removes all shinnery oak dune habitat, that restoring such dunes "is not currently feasible", and it outlined the 18 known mines by hand from aerial photos. A settlement signed on 21 July 2026 between the federal government and Texas vacated the listing; the Service must reassess within two years, and the Center for Biological Diversity appealed in August 2026.
LessonWhere dunes cannot be rebuilt, every acre a mine takes counts as a permanent loss.
Credit
US Fish and Wildlife Service
Watch for
The lizard reassessed
The US Fish and Wildlife Service, which asked the court to strip the protection and now calls its 2024 listing an "error", has agreed to decide again whether the dunes sagebrush lizard needs it. Mines in its range rely on voluntary agreements instead: Atlas Energy Solutions joined a 23-year one in January 2021 that lets it set aside land or pay per acre of habitat it mines.
Achieved whenthe Service publishes its new finding, due within two years of the settlement, with a habitat count that includes the sand mines' footprints.
Claimed by
US Fish and Wildlife Service, in a settlement with Texas, July 2026; contested by the Center for Biological Diversity, August 2026
Open
01
Mine footprints since 2022
A yearly map from 2017 to 2026 of the ground cleared by every frac sand mine in the Monahans Sandhills of west Texas, with hand-checked outlines and the code, carrying the Fish and Wildlife Service's measurements past January 2022 and showing the acres of shinnery oak dune each mine has removed and any it has restored.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Crops on reclaimed mines
A public check of whether Wisconsin frac sand mines reclaimed to farmland or prairie grow as well as the fields next to them, from satellite data and US Department of Agriculture crop maps.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Mine footprints since 2022
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A yearly map from 2017 to 2026 of the ground cleared by every frac sand mine in the Monahans Sandhills of west Texas, with hand-checked outlines and the code, carrying the Fish and Wildlife Service's measurements past January 2022 and showing the acres of shinnery oak dune each mine has removed and any it has restored.
Why it is still open
The Service measured 18 mines from aerial photos at four dates from autumn 2018 to January 2022, when they covered 2,895 ha (7,154 acres), 504 ha more than 15 months earlier, with blanks where photos were missing; the growth rates it collected from other groups' satellite studies all end earlier. No count after January 2022 was found, Texas does not require frac sand mines to reclaim land, and the Service must now reassess the lizard.
Built with what exists
Sentinel-2 satellite images and USDA National Agriculture Imagery Program aerial photos, read in Google Earth Engine or QGIS; an image segmentation model such as Meta's Segment Anything to draft outlines that a person corrects; Texas Commission on Environmental Quality registrations to name each site; the Service's table of mine sizes as a check.
First step
Download the Service's species status assessment and outline its 18 mines on images from early 2022, to check your outlines against its January 2022 sizes before extending them.
Done looks like
An outline for every mine in the Sandhills for each summer from 2017 to 2026, acres cleared per mine per year, a January 2022 total for the Service's 18 mines within 10% of its 2,895 ha, and all files in a public repository.
Open 02 · the brief
Crops on reclaimed mines
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public check of whether Wisconsin frac sand mines reclaimed to farmland or prairie grow as well as the fields next to them, from satellite data and US Department of Agriculture crop maps.
Why it is still open
At the DNR's nonmetallic mining advisory committee in October 2025, industry members resisted success standards tied to crop yield, saying operators would choose passive recreation as the end use if production records were required; the DNR said reclamation standards must be measurable. No published yields for reclaimed frac sand farmland were found, and the one long-term plot study, at UW–River Falls, measured prairie rather than crops.
Built with what exists
Sentinel-2 greenness (NDVI, a vegetation index) time series in Google Earth Engine; the USDA National Agricultural Statistics Service Cropland Data Layer, a yearly map of what is planted in each field; the DNR's map of industrial sand sites and county reclamation records, which NR 135 requires operators to file when reclamation is complete.
First step
Ask the DNR and the counties of west-central Wisconsin for the list of sand sites with completed or released reclamation, and pull Sentinel-2 histories for the first five.
Done looks like
For at least 20 reclaimed sand mine sites, the median growing-season NDVI and mapped crop for each year since reclamation, compared with fields within 1 km, with the gap and its spread published.