Industries / Finance and business services / Finance and banking / Fintech
Investing apps
Investing apps let people buy and sell shares and funds, or have a computer program manage their savings, from a website or a phone instead of through a broker on the telephone.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1983 to 2025.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1983
Orders typed from home
William Porter formed TradePlus in Palo Alto, California, in 1982 with $15,000 of start-up money, and its order-entry system went online in July 1983, letting customers place trades from a computer during market hours. In 1991 he founded E*Trade Securities, which offered flat-rate trades and free information through the online services America Online and CompuServe; its charge of $40 a trade fell to $19.95 in 1995 and to as little as $14.95 in 1996, by the account of the International Directory of Company Histories.
Credit
William Porter, TradePlus and E*Trade
2017
Rules for robo-advisers
A robo-adviser is a firm whose website or app asks a client questions, builds a portfolio from the answers with an algorithm and then manages it, often with little or no contact with a person. In February 2017 staff of the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) published guidance saying robo-advisers have the same duties as any registered investment adviser, and should take particular care in three areas: how they explain their service, how they gather enough information to give suitable advice, and compliance programs built for automated advice.
Credit
SEC Division of Investment Management
2019
Trades for zero commission
Robinhood began operating in 2013 and launched its first product in 2015. In its 2021 listing prospectus it says it "pioneered commission-free stock trading with no account minimums", and that before it did, commissions "had often ranged from $8 to $10 per trade". On 1 October 2019 Charles Schwab said it would cut its online commissions on US stocks, exchange-traded funds and options from $4.95 to zero from 7 October, though options still cost $0.65 per contract. The trades are paid for in another way: payment for order flow, fees that market makers pay a broker to send them its customers' orders, together with similar rebates on crypto trades, made up 75% of Robinhood's revenue in 2020 and 81% in the first quarter of 2021, by its prospectus.
LessonA broker that charges nothing per trade is paid elsewhere, here by the firms that fill the orders.
Credit
Robinhood; Charles Schwab
2021
Record fine for Robinhood
On 30 June 2021 FINRA, the self-regulatory body for US brokers, ordered Robinhood Financial to pay a $57 million fine, the largest in FINRA's history, and about $12.6 million in restitution to customers. FINRA found that the firm had given customers false or misleading information about margin, cash balances and "negative buying power"; that its systems failed repeatedly from 2018 to 2020, with the app fully shut down on 2 and 3 March 2020 during heavy market swings; and that it "relied on algorithms and bots to approve options trading, with minimal oversight", approving thousands of customers who did not meet its own criteria. Robinhood neither admitted nor denied the findings.
LessonAn app that lets anyone trade in seconds needs systems and supervision that hold up when everyone trades at once.
Credit
FINRA
2022
Free trades, different prices
Christopher Schwarz, Brad Barber, Xing Huang, Philippe Jorion and Terrance Odean sent about 85,000 market orders at the same moments through six accounts at five US brokers. The average round-trip cost, the loss from buying shares and selling them straight back, ranged from 0.07% to 0.46% of the trade before any commission, because the wholesalers that filled the orders gave different brokers different prices for the same trades; differences in payment for order flow did not explain the gap. The paper was posted in 2022 and published in the Journal of Finance in 2025.
LessonA zero commission does not make a trade free, and the authors call for disclosures that show the difference.
Credit
Christopher Schwarz, Brad Barber, Xing Huang, Philippe Jorion and Terrance Odean
2024
Nine in ten traders lose
India's securities regulator, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), studied individuals trading equity futures and options (F&O), contracts that let a trader bet on a price move with a small deposit. On 23 September 2024 it reported that 93% of more than 10 million individual F&O traders lost money in the three years to March 2024, an average of about ₹200,000 (₹2 lakh) each including costs and more than ₹1.8 trillion (₹1.8 lakh crore) in all; traders under 30 rose from 31% to 43% of the total in a year, and more than three in four loss-makers kept trading. After SEBI brought in "a series of regulatory measures", its July 2025 follow-up found that 91% of individual traders still lost money in the year to March 2025 and that their net losses rose 41% to about ₹1.06 lakh crore, while the number of individual traders fell by 20%, as reported by the broker Angel One.
LessonCheap, easy access drew millions into contracts on which most of them lost money, and most kept trading after losing.
Credit
SEBI
2025
A rule on nudges withdrawn
In 2020 Massachusetts securities regulators brought a case against Robinhood over "gamification", game-like features such as digital confetti after a trade; Robinhood dropped the confetti in 2021, and in January 2024 it agreed to pay $7.5 million to settle, without admitting or denying the claims. In August 2023 the SEC proposed rules that would have required brokers and advisers to remove or neutralize conflicts of interest in technology that predicts or steers investors' behavior. On 17 June 2025 it formally withdrew that proposal and 13 others, saying any future action would start with a new proposal.
LessonWithout a written federal rule, app features that push people to trade are dealt with one enforcement case at a time.
Credit
Massachusetts Securities Division; US SEC
Watch for
Stock tokens in an app
On 30 June 2025 Robinhood said its customers in the European Union could buy tokens tracking more than 200 companies, issued on Arbitrum, a network that runs on top of the Ethereum blockchain, and tradable 24 hours a day, five days a week, with dividends paid in the app; its chief executive, Vlad Tenev, said tokens for private companies such as OpenAI and SpaceX were included.
Achieved whenAn outside party, such as an EU regulator or an auditor, publishes confirmation that every token in issue is matched by a share held for its holder and that holders received the dividends due.
Claimed by
Robinhood, June 2025
Open
01
Investing app outages, logged
A public, continuously updated log of outages at at least 20 investing apps in at least three countries. It combines each app's own status page, where one exists, with outside evidence: a probe that loads each app's public website and login page every five minutes from two places, without signing in, and a count of app-store reviews that report the app is down. Each outage gets a start, an end, what failed, whether the app's own status page reported it, and the day's market conditions, such as trading volume.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
App nudges, recorded monthly
A public archive of what 20 investing apps in at least three countries show a new user, from sign-up to the order screen, including notifications, captured each month and coded against the SEC's 2021 list of "digital engagement practices": social networking tools; games, streaks and contests with prizes; points, badges and leaderboards; notifications; celebrations for trading; ideas presented at order placement; and chatbots. Use public demo modes, app-store screenshots and the team's own unfunded accounts, never real trades.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Investing app outages, logged
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public, continuously updated log of outages at at least 20 investing apps in at least three countries. It combines each app's own status page, where one exists, with outside evidence: a probe that loads each app's public website and login page every five minutes from two places, without signing in, and a count of app-store reviews that report the app is down. Each outage gets a start, an end, what failed, whether the app's own status page reported it, and the day's market conditions, such as trading volume.
Why it is still open
FINRA found that Robinhood's systems failed repeatedly from 2018 to 2020 (see above), and to study such outages Gregory Eaton, Clifton Green, Brian Roseman and Yanbin Wu had to rebuild them from user reports; they found Robinhood outages on 25 trading days from January to August 2020 (Journal of Financial Economics, 2022). In June 2025 the SEC withdrew its 2023 proposal to widen its systems-integrity rule, Regulation SCI, to "a broader range of key market participants". The apps' own records are patchy: of 17 status-page addresses tried for investing and savings apps in this research, 6 returned a public incident list, and the newest incident on Robinhood's was dated 25 April 2022. This research found no public log that compares outages across apps.
ideas.repec.orgnews.okstate.edugovinfo.govstatus.robinhood.com
Built with what exists
The public incident lists of apps whose status pages run on Atlassian Statuspage (/api/v2/incidents.json); Uptime Kuma, an open-source uptime monitor, for the probes; google-play-scraper and app-store-scraper to collect reviews; a low-cost AI model to sort reviews that report an outage, such as Meta's Muse Ember (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); Cboe's free daily market statistics for volume.
First step
Pull the incident lists of the apps that publish one, and set Uptime Kuma to probe the public pages of 20 apps every five minutes.
Done looks like
Twelve months of data for at least 20 apps, each outage timed to within five minutes and published with its evidence; a table of outages found by outside checks against those each app reported itself; and a back-test in which reviews alone recover at least 20 of the 25 Robinhood outage days in 2020 that Eaton and colleagues list.
Open 02 · the brief
App nudges, recorded monthly
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public archive of what 20 investing apps in at least three countries show a new user, from sign-up to the order screen, including notifications, captured each month and coded against the SEC's 2021 list of "digital engagement practices": social networking tools; games, streaks and contests with prizes; points, badges and leaderboards; notifications; celebrations for trading; ideas presented at order placement; and chatbots. Use public demo modes, app-store screenshots and the team's own unfunded accounts, never real trades.
Why it is still open
The SEC asked the public about these practices in 2021 and proposed rules in 2023, then withdrew the proposal in June 2025, and the Massachusetts settlement covered one app. Regulators have measured the effects in experiments: on a test app the UK FCA built, with more than 9,000 people, push notifications raised the number of trades by 11% and points and prize draws by 12% (June 2024), and the Ontario Securities Commission published a report on "dark patterns" in retail investing in February 2024. This research found no public, dated record of what investing apps actually show their users.
Built with what exists
The Android Studio emulator and Appium to drive the apps and take screenshots; a browser agent such as Browser Use for web versions (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); Label Studio to code each screen; an AI model whose weights can run locally, such as Mistral Large 4 (see the Note "A trillion open parameters"), to draft codes that a person checks.
First step
Turn the SEC's list of practices into a coding sheet and capture the sign-up screens of three apps without funding an account.
Done looks like
Six monthly captures of 20 apps, each screen tagged with date, app version and country, coded by two people with agreement of at least 0.8 on Cohen's kappa, a standard measure of agreement between coders, and released under an open license.