Industries / Construction and property / EPC contractors
Commissioning and handover
Commissioning is the run of checks and trials that takes a plant from mechanical completion, when everything is installed, through pre-commissioning checks, commissioning and first production, and ends with handing the plant and its records to the owner.
5
Milestones achieved, from 2013 to 2023.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
2013
Completion by system, in writing
Builders work area by area, but a plant is started up system by system: a cooling-water loop, a compressor train, a flare. The American Petroleum Institute's Recommended Practice 1FSC, first published in July 2013 and reaffirmed in December 2019, sets out this "systems completion" process: the steps that prove each system was built, installed, tested and prepared as designed, with certificates that pass "care, custody, and control" of the facility from builder to owner step by step. On Chevron's Meren gas compression platform off Nigeria, the facility was divided into 27 systems and 165 subsystems, and the company's engineers credited the method for a four-month offshore hook-up and commissioning before first gas on 28 June 2015.
Credit
API; Chevron Nigeria, whose account of Meren is its own
2013
Cracks stop a giant field
Kashagan, in the north Caspian Sea off Kazakhstan, began producing oil on 11 September 2013. On 24 September a gas leak on the onshore section of the line from D Island to the Bolashak processing plant stopped it; after a repair, a second leak on 9 October stopped it again, and a pressure test found more. Three outside laboratories (TWI in Britain, CSM in Italy and the Institut Français de la Corrosion) traced the failures to sulfide stress cracking, hairline cracks that form when hard steel is held under stress in wet hydrogen sulfide, caused by "unexpected locally elevated hardness in tiny areas of the steel", while finding the pipe specifications appropriate for the field. Saipem was hired in February 2016, in a US$1.8 billion deal, to build two new 95 km pipelines, and production restarted in late 2016.
LessonMeeting the specification on paper did not rule out hard spots in the steel as installed, and the line cracked within two weeks of first oil.
Credit
North Caspian Operating Company (NCOC), the operator; the three laboratories
2018
Completion carried offshore
Technip and Samsung Heavy Industries held a turnkey contract for the topsides of Martin Linge, a North Sea field platform, including offshore hook-up and completion. The modules left the yard in South Korea late and unfinished, and system reviews found more work; they went offshore in July 2018. The Norwegian Petroleum Directorate reported that hook-up and completion offshore, planned at seven to eight months, could take about two years, and Equinor reported the cost estimate up 85% since the development plan was submitted, to NOK 56 billion.
LessonThe directorate concluded that as much testing and completion as possible should be done on land, where access is easier and there is no limit on beds for workers.
Credit
Norwegian Petroleum Directorate, now the Norwegian Offshore Directorate
2020
One dictionary for handover
At handover the owner receives a record for every tagged item in the plant: what it is, its properties and its documents. CFIHOS, the Capital Facilities Information Handover Specification, began in 2012, when Shell asked USPI, a Dutch process-industry association, to turn its own engineering information specification into an industry standard. In January 2020 its governance moved to IOGP, the international association of oil and gas producers, as Joint Industry Project 36. The version 2.0 reference library files are dated October 2024, an extended library followed in November 2025, and the project lists nearly 80 member organizations, including operators, contractors and software makers.
Credit
Shell; USPI; IOGP and the JIP36 members
2023
Commissioning breaks a permit
Shell's ethane cracker near Monaca, Pennsylvania, fed ethane to its first furnace on 5 September 2022 and made its first polyethylene pellets in early October. Flange leaks, instrument trips and other faults during startup sent feed to the flares instead of to storage, and from October 2022 the plant's 12-month emissions of volatile organic compounds, and later of nitrogen oxides, carbon monoxide and hazardous air pollutants, exceeded its permit limits. On 24 May 2023 Shell signed a consent order with the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, accepting a civil penalty of $4,935,023 and setting aside $5 million for community projects.
LessonShell wrote that its permit had no short-term limits for startup and that its application "did not, however, include unanticipated malfunctions", and the regulator still counted commissioning emissions against the plant's 12-month limits.
Credit
Pennsylvania DEP; Shell Chemical Appalachia
Watch for
Handover compiled 98% faster
Octave, which sells OnSite Completions (formerly Intergraph Smart Completions), says the software cuts turnover and handover compilation time by 98%, execution setup costs by 70%, administrative costs by 45% to 50% and capital spending by 1%. It names no project and no outside measurement.
Achieved whenAn owner or auditor publishes before-and-after handover times and costs for named projects.
Claimed by
Octave, on a page posted in 2026
AI checks handover data
Rihal says its Data eXtract (RDX) uses AI and optical character recognition to pull metadata from engineering drawings, documents and datasheets, and that with Data Refine (RDR) it validates that data against an owner's reference data, with evidence for CFIHOS versions 1.5 and 2.0. The CFIHOS software database that lists it says CFIHOS "does not test the software" and that all conformance statements are self-reported.
Achieved whenAn independent test scores the tools' extraction and validation on handover data with a known answer key.
Claimed by
Rihal, in a database entry dated 17 September 2026
Open
01
Handover checkers, tested blind
A public handover dataset for an imaginary plant in the CFIHOS 2.0 format, about 10,000 tags with their equipment, properties and documents, seeded with a published list of planted errors of known kinds: missing required properties, wrong units, tags in the wrong class, broken links between tags and documents, and duplicate tags. A scoring script reports what any validator finds and misses.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Forecast startup flaring, then check
A method that forecasts, month by month, how much a new plant will flare and emit while it is commissioned, using only documents filed before startup (the permit application, design capacities, flare guarantees), and a public record of such forecasts scored later against the emissions each plant reports.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Handover checkers, tested blind
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public handover dataset for an imaginary plant in the CFIHOS 2.0 format, about 10,000 tags with their equipment, properties and documents, seeded with a published list of planted errors of known kinds: missing required properties, wrong units, tags in the wrong class, broken links between tags and documents, and duplicate tags. A scoring script reports what any validator finds and misses.
Why it is still open
The CFIHOS software database states that "CFIHOS does not test the software" and that conformance statements are self-reported. The only public test data found are eight simulated files for version 1.5 that Elvismary Molina de Armas and colleagues released with their April 2025 paper on a CFIHOS validator built around Petrobras's SmartPlant P&ID data; they report that "all results came out as expected", with no miss or false-alarm rates. Equinor's open NeqSim exporter checks mapping controls but says it "cannot decide whether an identifier is semantically correct". In a check made for this page, 13 of the 21 CSV files in the Core version 2.0 download did not read as UTF-8 text, although the release notes say the files are UTF-8.
conformance.jip36-cfihos.orglink.springer.comgithub.comgithub.com
Built with what exists
The free CFIHOS 2.0 Core reference data library (CSV files); Python with pandas; open data-validation libraries such as Frictionless or Great Expectations; vendor validators whose makers agree to be tested.
First step
Download the Core library, pick 20 tag classes, generate 1,000 tags in Python, plant 100 errors of five kinds, and run one open validator over them.
Done looks like
The dataset and its answer key published, at least three validators run on it, and the share of planted errors found and the false-alarm rate published for each kind of error, with the whole run repeatable by anyone.
Open 02 · the brief
Forecast startup flaring, then check
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A method that forecasts, month by month, how much a new plant will flare and emit while it is commissioned, using only documents filed before startup (the permit application, design capacities, flare guarantees), and a public record of such forecasts scored later against the emissions each plant reports.
Why it is still open
Simulation studies since 2009 model ways to cut flaring during ethylene plant startups; Chaowei Liu and Qiang Xu of Lamar University wrote in 2010 that "fundamental and quantitative studies on start-up flaring emissions are still lacking", and no study found compares a forecast made in advance with a named new plant's reported emissions. Shell's Pennsylvania cracker had no short-term startup limits in its permit, and Shell wrote that its application did not include unanticipated malfunctions.
Built with what exists
The permit documents, monthly emission exhibits and commissioning reports on the Pennsylvania DEP's Shell portal; EPA Greenhouse Gas Reporting Program facility data; DWSIM, an open-source process simulator, for mass balances; Python.
First step
Download Shell's monthly emission data (Exhibit A of the May 2023 order) and its plan approval documents from the DEP portal, and set them out month by month.
Done looks like
A back-cast of the Pennsylvania plant's first 12 months, built only from documents dated before September 2022 and scored against its reported monthly emissions; then forecasts posted with a timestamp, for example on Zenodo, for at least three plants due to start up, each scored within a year of startup in tonnes per month of volatile organic compounds and nitrogen oxides.