Industries / Construction and property / Engineering and architecture
Cost and quantities
Cost and quantities work measures how much material and labor a design needs and forecasts what it will cost; the person who does it is called a quantity surveyor or cost estimator.
5
Milestones achieved, from 1868 to 2023.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1868
Surveyors form a professional body
A Surveyors Club had met in London since 1792. On 15 June 1868 surveyors met at the Westminster Palace Hotel and elected the first council of the body that became the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS), which now publishes the measurement rules below.
Credit
the founding members of the Institution of Surveyors
2002
Overruns measured, not guessed
Bent Flyvbjerg, Mette Skamris Holm and Søren Buhl compared estimated and actual costs for 258 transport projects worth US$90 billion in 20 countries. Costs were underestimated in almost 9 of 10 projects, and actual costs averaged 28% above estimates: 45% for rail, 34% for tunnels and bridges and 20% for roads. Sources disagree on how general this is: Paul Chapman of Oxford found a typical overrun of 2.4% across 138 English road schemes completed from 2001 to 2016, and wrote in 2024 that the data behind the larger studies does not appear to be openly available.
LessonThe authors concluded that the gap is best explained by "strategic misrepresentation" rather than honest error.
Credit
Bent Flyvbjerg, Mette Skamris Holm and Søren Buhl, Aalborg University
2002
Adding an optimism markup
UK Treasury guidance tells officials to raise early cost estimates for optimism bias, the habit of expecting projects to cost less and finish sooner than they will. Its figures come from a 2002 Mott MacDonald study of overruns on past UK public projects; for an unusual building at the early business-case stage, the markup starts at 51% of capital cost, and for a standard building at 24%.
Credit
HM Treasury; Mott MacDonald
2012
A shared measuring rulebook
RICS's New Rules of Measurement (NRM) set standard rules for measuring building work and planning its cost: NRM 1 for early estimates and cost plans, NRM 2 for detailed measurement and NRM 3 for maintenance work. NRM 1 (second edition) and NRM 2 came out on 15 March 2012, NRM 3 in 2014 and an updated set in October 2021.
Credit
Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors
2023
Comparing transit costs worldwide
The Transit Costs Project at New York University's Marron Institute built a public database of more than 900 rapid-rail projects in 59 countries and found the United States the sixth most expensive country for this work, with phase 1 of New York's Second Avenue Subway the most expensive subway in the world per kilometer.
Credit
Eric Goldwyn, Alon Levy, Elif Ensari and Marco Chitti, NYU Marron Institute
Watch for
AI quantity takeoff
A takeoff is the step in which an estimator measures quantities, such as floor areas or the number of doors, from drawings. A study hosted on Togal.AI's website, by authors from the University of Kansas, Arizona State University, UNC Charlotte and the Simplar Foundation, reported about 70% time savings with results within 5% of a standard manual tool, from one first-time user in March 2025. An independent paper by Hooman Sadeh and colleagues (June 2026) tested the tool on 29 line items of one commercial project and found area quantities consistently underestimated while counts matched almost exactly.
Achieved whenRepeated independent tests on many drawing sets show results within estimators' normal tolerance without manual correction.
Claimed by
Togal.AI, 2025
Open
01
A takeoff answer key
A public set of drawing sets with an answer key of quantities (floor areas, wall lengths, door and window counts) that any takeoff tool can be scored against. Produce the drawings from building models, so the model gives the true quantities, and add a careful hand takeoff by two estimators.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Open record of budgets kept
An open dataset of public buildings (schools, libraries, courthouses, hospitals) giving the approved budget at the decision to build, the final cost and both dates, each figure linked to a public record such as an audit report or board minutes.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
A takeoff answer key
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public set of drawing sets with an answer key of quantities (floor areas, wall lengths, door and window counts) that any takeoff tool can be scored against. Produce the drawings from building models, so the model gives the true quantities, and add a careful hand takeoff by two estimators.
Why it is still open
The published tests of AI takeoff are small: the Togal.AI study used one first-time user on five drawings, and the independent paper by Sadeh and colleagues covered one project. This research found neither the drawings nor an answer key published for others to rerun.
Built with what exists
The free Common BIM Files and other public IFC models; IfcOpenShell to read true quantities; Bonsai to make the drawings; two human estimators; the tools under test.
First step
Export the floor plans of the Common BIM Files duplex apartment to PDF and list 50 quantities from the model as the first part of the answer key.
Done looks like
Three drawing sets and at least 300 quantities, published with a table of each tool's error by item type against the model's quantities and against the two estimators.
Open 02 · the brief
Open record of budgets kept
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open dataset of public buildings (schools, libraries, courthouses, hospitals) giving the approved budget at the decision to build, the final cost and both dates, each figure linked to a public record such as an audit report or board minutes.
Why it is still open
Paul Chapman of Oxford's Saïd Business School wrote in 2024 that the project databases behind widely cited overrun studies "do not appear to be openly available", quoting a 2023 critique, and that one consultant's claims rest on "a proprietary detailed database of over 1100 major projects", so the claims cannot be independently tested. His own study listed each of its 138 road schemes.
Built with what exists
Public audit reports and board papers; a web agent to gather them (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); a reviewer model that checks each figure against its source for a person to confirm (see the Note "Seven more flagged").
First step
Collect the budget and final cost of 20 school buildings from one national audit office's reports.
Done looks like
At least 200 buildings from at least three countries, each with two sourced figures, a second person confirming at least 18 of 20 random entries, and a published chart of how far final costs ran over or under budget.