BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Government / Emergency services

Wildfire response

Fighting wildland fires, the trade's term for fires in forests, grass and bush, and moving people out of their path.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1940 to 2025.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1940

    Firefighters by parachute

    Smokejumpers are firefighters who parachute to fires far from roads. On 12 July 1940 Rufus Robinson and Earl Cooley parachuted onto the Martin Creek Fire on Idaho's Nez Perce National Forest, the nation's first "live" fire jump by the US Forest Service's account. The Forest Service now has about 320 smokejumpers at seven bases, and the Bureau of Land Management runs two more bases, in Boise, Idaho, and Fairbanks, Alaska.

    fs.usda.govfs.usda.govfs.usda.gov

    Credit

    US Forest Service; Rufus Robinson and Earl Cooley

  2. 1957

    Ten orders from fatal fires

    On 5 August 1949 a fire at Mann Gulch in Montana's Helena National Forest blew up and cut off a crew of 15 smokejumpers; of the 16 men on site, only 3 survived. The foreman, Wag Dodge, lit a small escape fire and lay in its burned ground, which the main fire went around. In 1957 a task force commissioned by Forest Service Chief Richard E. McArdle reviewed the records of 16 fires between 1937 and 1956 in which firefighters died, and wrote the Ten Standard Firefighting Orders, "to be committed to memory by all personnel with fire control responsibilities." A list of 13 "Watch Out" situations followed, with 5 more added in 1987, and both are printed in the US interagency Incident Response Pocket Guide.

    LessonPatterns found across many fatal fires became a short list that every firefighter memorizes.

    foresthistory.orgnwcg.gov

    Credit

    Richard E. McArdle's 1957 task force, US Forest Service

  3. 1972

    A formula for fire spread

    Richard Rothermel of the Forest Service's Intermountain station in Ogden, Utah, published a mathematical model that estimates how fast a fire's front moves and how intensely it burns across a wide range of wildland fuels, from measured properties of the fuel and its surroundings rather than from earlier burns of that fuel. With adjustments by Frank Albini in 1976, it has been used in US fire and fuels management systems since 1972, by the Forest Service's own 2018 review. In 2013 Patricia Andrews, Rothermel himself and Cruz reported that the model's wind speed limit, based partly on Tasmanian grass fires of 7 February 1967, was too restrictive, and recommended replacing it.

    LessonA limit drawn from one set of observations stayed in fire predictions for four decades before a re-analysis found it too tight.

    research.fs.usda.govresearch.fs.usda.govdoi.org

    Credit

    Richard C. Rothermel, US Forest Service

  4. 2009

    Leave early, not stay

    On 7 February 2009, Black Saturday, bushfires in Victoria, Australia, killed 173 people. Australia's "stay or go" policy had encouraged home owners to decide when and if to leave, and treated staying to defend a well-prepared home as a sound choice. The Victorian Bushfires Royal Commission's final report of 31 July 2010 judged the policy sound but too "simplistic", said "leaving early is still the safest option", and recommended refuges and shelters in vulnerable areas. Victoria's Country Fire Authority (CFA) revised the policy to put "far greater emphasis on protection of life by leaving early", and Victoria added daily fire danger ratings, four-day forecasts and a national telephone warning system.

    LessonAdvice that lets residents stay and defend must also say plainly that leaving early is safest.

    wildfiretoday.comnews.cfa.vic.gov.au

    Credit

    2009 Victorian Bushfires Royal Commission; CFA

  5. 2013

    A shelter cannot stop flame

    On 30 June 2013 the Yarnell Hill Fire in Arizona overran the Granite Mountain Interagency Hotshot Crew, and all 19 crew members died. The Serious Accident Investigation Team found that the crew had left a burned area and was walking through unburned brush toward a safety zone when thunderstorm winds turned the fire, which then moved at 10 to 12 miles per hour (16 to 19 km/h). The crew had less than two minutes to prepare a site and was deploying fire shelters, the small tents wildland firefighters carry as a last resort, when the fire reached them; heavy brush put flames in direct contact, and temperatures passed 2,000 °F (about 1,090 °C). For more than 30 minutes before, nobody else on the fire realized the crew had left the burned area.

    LessonA fire shelter cannot survive direct flame contact, and others on a fire must know where each crew is.

    investigativemedia.com

    Credit

    Yarnell Hill Fire Serious Accident Investigation Team, report of 23 September 2013

  6. 2018

    Refuges when roads closed

    On 8 November 2018 the Camp Fire reached Concow, Paradise and Magalia in Butte County, California, and about 40,000 people evacuated; 85 died and more than 18,000 structures were destroyed. The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) rebuilt the day from more than 2,600 observations and found that heavy traffic, roads closed by fire and debris, and fire reaching people in their cars hampered the evacuation. First responders set up 31 temporary refuge areas, such as parking lots, holding more than 1,200 civilians, and NIST counted 198 rescue or assistance events involving at least 1,000 people. NIST also found that a 2016 multi-agency exercise in Paradise, which practiced reversing inbound lanes, made the real evacuation more efficient.

    LessonA rehearsed evacuation plan helped, but a town with few roads out also needs places where people can shelter when the roads close.

    nvlpubs.nist.gov

    Credit

    Alexander Maranghides and colleagues, NIST, July 2023

  7. 2025

    Alerts that did not arrive

    In January 2025 the Eaton and Palisades fires burned through parts of Los Angeles County. An independent review by McChrystal Group, commissioned by the county's Board of Supervisors and released on 25 September 2025, found that county rules on evacuation warnings and orders were "outdated, unclear and contradictory" and did not clearly say who issues them, that the emergency management office's staffing was "fundamentally inadequate", and that a computer-aided dispatch system in use was 38 years old. Some residents got no alert, possibly because of limited cell coverage in the mountains, power shutoffs that cut cell towers, downed lines or heavy smoke; during the Eaton Fire, wind grounded the aircraft watching the fire almost as soon as it started.

    LessonAn alert depends on knowing where the fire is and on the towers that carry the message, and a wind-driven fire can take away both.

    file.lacounty.gov

    Credit

    McChrystal Group, for Los Angeles County

Watch for

  1. Smoke cameras before 911 calls

    ALERTCalifornia, run by the University of California San Diego with CAL FIRE, the state's fire agency, links 1,263 cameras that send alerts to all 21 of CAL FIRE's emergency command centers, and since 2023 an AI model has watched the images for smoke. Its director, Neal Driscoll, told Route Fifty that in 2025 the system helped with about 3,600 wildfire incidents, and that in more than half of them it alerted fire officials before any 911 caller.

    Achieved whena party outside UC San Diego and CAL FIRE publishes, for a full fire season, the share of fires the cameras detected, their false alarms, and the minutes gained over the first 911 call.

    route-fifty.com

    Claimed by

    Neal Driscoll, ALERTCalifornia, July 2026

  2. One US wildland fire service

    Interior Secretary Doug Burgum created the US Wildland Fire Service by secretarial order in January 2026, joining the wildland fire operations of six Interior agencies, including the National Park Service, the Bureau of Indian Affairs and the Bureau of Land Management. About 3,900 employees had moved to it by March 2026, by internal Interior statements reported by E&E News; the Forest Service's firefighters, in the Agriculture Department, stay separate. Interior says there is "no gap in response capability or readiness"; former officials and congressional appropriators have questioned the change, and its mission statement was still being written.

    Achieved whenan outside reviewer, such as the Government Accountability Office, compares response times and sharing of crews and aircraft for at least one full fire season before and after the change.

    eenews.net

    Claimed by

    US Department of the Interior, January to March 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Score evacuation models on Paradise

    A public test that runs several open traffic evacuation models on the roads of Paradise, Concow and Magalia, using the evacuation orders, road closures and burnovers NIST recorded for the Camp Fire, and scores each model's traffic hour by hour against what NIST observed. A burnover is a fire passing over people or vehicles.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Warning time against fire arrival

    A public table, drawn from official reviews, of how many minutes before the fire arrived each community where people died received an evacuation warning and an evacuation order, for major wildland fires since 2009 in several countries.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Score evacuation models on Paradise

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test that runs several open traffic evacuation models on the roads of Paradise, Concow and Magalia, using the evacuation orders, road closures and burnovers NIST recorded for the Camp Fire, and scores each model's traffic hour by hour against what NIST observed. A burnover is a fire passing over people or vehicles.

Why it is still open

NIST's 2023 supplement lists every one of its more than 2,600 observations with a time and a location, and maps the traffic on Paradise's main roads hour by hour. Published simulations of the Paradise evacuation, such as a pipeline built on the SUMO traffic simulator by Yu Chen and colleagues (2020) and a 2023 UC Berkeley report, do not report a comparison with those observations, and a search found none that did.

nvlpubs.nist.govarxiv.orggeomechanics.berkeley.edu

Built with what exists

Eclipse SUMO, an open-source traffic simulator; WUI-NITY, a wildfire evacuation platform described by Wahlqvist, Ronchi and colleagues in 2021; OpenStreetMap road data; NIST's observation tables, read into a spreadsheet.

  1. First step

    Draw NIST's traffic map for the 08:00 hour onto OpenStreetMap road segments and run one SUMO scenario against it.

  2. Done looks like

    At least three models run on the same inputs, each predicting the traffic state of every main road segment for every hour from 08:00 to 14:00 on 8 November 2018, with the share of segment-hours that match NIST's traffic maps published for each model, and the inputs and code released so others can add a model.

Open 02 · the brief

Warning time against fire arrival

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table, drawn from official reviews, of how many minutes before the fire arrived each community where people died received an evacuation warning and an evacuation order, for major wildland fires since 2009 in several countries.

Why it is still open

Each review covers one fire, such as NIST's for the Camp Fire and McChrystal Group's for Los Angeles County's 2025 fires. A 2026 study comparing three communities (Jing, Sedighi and Liu) measures how long residents expect to need to prepare, not the warnings they actually got. A 2024 perspective in PNAS Nexus by Costas Synolakis and Georgios Karagiannis, written after the Lahaina fire, calls for renewed emphasis on alerts and evacuations but gives no table of warning times across fires.

nvlpubs.nist.govfile.lacounty.govdoi.orgpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Built with what exists

the published review reports; a language model that pulls out every time-stamped warning, order and fire arrival with its page number; two people who check each row against the page.

  1. First step

    Fill in the Paradise rows from NIST's observation table and test the column layout before adding a second fire.

  2. Done looks like

    At least eight fires with deaths, in at least three countries; for each named community, the times of the first official warning, the evacuation order and the fire's arrival, each traced to a page, with the minutes between them; every row checked by two people, and their disagreements listed.