Industries / Transport and vehicles / Aerospace and defense / Defense contracting
Maintenance
Maintenance is the work of inspecting, repairing and overhauling military equipment and keeping its records, split between military units, government depots and contractors.
5
Milestones achieved, from 1997 to 2020.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1997
A cap on outsourced repairs
A US law added in 1988, 10 U.S.C. 2466, limits how much depot-level maintenance, the heavy repair and overhaul done at large workshops, each military department may contract out to companies; before a 1994 amendment the limit was 40% of the workload. In November 1997 Congress raised it to 50% of the funds for such work, the "50/50 rule", with the rest done by Department of Defense employees. The department must report the split to Congress each year.
Credit
US Congress
2007
Paying for available jets
The UK Ministry of Defence moved the heavy repair of its Tornado and Harrier jets to one base per type (RAF Marham and RAF Cottesmore), ran it as a production-line "pulse line", and wrote industry contracts for a number of available aircraft or engines rather than a number of repairs or spare parts. The NAO reported on 17 July 2007 that support costs fell by £1.4 billion over six years (£1.3 billion for Tornado, £109 million for Harrier) while availability was broadly kept, and that minor maintenance time fell 19% for Harrier and 37% for Tornado. It warned of too few trained staff and late spares.
Credit
UK Ministry of Defence and its industry partners
2009
A safety case on paper
On 2 September 2006 the RAF Nimrod XV230 caught fire in flight over Afghanistan and all 14 people aboard died. A safety case is a written argument, backed by evidence, that a system's hazards have been found and controlled. Charles Haddon-Cave's Nimrod Review, published on 28 October 2009, found that the Nimrod safety case, drawn up from 2001 to 2005 by BAE Systems and a Ministry of Defence project team with QinetiQ as independent adviser, was "a lamentable job from start to finish" that missed the key dangers and had become "a paperwork and 'tick-box' exercise". It said the loss would have been avoided had the case been done properly. It recommended a new airworthiness regime under an independent Military Airworthiness Authority, and that safety cases be brought in-house and renamed "Risk Cases".
LessonA safety case written and signed off as paperwork protects no one.
Credit
Charles Haddon-Cave
2013
Fixing submarine upkeep
Australia's six Collins class submarines, commissioned from 1996 to 2003, spent long periods out of service. A review led by John Coles, a British engineer, found in its final report, released on 24 April 2013, that "there has been no proper sustainment system in place" since 1996. Andrew Davies of the Australian Strategic Policy Institute wrote in 2024 that the review compared six other submarine-operating nations and found Australia's performance "by far the worst", and that within a couple of years Collins availability exceeded the international benchmark.
LessonThe boats were sound but the support system around them was not, and it was fixed by settling who does what and holding each party to account.
Credit
John Coles; ASC, the government-owned maintainer; Australian Department of Defence
2020
Bad data grounds good jets
The F-35 fighter's Autonomic Logistics Information System (ALIS) supports its operations, mission planning, supply chain and maintenance. In March 2020 GAO reported that problems with ALIS "continue to pose significant challenges", with "inaccurate or missing data sometimes leading ALIS to ground flight-ready aircraft", and that the Pentagon had no strategy for its redesign. The Pentagon began an upgrade in January 2020, to be renamed the Operational Data Integrated Network (ODIN); GAO closed its recommendations in April 2026 after the department showed it was tracking ODIN performance measures.
LessonA maintenance records system with bad data can stop sound equipment from working.
Credit
GAO; F-35 Joint Program Office
Watch for
ALIS gives way to ODIN
The F-35 Joint Program Office says it has met its "ODIN Inflection Point": the first release of ODIN operating software was delivered and validated by the operational test squadron, new ODIN hardware has replaced ALIS hardware across the fleet, and the remaining parts of ALIS can start to be retired.
Achieved whenGAO or the Pentagon's Director, Operational Test and Evaluation reports that ALIS is retired and that data errors no longer ground flight-ready aircraft.
Claimed by
F-35 Joint Program Office and Lockheed Martin, November 2026
Software flags needless checks
The Royal Navy's 1710 Naval Air Squadron and the UK's Defence Equipment & Support agency relaunched Motherlode, a maintenance analysis tool, as an AI-enabled version 3. They showed it finding maintenance tasks that found no faults and could be safely spaced further apart, and forecasting the spares a detachment needs. It covers Merlin, Wildcat, Apache and Chinook helicopters and is being extended to Poseidon, Wedgetail and Protector aircraft in 2026. No figures for hours saved have been published.
Achieved whenthe UK Military Aviation Authority approves longer intervals on the tool's evidence, or an outside body such as the NAO reports measured gains in availability or hours.
Claimed by
Royal Navy, February 2026
Open
01
Scoring AI manual conversion
A public test for turning old maintenance manuals into S1000D, the international XML specification that splits technical manuals into reusable "data modules". Take 50 procedures from manuals cleared for public release, for equipment such as generators, tents and field kitchens and civil machinery (never weapons), have a person convert each to S1000D by hand as the answer key, then run AI conversion pipelines and score them on schema validity, business-rule checks, and step-by-step agreement with the key: missing steps, changed values and lost warnings.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Availability deals, checked by auditors
A public table of every performance-based or availability support contract, where a company is paid for aircraft, ships or vehicles ready for use rather than for repairs done, that a national audit office has examined: GAO in the US, the NAO in the UK, the ANAO in Australia, Canada's Auditor General and others. For each, record the system, contractor, years, availability target, measured result, cost change and the auditor's verdict, each with a quoted sentence and page number.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Scoring AI manual conversion
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public test for turning old maintenance manuals into S1000D, the international XML specification that splits technical manuals into reusable "data modules". Take 50 procedures from manuals cleared for public release, for equipment such as generators, tents and field kitchens and civil machinery (never weapons), have a person convert each to S1000D by hand as the answer key, then run AI conversion pipelines and score them on schema validity, business-rule checks, and step-by-step agreement with the key: missing steps, changed values and lost warnings.
Why it is still open
Vendors now sell AI-assisted conversion. HCLTech, an IT services company, says its framework can "convert legacy documents to XML automatically" and cites a client that saved over US$10 million a year, but it gives no error rates. A search found no public accuracy study or shared test set for this task.
Built with what exists
The S1000D specification and schemas, free from s1000d.org; the open-source s1kd-tools, whose s1kd-validate and s1kd-brexcheck check schemas and business rules; PyMuPDF; an AI model that reads page images, such as Claude (see the Note "Seven more flagged"), and an open-weights model run on local hardware, such as Mistral Large 4 (see the Note "A trillion open parameters"); GitHub.
First step
Pick five procedures from one public generator manual, convert them by hand with s1kd-tools, and write the scoring rules.
Done looks like
50 procedures with hand-made answer keys under an open license; for at least two models, the share of modules that pass s1kd-validate and s1kd-brexcheck, and a count per procedure of missing or altered steps, numbers and warnings, checked by a second person on 10 procedures.
Open 02 · the brief
Availability deals, checked by auditors
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table of every performance-based or availability support contract, where a company is paid for aircraft, ships or vehicles ready for use rather than for repairs done, that a national audit office has examined: GAO in the US, the NAO in the UK, the ANAO in Australia, Canada's Auditor General and others. For each, record the system, contractor, years, availability target, measured result, cost change and the auditor's verdict, each with a quoted sentence and page number.
Why it is still open
The main US study, Project Proof Point, analyzed 21 of 89 US performance-based logistics arrangements and concluded that they cut cost per unit of performance. It was run by Deloitte Consulting, Supply Chain Visions and Auburn University with the Pentagon's materiel readiness office, and its authors wrote that "the specifics of the analysis cannot be shared in a public forum" because the data was proprietary. GAO reviewed 29 US programs in 2008 and found mixed results: for the only two systems supported both ways, the performance-based arrangement cost more, and missing cost data kept DOD from judging the rest. It noted that the UK calls the approach "contracting for availability". Audit offices have published such single studies, but a search found no public table that brings them together across countries or years.
Built with what exists
Audit office report archives (gao.gov, nao.org.uk, anao.gov.au, oag-bvg.gc.ca); pdftotext; an AI model filling a fixed form per contract with quoted evidence (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); a spreadsheet; GitHub.
First step
Extract the targets and results from the NAO's 2007 fast-jet report and two GAO reports on performance-based logistics, and settle the table's columns.
Done looks like
At least 40 contracts from at least four audit offices, 2000 to 2025, each with a quoted target and result; two people independently code 15 and agree on the verdict for at least 13; and a summary of how many met their availability target and how many cut cost, set beside Proof Point's claims.