BRENNEN

Industries / Finance and business services / Legal and professional services / Consulting

Keeping and reusing knowledge

Keeping and reusing knowledge is how a consulting firm stores what it learned on past work, finds it again for the next client, and keeps each client's secrets from the others.

5

Milestones achieved, from 1999 to 2024.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1999

    Two ways to share

    Morten Hansen, Nitin Nohria and Thomas Tierney studied knowledge management at consulting firms, health care providers and computer makers and found two strategies. Firms selling fairly standard work write knowledge down and store it in databases for anyone to reuse, which they called codification; firms solving one-off problems share it mainly person to person, with computers used to help people talk, which they called personalization. They warned in Harvard Business Review that stressing the wrong one, or trying both, can undermine a business.

    ebi.ac.uk

    Credit

    Morten T. Hansen, Nitin Nohria and Thomas J. Tierney

  2. 2017

    Client emails exposed

    Deloitte discovered in March 2017 that hackers had got into its global email system, possibly since October or November 2016, through an administrator's account that needed only a single password, with no two-step verification, The Guardian reported. The newspaper was told about 5 million emails were in the cloud system and could have been reached; Deloitte said the number at risk was a fraction of that, and six clients had been told their information was affected.

    LessonA firm's store of client correspondence is a target, and one weakly protected account can open it.

    theguardian.com

    Credit

    Nick Hopkins, The Guardian

  3. 2021

    Walls between advice and investing

    MIO Partners, a McKinsey affiliate that invests for current and former McKinsey partners and employees, agreed to pay an $18 million penalty. The US Securities and Exchange Commission found that McKinsey partners who oversaw MIO's investment choices also had access, through consulting work, to confidential information about companies MIO invested in, and that MIO lacked adequate policies to stop its misuse; MIO neither admitted nor denied the findings.

    LessonWhat consultants learn from clients needs barriers inside the firm as well as outside it.

    sec.gov

    Credit

    US Securities and Exchange Commission

  4. 2023

    Government plans passed on

    From 2013 to 2016 Peter Collins, a PwC partner in Australia, received confidential information from Treasury consultations on new anti-avoidance tax laws. Despite signing several confidentiality agreements, he shared it with PwC partners and others in Australia and overseas, to help clients avoid laws that put A$180 million a year of tax at stake, according to the Australian Senate committee report "PwC: A calculated breach of trust" (June 2023). The Tax Practitioners Board had sanctioned Collins and PwC, and Neil Chenoweth of the Australian Financial Review made the case public in January 2023.

    LessonSigned confidentiality agreements did not stop a government's plans from spreading inside a firm.

    aph.gov.au

    Credit

    Senate Finance and Public Administration References Committee; Tax Practitioners Board; Neil Chenoweth

  5. 2024

    Deleted files, criminal charge

    McKinsey & Company agreed to pay $650 million under a deferred prosecution agreement, in which charges are dropped if the company meets agreed terms, to resolve a US criminal and civil investigation of its advice to Purdue Pharma on selling OxyContin. A former senior partner, Martin Elling, agreed to plead guilty to obstruction of justice; US Attorney Christopher Kavanaugh said Elling "personally deleted various Purdue related electronic materials from his McKinsey laptop with the intent to obstruct future investigations." Kavanaugh called the resolution "the first time a management consulting firm has been criminally responsible for advice it has given resulting in the commission of a crime by a client."

    LessonDestroying engagement records can itself become the crime.

    npr.org

    Credit

    US Department of Justice

Watch for

  1. An agent inside Lilli

    CodeWall, a company that sells AI security testing, says its autonomous agent found a flaw in Lilli, McKinsey's internal AI platform, on 28 February 2026 and within two hours had read and write access to the production database, which it says held 46.5 million chat messages, 728,000 files and 57,000 user accounts. CodeWall says McKinsey patched the flaw on 2 March, the day after its report; the AI Incident Database's summary has McKinsey saying it found no evidence that client data or client confidential information were accessed.

    Achieved whenan independent review confirms what the agent could reach and whether anything was taken.

    codewall.aiincidentdatabase.ai

    Claimed by

    CodeWall, March 2026

Open

  1. 01

    A register of commissioned reports

    For one national government, every consulting contract on its public register in one financial year matched to the report it produced, and each marked published (with a link), mentioned but unpublished, or not found.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Lessons reused, clients hidden

    A test of whether an AI assistant can give a consultant a useful lesson from past work without revealing which client it came from or that client's confidential facts. It needs a made-up firm archive (for example 40 fictional clients, some of them competitors, with planted secret figures) and a set of questions, including multi-turn attempts to extract the hidden facts.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A register of commissioned reports

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

For one national government, every consulting contract on its public register in one financial year matched to the report it produced, and each marked published (with a link), mentioned but unpublished, or not found.

Why it is still open

Australia's contract register, AusTender, reports the value of consultancy contracts awarded, not the reports they produce. In answers to a Senate committee in 2023, eight departments gave counts of the consultants' reports they had commissioned over three financial years, and the Australia Institute's chart of those answers shows 256 published and 1,588 not published; the answers are counts, not a list that links each contract to its report. Searches in this session found no public register that does.

help.tenders.gov.audatawrapper.dwcdn.net

Built with what exists

AusTender's data export and the contract-notice datasets on data.gov.au; site searches of department websites; a language model to match report titles and dates to contracts; a spreadsheet log that a second person checks.

  1. First step

    Export one month of consultancy contracts from AusTender and try to find the report for each, timing the search.

  2. Done looks like

    Every consultancy contract of A$100,000 or more awarded in one financial year classified, a second person agreeing on 95 of 100 checks chosen at random, and the share published reported by department.

Open 02 · the brief

Lessons reused, clients hidden

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A test of whether an AI assistant can give a consultant a useful lesson from past work without revealing which client it came from or that client's confidential facts. It needs a made-up firm archive (for example 40 fictional clients, some of them competitors, with planted secret figures) and a set of questions, including multi-turn attempts to extract the hidden facts.

Why it is still open

Access-control tests exist that block one client's documents from another's users entirely, such as the ogx-evals artifact for a 2026 paper on multitenant retrieval, but reuse without disclosure is not tested. A 2026 survey of 118 papers on protecting retrieval systems found that most evaluations use general question-answering data and simple attacks rather than sensitive data and adaptive multi-turn extraction, and that a three-question attacker recovered 48.3% of hidden facts even when verbatim copying was blocked.

arxiv.org

Built with what exists

a language model to write the fictional archive; an open retrieval stack such as OGX (formerly Llama Stack) and the ogx-evals code; current AI models as the assistants under test; blind human graders for usefulness.

  1. First step

    Write 10 fictional clients and 200 documents with planted facts, and run 50 attack conversations against one open setup.

  2. Done looks like

    At least five assistant setups each run against 1,000 attack conversations, with a public table of hidden facts recovered (%) and client identities guessed (%) beside a blind usefulness score, and the dataset and code released.