BRENNEN

Industries / Finance and business services / Legal and professional services / Consulting

Carrying out the advice

Carrying out the advice is the work of putting a recommendation into practice, by changing how people work or installing new systems, and then checking whether results improved.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1911 to 2020.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1911

    Work set by study

    In The Principles of Scientific Management, first printed in American Magazine in 1911, Frederick W. Taylor described bringing his methods into the Bethlehem Steel Company. He wrote that a gang of about 75 men carried pig iron, in pieces of about 92 pounds, up a plank onto rail cars at an average of 12½ long tons per man per day, and that his study showed a first-class handler should load 47 to 48 tons. Seven of every eight handlers were taken off the work, and Taylor wrote that almost all were given other jobs at the company.

    en.wikisource.org

    Credit

    Frederick Winslow Taylor

  2. 2011

    The 70% failure figure

    A failure rate of 70% is often quoted for programs that change how organizations work. Mark Hughes reviewed five published sources of that figure in the Journal of Change Management and found no valid and reliable empirical evidence behind any of them.

    LessonA widely repeated number about change programs can rest on no measurement at all.

    api.openalex.org

    Credit

    Mark Hughes

  3. 2013

    Consulting tested by lottery

    Economists paid a large international consulting firm to give free management consulting to randomly chosen plants of large Indian textile firms, 28 plants of 17 firms in all, and compared them with control plants that received only the first diagnosis. The project ran from August 2008 to August 2010 and cost US$1.3 million, funded by Stanford University and the World Bank. The published paper reports that adopting the practices raised productivity by 17% in the first year, through better quality and efficiency and less inventory; the authors call it the first experimental evidence on management practices in large firms.

    api.crossref.orgnber.org

    Credit

    Nicholas Bloom, Benn Eifert, Aprajit Mahajan, David McKenzie and John Roberts

  4. 2016

    A founding model questioned

    Kurt Lewin's "unfreezing, changing, refreezing" is widely treated as the classic way to manage change. Stephen Cummings, Todd Bridgman and Kenneth Brown compared what Lewin wrote with how later works present it, and argued in the journal Human Relations that he never developed such a model and that it took form after his death.

    LessonRead what a method's supposed founder wrote before building on it.

    api.openalex.org

    Credit

    Stephen Cummings, Todd Bridgman and Kenneth G. Brown

  5. 2018

    Small firms grow after advice

    In Puebla, Mexico, 432 small and medium businesses applied for consulting subsidized by the state government, and 150 chosen at random received a year of help from one of nine local consulting firms, between March 2008 and February 2009; firms paid 10% to 30% of the market price, depending on size. The researchers found higher productivity and return on assets after a year, and in the Journal of Political Economy version, from social security records, about 50% more employees and a larger wage bill five years after the program.

    openknowledge.worldbank.orgapi.semanticscholar.org

    Credit

    Miriam Bruhn, Dean Karlan and Antoinette Schoar

  6. 2020

    Half the changes dropped

    The economists behind the Indian experiment went back to the weaving plants in 2017 and found that about half of the management practices adopted there had been dropped, most often because managers left or directors lacked time. A large gap in practices and performance between treated and control plants remained, and many practices had spread to the same firms' other plants, though few to other firms.

    LessonChanges that depend on a few key people fade when those people leave.

    nber.org

    Credit

    Nicholas Bloom, Aprajit Mahajan, David McKenzie and John Roberts

Watch for

  1. Fees tied to results

    Michael Birshan, McKinsey's managing partner for the UK, Ireland and Israel, said at a London media event that roughly a quarter of McKinsey's global fees now come from outcomes-based pricing, in which pay depends on results the firm delivers, though some fixed components remain.

    Achieved whena firm publishes, or an outside party audits, the share of fees that depended on measured client results and how those results were measured.

    finance.yahoo.com

    Claimed by

    McKinsey & Company, November 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Recommendations, followed up

    For one government, a list of the reviews it commissioned from consulting firms over five years, every recommendation in them, and the public evidence (annual reports, budget papers, audit-office follow-ups, answers to parliament) of whether each was carried out.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Paid on results, counted

    A yearly public count of how much US federal money for management consulting is paid under contracts whose fee depends on results (incentive and award-fee contracts), against fixed-price and hourly contracts, with a sample of contracts read to record which result the fee depends on.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Recommendations, followed up

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

For one government, a list of the reviews it commissioned from consulting firms over five years, every recommendation in them, and the public evidence (annual reports, budget papers, audit-office follow-ups, answers to parliament) of whether each was carried out.

Why it is still open

Such tracking exists for oversight bodies: Elston and Zhang followed all 615 recommendations the UK Public Accounts Committee made in 2010 to 2012 through the government's progress reports, and audit offices publish follow-ups of their own recommendations. Searches in this session found no tracker for recommendations made by consulting firms.

api.openalex.org

Built with what exists

government contract registers and published report PDFs; a language model to pull out each recommendation and sort the evidence into fixed answers (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); a spreadsheet log that a second person checks.

  1. First step

    Take five consulting reviews that one department has published, list their recommendations, and search for evidence on each, timing how long it takes.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 30 reviews and 500 recommendations, each marked carried out, partly carried out, not carried out or no public evidence, with every mark linked to its evidence, and a second person agreeing on 90 of 100 marks chosen at random.

Open 02 · the brief

Paid on results, counted

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A yearly public count of how much US federal money for management consulting is paid under contracts whose fee depends on results (incentive and award-fee contracts), against fixed-price and hourly contracts, with a sample of contracts read to record which result the fee depends on.

Why it is still open

Firms' own figures are all that exist. McKinsey's quarter-of-fees figure is its own, and AI News Weekly, citing the Financial Times, reported in May 2026 that there is no public data on what share of McKinsey or Deloitte contracts have been renegotiated to outcome-based terms. Searches in this session found no published count of public consulting contracts by pricing type.

aiweekly.co

Built with what exists

the public API of USAspending.gov, whose award search filters by contract pricing type and by industry code (NAICS 541611 is management consulting); Python; a language model to read contract documents.

  1. First step

    Pull fiscal year 2025 for NAICS 541611 split by pricing type, and check the totals against the USAspending website.

  2. Done looks like

    A table for fiscal years 2010 to 2025 by pricing type and agency, published with its code and matching USAspending's own totals within 1%, plus 50 incentive or award-fee contracts read and coded for the result that sets the fee.