Industries / Transport and vehicles / Automotive / Collision repair
Structural repair
Structural repair puts the load-bearing frame or body shell back to its factory shape and strength, by pulling it straight on a bench and by cutting out damaged parts and joining in new ones.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1949 to 2025.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1949
A hydraulic ram pulls frames
Blackhawk introduced the "Damage Dozer" in 1949: two heavy steel beams joined at a hinge, with a hydraulic ram near the joint. One beam was anchored to one side of the car and the other chained to the bent part of the body or frame, and the ram forced them apart. The anchor points were sometimes damaged, which shops accepted as unavoidable. Blackhawk's later Korek system set steel tracks into a hardened concrete floor to hold anchors and pulling towers.
Credit
Blackhawk, by the account of former shop manager Charlie Barone in BodyShop Business
1971
Pulled opposite the crash
Lavell (Finis L.) Chisum, who ran a body shop in Anchorage, Alaska, built a frame machine with a pulling tower and sold the first one to Glacier Lincoln Mercury in June 1968. His US patent 3,630,066, filed in March 1969 and granted on 28 December 1971, pulls a chain from a tower "in a direction opposite to at least one prior force that previously caused" the damage. Chief Automotive bought the patent in 1972 and sold the machine as the EZ Liner.
Credit
Lavell Chisum; Chief Automotive
1972
A bench for any car
In a unitized body, the shell itself carries the loads, with no separate frame. European shops checked such bodies on fixtures made for one model, which were often not available when a car came in, so technicians judged the structure by eye. In 1972 the Swede Uno Johansson and the engineering firm SEMFA built the Car-O-Liner, a universal bench on which any car is measured against "exactly the same data plane", with the company's measuring data as a three-dimensional guide to the body. Volvo brought one to the United States for evaluation in 1978, when about 25% of cars there had unitized bodies.
LessonA check that needs a special part for every model gets skipped.
Credit
Uno Johansson and SEMFA (Car-O-Liner); Volvo, by the account of Dave Demarest, a Car-O-Liner distributor
2017
Glued roof costs $31.5 million
In 2012 John Eagle Collision Center in Dallas replaced the hail-damaged roof of a 2010 Honda Fit with adhesive, where Honda's procedure called for spot welds and MIG plug welds. In a 2013 crash the roof buckled, and the next owners, Matthew and Marcia Seebachan, were trapped in the burning car. In October 2017 a Dallas County jury set damages at $42 million and held the shop 75% responsible, $31.5 million.
LessonThe carmaker's written repair procedure became the standard a shop is judged by in court.
Credit
Dallas County jury; Todd Tracy for the plaintiffs
2019
Weld rules by steel grade
Car bodies now mix steels of very different strength, measured in megapascals (MPa), and some grades lose strength when heated. Honda's welding and sectioning guideline, first issued in October 2019 and in its seventh version by September 2025, covers all its models: MAG (gas-shielded arc) butt welds are approved only on steel up to 780 MPa; on 1,500 MPa hot-stamped steel, plug welds are allowed only where a model's manual says so, and spot welds only with the welder set by hand to Honda's listed conditions, after a 10-micron aluminum coating is sanded off.
Credit
American Honda
2023
Packs that cannot be opened
Reuters reported in March 2023 that many electric cars were written off after minor crashes because their battery packs could not be repaired or assessed. Tesla's Texas-built Model Y glues its cells into a pack that forms part of the body; Sandy Munro, whose firm tears down cars, called it "zero repairability". Allianz said battery damage was a few percent of its German motor claims but 8% of their cost. A later count by the data firm Cap HPI, covering 2015 to August 2024, found 0.9% of British EVs under five years old written off, against 1.89% of petrol and diesel cars.
LessonA battery built into the body makes its cost part of the crash repair, unless the maker shares the data needed to judge the damage.
Credit
Reuters; Thatcham Research; Allianz Center for Technology; Cap HPI
2025
A cast rear, crash-tested
Large one-piece aluminum castings replace dozens of stamped parts, and repairers feared that any damage would mean replacing the whole piece. In September 2025 Thatcham Research published a two-year study of Tesla's Model Y. At 15 km/h the casting took no structural damage. At 25 km/h it cracked and had to be replaced, but at £716 for the part the repair still cost less than on the Model 3's multi-part steel rear: £2,167 less for partial replacements and £519 less for full ones.
Credit
Thatcham Research
Watch for
Castings with cutting zones
Ford says its electric midsize pickup, due in 2027, was designed to be repairable at typical crash speeds, with predefined cutting zones in its large aluminum castings so that a shop can replace a damaged section instead of the whole piece. Alan Clarke, Ford's executive director of advanced EV development, said "it's easier to repair a vehicle that has unicastings".
Achieved whenFord publishes sectioning procedures for the production truck and an outside party, such as Thatcham Research, crash-tests it and reports the repair costs.
Claimed by
Ford, March and July 2026
Battery casings repaired in place
Thatcham Research's EV Blueprint says a damaged battery casing or bracket could be repaired without removing the pack, or the pack swapped for a much cheaper refurbished one, so that a three-year-old EV with a minor side impact is not written off. It sets out eight requirements for carmakers, including battery diagnostics that independent shops and insurers can use. In its survey with the Centre for Economics and Business Research, battery issues were the main concern of 44.6% of insurers.
Achieved whena carmaker publishes an approved casing or bracket repair for a current EV, and an insurer or Thatcham reports fewer battery write-offs for that model.
Claimed by
Thatcham Research, March 2026
Open
01
Shop spot welds, tested
A public tally of spot welds made with body-shop squeeze-type resistance spot welders, the two-armed welders that clamp the panels and pass a current through them, on 1,500 MPa hot-stamped steel at the settings carmakers publish. Each weld is pulled apart and measured, and the results set beside the same joints made on a production-grade welder.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Welded cracks in castings
Fatigue tests, which load a part back and forth until it breaks, on coupons cut from scrap one-piece rear castings: some uncracked, some cracked and welded by the carmaker's rules, and some welded with a backing plate behind.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Shop spot welds, tested
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public tally of spot welds made with body-shop squeeze-type resistance spot welders, the two-armed welders that clamp the panels and pass a current through them, on 1,500 MPa hot-stamped steel at the settings carmakers publish. Each weld is pulled apart and measured, and the results set beside the same joints made on a production-grade welder.
Why it is still open
Carmakers disagree. Honda allows spot welds on 1,500 MPa steel with the welder set by hand to its listed conditions. Nissan's manuals say "never spot weld" steel above 980 MPa, and tell shops to add 20% to 30% more spot welds because "the capacity of repair shop spot welding machines is smaller than that of factory welding machines". Carmakers such as FCA require each shop to weld and break test coupons before working on a car, but those results stay in the shop, and a search for published destructive tests of repair-shop welds found peel tests of factory-style welds only.
Built with what exists
Coupons cut from new hot-stamped steel blanks or new service B-pillars; two or three shop spot welders lent by tool distributors; I-CAR's destructive weld test (prying the joint apart and measuring the nugget, the fused spot); a university tensile tester for shear and cross-tension loads; photos of every broken weld in a public repository.
First step
Ask a community college collision program and one tool distributor for a welder and bench time, buy twenty 1,500 MPa coupons, and run a first batch of 40 welds under the instructor.
Done looks like
At least 300 welds from at least three welder models, each logged with settings, nugget diameter and how it broke (pulled out of the sheet or split at the joint), with peak loads for at least 60, published as open data with the share that met the nugget sizes the carmakers publish.
Open 02 · the brief
Welded cracks in castings
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
Fatigue tests, which load a part back and forth until it breaks, on coupons cut from scrap one-piece rear castings: some uncracked, some cracked and welded by the carmaker's rules, and some welded with a backing plate behind.
Why it is still open
Tesla's procedure, as InsideEVs described it in June 2024, lets shops weld cracks of up to 50 mm in many areas of a casting, and up to 30 mm with a backing plate in others. The closest published fatigue test of weld-repaired aluminum castings used F357-T6 castings (Esposito and colleagues, 2019), not the high-pressure die-cast alloys of car bodies, and a July 2026 review by Matteo Strano and colleagues at Politecnico di Milano treats the repairability of such castings as an open issue.
Built with what exists
Scrap rear castings bought from salvage yards; a band saw or waterjet to cut coupons; a fatigue crack started by loading or a saw slot; a pulse MIG welder with aluminum wire; X-ray or CT scans for porosity before and after welding; a servo-hydraulic fatigue tester at a university materials lab.
First step
Buy one scrap rear casting, cut ten coupons from a flat area, and scan two for porosity to see how much the base metal varies.
Done looks like
At least 30 coupons in three groups, each run to failure at two load levels, with stress against cycles to failure, porosity scans and fracture photos published for every coupon.