BRENNEN

Industries / Transport and vehicles / Automotive / Auto repair

Diagnosis

Diagnosis is finding out why a car misbehaves: reading its warning lights, fault codes and live data, testing parts, and deciding what to repair or replace.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1950s to 2022.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1950s

    Many meters in one cabinet

    A motor tester put several engine instruments into one wheeled unit, so a mechanic could check ignition and electrical systems, engine vacuum, engine speed and exhaust from one place instead of with separate gauges. The Henry Ford museum holds a Sun Motor Tester, Master Model, made between 1945 and 1955, that the racing driver Bobby Unser used at the Unser garage in Albuquerque, New Mexico.

    thehenryford.org

    Credit

    Sun Electric Corporation, Chicago

  2. 1971

    Cars get a test socket

    Volkswagen's service bays connected a computer to a test socket fitted to the cars it was building, with an adaptor for VWs built after 1965. A plastic program card set the checks for each model, and the print-out held 88 readings: 28 measured automatically and 60 entered by the mechanic, who could not skip a step. The trade weekly Commercial Motor reported it in November 1971, and Volkswagen's own chronicle lists the system under 1971.

    archive.commercialmotor.comvolkswagen-group.com

    Credit

    Volkswagen

  3. 1988

    First self-checks fall short

    California's first rules for on-board diagnostics (OBD), the car's own checks on its emission parts, took effect in 1988 and were required on all 1991 and newer vehicles. TransportPolicy.net, run by the International Council on Clean Transportation and DieselNet, says this first generation worked less well than it could because it watched only a few emission parts and was not set to any level of emission performance.

    LessonA self-check helps a repairer only when it watches the whole system.

    transportpolicy.net

    Credit

    California Air Resources Board (CARB)

  4. 1996

    One plug, one code list

    CARB's second-generation rules, OBD II, apply to nearly all 1996 and newer cars, pickups and SUVs under 14,000 lb. The car turns on a warning light when an emission part fails and stores details "so that a repair technician can accurately find and fix the problem." The rules point to SAE International standards for a common diagnostic connector, SAE J1962, and for how codes are read, and CARB wrote in 1996 that most of those SAE documents might not have been created without its requirement.

    ww2.arb.ca.govarb.ca.gov

    Credit

    CARB; SAE International

  5. 2002

    Confirmed fixes, searchable online

    In 1988 Autoline Telediagnosis opened a telephone hotline for mechanics stuck on a repair, staffed by four technicians. In 2002 the company, renamed Identifix in 1995, put the hotline's solved cases online as Direct-Hit, so a technician could look up what fixed the same fault on the same model. Identifix says Direct-Hit now holds more than 3 million fixes submitted and confirmed by technicians.

    identifix.com

    Credit

    Identifix, founded by Bill Sauer

  6. 2022

    Fault codes outgrow their format

    Carmakers told CARB that the standard fault codes were close to running out as hybrids and new emission parts multiplied, and proposed a newer message format, Unified Diagnostic Services (UDS, ISO 14229), which allows far more codes and more detail per code. CARB adopted rules requiring UDS from the 2027 model year on light- and medium-duty vehicles that use the standard CAN link (ISO 15765-4), optional from 2023, and California's Office of Administrative Law approved them on 22 November 2022.

    ww2.arb.ca.govww2.arb.ca.gov

    Credit

    CARB; vehicle manufacturers

Watch for

  1. AI helpers inside repair software

    Bosch says an AI assistant in its ESI[tronic] diagnostic software will check a car's fault data against carmakers' repair guidelines, wiring diagrams and Bosch's database of past workshop repairs, then give a step-by-step test plan that technicians can question in plain words; it is due worldwide at the end of 2026 in the ESI[tronic] 2026/4 release, and Bosch says it aims to raise first-time fix rates. ALLDATA says its Diagnostic Intelligence, launched in October 2026, starts from a fault code or symptom and lists probable causes in order, known fixes and shortcut tests.

    Achieved whensomeone outside the two companies publishes a test on cases with confirmed fixes showing how often each assistant names the right cause first.

    autosphere.cavehicleservicepros.com

    Claimed by

    Bosch, July 2026; ALLDATA, October 2026

Open

  1. 01

    AI helpers on planted faults

    A public test in which known, reversible faults are planted in training cars, such as an unplugged sensor, a resistor added to a sensor's ground wire, a pinched vacuum hose or a pulled fuse. For each fault, record the symptoms, fault codes, freeze-frame data (a snapshot of sensor readings taken when the code set) and live data. Then ask AI assistants, and technicians working without them, to name the cause, and count how often each names the planted fault first and how many tests it takes.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Counting good parts thrown away

    Collect the low-voltage parts that shops remove during repairs, such as sensors, relays, throttle bodies and wheel-speed sensors, test each on a bench against the maker's specification, and publish the share that still worked, by part type and by the reason the shop gave for replacing it.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

AI helpers on planted faults

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test in which known, reversible faults are planted in training cars, such as an unplugged sensor, a resistor added to a sensor's ground wire, a pinched vacuum hose or a pulled fuse. For each fault, record the symptoms, fault codes, freeze-frame data (a snapshot of sensor readings taken when the code set) and live data. Then ask AI assistants, and technicians working without them, to name the cause, and count how often each names the planted fault first and how many tests it takes.

Why it is still open

Bosch and ALLDATA announced their AI assistants in 2026 without published accuracy figures. Research papers test on carmakers' private data, such as a 2026 study on 885 cases from one truck maker, and the nearest public set, from a 2026 master's thesis, holds 75 search questions over NHTSA complaints and bulletins rather than faults on real cars.

autosphere.caarxiv.orggithub.com

Built with what exists

Training cars at a college automotive program; a scan tool, plus an OBD adapter and the open-source python-OBD library to save the data; AI models such as Claude, Gemini and GPT given identical data and run several times each (see the Note "All twenty times"); commercial assistants where the test team holds a subscription.

  1. First step

    Write a list of 50 reversible faults with a college instructor and record the data for the first ten.

  2. Done looks like

    50 planted faults on at least two cars, each tried by at least three AI helpers and three technicians working alone, with the share of first answers that name the planted fault and the median number of tests, published with the raw data.

Open 02 · the brief

Counting good parts thrown away

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Collect the low-voltage parts that shops remove during repairs, such as sensors, relays, throttle bodies and wheel-speed sensors, test each on a bench against the maker's specification, and publish the share that still worked, by part type and by the reason the shop gave for replacing it.

Why it is still open

In a 2006 survey of 98 people at carmakers and parts suppliers by Joe Barkai of the analyst firm Manufacturing Insights, carmakers put their "no fault found" rate, the share of parts returned under warranty that test as working, mostly at 20% to 30%, and higher for electronic controllers; these were estimates for warranty claims, not measurements, and Barkai noted that parts "do not test well outside of the vehicle". Identifix, which sells diagnostic software, tells shops how to estimate what a wrong diagnosis costs them but gives no measured rate, and this research found no published count of good parts removed by independent shops.

warrantyweek.comidentifix.com

Built with what exists

A bench power supply; a lab oscilloscope such as a PicoScope; test values from carmakers' service information; a shared spreadsheet log.

  1. First step

    Ask two shops to bag and label every sensor and relay they remove for four weeks.

  2. Done looks like

    500 removed parts from at least 10 shops, each with its test result and the shop's reason for replacing it, and the share found good, published as open data with the test method; parts that pass on the bench are rechecked in a known-good car of the same model, to meet Barkai's objection.