BRENNEN

Industries / Retail, hospitality and personal services / Retail and e-commerce / Auto parts retail

Returns and cores

Returns work takes back parts that were the wrong fit, not needed or said to be faulty, and collects the worn parts, called cores, and the old batteries that customers hand in so they can be rebuilt or recycled.

5

Milestones achieved, from 1989 to 2025.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1989

    Old battery for new

    In 1989 Battery Council International (BCI), the trade group of lead battery makers, drafted a model state law that bans dumping lead-acid batteries, makes retailers accept used ones and post a sign saying so, and sets a core charge, a refundable deposit paid on a new battery when no old one is handed in. The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) says 45 states have enacted laws based on the model, with core charges of $5 to $20 set by each state, and names retailers such as AutoZone, Costco and Batteries Plus among the collection points; battery makers pay the retailers for the old batteries. BCI's own table of state laws lists, for example, a required $5 deposit in Connecticut and $10 in Arkansas.

    LessonThe EPA credits disposal bans, core charges and the store counter, in a network paid for by industry rather than government, for recycling 99% of lead-acid batteries, its 2018 figure.

    epa.govbatterycouncil.org

    Credit

    Battery Council International; state legislatures

  2. 2012

    Cores counted

    A core is the worn part, such as a starter, an alternator or a gearbox, that a remanufacturer strips, rebuilds and tests to the original specification. From its survey of US firms, the US International Trade Commission (USITC) put US output of remanufactured vehicle parts at $6.2 billion in 2011, made by 30,653 full-time workers and equal to 1 to 2% of US vehicle parts sales, and reported that remanufactured parts cost on average 20 to 50% less than most new ones. Carmakers' dealers collect cores and hand out rebuilt parts in a closed loop, while independent remanufacturers buy cores from salvage yards and core brokers; both rely on a core deposit, added to the price and credited back when the old part comes back.

    LessonBrazil, China and India restricted or banned trade in cores or remanufactured goods, often by treating cores as used goods, so where an old part may legally travel decides where it can be rebuilt.

    webarchive.library.unt.edu

    Credit

    USITC, investigation 332-525

  3. 2022

    Open the box first

    In October 2022 the Automotive Aftermarket Suppliers Association (AASA) and a group of parts makers launched CheckThePart.com, which asks counter staff to open every returned box, confirm that the part matches the paperwork and the brand on the box, and take back a never-fitted part as a return, not a warranty claim. Items sent back for credit have included worn original parts and bricks put in to fill the box. The AASA estimates that fraudulent warranty returns cost parts stores more than $600 million a year, and that 53% of warranty returns were new parts or parts not made by the maker whose box they came back in.

    LessonThe figures are the industry's own estimates, and published return rates disagree: the AASA puts auto parts returns at 22.6%, the highest of any retail category, while a National Retail Federation figure quoted in 2023 is 19.4% of parts ordered online.

    aftermarketnews.commotor.commotor.com

    Credit

    AASA; Standard Motor Products, Dorman Products, KYB, MPA, Mevotech, MotoRad of America and FDP Brakes; endorsed by the Auto Care Association

  4. 2025

    Cores enter China

    In March 2025, 1,080 used transmission control modules, the computers that shift an automatic gearbox, arrived at the Chongqing Lianglu Guoyuan Port Comprehensive Bonded Zone, an area where goods stay under customs control, to be rebuilt by Chongqing Yuxiang Intelligent Technology. China Daily called it the official landing of China's first bonded remanufacturing business, approved as a pilot by Chongqing Customs with the city's commerce commission and ecology and environment bureau. The company estimated that it would rebuild about 250,000 transmissions, engines and their parts a year under bond.

    LessonA country that restricts imports of used goods can still take in cores by keeping them, and the work done on them, inside a customs zone.

    govt.chinadaily.com.cngovt.chinadaily.com.cn

    Credit

    Chongqing Customs; Chongqing Yuxiang Intelligent Technology

  5. 2025

    Any seller takes batteries

    From 18 August 2025 the EU Batteries Regulation makes every seller of batteries take back waste batteries free of charge, without requiring the customer to buy a new one and whatever their brand or origin, for each category it sells, including SLI batteries (the starting, lighting and ignition batteries in cars). Sellers that sell at a distance must provide enough collection points across each country. Germany's law carrying out the regulation, the Batterierecht-Durchführungsgesetz (BattDG), in force from 7 October 2025, also makes sellers charge a €7.50 deposit on each starter battery sold to a buyer who hands in no old one, refunded when an old battery comes back, and makes online sellers refund it on proof, no more than two weeks old, that the old battery was handed in elsewhere.

    publications.europa.eugesetze-im-internet.de

    Credit

    European Parliament and Council (Regulation (EU) 2023/1542); German Bundestag

Watch for

  1. Faulty parts flown back

    The China Automotive Engineering Research Institute (CAERI) says it has opened China's first bonded testing pilot for faulty vehicle parts from abroad, in a customs zone in Chongqing, so that parts that failed in other countries can be flown in and tested there despite China's limits on importing used machinery, then sent abroad again or disposed of. It covers 18 kinds of core parts, among them engines, transmissions and wiper motors, and the first batch held wiper motors, oil pumps and cylinder heads from Latin America, Southeast Asia and Africa.

    Achieved whencustoms figures or an outside party report how many returned parts have been tested there and what the tests found, or parts makers outside CAERI use it routinely.

    english.liangjiang.gov.cn

    Claimed by

    CAERI, reported by the Liangjiang New Area government, July 2026

Open

  1. 01

    A tally of returned parts

    A public, part-by-part record of what happens to parts returned to stores as faulty. Each returned starter, alternator or battery is photographed with its box, tested on the store's own bench tester by store staff, and recorded as faulty, no fault found, never fitted, or not the brand named on the box.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Battery take-back put to test

    A public check of whether sellers of car batteries take old ones back as the law requires: in the EU, any seller of car batteries, free of charge and without a purchase; in Germany, also charging and refunding the €7.50 deposit; in US states with laws based on BCI's model, retailers accepting used batteries and posting the required notice. For each seller it records what staff say when asked, the notice on display, and, for online sellers, the collection points they offer.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A tally of returned parts

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, part-by-part record of what happens to parts returned to stores as faulty. Each returned starter, alternator or battery is photographed with its box, tested on the store's own bench tester by store staff, and recorded as faulty, no fault found, never fitted, or not the brand named on the box.

Why it is still open

The best-known figures are the industry's own estimates: the AASA says fraudulent warranty returns cost parts stores more than $600 million a year and that 53% of warranty returns were new parts or another maker's part. A trade-press survey of parts makers reports that many find fewer than half of parts returned as faulty have any problem, and some electronics suppliers put the share of wrong claims nearer 90%, without publishing counts. A search found no published tally of what returned parts turn out to be.

motor.comvehicleservicepros.com

Built with what exists

The starter, alternator and battery testers already used at many parts store counters; phone photos of each part and box; a vision-language model such as Claude Fable 5.2 (see the Note "Three working devices") to read part numbers and makers' marks, with a person checking each reading; a second model as reviewer to flag records whose photo and verdict disagree (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); a shared spreadsheet.

  1. First step

    Ask one store manager to photograph and bench-test every starter and alternator returned under warranty for one month, and log the results in a shared sheet.

  2. Done looks like

    300 parts returned as faulty, from at least two stores in different chains, each published with photos, the test printout and a verdict, with the share in each verdict group; a second tester retests 30 parts chosen at random and agrees on at least 27.

Open 02 · the brief

Battery take-back put to test

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public check of whether sellers of car batteries take old ones back as the law requires: in the EU, any seller of car batteries, free of charge and without a purchase; in Germany, also charging and refunding the €7.50 deposit; in US states with laws based on BCI's model, retailers accepting used batteries and posting the required notice. For each seller it records what staff say when asked, the notice on display, and, for online sellers, the collection points they offer.

Why it is still open

The EPA's case study credits widespread retailer participation, and BCI publishes each state's rules, but a search found no published audit of whether stores follow them. The EU duty on every seller has applied only since 18 August 2025.

epa.govpublications.europa.eu

Built with what exists

The EU regulation, the BattDG and BCI's state table as checklists; a short script for volunteers who ask at the counter, carrying no battery; Browser Use (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over") to save online sellers' take-back pages; a spreadsheet with photos of posted notices.

  1. First step

    List 40 car battery sellers in one German city and 40 in one US state, and photograph the take-back notice each displays, or record that there is none.

  2. Done looks like

    200 sellers in at least three countries, each with the date, method, answer and a photo or saved page; 20% rechecked by a second person on another day; and the share that complied published by country and by type of seller (parts chain, supermarket, online shop).