BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Government / Courts / Arbitration

Commercial arbitration

Deciding disputes between businesses, or between a business and a state under a contract, before private judges called arbitrators, usually with an institution that manages the case, ending in a written decision called an award.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1923 to 2023.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1923

    A court for world trade

    The International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) set up its International Court of Arbitration in 1923. The Court sees that the ICC Arbitration Rules are applied and reviews ("scrutinises") awards before they are issued, with a secretariat of more than 100 lawyers and staff in Paris, New York, São Paulo, Singapore, Abu Dhabi and Hong Kong; in December 2025 it registered its 30,000th case, and it took in 894 new cases that year.

    iccwbo.orgiccwbo.org

    Credit

    International Chamber of Commerce

  2. 1926

    A national arbitration service

    The American Arbitration Association (AAA), a not-for-profit, was founded in 1926 to run arbitrations across the United States. It administers cases but does not decide them: arbitrators from its panels do, and its staff check draft awards only for matters such as formatting. By its own count it has handled more than nine million cases, and more than 500,000 a year in each of 2024 and 2025.

    adr.orgadr.org

    Credit

    American Arbitration Association

  3. 2016

    Counting women on tribunals

    In 2016 the ICC began publishing how many of its arbitrators were women: 136 of 1,313 in 2015 (10.4%) and 209 of 1,411 in 2016 (14.8%). The Equal Representation in Arbitration Pledge, drawn up in 2015 and launched in 2016, asks signatories to appoint more women and now has more than 6,000 signatories in 143 countries; in 2025 women were 29.6% of the arbitrators confirmed or appointed in ICC cases.

    LessonInstitutions moved faster than parties: in 2016 the ICC Court, which appoints arbitrators in fewer than a quarter of cases, made 46.5% of the appointments of women.

    iccwbo.orgarbitrationpledge.comiccwbo.org

    Credit

    ICC International Court of Arbitration; Sylvia Noury KC, founder of the ERA Pledge

  4. 2017

    A fast track by default

    From March 2017 the ICC's Expedited Procedure Provisions applied automatically to smaller claims unless the parties opted out: one arbitrator, who may decide on the documents alone, and an award due six months after the first case management conference. By the end of 2025 the ICC had run 1,034 cases this way and issued 591 awards. Its 2026 Rules, in force from 1 June 2026, raise the threshold to US$4 million and add, for parties who agree to it, a highly expedited track with the award due within three months and reasons optional.

    iccwbo.orgiccwbo.orgfreshfields.com

    Credit

    ICC International Court of Arbitration

  5. 2020

    Hearings move online

    When the pandemic closed hearing rooms, cases went to video. In a 2021 survey of more than 1,200 people by Queen Mary University of London and the law firm White & Case, 72% had used virtual hearing rooms at least sometimes, where in their 2018 survey 64% had never used them, and 87% of arbitrators would hold a scheduled hearing online rather than postpone it. Respondents said they wanted a mix in future: fully virtual hearings for procedural matters, with in-person kept open for the main hearing.

    qmul.ac.uk

    Credit

    Queen Mary University of London's School of International Arbitration and White & Case, for the measurement

  6. 2023

    Fraud found after the award

    In 2017 a London-seated tribunal ordered Nigeria to pay the company Process & Industrial Developments (P&ID) US$6.6 billion under a gas contract, a sum that with interest passed US$11 billion. On 23 October 2023 Mr Justice Robin Knowles of the Commercial Court in London upheld Nigeria's challenge, finding the awards had been obtained by fraud: witness evidence that hid bribes paid to a Nigerian official, more bribes during the arbitration to keep them hidden, and P&ID's keeping of more than 40 of Nigeria's internal legal documents that reached it during the case.

    LessonThe judge wrote that a tribunal "of the greatest experience and expertise is not enough", credited court-ordered disclosure of documents for finding the truth, and noted that the privacy of arbitration meant "no public or press scrutiny".

    caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk

    Credit

    Commercial Court of England and Wales; Nigeria's legal team

Watch for

  1. AI drafts the award

    The AAA offers an "AI arbitrator", built on its own past awards, for two-party cases decided on documents alone: construction cases from 3 November 2025, and all such business-to-business cases from 9 November 2026. The AI summarises each side's submissions for the parties to confirm and drafts a proposed award, which a trained human arbitrator reviews, revises and issues; the AAA says early testing showed resolution 20–25% faster and costs 35% or more lower.

    Achieved whensomeone outside the AAA publishes how AI-assisted cases compare with ordinary ones on time, cost and how often the human arbitrator changed the draft.

    adr.orgadr.orgprnewswire.com

    Claimed by

    American Arbitration Association, November 2025 and November 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Testing AI-drafted awards

    A set of 50 fictional two-party business disputes decided on documents, such as unpaid invoices or late delivery under a supply contract, each with a full file of contract, letters and evidence, decided separately by three experienced arbitrators who write reasoned awards, plus a method for scoring AI-drafted awards against them.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Transcripts tested on mock hearings

    Ten hours of recorded mock arbitration hearings read from fictional scripts (openings, a witness questioned on dates and sums, an expert on delay), spoken by people with a range of accents, with checked reference transcripts, and a scoring of speech-to-text systems against them.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Testing AI-drafted awards

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A set of 50 fictional two-party business disputes decided on documents, such as unpaid invoices or late delivery under a supply contract, each with a full file of contract, letters and evidence, decided separately by three experienced arbitrators who write reasoned awards, plus a method for scoring AI-drafted awards against them.

Why it is still open

The AAA's AI arbitrator was trained on real AAA awards, and the only figures published on it are the AAA's own from early testing (20–25% faster, 35% or more cheaper), with nothing on how often its drafts match a human decision. Searches of the web, arXiv and GitHub in November 2026 found no public test set that compares AI-drafted awards with human ones.

adr.org

Built with what exists

Current large language models, including open-weight ones such as Mistral Large 4 (Note: "A trillion open parameters"); Python for scoring; a blind rating form for the arbitrators who judge the drafts.

  1. First step

    Write five fictional files of under 40 pages each and ask three volunteer arbitrators, for example through a local Chartered Institute of Arbitrators branch, to decide them.

  2. Done looks like

    50 fictional files and 150 human awards published under an open licence, drafts from at least three AI systems, and a table showing, for each system, how often its draft agreed with the human majority on who wins and on the amount (within 10%), and how many of its references to the file were wrong, as rated by arbitrators who did not know which draft was which.

Open 02 · the brief

Transcripts tested on mock hearings

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Ten hours of recorded mock arbitration hearings read from fictional scripts (openings, a witness questioned on dates and sums, an expert on delay), spoken by people with a range of accents, with checked reference transcripts, and a scoring of speech-to-text systems against them.

Why it is still open

Published tests of speech-to-text on legal hearings use real court audio in one setting, such as UK Supreme Court hearings (Hadeel Saadany and colleagues, 2022) and French legal speech in Quebec (Nicolas Garneau and Olivier Bolduc, 2024), and arbitration hearings are private, so their audio is not available to test on. No court rule, judicial guidance or professional standard sets an acceptable word error rate (the share of words a system gets wrong) for legal transcription, by a speech-recognition vendor's own account, and a November 2026 search found no public test set of arbitration hearing audio. In the 2025 Queen Mary and White & Case survey, 51% named errors and bias as an obstacle to more use of AI in arbitration.

arxiv.orgarxiv.orgspeechmatics.comqmul.ac.uk

Built with what exists

Open speech models such as OpenAI's Whisper; commercial services such as ElevenLabs Scribe v3 (Note: "Fewer word errors"); speaker-labelling software; the Python library jiwer to count word errors.

  1. First step

    Write a 30-minute fictional cross-examination with 40 dates, sums and names, record it with four readers, and score two systems.

  2. Done looks like

    Audio and transcripts published under an open licence, and a table for at least five systems giving the word error rate, the error rate on names and numbers, and the share of wrongly labelled speakers, for each accent group.