BRENNEN

Industries / Construction and property / Real estate / Appraisal

Equipment and art

Equipment and art appraisal is estimating what movable things would sell for, such as machines, vehicles, aircraft, artworks, jewelry and collectibles, mostly from price guides, auction results and dealers' sales, for lenders, insurers, tax offices, courts and estates.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1926 to 2025.

3

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

3

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1926

    Car values in print

    Les Kelley, who ran a used-car lot in Los Angeles, turned his list of the cars he wanted to buy, and the prices he would pay, into the first Blue Book of Motor Car Values. Dealers and lenders gained a shared printed reference for what a used car was worth, so a value could come from a published guide and not only from one buyer's judgment.

    coxautoinc.com

    Credit

    Les Kelley (Kelley Blue Book); the account is that of Cox Automotive, which owns Kelley Blue Book

  2. 1936

    Appraisers beyond land organize

    The American Society of Technical Appraisers first met in February 1936. Its members valued "real and personal property", land and buildings and also movable things such as machinery, and one reason for starting it was that an existing real estate appraisal group admitted only licensed brokers. It became part of the American Society of Appraisers (ASA), incorporated in 1952, which in 1968 split its work into specialties it calls disciplines.

    appraisers.org

    Credit

    the society's founders, Earl P. Marshall, Robert W. Stevens, Stuart C. Tait and Samuel W. Gibson

  3. 1968

    An art panel for taxes

    The IRS created the Commissioner's Art Advisory Panel, dealers, curators and scholars who review the appraisals of art filed with income, estate and gift tax returns; an audited return that claims $50,000 or more for one work must be referred to it. In fiscal 2023 the panel reviewed 195 items claimed at $795.5 million in 37 cases and changed the value of 92 of them, 47%, and the IRS adopted 63% of its recommendations in full.

    LessonA small net change can hide deep cuts: the year's net change was a 2% decrease, but the 63 items the panel lowered went from a claimed $150.5 million to $81.4 million.

    irs.gov

    Credit

    the IRS Art Advisory Panel

  4. 1984

    Aircraft appraisers get certified

    The International Society of Transport Aircraft Trading (ISTAT) runs a certification program for people who value airliners for leasing companies and lenders; ISTAT says the program turned 40 in 2024. By March 2025 it had about 100 certified appraisers and 40 candidates.

    istat.org

    Credit

    ISTAT

  5. 2005

    Auction estimates run high

    An auction house prints a pre-sale estimate, a low-to-high price range, for each lot before the sale. Using 30 years of sales, Jianping Mei and Michael Moses found "a consistent upward bias" in the estimates for expensive paintings. In 2023 Mathieu Aubry, Roman Kräussl, Gustavo Manso and Christophe Spaenjers built a neural network that values art from images and sale data, and found that where its value sat above the house's estimate, prices tended to beat the estimate, so the houses' errors can be predicted.

    LessonAn estimate published by the seller's agent is not a neutral value.

    ideas.repec.orgfaculty.haas.berkeley.edu

    Credit

    Mei and Moses (Journal of Finance, 2005); Aubry, Kräussl, Manso and Spaenjers (Journal of Finance, 2023)

  6. 2025

    Auction house appraisal fails

    WT Art Partnership gave five ancient Chinese paintings to the Metropolitan Museum of Art and claimed deductions of more than $73 million, on appraisals by China Guardian, a Beijing auction house. The US Tax Court held that these were not "qualified appraisals" under the tax law, because China Guardian was a firm and not an individual appraiser, valued one painting claimed at $26 million at $12 million, and upheld the 40% penalty for gross overvaluation.

    LessonAn auction estimate made to win a sale is not a tax appraisal.

    thetaxadviser.com

    Credit

    US Tax Court, WT Art Partnership LP, T.C. Memo. 2025-30; reported by The Tax Adviser

Watch for

  1. AI values art for lenders

    Artsignal says it values thousands of artworks, jewelry pieces, watches and collectibles at once, mainly for lenders, by finding comparable past sales through visual search across "about 15 million historic sales" and adjusting older prices with its own market indexes. It says users can edit the comparables and that "all the logic is auditable". Christie's Ventures has invested in it.

    Achieved whenA lender or other outside party publishes Artsignal's error against later sale prices.

    culturedmag.com

    Claimed by

    Sam Glatman, Artsignal's co-founder and chief executive, November 2026

  2. Free AI estimates for collectors

    MyArtBroker offers instant valuations of prints built from sales at 400 auction houses, Artscapy offers free AI estimates and a paid appraisal for £59.99, and the new owner of Artnet and Artsy, Beowolff Capital, says it is building AI valuation models. Bloomberg's report gives no accuracy figures and no independent test.

    Achieved whenAn outside party scores these estimates against hammer prices, the winning bids, of sales held after the estimates were made.

    thestar.com.my

    Claimed by

    MyArtBroker, Artscapy and Beowolff Capital, reported by Bloomberg, February 2026

  3. Photos price wrecked cars

    RB Global reports an AI "total loss predictor" in its salvage-vehicle business, which uses images and data to judge whether a damaged car is worth repairing or should be written off. Coverage of its results reports accuracy in the high 90s in percent in testing, and a wider rollout planned for 2026.

    Achieved whenAn insurer or auditor outside RB Global reports its accuracy in routine use.

    digitalcommerce360.com

    Claimed by

    RB Global, fourth-quarter 2025 results, February 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Art estimates scored before sale

    A public test that collects estimates for auction lots not yet sold and locks them before each sale: estimates from AI models, the auction house's own estimate and a simple baseline such as the artist's last sale price. Each is then scored against the hammer price.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Checker for donated-art appraisals

    A tool that reads the appraisal behind a US tax deduction for donated art, with its IRS Form 8283 summary, and checks it against the contents and appraiser rules that Treasury Regulation 1.170A-17 requires: among them an individual appraiser with verifiable education and experience, an appraisal made no earlier than 60 days before the gift, and a fee not based on the appraised value. It is built and tested only on made-up documents.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  3. 03

    Art panel reports as data

    One table covering every published annual report of the IRS Art Advisory Panel, giving for each year the items and cases reviewed, the total claimed and recommended values, the split between raised, lowered and accepted items, and the share of the panel's advice the IRS adopted.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Art estimates scored before sale

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test that collects estimates for auction lots not yet sold and locks them before each sale: estimates from AI models, the auction house's own estimate and a simple baseline such as the artist's last sale price. Each is then scored against the hammer price.

Why it is still open

Published studies, such as Aubry and colleagues (2023) and Mei and colleagues (December 2025), look back at sales already made, and the commercial tools above publish no independent accuracy tests.

arxiv.orgthestar.com.my

Built with what exists

Auction houses' public lot pages, keeping only facts (lot number, estimate, result and link) and only from sites whose terms allow it, collected with Browser Use 1.0 (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); estimates from Claude Fable 5.2 (see the Note "Three working devices") and from Liquid AI's small open LFM3 vision model (see the Note "One GPU to fine-tune"), each run many times to show the spread (see the Note "All twenty times"); each batch locked with a timestamp, such as a public git commit or a Wayback Machine snapshot.

  1. First step

    Pick one coming sale of prints, which have many lots and frequent repeat sales, publish the scoring rules and lock the first batch.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 300 lots from at least three sales in two countries, all locked before the sale, with each source's median absolute error on a log scale and the share of hammer prices that fell inside its range, stating whether the buyer's premium is included.

Open 02 · the brief

Checker for donated-art appraisals

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A tool that reads the appraisal behind a US tax deduction for donated art, with its IRS Form 8283 summary, and checks it against the contents and appraiser rules that Treasury Regulation 1.170A-17 requires: among them an individual appraiser with verifiable education and experience, an appraisal made no earlier than 60 days before the gift, and a fee not based on the appraised value. It is built and tested only on made-up documents.

Why it is still open

The Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (TIGTA) found that 54% of the sampled paper returns that claimed more than $500,000 in donated property, and had errors, had no appraisal attached, and the WT Art case of 2025 turned on whether the appraiser qualified. This research found no public tool or test set for checking these appraisals.

tigta.govlaw.cornell.edu

Built with what exists

The regulation text and Form 8283, both US government works; made-up appraisals written with Claude Fable 5.2; field extraction with Meta's Muse Ember (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); a long-document review pass of the kind in the Note "Seven more flagged".

  1. First step

    Turn paragraphs (a)(3) and (b) of the regulation into about 20 yes-or-no tests, each with its citation.

  2. Done looks like

    An open set of at least 200 made-up appraisals with known planted defects, and, on a held-out set built by someone else, the checker finding at least 95% of defects with at least 90% of its flags correct, each flag citing the paragraph of the regulation it rests on.

Open 03 · the brief

Art panel reports as data

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

One table covering every published annual report of the IRS Art Advisory Panel, giving for each year the items and cases reviewed, the total claimed and recommended values, the split between raised, lowered and accepted items, and the share of the panel's advice the IRS adopted.

Why it is still open

Each year is a separate PDF, the fiscal 2018 table loses its column alignment when its text is extracted, and the panel was rechartered in April 2026, so new reports will follow.

irs.govpublic-inspection.federalregister.gov

Built with what exists

The IRS PDFs and archived copies; pdftotext; Meta's Muse Ember or Claude Fable 5.2 to extract the tables, with arithmetic checks.

  1. First step

    List every version of IRS Publication 5392 on irs.gov and in web archives, and download them.

  2. Done looks like

    Every available year, each row adding up to the report's totals within $1, two independent extractions that agree, and a chart of the net change by year, such as the 18% decrease in fiscal 2018 and the 2% decrease in fiscal 2023.