Industries / Construction and property / Real estate / Appraisal
Commercial property
Commercial property valuation is estimating what offices, shops, warehouses, hotels, blocks of rented flats, data centers and land would sell for, mostly by turning the rent a building earns into a capital value, for lenders, investors, property funds and company accounts.
6
Milestones achieved, from 1914 to 2024.
3
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1914
Tables for capitalizing rent
Richard Parry, a surveyor, published Valuation Tables through the Estates Gazette in London, and the Institute of Actuaries reviewed the book in January 1914. Tables like his give the "years' purchase", the number by which a valuer multiplies a yearly rent to get a capital value at a chosen interest rate, so the figure could be looked up instead of worked out by compound interest.
Credit
Richard Parry
1978
An index built from appraisals
From the first quarter of 1978 the National Council of Real Estate Investment Fiduciaries (NCREIF) has published quarterly returns on commercial buildings held for US pension funds and other tax-exempt investors, with values taken from appraisals, not sales. By Joseph Gyourko's count, at the end of 2002 its index covered 3,680 properties appraised at $121.9 billion.
Credit
NCREIF
1991
Appraisal smoothing measured
David Geltner set out models of "smoothing": an index built from valuations swings less, and turns later, than the prices buildings actually fetch, and he gave ways to recover the true volatility. Gyourko later showed why the lag is strong: most institutional buildings are appraised once a year, mostly in the fourth quarter, and the NCREIF index's standard deviation was "barely above 1", against at least four times that for listed property companies (REITs) and stocks.
LessonAn index made of valuations understates risk and turns late, and needs correcting before it is used to judge risk.
Credit
David Geltner
2000
Fair value enters company accounts
International Accounting Standard 40 (IAS 40, Investment Property), issued in April 2000, lets a company carry buildings it rents out at fair value, the price a sale would fetch now, with changes in that value counted in profit or loss as they occur; the other option is to carry them at cost and disclose fair value. Under these rules a valuer's figure moves a company's reported earnings.
Credit
the International Accounting Standards Committee, predecessor of the IASB
2016
Property funds stop paying out
An open-ended fund buys back its units on demand, but buildings take months to sell. After the UK's EU referendum in June 2016, a number of UK open-ended property funds suspended dealing; in March 2020 valuers declared "material valuation uncertainty", meaning they could not value with normal confidence, and many funds suspended again. The Financial Conduct Authority's (FCA's) rules, in force from 30 September 2020, require a retail property fund to suspend when the independent valuer finds material uncertainty over more than 20% of its property, unless the manager and the depositary agree that staying open is in investors' interests.
LessonIn the FCA's words, a unit price that overstates the buildings means "investors redeeming units will receive more cash than they should", at the expense of those who stay.
Credit
the FCA; the funds' standing independent valuers
2024
Office appraisals trail sale prices
After interest rates rose in 2022, sale prices fell faster than appraisals. MSCI's Jim Costello reported in December 2024 that appraised values for US central-business-district offices had fallen 43% from their peak by mid-2024, while MSCI's index of transaction prices stood 51% below its peak. In November 2023 the European Central Bank (ECB) reported the euro area's largest listed landlords trading more than 30% below net asset value, the appraised value of their holdings less debt, their widest discount since 2008, and its bank inspectors later found valuers relying on sales evidence from 2021 or earlier.
LessonWhen few buildings trade, appraisals anchored to old deals lag, and supervisors now test valuations against current evidence.
Credit
MSCI; the European Central Bank
Watch for
AI drafts appraisal reports
Valcre, which sells commercial appraisal software, says 80% of the text its Narrative Writer generated since an April 2026 rollout was used in completed reports, without saying how this was measured. Its AI Import tool, starting to roll out, reads rent rolls (lists of tenants, rents and lease dates), leases, expense statements and sale brochures into the appraiser's database.
Achieved whenA lender's review appraisers, an auditor or a researcher outside Valcre publishes measured error rates for the drafted text or the extracted rent-roll fields on real reports.
Claimed by
Valcre, July 2026
Agents inside ARGUS
ARGUS is software that valuers use to build discounted cash flow models, which forecast a building's income and convert it to today's money. Its owner, Altus Group, says ARGUS Assist lets users ask in plain language, after which "specialized AI agents automatically execute tasks across the ARGUS Intelligence platform". The release gives no performance figures or release date.
Achieved whenThe tool is generally released and a valuation firm or auditor outside Altus reports measured time or error results on real models.
Claimed by
Altus Group, April 2026
Data center guidance rewritten
A working group of the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) aims to replace RICS's 2011 guidance on valuing data centers "within twelve months". It has chosen discounted cash flow as the main method for finished, leased sites, and notes that much of the market evidence "sits behind confidentiality agreements".
Achieved whenRICS publishes the replacement and published valuations, such as data center REITs' reports, cite it.
Claimed by
the RICS working group, as reported by BTG Eddisons, the employer of one member, June 2026
Open
01
Lease terms a valuer needs
An open set of 200 commercial leases (office, retail and industrial) taken from exhibits to US SEC filings, each labeled for the terms a valuer types into a cash flow model: parties, floor area, start and expiry dates, rent for each year, the rule for rent increases or reviews, rent-free months, break and renewal options, who pays the running costs (a gross or a net lease) and the deposit. Ship it with a scoring script.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Stale values in CMBS loans
A public table, refreshed monthly, of the loans inside US commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS, bonds backed by pools of commercial property loans). For each loan it shows the property's value when the bond was issued, its most recent value and that value's date, and net operating income (NOI, rent less running costs) then and now. It flags loans whose NOI has fallen by 20% or more with no new valuation in 24 months, and shows what a simple income valuation, latest NOI divided by a stated capitalization rate, would give instead.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Lease terms a valuer needs
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open set of 200 commercial leases (office, retail and industrial) taken from exhibits to US SEC filings, each labeled for the terms a valuer types into a cash flow model: parties, floor area, start and expiry dates, rent for each year, the rule for rent increases or reviews, rent-free months, break and renewal options, who pays the running costs (a gross or a net lease) and the deposit. Ship it with a scoring script.
Why it is still open
The only public lease benchmark found, by Leivaditi and colleagues (2020), was audited in 2026 by researchers who found it "full of annotation errors and inconsistencies". CUAD, a public set of 510 contracts under the CC BY 4.0 license, labels clause types for legal review, not rent schedules.
Built with what exists
EDGAR full-text search, which covers all electronic SEC filings since 2001, exhibits included; Meta's Muse Ember for long-document extraction (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat") and Claude Fable 5.2 (see the Note "Three working devices") as baseline readers; Gemini Decision 1 for multiple-choice fields such as the lease type (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); release under CC BY 4.0, as CUAD was.
First step
Search EDGAR exhibits for "lease agreement" with "base rent", collect 50 candidates, draft the field list with a practicing valuer, and label 10 leases together.
Done looks like
200 leases, each labeled by two people with disagreements resolved and agreement reported for each field; a public scorer for any model's output; scores for at least two models; and rent schedules computed from the labels that match a hand calculation within 1%.
Open 02 · the brief
Stale values in CMBS loans
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table, refreshed monthly, of the loans inside US commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS, bonds backed by pools of commercial property loans). For each loan it shows the property's value when the bond was issued, its most recent value and that value's date, and net operating income (NOI, rent less running costs) then and now. It flags loans whose NOI has fallen by 20% or more with no new valuation in 24 months, and shows what a simple income valuation, latest NOI divided by a stated capitalization rate, would give instead.
Why it is still open
SEC rules already require each bond's filings to report the value at issue, the most recent value and its date, and the most recent NOI, loan by loan. The one open parser of these files found, visulate-abs, stores them but offers no view of valuations or how old they are. ECB inspectors found valuers relying on evidence from 2021 or earlier.
Built with what exists
Form ABS-EE asset data files (EX-102 XML), public on EDGAR; visulate-abs (MIT license) as a starting parser; Python and DuckDB; an AI coding agent such as Claude Fable 5.2 to write and test the parsers. Public data only, and no trading.
First step
Download one month of EX-102 files for 20 deals, map the value, date and NOI fields, and count the loans with no valuation newer than the bond's issue.
Done looks like
Every CMBS deal filing ABS-EE data for the latest month covered, with method and code published so that a third party running one script gets the same loan counts and flags, and a headline figure, by property type, for the share of loans whose latest valuation is still the one from issue.