Industries / Finance and business services / Advertising and marketing
Customer data and email
This is the work of keeping records on a company's own customers, such as mailing lists, loyalty-card purchases and email sign-ups, and of contacting those customers directly by mail and email within the limits of privacy law.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1967 to 2025.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1967
Direct marketing gets a name
In a speech to the Boston chapter of the American Marketing Association at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), the advertising executive Lester Wunderman named and defined "direct marketing": using any channel, such as mail, to put a seller in direct contact with a buyer and ask for a reply. Sources disagree on the date: his agency's 2019 notice of his death gives the 1967 MIT speech, while a company history on Encyclopedia.com says he first used the term in public in a 1961 speech to the Hundred Million Club of New York, a direct-mail group.
Credit
Lester Wunderman, Wunderman, Ricotta & Kline
1978
A mass email to ARPANET
In May 1978 a message from Gary Thuerk, a marketer at Digital Equipment Corporation (DEC), invited readers to see the new DECSYSTEM-20 computers and was sent to hundreds of addresses on ARPANET, the US government computer network of the day. The mail program held only 320 addresses, so the rest spilled into the message itself. The Defense Communications Agency, which ran the network, called it "a flagrant violation" of the rule that ARPANET was for official US government business only. Brad Templeton, who keeps the original message, calls it "possibly the first spam ever."
LessonUnrequested advertising by email drew complaints the first time it was sent.
Credit
Gary Thuerk and Carl Gartley, DEC
1995
A loyalty card nationwide
Tesco launched Clubcard in all its UK stores on 13 February 1995, after a trial in a few stores. Members showed the card at the checkout, and the data firm Dunnhumby, founded by Edwina Dunn and Clive Humby, used the purchase records to sort customers into groups and post them money-off vouchers, chosen for each member by 1997. Dunn says Tesco overtook Sainsbury's within a year and that Clubcard helped double Tesco's grocery market share in under three years; those are her figures. Grant Harrison, who led Tesco's Clubcard team, says Dunnhumby "did not design Clubcard" but analyzed its data.
LessonThe records of what each member bought proved useful well beyond discounts; Tesco drew on them for its Finest own-label range, store locations and new businesses such as Tesco Bank.
Credit
Tesco (Grant Harrison's team) and Dunnhumby
2018
Europe's data law applies
The European Union's General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) applied from 25 May 2018. It gives people the right to object at any time to the use of their personal data for direct marketing, after which the data may no longer be used for it. Breaches of these rights can be fined up to €20 million or 4% of a company's worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higher.
Credit
the European Parliament and the Council of the European Union
2021
Mail apps hide opens
Apple announced Mail Privacy Protection in June 2021 as part of iOS 15. It stops senders from using invisible pixels, tiny images that report back when a message is displayed, to learn when a user opens an email, and it hides the user's IP address, the number that can reveal location.
LessonThe open rate, a standard measure of an email campaign, depends on a tracking method that the reader's mail app can switch off.
Credit
Apple
2024
Inboxes set stricter rules
From 1 February 2024 Gmail has required anyone sending more than 5,000 messages a day to Gmail addresses to prove the mail comes from them (authentication), offer one-click unsubscribe and keep reported spam below 0.3%. Google's announcement added that unsubscribe requests must be processed within two days, and Yahoo backed the same changes. US law, the CAN-SPAM Act of 2003, gives a sender up to 10 business days to honor an opt-out.
LessonThe mailbox providers, which decide what reaches the inbox, now set tighter rules for marketing email than the law.
Credit
Google (Gmail) and Yahoo
2025
Chrome keeps third-party cookies
Third-party cookies are small files that let ad companies recognize the same browser across different websites. Google said in January 2020 that it planned to phase them out of Chrome "within two years". In April 2025, citing "divergent perspectives" among publishers, developers, regulators and the ad industry, it said it would keep its current approach, leaving the choice in Chrome's settings, and would not add a new prompt.
LessonA plan that depended on one browser maker's timetable was overturned after five years of preparation by the ad trade.
Credit
Google
Watch for
One request to every broker
California's privacy agency, CalPrivacy, runs the Delete Request and Opt-out Platform (DROP), through which a California resident sends one deletion request to every registered data broker, a business that sells personal information it did not collect from the person directly. Brokers have had to download and process the requests since 1 August 2026. In October 2026 the agency said more than 560,000 people had signed up, that brokers had reported deleting close to 100 million consumer profiles, and that 99.9% of users had had information deleted by at least one broker. The deletion figures are reported by the brokers themselves. In June 2026 The Markup and CalMatters asked readers who use DROP to report what brokers tell them and to check again after the deadline; no results had been published by November 2026.
Achieved whenthe independent audits of brokers that the Delete Act requires from 1 January 2028, or an outside test such as The Markup's, confirm that records marked deleted are gone.
Claimed by
CalPrivacy (the California Privacy Protection Agency), October 2026
Open
01
Score AI inbox previews
A test that sends a fixed set of marketing emails to accounts on Apple Mail with Apple Intelligence, Gmail and Yahoo Mail, captures the preview or summary each inbox shows before the email is opened, and scores whether it states the main offer, discount code and end date correctly.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Time the two-day unsubscribe
A public audit, repeated every six months, of how quickly large brands stop marketing email after an unsubscribe, measured against Gmail's and Yahoo's two-day rule and the 10 business days allowed by US law, using test addresses the auditor owns.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Score AI inbox previews
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A test that sends a fixed set of marketing emails to accounts on Apple Mail with Apple Intelligence, Gmail and Yahoo Mail, captures the preview or summary each inbox shows before the email is opened, and scores whether it states the main offer, discount code and end date correctly.
Why it is still open
Apple, Gmail and Yahoo now rewrite or extract parts of marketing emails in the inbox list. Inbox Monster, an email-testing firm, reports from live tests that Apple's AI previewed footer fine print so that a "Take 10% off" email read as a "100% off sale", and that extractions pulled discount codes from disclaimers instead of the main offer and showed the wrong image. These are examples, not counts, and searches found only vendor advice and single cases, no published rate of how often inbox previews misstate an offer.
Built with what exists
a sending domain the tester owns, set up with the SPF, DKIM and DMARC records that prove where mail comes from; test accounts on each mail service; an iPhone or Mac with Apple Intelligence turned on; Python to generate email variants that move the offer between an image, the heading, the body text and the footer; screenshots of each inbox; a small AI model to compare each preview with the true offer (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"), checked by a person on a sample.
First step
Write 20 emails that differ only in where the offer sits, send each to one account on each service, and screenshot the inbox before opening.
Done looks like
For 300 test emails, the share of previews on each service that state the main offer correctly, that show a wrong number or code, and that present fine print as the offer, published with every email and screenshot.
Open 02 · the brief
Time the two-day unsubscribe
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public audit, repeated every six months, of how quickly large brands stop marketing email after an unsubscribe, measured against Gmail's and Yahoo's two-day rule and the 10 business days allowed by US law, using test addresses the auditor owns.
Why it is still open
The Online Trust Alliance audited the top 200 North American online retailers each year from 2014 to 2018, unsubscribing and then watching for at least 30 days; in 2017 it found that 88% stopped sending immediately. Those audits ended before the 2024 rules, and searches found no audit since that times the stop against the two-day limit. A January 2023 test by the review site Email Tool Tester of more than 30 US retailers found four that kept sending after a Gmail unsubscribe, but it did not time the stop.
Built with what exists
test addresses on Gmail, Yahoo and a domain the auditor owns; Python with IMAP to log every message and its unsubscribe headers, including the one-click header defined in RFC 8058 (2017); a small AI model to sort marketing email from receipts and account notices, such as Meta's Muse Ember (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat").
First step
Choose the 200 brands, sign one owned address up to each, and start the message log.
Done looks like
For at least 200 brands, the number of days from unsubscribe to the last marketing email, the share that stop within two days and within 10 business days, and the share whose mail carries a working one-click header, published with the raw message log.