BRENNEN

Industries / Health / Healthcare / Urgent care

Triage

Triage is the work of sorting people who need care by how urgent their problem is, and steering each one to the right place: self-care, a family doctor, a walk-in clinic, phone advice or an emergency department.

7

Milestones achieved, from 2000 to 2024.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2000

    Five levels of urgency

    R. C. Wuerz, D. R. Eitel and colleagues found three-level triage unreliable and built the Emergency Severity Index (ESI), which sorts emergency patients into five levels. In a test on 493 adults at two urban hospitals, two nurses triaging the same patient agreed closely (weighted kappa 0.80, where 1 is perfect agreement). Of 67 patients put in the lowest level, 17 needed any test or procedure and none was admitted.

    europepmc.org

    Credit

    R. C. Wuerz, D. R. Eitel and colleagues

  2. 2010

    A share of ED visits

    R. M. Weinick, R. M. Burns and A. Mehrotra estimated that 13.7% to 27.1% of US emergency department visits could take place at an urgent care center or a retail clinic, chiefly for minor acute illnesses, strains and fractures, at a potential saving of about $4.4 billion a year. They found some evidence that patients can safely direct themselves to these sites, and said more research on quality was needed.

    europepmc.org

    Credit

    R. M. Weinick, R. M. Burns, A. Mehrotra

  3. 2013

    Minor only in hindsight

    M. C. Raven, R. Y. Hsia and colleagues applied a common rule for spotting "nonemergency" visits to 34,942 US emergency department visits from a 2009 national survey. Only 6.3% had a discharge diagnosis judged treatable in primary care, but those patients had arrived with the same complaints as 88.7% of all visits. Among visits with those complaints, 11.1% were triaged as needing immediate or emergency care and 12.5% were admitted.

    LessonA diagnosis known at discharge cannot show that a patient should have gone elsewhere, because at the door the same complaint can be minor or serious.

    europepmc.org

    Credit

    M. C. Raven, R. A. Lowe, J. Maselli, R. Y. Hsia

  4. 2014

    Call before walking in

    In January 2014 the Capital Region of Denmark, which includes Copenhagen, folded its out-of-hours family doctor service into Medical Helpline 1813, an advice line it had opened in January 2012, and staffed it with nurses and doctors who use a decision support tool. From 1 April 2014 Denmark required a referral before a visit to any emergency department, acute clinic or injury clinic. An outside survey by VIVE, the Danish Center for Social Science Research, counted 7 home visits per 1,000 residents in the region in 2016, 84% fewer than in 2014, while phone consultations per 1,000 residents stayed about the same. A 2025 study puts the line at about 1 million calls a year.

    pure.vive.dkpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    Capital Region of Denmark

  5. 2019

    Triage scales measured together

    J. M. Zachariasse, Henriette Moll and colleagues at Erasmus MC in Rotterdam pooled 66 studies of 33 triage systems. Only three had enough comparable studies: the Canadian Triage and Acuity Scale, ESI and the Manchester Triage System. In adults, the share of patients later admitted to intensive care whom a scale had placed in its top two levels ranged from 58% to 88% across studies, and no system did clearly better than the others.

    LessonA triage scale's accuracy in one hospital does not carry over to another.

    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    J. M. Zachariasse, Henriette Moll and colleagues

  6. 2020

    Booked slots, one queue

    At the end of 2020 NHS England began 111 First. People were asked to use the NHS 111 phone line or website before going to an emergency department, and those judged to need urgent or emergency care were given an arrival time slot at an emergency department or urgent care center. Researchers from Oxford and Southampton interviewed 27 staff at nine sites in deprived areas of England between October 2020 and July 2021. Hospitals kept their own triage, so booked patients were assessed again on arrival and joined the same queue as everyone else.

    LessonA booking made before arrival saves no time if the front door sorts everyone again into one queue.

    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    NHS England (the program); Jennifer MacLellan, Joanne Turnbull and colleagues (the study)

  7. 2024

    Steering software checked in Berlin

    SmED is German software, based on the Swiss SMASS system, that asks about symptoms and recommends how soon and where a person should be seen. Germany's 116117 on-call line has used it since 2020, says the Zi, the institute that runs it. Researchers at the Charité in Berlin and Leipzig University Hospital compared its Kontakt+ version with the treating doctors' decisions for 1,840 adults who walked into emergency departments. It agreed in 19% of cases, was more cautious in 66% and less cautious in 15%. An expert panel judged 49 patients (2.7%) potentially endangered, against an expected rate below 1%.

    LessonSoftware that sends walk-ins elsewhere needs a firm, prompt appointment at the place it sends them; the authors said patients should not be referred for care at a later time on its advice.

    europepmc.orgzi.de

    Credit

    A. Slagman, M. Möckel, A. Gries and colleagues

Watch for

  1. Germany routes care by 116117

    Germany's emergency care reform would make the 116117 line an acute control center that decides how urgent a call is, works with the 112 ambulance center, and can send a visiting doctor or switch on a telemedicine service. It would also set up integrated emergency centers at selected hospitals, each joining an emergency department, a doctors' on-call practice and one central triage point. The AOK federal association of statutory health insurers lists the Bundestag vote as 15 October 2026 and the Bundesrat's second reading as 20 November 2026, with parts in force from 1 January 2027.

    Achieved whenintegrated centers run under the law and an outside evaluation reports where their walk-in patients were sent and how many came back.

    bundesgesundheitsministerium.deaok.deaok.de

    Claimed by

    Federal Ministry of Health (minister Nina Warken), whose draft the federal cabinet approved on 22 April 2026

  2. Digital triage before the call

    The Netherlands Triage Standard (NTS) is a set of triage rules meant for emergency department nurses, triage staff at out-of-hours family doctor posts and ambulance dispatchers. On 30 October 2026 its foundation delivered certification requirements and a first development version of content for national "digital triage preparation", in which patients enter their complaints in a set form before they contact a family doctor or out-of-hours post.

    Achieved whencertified software is in use at out-of-hours posts and an outside study reports its effect on call length and on the urgency assigned.

    de-nts.nlde-nts.nl

    Claimed by

    Stichting NTS, October 2026

Open

  1. 01

    An archive of posted waits

    A public archive of the wait times that urgent care centers, walk-in clinics and emergency departments post on their websites and apps, read every 15 minutes, with a table saying what each operator's "wait" measures (to registration, to triage or to a clinician) and how the operator says it is worked out. Collect only where the sites' terms allow, and no patient data.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    An open front-door simulator

    An open-source simulation of one region's front door to urgent care: a phone and online advice line, walk-in urgent care and an emergency department, with invented patients whose numbers match published monthly totals. It compares three rules: walk-in only; booked arrival slots with a second triage at the door, as staff described under 111 First; and booked slots that skip the second triage.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

An archive of posted waits

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public archive of the wait times that urgent care centers, walk-in clinics and emergency departments post on their websites and apps, read every 15 minutes, with a table saying what each operator's "wait" measures (to registration, to triage or to a clinician) and how the operator says it is worked out. Collect only where the sites' terms allow, and no patient data.

Why it is still open

Posted waits are common, but the published accuracy test covered four emergency departments in one Ohio hospital system: the posted wait missed the actual one by a mean of 31.5 minutes at the busy site and by 1.3 to 8.6 minutes at three small ones. Alberta Health Services posts live estimated waits for hospitals in six cities and calls them approximate, and US hospitals define "wait" in different ways. A search found no public archive that spans operators or countries.

europepmc.orgalbertahealthservices.cahealthcaredive.com

Built with what exists

Scheduled Python collectors; Playwright, or Browser Use 1.0, an open-source agent that drives Chrome, for pages that build their wait widget in the browser (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); Parquet files on a public object store; a simple same-hour-last-week forecast as the baseline.

  1. First step

    List 50 sites in two countries that post waits, record what each says its number means, and run the collector for two weeks.

  2. Done looks like

    12 months of readings every 15 minutes from at least 300 sites run by at least 10 operators in at least 3 countries, with at least 95% of scheduled readings captured; a definitions table for every operator; and the mean absolute error, in minutes, of a baseline forecast of each site's posted wait 2 hours ahead.

Open 02 · the brief

An open front-door simulator

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open-source simulation of one region's front door to urgent care: a phone and online advice line, walk-in urgent care and an emergency department, with invented patients whose numbers match published monthly totals. It compares three rules: walk-in only; booked arrival slots with a second triage at the door, as staff described under 111 First; and booked slots that skip the second triage.

Why it is still open

The closest open models cover one piece each. Pilbery and colleagues at Yorkshire Ambulance Service built a discrete event simulation of NHS 111 callers sent to primary care in Bradford and put the code on GitHub. Monks and Harper published a tutorial model of an urgent care call center. Neither models walk-in centers and the emergency department together, and neither tests triage repeated at the door.

pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govopenresearch.nihr.ac.uk

Built with what exists

SimPy or Ciw (Python libraries for queue simulation); the MOOOD-study code as a starting point; Streamlit for a web front end; NHS England's published monthly statistics on emergency department attendances and NHS 111 activity, used as totals only, with no patient records.

  1. First step

    Download 24 months of published monthly figures for one integrated care board and fit hourly arrival rates by day of the week.

  2. Done looks like

    Code under an open license that reproduces 12 months of one English area's published monthly attendances by department type, and its NHS 111 call volumes, within 10%; and a published table of simulated time from arrival to clinician under the three rules at three levels of demand.