BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Education / Tutoring

Pricing and access

What tutoring costs, who pays for it, and what governments do when families spend heavily on it or poorer students go without.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1980 to 2024.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1980

    Korea bans private tutoring

    After taking power in 1980, Chun Doo-hwan's military government banned private tutoring in academic subjects, at a time when about 12.9% of elementary, 15.3% of middle and 26.2% of high school pupils had tutors. Families evaded the ban: college students posed as high schoolers to reach pupils' apartments, and hotels housed secret cram schools. In 2000 the courts declared the prohibition unconstitutional.

    LessonThe number of tutoring institutes, called hagwons, grew from 381 in 1980 to 14,043 in 2000 and 31,000 in 2007, and in 2004 Korea turned to improving state schools instead, since a ban "addressed only the symptoms rather than the causes".

    hse.ru

    Credit

    Mark Bray, UNESCO International Institute for Educational Planning (2009), citing Korean studies

  2. 1999

    Tutoring called a shadow

    UNESCO's International Institute for Educational Planning published Mark Bray's The shadow education system: private tutoring and its implications for planners in 1999, which Bray later called the first significant cross-national study of private tutoring. The shadow image holds that tutoring exists only because schooling does, changes shape as schooling changes, and gets far less attention. In 2021 UNESCO's Global Education Monitoring Report called private tutoring one of the largest household spending items on education, rising in many countries and widening inequality, and found that less than half of countries regulate it.

    connect.unevoc.unesco.orghse.ruworld-education-blog.org

    Credit

    Mark Bray, IIEP; UNESCO Global Education Monitoring Report team

  3. 2006

    Free tutoring, little used

    The US No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 required districts with schools that missed state goals for three years in a row to offer low-income students free tutoring outside the school day from state-approved providers, called supplemental educational services. The Government Accountability Office found that participation among eligible students rose only from 12% in 2003-04 to 19% in 2004-05, that districts struggled to tell parents in time and to attract providers to rural areas and to students with disabilities, and that 85% of states wanted help with methods for evaluating providers.

    LessonPaying for tutoring did not get it to students; how families were told and where providers would go decided who was served.

    gao.justia.com

    Credit

    US Government Accountability Office (GAO-06-758)

  4. 2009

    Court upholds the hagwon curfew

    In October 2009 South Korea's Constitutional Court rejected a petition from hagwon operators, parents and students who argued that night-time limits on cram school hours violated educational rights. Each city and province sets the hours by ordinance; Seoul planned a 10 p.m. limit, and the government paid rewards to citizens who reported schools that broke the rules. Seoul still limited hagwons to 5 a.m. to 10 p.m. in 2025, when a city council member proposed letting high school academies stay open until midnight.

    koreatimes.co.krasiae.co.kr

    Credit

    Constitutional Court of Korea; Seoul Metropolitan Office of Education

  5. 2021

    China makes tutors nonprofits

    On 24 July 2021 the Communist Party's Central Committee and the State Council ordered companies tutoring school subjects for pupils in compulsory schooling to re-register as nonprofits, barred new ones, banned them from raising capital or taking foreign investment, and banned classes on weekends and holidays. By February 2022 the Ministry of Education said online subject-tutoring institutions had been cut by 84.1% and offline ones by 83.8%; New Oriental's founder said its revenue had fallen 80% and its market value 90%; and Beijing set guidance fees of 20 to 80 yuan per student per class.

    LessonDemand did not vanish with the companies; by November 2021 New Zealand's foreign ministry reported "underground" individual tutoring becoming regulators' next target.

    caixinglobal.comchinadaily.com.cnmfat.govt.nz

    Credit

    CPC Central Committee and State Council; Ministry of Education

  6. 2024

    England's tutoring subsidy ends

    England's National Tutoring Programme paid 75% of schools' tutoring costs in 2021/22, 60% in 2022/23 and 50% in 2023/24, its final year. The government had aimed for six million 15-hour courses by 2024; Department for Education figures counted 5,324,213 courses started from November 2020. The share of state schools taking part fell from 87% in 2021/22, by the National Audit Office's count, to 50.1% in 2023/24, by the department's.

    LessonSchools left as the subsidy fell; in NFER's survey of senior leaders, the lower rate was a key reason for no longer taking part.

    assets.publishing.service.gov.uknao.org.uktes.com

    Credit

    Department for Education; National Audit Office; NFER

  7. 2024

    Korea's tutoring bill peaks

    South Korean families spent a record 29.2 trillion won (about US$20 billion) on private after-school classes for school pupils in 2024, the fourth record in a row, while the number of pupils fell 1.5%; 80% of pupils took part. Households earning more than 8 million won a month spent 676,000 won per child each month, against 205,000 won in households earning 3 million won or less. In 2025 total spending fell 5.7% to 27.5 trillion won as pupil numbers kept falling, but monthly spending per participating pupil reached a record 604,000 won.

    koreatimes.co.krkoreatimes.co.kr

    Credit

    Statistics Korea and the Ministry of Education (2024 survey); Ministry of Data and Statistics (2025 survey)

Watch for

  1. After-school classes cut spending

    South Korea's Ministry of Education said that more after-school programs for elementary pupils may be behind the 2025 fall in private tutoring spending, while saying a single cause is hard to pinpoint; the statistics ministry pointed to the shrinking school-age population.

    Achieved whenAn independent analysis separates the effect of the after-school expansion from falling enrollment, for example by comparing areas that expanded programs at different times.

    koreatimes.co.kr

    Claimed by

    Ministry of Education, March 2026

Open

  1. 01

    A world tutoring price table

    A monthly table of posted hourly prices for math, English and exam tutoring in 30 cities across at least 15 countries, taken from public listings on tutoring marketplaces and agencies' price pages and split by school level and by online or in person. Store only prices, subjects, places and dates, never tutors' names or photos, and set each city's median against local average earnings from official statistics.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    What governments paid per hour

    A public ledger of the price per student-hour that governments paid tutoring providers in their programs, such as England's National Tutoring Programme, US supplemental educational services and state or district programs bought with US pandemic relief money, taken from published contracts, audits and evaluations, with group size and tutor type recorded for each.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A world tutoring price table

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A monthly table of posted hourly prices for math, English and exam tutoring in 30 cities across at least 15 countries, taken from public listings on tutoring marketplaces and agencies' price pages and split by school level and by online or in person. Store only prices, subjects, places and dates, never tutors' names or photos, and set each city's median against local average earnings from official statistics.

Why it is still open

The best figures are national household surveys, such as South Korea's, each covering one country. Platforms publish national averages for one country at a time, such as Superprof's January 2022 UK guide, which quotes The Tutor Pages' £29 to £41 an hour. The price studies this research found cover a single platform, such as a 2026 student project that modeled the hourly rates of 1,413 exam tutors on Russia's Profi.ru; no cross-country price series was found.

github.comsuperprof.co.ukkoreatimes.co.kr

Built with what exists

A web agent such as Browser Use (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over") collecting listings within each site's terms; Gemini Decision 1 (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass") or another AI model to sort each listing into fixed subject, level and format categories; official wage statistics.

  1. First step

    Collect one month of listings for five cities, sort them, and check 100 by hand.

  2. Done looks like

    Six monthly releases in a row for 30 cities, each city median based on at least 100 listings, a hand check of 200 sorted listings showing at least 95% correctly categorized, and Seoul's figures compared with Korea's official survey.

Open 02 · the brief

What governments paid per hour

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public ledger of the price per student-hour that governments paid tutoring providers in their programs, such as England's National Tutoring Programme, US supplemental educational services and state or district programs bought with US pandemic relief money, taken from published contracts, audits and evaluations, with group size and tutor type recorded for each.

Why it is still open

The best-known cost tool, the National Student Support Accelerator's Tutoring Cost Calculator, estimates US program costs from academic studies, nonprofits' IRS 990 tax forms and interviews, not from what governments paid providers, and England's audit office found the department lacked detailed assurance about how the first year's tutoring money was spent. A Stanford study of 123 US district contracts for tutoring, curriculum and software, published in August 2025, coded which ones tie payment to student results, not the price per hour.

nssa.stanford.edunao.org.ukscale.stanford.edu

Built with what exists

An AI agent such as Claude reading contract notices (the UK's Contracts Finder, the US USAspending.gov database, state procurement portals) and audit reports; a spreadsheet with a quoted source for every row.

  1. First step

    Fill the rows for England's tuition partners and for three US states' supplemental educational services from GAO and state reports.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 40 programs in at least four countries, each with a price per student-hour, group size, tutor type and source quote, and 20 rows checked by a second person.