BRENNEN

Industries / Construction and property / Real estate / Title and escrow

Closing fraud

This is the work of stopping thieves who redirect closing money or sell property they do not own, and of keeping criminals from using property purchases to hide money.

6

Milestones achieved, from 2016 to 2026.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2016

    Cash buyers' owners reported

    FinCEN, the US Treasury's financial intelligence unit, ordered certain title insurance companies to name the real people behind companies that paid all cash, with no bank loan, for high-end homes in Manhattan and Miami-Dade County. The orders, called geographic targeting orders, were issued on 13 January 2016 and ran from 1 March to 27 August 2016. FinCEN chose title insurers because title insurance is part of most purchases.

    fincen.gov

    Credit

    Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN)

  2. 2018

    FBI team freezes diverted wires

    In February 2018 the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) set up a Recovery Asset Team that asks the receiving bank to freeze money as soon as a victim reports a fraudulent wire. In its first month it handled a New York buyer who had wired $50,000 after a forged email from the closing agent; the bank returned all of it. By the FBI's count the team acted on 1,061 incidents worth $257 million in 2018 and recovered 75%. In 2025 it froze in full a wire of over $449,000 sent by home buyers after an email posing as their attorneys.

    ic3.govic3.gov

    Credit

    FBI IC3; receiving banks

  3. 2018

    Impostor sellers cost solicitors

    In two London cases decided together on 15 May 2018, fraudsters posing as the registered owners of houses had sold them through real solicitors and estate agents; one buyer, Dreamvar, paid £1.1 million. The Court of Appeal held that the solicitors who acted for the impostors were in breach of trust and of their completion undertaking, and refused to excuse the buyer's own solicitors, Mishcon de Reya, although they had acted honestly.

    LessonThe court put the loss on the firms that handled the money rather than on the buyer, so checking that a seller is the real owner became their risk.

    caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk

    Credit

    Court of Appeal of England and Wales, Lord Justice Patten and Lord Justice Floyd, with Lady Justice Gloster dissenting on relief for Mishcon

  4. 2020

    Wire instructions checked independently

    From 2 January 2020, ALTA's best practices for title and settlement companies require a written wire transfer procedure, tested at least once a year, that confirms outgoing wire instructions through a channel separate from the message that delivered them and warns consumers of wire fraud, plus a written plan for responding when fraud happens.

    alta.org

    Credit

    American Land Title Association (ALTA)

  5. 2023

    Title agents most impersonated

    FinCEN studied banks' reports of business email compromise in real estate for 2020 and 2021. In these scams a criminal takes over or imitates someone's email to redirect a payment. Its analysis, released on 30 March 2023, found that the people most often impersonated were those in the title and closing process, such as title agents, closing agents and escrow companies, and that nearly 88% of incidents first sent the money to accounts at US banks.

    fincen.gov

    Credit

    FinCEN

  6. 2026

    Cash-sale reporting rule struck down

    On 28 August 2024 FinCEN finalized a rule requiring closing and settlement agents to report transfers of homes to companies and trusts that no bank financed, due to start on 1 December 2025 and then postponed to 1 March 2026. On 19 March 2026 the US District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, in Flowers Title Companies v. Bessent, vacated the whole rule, holding that it exceeded FinCEN's authority under the Bank Secrecy Act; a federal court in Florida reached the opposite view in a separate case.

    LessonA reporting duty placed on closing agents needs clear footing in statute, and a court can stop it nationwide before the first report is filed.

    gibsondunn.com

    Credit

    Flowers Title Companies; Judge Jeremy D. Kernodle

Watch for

  1. Reporting rule on appeal

    FinCEN maintains that its residential real estate reporting rule is lawful and appealed the Texas ruling to the Fifth Circuit on 11 May 2026; until then, no reports are required.

    Achieved whenThe Fifth Circuit reverses the ruling and FinCEN resumes collecting reports from closing agents.

    jdsupra.com

    Claimed by

    FinCEN, May 2026

  2. Deepfake sellers at closing

    In ALTA's 2026 study of 245 title professionals, 59% of firms reported at least one attempt in 2025 by someone posing as a property's seller, up from 28% in ALTA's 2024 survey, and 58% said deepfakes, AI-made video or voice that imitates a real person, were at least somewhat common.

    Achieved whenA court, prosecutor or law enforcement report documents a closing in which a deepfake passed a title company's or notary's identity check.

    nar.realtor

    Claimed by

    ALTA survey respondents, in a study sponsored by CertifID, September 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Closing-email fraud test set

    A public, labeled set of made-up email threads from home purchases, with fictional people and firms, in which some threads contain an attempt to change the payment instructions: a look-alike sender address, a hijacked reply, a last-minute "new account" message. Score email-security filters and AI models on catching the attempts without flagging ordinary closing mail.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Count impostor-seller cases

    A public, coded file of US cases in which someone posed as a property's owner to sell or mortgage it, drawn from court records, prosecutors' press releases and local news since 2020. Code each case for property type, why the owner was absent, how identity was checked (remote notary, seller-chosen notary, in person), how the fraud was caught and the loss, with owners' names replaced by codes.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Closing-email fraud test set

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, labeled set of made-up email threads from home purchases, with fictional people and firms, in which some threads contain an attempt to change the payment instructions: a look-alike sender address, a hijacked reply, a last-minute "new account" message. Score email-security filters and AI models on catching the attempts without flagging ordinary closing mail.

Why it is still open

No public labeled set of real estate payment-diversion emails was found. The one recent academic study found, a 2026 paper at the European Conference on Cyber Warfare and Security, is a qualitative study of a few real incidents and says that empirical cross-case analysis of email fraud in real estate "remains limited"; FinCEN's analysis works from banks' summary reports, not the messages. The one public business email compromise set found, BEC-2 (Rohit Dube, Journal of Computer Virology and Hacking Techniques, 2025), holds 279 single emails written with AI models, and none of them mentions escrow, a closing or a real estate deal.

papers.academic-conferences.orgfincen.govgithub.com

Built with what exists

Scenarios from FinCEN's 2016 advisory on email compromise and the IC3 annual reports' case examples; ordinary business mail from the public Enron email set for clean threads, rewritten into closing threads; open email filters such as SpamAssassin; the BEC-2 emails as a general baseline; AI models that return probabilities for fixed-answer questions (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass").

  1. First step

    Write 50 closing threads from the FinCEN and IC3 examples, have two people label them separately, and measure how often they agree.

  2. Done looks like

    2,000 published threads, about 20% containing a diversion attempt, labeled by two people with their agreement reported, and a table of each tool's catch rate and false-alarm rate.

Open 02 · the brief

Count impostor-seller cases

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, coded file of US cases in which someone posed as a property's owner to sell or mortgage it, drawn from court records, prosecutors' press releases and local news since 2020. Code each case for property type, why the owner was absent, how identity was checked (remote notary, seller-chosen notary, in person), how the fraud was caught and the loss, with owners' names replaced by codes.

Why it is still open

ALTA's surveys count firms that saw attempts, not cases. The FBI's IC3 reports a "Real Estate" category that covers investment, rental and timeshare fraud, while closing wire fraud is filed as business email compromise. When a Georgia TV station asked the state Attorney General's office for vacant-land fraud reports, a spokesperson said the office "did not find any in their records".

nar.realtoric3.govfox19.com

Built with what exists

CourtListener's free API for federal court records; US Attorneys' press releases on justice.gov; a web agent to gather state and county cases (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); an AI model to code each case against a written codebook, with a person checking every case.

  1. First step

    Search CourtListener and justice.gov for 2023 to 2026 federal cases that mention seller impersonation or vacant land, and code the first 20.

  2. Done looks like

    150 cases from at least 15 states coded to a published codebook, with two coders' agreement reported and a table of how the frauds were caught.