BRENNEN

Industries / Media, arts and recreation / Media and entertainment / Ticketing

Refunds

Refunds covers giving money back when an event is cancelled, postponed or moved, and the credits and vouchers sometimes offered instead.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1889 to 2024.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1889

    A stub for rainouts

    Baseball clubs once used hard cardboard tickets that were collected at the gate and sold again; when rain stopped a game before the fifth inning, fans lined up for a ticket to the next game, joined by "free riders and fence jumpers" who had not paid. Abner Powell, co-owner of the New Orleans club, whose team had 20 home games postponed in the first six weeks of the 1888 season, worked with an Arkansas printer in 1889 to make perforated tickets with a detachable, dated "rain-stub" that the buyer kept for a later game, The Hardball Times recounts from contemporary newspapers and Baseball Digest.

    LessonA refund needs proof of purchase that only the buyer holds.

    tht.fangraphs.com

    Credit

    Abner Powell

  2. 2020

    Vouchers in place of cash

    On 9 April 2020 Germany's federal cabinet approved a "voucher solution" letting organizers give ticket holders a voucher worth the ticket price, in place of a refund, for events that could not take place because of COVID-19, usable for the rescheduled event or an equivalent one. Holders for whom a voucher was unreasonable could demand cash, and vouchers not used were to be refunded at the end of 2021.

    LessonVouchers kept organizers' cash in the business while venues were shut, at the cost of holding fans' money until the end of 2021.

    bundesregierung.de

    Credit

    German federal government (Monika Grütters, minister of state for culture)

  3. 2020

    Refunds for postponed shows

    On 17 April 2020 US Representatives Bill Pascrell and Katie Porter wrote to Live Nation and Ticketmaster objecting to what they called a policy "to refuse refunds to all requesting fans" for events postponed by the COVID-19 pandemic. That month Ticketmaster announced refunds for cancelled and postponed Live Nation and AEG shows; its president, Jared Smith, said "the money we need to refund fans is held by our clients", the venues and promoters, and that refunds were being offered for all cancelled events and more than 80% of nearly 30,000 events cancelled, postponed or rescheduled.

    LessonThe ticket company processes the refund, but the organizer usually holds the money.

    insidernj.commusic.mxdwn.com

    Credit

    Bill Pascrell and Katie Porter; Ticketmaster

  4. 2023

    A final refunded in full

    After the independent review blamed UEFA for the chaos at the 2022 Champions League final, UEFA announced in March 2023 that it would refund all 19,618 tickets in Liverpool's allocation in full, at prices from £59.40 to £585.70, though the match had been played, Sky Sports reported.

    LessonA refund can answer an organizer's failure at the gates, not only a cancellation.

    skysports.com

    Credit

    UEFA

  5. 2023

    Fees refunded after a complaint

    After The Cure's Robert Smith objected publicly to the fees on his band's 2023 North American tour, he announced on 16 March 2023 that Ticketmaster had "agreed with us that many of the fees being charged are unduly high" and would refund $10 a ticket on the lowest-priced tickets and $5 on all others to Verified Fan buyers, automatically, with lower fees on later sales.

    LessonFees are set in contracts between seller, venue and promoter, and one artist's public objection was enough to change them for a tour.

    ultimateclassicrock.com

    Credit

    Robert Smith; Ticketmaster

  6. 2024

    Credit instead of refunds, reversed

    StubHub had promised full refunds for cancelled events under its "FanProtect Guarantee", but in late March 2020 it switched to giving 120% of the price as credit for future purchases. After an investigation by California's Department of Justice it went back to cash refunds in May 2021, and on 22 August 2024 the state's attorney general announced a settlement recording $20 million in refunds to more than 45,000 Californians and a $295,000 penalty.

    LessonRegulators treated the refund terms in force when a ticket was bought as binding, whatever changed later.

    oag.ca.gov

    Credit

    California Attorney General (Rob Bonta)

Watch for

  1. Refund rules in federal law

    The TICKET Act would require US ticket sellers to show the total price up front, ban speculative ticket sales and set out refund policies; the Senate Commerce Committee approved it in February 2025, and the notice for a Senate subcommittee hearing on ticket fees and bots on 28 January 2026 recalled that approval. No source found reports a vote by the full Senate.

    Achieved whenthe act becomes law and the FTC or a state brings a case under its refund provisions.

    markey.senate.govcommerce.senate.gov

    Claimed by

    Senators Ed Markey and Eric Schmitt, February 2025; Senate Commerce subcommittee chaired by Marsha Blackburn, January 2026

Open

  1. 01

    A tracker for refund terms

    A public, versioned record of the refund and cancellation terms of 30 primary and resale sellers in 10 countries, with each change dated and the rules pulled out into a table fans can compare.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    A log of refund times

    A volunteer-reported log of how many days refunds took after cancellations, by seller and country, compared with what each seller says.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A tracker for refund terms

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, versioned record of the refund and cancellation terms of 30 primary and resale sellers in 10 countries, with each change dated and the rules pulled out into a table fans can compare.

Why it is still open

Sellers have changed refund terms after tickets were sold, as StubHub did in March 2020. Open Terms Archive, an open-source project that records changes to online services' terms, lists about 300 services in its general collection on GitHub, and none of them is a ticket seller, as listed on 19 November 2026.

oag.ca.govgithub.com

Built with what exists

The Open Terms Archive engine, published under the EUPL 1.2 license; a language model such as Claude to extract the rules (refund on cancellation, on postponement, whether fees come back, deadlines) into a fixed format, with each extracted rule linked to the clause it came from.

github.com

  1. First step

    Write Open Terms Archive declarations for five sellers' refund pages and run the engine for a week.

  2. Done looks like

    Thirty sellers in 10 countries tracked daily for six months, with extracted rules checked by hand on 100 documents at 95% agreement or better and every change in the period dated.

Open 02 · the brief

A log of refund times

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A volunteer-reported log of how many days refunds took after cancellations, by seller and country, compared with what each seller says.

Why it is still open

StubHub says it "typically processes refunds within 5–10 business days once the cancellation is confirmed". California's attorney general found StubHub had failed to pay refunds on time during the pandemic, and on 29 September 2026 New York's attorney general sued the promoters of a festival cancelled 10 days before it was due to begin in September 2025 for failing to refund more than $243,000 paid by 521 ticket buyers. Searches found company statements and individual complaints but no published measurement of refund times across sellers.

newsroom.stubhub.comoag.ca.govag.ny.gov

Built with what exists

A web form and a forwarding email address to which volunteers send their own cancellation and refund emails, with personal details stripped on arrival; a language model to extract the dates, checked by hand; a public dashboard.

  1. First step

    Set up the form and log refunds from one cancelled tour this month.

  2. Done looks like

    Five hundred refunds logged from at least 50 cancelled events, with the median and 90th-percentile days to refund for every seller with 20 or more cases, and 100 cases checked against the original emails.