BRENNEN

Industries / Media, arts and recreation / Media and entertainment / Ticketing

Entry and scanning

Entry and scanning is checking each ticket at the gate and getting the crowd inside safely: ushers and turnstiles, barcode scanners, phone taps and face matching.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1902 to 2023.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1902

    A machine that counts tokens

    A ticket machine made around 1902 for the Alhambra Theatre in Leicester Square, London, issued differently shaped metal tokens for the Pit and the Stalls, and a counter on each stack, the "Vernon Revolution Counter" patented in 1893, recorded how many were issued. Ushers collected the tokens on a rod or string and took them back to the box office, where they could be checked against the counter, the Victoria and Albert Museum says.

    LessonA ticket check is also an audit: counting what was issued against what came back shows whether money went missing.

    collections.vam.ac.uk

    Credit

    Alhambra Theatre; Accurate Check Taker Ltd, the probable maker

  2. 1979

    Eleven deaths at the doors

    Before The Who played Riverfront Coliseum in Cincinnati on 3 December 1979, about 8,000 people were packed around two banks of glass doors that were not due to open until 7 p.m.; most tickets were general admission, with first come, first served "festival" seating, and only a few thousand reserved seats, Rolling Stone reported. When the crowd surged, 11 people aged 15 to 27 died of asphyxiation. The city banned festival-style seating that year and lifted the ban in 2004, Fox19 reported.

    LessonUnreserved tickets turn entry into a race, and the number of doors open decides how dangerous the race is.

    rollingstone.comfox19.com

    Credit

    City of Cincinnati

  3. 2019

    Barcodes that keep changing

    In May 2019 Ticketmaster announced SafeTix, which ties each ticket to a fan's phone with an encrypted barcode that "automatically refreshes every few seconds", so a screenshot or photocopy no longer works, and adds near-field communication (NFC) for "tap and go" entry; it was to be installed at more than 350 venues that year, NFL stadiums among them. TicketNews noted that the same system stops fans transferring tickets except through Ticketmaster's own system.

    LessonThe code that defeats copies also keeps resale and fans' data inside the seller's system.

    ticketnews.com

    Credit

    Ticketmaster

  4. 2021

    Ticketless fans at Wembley

    At the Euro 2020 final at Wembley on 11 July 2021, about 2,000 people without tickets got into the stadium, around 400 of whom were thrown out, through 17 "mass breaches" of disabled access gates and emergency fire doors, a review by Baroness Louise Casey for the Football Association found; it called the day a "near miss" for deaths.

    LessonGates built for access and emergencies are the weak point when a crowd without tickets wants in.

    skysports.com

    Credit

    Baroness Casey of Blackstock; The Football Association

  5. 2022

    Fake tickets wrongly blamed

    At the Champions League final at the Stade de France near Paris on 28 May 2022, Liverpool fans were crushed in queues for hours and teargassed by police, and kick-off was delayed by nearly 40 minutes. Afterwards Liverpool fans were blamed for arriving late and using fake tickets; an independent review commissioned by UEFA and led by Tiago Brandão Rodrigues, a former Portuguese sports minister, found both claims wrong and concluded in 2023 that UEFA, as event owner, "bears primary responsibility for failures which almost led to disaster".

    LessonBlaming counterfeit tickets for a failure at the gates can hide the failure of the entry plan itself.

    insideworldfootball.com

    Credit

    Independent review panel (Tiago Brandão Rodrigues)

  6. 2023

    Faces used to refuse entry

    On 25 January 2023 New York's attorney general wrote to Madison Square Garden Entertainment about its use of facial recognition to identify and turn away lawyers from firms suing the company, a policy that could affect up to 90 law firms. The letter said this "may violate the New York Civil Rights Law" and other laws against discrimination and retaliation, and that the software "may be plagued with biases and false positives against people of color and women".

    LessonA camera that can let a ticket holder in can also keep a named person out.

    jurist.org

    Credit

    New York State Office of the Attorney General

Watch for

  1. Faces in place of tickets

    Wicket, a face-matching company, says it has processed more than five million "Express Entry" face scans at live events, in which fans link a selfie to their ticket and walk through lanes with face scanners; the University of Florida became the first college venue to use it, in the 2025 football season. Biometric Update, citing Sports Business Journal, reported that Major League Baseball's Go-Ahead Entry lanes, with technology from NEC, are 141% faster than standard lanes with 2.4 times the scans per minute. Both programs are optional.

    Achieved whenan outside party publishes measured entry rates for face lanes beside scanning lanes at the same gates, with how often the system wrongly admits or refuses someone.

    idtechwire.combiometricupdate.com

    Claimed by

    Wicket, October 2025; Major League Baseball, March 2025

Open

  1. 01

    A gate-speed benchmark

    Independent, published measurements of how many people per minute pass through a lane that checks paper tickets, fixed QR codes, rotating codes, NFC phone taps or faces, under the same conditions.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Rotating codes, open source

    Rotating QR codes for an open-source box office: each ticket's code changes every 15 to 30 seconds from a secret shared with the scanner, so a screenshot stops working, and the scanner can check it without a network connection.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A gate-speed benchmark

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Independent, published measurements of how many people per minute pass through a lane that checks paper tickets, fixed QR codes, rotating codes, NFC phone taps or faces, under the same conditions.

Why it is still open

The speed figures for face lanes are the operators' own. The UK's Sports Grounds Safety Authority uses 660 people per entry point per hour as the recommended maximum rate of entry in its worked examples of the Guide to Safety at Sports Grounds. Searches found vendor and planning figures ranging widely but no independent field comparison by method.

biometricupdate.comsgsa.org.uk

Built with what exists

Overhead cameras mounted with the venue's permission and signs telling fans, with faces blurred at capture and no images kept; open detection and tracking models such as Ultralytics YOLO with ByteTrack to count people crossing a line; hand tally counters to check the counts; Python.

  1. First step

    Ask one small venue that scans phones to allow a counted test of two lanes at one show, and compare the camera count with a hand count.

  2. Done looks like

    Counts from at least 20 events and 10,000 entries, giving people per minute per lane for each method with 95% confidence intervals, and camera counts within 3% of hand counts on every lane checked.

Open 02 · the brief

Rotating codes, open source

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Rotating QR codes for an open-source box office: each ticket's code changes every 15 to 30 seconds from a secret shared with the scanner, so a screenshot stops working, and the scanner can check it without a network connection.

Why it is still open

Ticketmaster's SafeTix uses rotating barcodes but is closed to other sellers. Google Wallet supports rotating barcodes built on TOTP (time-based one-time passwords, the method many sign-in apps use, defined in RFC 6238), but only inside Google Wallet passes. pretix, an open-source ticket shop, offers random codes checked against a database or signed codes that a scanner can verify offline; both stay the same, so a copy works for whoever is scanned first.

ticketnews.comdevelopers.google.comdocs.pretix.eu

Built with what exists

pretix's plugin system; a TOTP library such as pyotp; a web page on the fan's phone to show the changing code; a scanner app adapted to check it.

  1. First step

    Build a web page that shows a changing code for a pretix test ticket and verify it with a short script on a second phone.

  2. Done looks like

    A published plugin and scanner; in a test of 1,000 scans with the scanner offline, every screenshot older than 60 seconds is rejected, every live code is accepted, and the median scan takes under one second.